Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2020-09
The sounds of silence in Australian collective memory and popular counter-narratives ( Los sonidos del silencio en la memoria colectiva australiana y en los relatos alternativos populares )
In 1968, the Australian anthropologist W. E. H. Stanner famously articulated that the nation’s history had been wracked by a ‘great Australian silence’ with regard to the recognition of Indigenous experience. Australia’s sense of its past, he argued, its very collective memory, had been built on a state of forgetting. Beyond that disciplinary silence, however, important historical ‘noise’ was being made about Indigenous history. Popular historical fiction and poetry, Indigenous family histories and forms of popular protest all offered important counter-narratives to that formal silence from the History discipline. Scholarship in the fields of anthropology and archaeology further pressed against the silences and silencing of Australian History. This paper uses the idea of silence to complicate historiographical space in Australia. By contemplating formal History texts, vernacular historical accounts and history-making beyond the discipline, it seeks to extend our understandings of national historiographies and historical knowledge.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AttwoodB. (2017). Denial in a settler society: The Australian case. History Workshop Journal, 84(Autumn), 24–43.
2.
BennettT., Buckridge, P., Carter, D., & Mercer, C. (1992). Celebrating the nation: A critical study of Australia’s bicentenary. St Leonards, NSW: Allen & Unwin.
3.
BergerS. (2007). Introduction. In BergerS. (Ed.), Writing the nation: A global perspective (pp. 1–29). Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.
4.
BergerS. (2008). Narrating the nation: Historiography and other genres. In BergerS.EriksonasL.MycockA. (Eds.), Narrating the nation: Representations in history, media and the arts (p. xii). New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
5.
BlaineyG. (1957). A centenary history of the University of Melbourne. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
6.
BoardP. (1916). History and Australian history (Address by Mr. P. Board, M.A. Director of Education, at the Annual Meeting of the Historical Society, 22nd February). Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society, 3(6), 290–293.
7.
BonwickJ. (1870). The last of the tasmanians: Or, the Black war of Van Dieman’s land. London: Marston.
8.
BoucherL. (2009). Trans/national history and disciplinary Amnesia: Historicising White Australia at Two Fins de Siècles. In CareyJ.McLiskyC. (Eds.), Creating White Australia (pp. 44–64). Sydney: Sydney University Press.
ChakrabartyD. (2010). Empire, ethics, and the calling of history: Knowledge in the postcolony. In S. Jobs & A. Lüdtke (Eds.), Unsettling history: Archiving and narrating in historiography (pp. 63–88). Frankfurt: Campus Verlag.
11.
ChakrabartyD. (2011) The Politics and Possibility of Historical Knowledge: Continuing the Conversation. Postcolonial Studies14, 243–250.
12.
ClarkA. (2008). History’s Children: History Wars in the Classroom. Sydney: UNSW Press.
13.
CoghlanT. A.EwingT. T. (1902). The progress of Australasia in the nineteenth century. London: Linscott Publishing Company.
14.
Commonwealth of Australia. (1914). Historical records of Australia (Vol. 1. 26 1). Canberra: Author.
15.
CrampK. R. (1917). The Australian historical society — The story of its foundation’. Journal of the Royal Australian Historical Society, 4(1), 1–14.
16.
CurthoysA. (2008). WEH stanner and the historians. In BeckettJ.HinksonM. (Eds.), An appreciation of difference: WEH Stanner and Aboriginal Australia (pp. 233). Canberra: Aboriginal Studies Press.
17.
DarkE. (1941). The Timeless Land. London: Collins.
18.
DortinsE. (2009). The many truths of Bennelong’s tragedy. Aboriginal History, 33, 53–75.
19.
DunlopE. H. (1841, October15). The Aboriginal Mother. The Sydney Herald.
20.
ElbourneE. (2003). The sin of the settler: The 1835-36 select committee on Aborigines and debates over virtue and conquest in the early nineteenth-century British White settler empire. Journal of Colonialism and Colonial History, 4(3), 3.
21.
FavencE. (1888). The History of Australian Exploration from 1788 to 1888. Sydney: Turner and Henderson.
22.
First Nations National Constitutional Convention. (2017, May 26). UluruStatement from the Heart.
23.
FitzgeraldS. (1989). The Garden Palace and Sydney’s International Exhibition of 1879. In ColtheartL. (Ed.), Significant sites: History of public works in New South Wales (pp. 67–95). Sydney: Hale and Iremonger.
24.
FletcherB. (1988). The 1888 centenary celebrations and new developments in the writing of Australian history. Sydney: University of Sydney.
25.
FletcherB. (1990). A miscarriage of history’: The first official Australian history textbook in New South Wales 1889-1901. History of Education Review, 19(1), 16–28.
26.
FletcherB. (1993). Australian history in New South Wales, 1888-1938. Sydney: New South Wales University Press.
27.
GhoshD. (2012). Another set of imperial turns?”. American Historical Review, 117, 772–793.
28.
GriffithsB. (2018). Deep time dreaming: Uncovering Ancient Australia. Melbourne: Black Inc.
29.
GriffithsT. (1987). Past silences: Aborigines and convicts in our history-making. Australian Cultural History, 6, 18–32.
30.
GriffithsT. (1996). Hunters and collectors: The antiquarian imagination in Australia. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
31.
GriffithsT. (2013). The Forest and the Trees. In ClarkA.AshtonP. (Eds.), Australian History Now (pp. 251–268). Sydney: New South.
32.
GrossmanM. (2003). Introduction. In M. Grossman (Ed.), Blacklines: Contemporary critical writing by Indigenous Australians (pp. 1–14). Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
33.
HaebichA. (2011). Forgetting Indigenous histories: Cases from the history of Australia’s stolen generations. Journal of Social History, 44, 1033–1046.
HamiltonG. (1880). (‘An Old Hand’). Experiences of a colonist forty years ago: A journey from Port Phillip to South Australia in 1839 and a Voyage from Port Phillip to Adelaide in 1846 by an Old Hand; with Illustrations. Adelaide: J. Williams.
36.
HealyC. (1997). From the ruins of colonialism: History as social memory. Melbourne: Cambridge University Press.
JohnstonA. (2018). ‘The Aboriginal Mother’: Poetry and politics. In J. Lydon & L. Ryan (Eds.), Remembering the Myall Creek Massacre (pp. 68–84). Sydney: New South Publishing.
42.
KarskensG. (2019). Life and death on Dyarubbin. Griffith Review, 63, 102–106.
43.
KarstedtS. (2009). The life course of collective memories: Persistency and change in West Germany between 1950 and 1970. Polish Sociological Review, 165, 27–38.
44.
Kay (Brogo)J. (1884, March1). On Mumbulla. Bega Standard.
45.
KearyA. (2009). Christianity, colonialism, and cross-cultural translation: Lancelot Threlkeld, Biraban, and the Awabakal. Aboriginal History, 33, 117–155.
46.
KleinK. L. (1999). Frontiers of Historical Imagination: Narrating the European Conquest of North America, 1890–1990. Berkeley: University of California Press.
47.
KuhnA. (2002). Family secrets: Acts of memory and imagination (2nd ed.). London: Verso.
48.
LakeM. (2016). and out of empire: Old labels and new histories. In A. Burton & D. Kennedy (Eds.), How empire shaped us (pp. 83–94). London: Bloomsbury.
49.
LydonJ. (2018). Witnessing Myall Creek. In LydonJ.RyanL. (Eds.), Remembering the Myall Creek Massacre (pp. 52–67). Sydney: New South Publishing.
50.
MacintyreS.ClarkA. (2003). The history wars. Carlton: Melbourne University Press.
51.
MacintyreS.JulianT. (1995). Introduction. In MacintyreS.ThomasJ. (Eds.), The discovery of Australian history, 1890-1939 (pp. 1–9). Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
52.
MandlerP. (2002). History and National Life. London: Profile Books.
53.
ManneR. (2011). Introduction. In StannerW. E. H. (Ed.), The dreaming and other essays (pp. 1–18). Melbourne: Black Inc.
54.
MaynardJ. (2003). Vision, voice and influence: Aboriginal activism in the 1930s. Australian Historical Studies, 34(121), 91–105.
55.
Melbourne International Exhibition. (1880). The official catalogue of the exhibits. Melbourne: Mason, Firth and McCutcheon.
56.
MestonA. L. (1941). A Junior History of Australia. 3rd ed. Oxford, Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
57.
MorganH. (1988). The guilt industry. IPA Review, 42(1), 17–20.
58.
MudieI. (1968). Letter to W.E.H. Stanner, 7 November 1968(MS3752: Series 18, Item 21). Canberra: Australian Institute for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies.
59.
MulvaneyD. J. (1975). The pre-history of Australia. Ringwood: Penguin.
60.
MundyG. C. (1855). Our antipodes: Or, residence and rambles in the Australasian colonies (3rd ed.). London: Richard Bently.
61.
NelsonE.SmithS.GrimshawP. (2002). Letters from Aboriginal Women of Victoria, 1867-1926(University of Melbourne History Research Papers 11). Melbourne: History Dept., University of Melbourne.
62.
New South Wales Department of Education. (1957). Syllabus in History. Sydney: New South Wales Department of Education.
63.
NugentM. (2003). Aboriginal family history: Some reflections. Australian Cultural History, 22, 143–153.
64.
NugentM. (2017). Entanglement of oral sources and colonial records. In ReidK.PaisleyF. (Eds.), Sources and methods in histories of colonialism (pp. 160–177). London: Routledge.
65.
PaisleyF. (2017). Living empire. In ReidK.PaisleyF. (Eds.), Sources and methods in histories of colonialism (pp. 178–193). London: Routledge.
66.
PortusG. V. (1932). Australia Since 1606. Melbourne: Oxford University Press.
67.
ReadP. (2013). Making Aboriginal history. In ClarkA.AshtonP. (Eds.), Australian history now (pp. 24–39). Sydney: New South.
68.
ReeceR. H. W. (1979). The Aborigines in Australian historiography. In MosesJ. A. (Ed.), Historical disciplines and culture in Australasia (pp. 253–281). St Lucia, QLD: University of Queensland Press.
69.
ReynoldsH. (1998). This whispering in our hearts. Sydney: Allan & Unwin.
70.
RobertH. (2016). Paved with good intentions: Terra Nullius, Aboriginal land rights and settler-colonial law. Ultimo, NSW: Halstead Press.
71.
RobinsonG. A. (1998). The Journals of George Augustus Robinson, Chief Protector, Port Phillip Aboriginal Protectorate (Vol. 4). Melbourne: Heritage Matters.
72.
RüsenJ. (2005a). History: Narration, interpretation, orientation. New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
73.
RüsenJ. (2005b). Preface. In StraubJ. (Ed.), Narration, identity, and historical consciousness (pp. vii–xii). New York, NY: Berghahn Books.
74.
ScottE. (1916). A short history of Australia. London: Oxford University Press.
75.
SpivakG. C. (1988). Can the Subaltern speak? In NelsonC.GrossbergL. (Eds.), Marxism and the interpretation of culture (pp. 271–313). Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.
76.
StannerW. E. H. (1968). After the dreaming, 1968 Boyer lectures. Sydney: Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
77.
StolerA. L. (2009). Along the archival grain: Epistemic anxieties and colonial common sense. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
78.
SutherlandA.SutherlandG. (1877). The History of Australia: From 1606–1876. Melbourne, Sydney and Adelaide: George Robertson.
79.
TammM. (2013). Beyond history and memory: New perspectives in memory studies. History Compass, 11, 458–473.
80.
ThomasJ. (1988). 1938: Past and present in an elaborate anniversary. Australian Historical Studies, 23(91), 77–89.
81.
ToutD. (2017). Encountering Indigeneity: Xavier Herbert, ‘Inky’ Stephensen and the Problems of Settler Nationalism. Cultural Studies Review, 23(2), 141–161.
82.
TrouillotM. (1995). Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History. Boston: Beacon Press.
83.
TyrrellI. (1991). American exceptionalism in an age of international history. The American History Review, 96, 1031–1055.
84.
TyrrellI. (2005). Historians in public: The practice of American history, 1890-1970. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
85.
VeraciniL. (2007). Historylessness: Australia as a settler colonial collective. Postcolonial Studies, 10, 271–285.
86.
WardR. (1952). Man Makes History. Sydney: Shakespeare Head Press.
87.
WestJ. (2011). The history of Tasmania (Vol. 1. 2). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
88.
WillardM. (1923). A history of the White Australia policy. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press.
89.
WinterJ. (2010). Thinking about Silence. In Ben Ze-evE.GinioR.WinterJ. (Eds.), Shadows of War (pp. 3–31). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
90.
WolfeP. (2005). Islam, Europe and Indian Nationalism: Towards a postcolonial transnationalism. In CurthoysA.LakeM. (Eds.), Connected worlds: History in transnational perspective (pp. 233–265). Canberra: ANU E-Press.
91.
WoodG. A. (1922). The Discovery of Australia. London: MacMillan & Co.
92.
WrightJ. (1945). Niggers Leap New England. Meanjin, 4(2), 85.
93.
YoungC. (1987). Aboriginal Education and the Teaching of History.Teaching History (NSW), 21(4), 9–14.
