Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2018-09
Gaining legitimacy: mentoring as an avenue to navigate the transition into a new academic workplace / Conseguir legitimidad: las mentorías como medio para gestionar la transición a un puesto académico distinto
This paper discusses the learning and development experiences of academics who make transitions between higher education institutions involving multiple communities. In these communities, they may act on the periphery as both newcomers and academics with established credentials that may have a significant impact on their participation. In acknowledging this, this paper uses Lave and Wenger’s concept of Community of Practice to better understand how these academics gain their legitimacy, and whether mentoring has a specific role to play in their development into full members of communities. Based on the analysis of the themes generated from 12 in-depth semi-structured interviews with academics who have experienced transitions between higher education institutions, this paper suggests that restricted access to a mentoring programme may lead these academics to question their status benefits and their development into full participants of communities. Referring to the examples of mentoring programmes used in other universities, this paper shows that among experienced academics, mentoring can contribute to their development and provide a range of psychosocial benefits from the increased level of support.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AllenT. D.EbyL. T.PoteetM. L.LentzE.LimaL. (2004). Career benefits associatedwith mentoring for protégés: A meta-analysis. Journal of Applied Psychology, 89, 137–149.
2.
BakerV. L.PiferM. J.GriffinK. A. (2014). Mentor-protégé fit. International Journal for Researcher Development, 5, 83–98.
3.
BarrettM. S.BallantyneJ.HarrisonS.TemmermanN. (2009, September). On building acommunity of practice: Reflective narratives of academic learning and growth. Reflective Practice: International and Multidisciplinary Perspectives, 10, 403–416.
4.
BeckettD.HagerP. (2002). Life, work and learning. London: Routledge.
5.
BERA (British Educational Research Association). (2011). Revised ethical guidelines for educational research. London: Author.
6.
BillettS. (2004). Workplace participatory practices: Conceptualising workplaces as learning environments. The Journal of Workplace Learning, 16, 312–324.
7.
BillettS.SomervilleM. (2004, July). Transformations at work: Identity and learning. Studies in Continuing Education, 26(2), 309–326.
8.
BoerenE.Lokhtina-AntoniouI.SakuraiY.HermanC.McAlpineL. (2015). Mentoring: A review of early-career researcher studies. Frontline Learning Research, 3, 68–80; Special issue.
9.
BoudD.SolomonN. (2003). “I don’t think I am a learner”: Acts of naming learners at work. Journal of Workplace Learning, 15, 326–331.
10.
BraunV.ClarkeV. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3, 77–101.
11.
BusherH.JamesN.PielaA.PalmerA. M. (2014). Transforming marginalised adult learners’ views of themselves: access to higher education courses in England. British Journal of Sociology of Education, 35, 800–817.
12.
CastellóM.IñestaA. (2012). Texts as artifacts-in-activity: Developing authorial identity and academic voice in writing academic research papers. In CastellóM.DonahueC. (eds.), University writing: Selves and texts in academic societies (pp. 179–200). Bingley, UK: Emerald.
13.
ClandininD. J.ConnellyF. M. (2000). Narrative inquiry: Experience and story in qualitative research. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.
14.
CohenE. (1994). Restructuring the classroom: Conditions for productive small groups. Review of Educational Research, 64, 1–35.
15.
CohenL.ManionL.MorrisonK. (2007). Research methods in education (6th ed.). London: Routledge Falmer.
16.
ConnorM.PokoraJ. (2007). Coaching and mentoring at work: Developing effective practice. Maidenhead: Open University Press.
17.
CoxM. D. (2013). The impact of communities of practice in support of early-career academics. International Journal for Academic Development, 18, 18–30.
18.
CreswellJ. W. (2003). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (2nd ed.). London: Sage.
19.
CrispG.CruzI. (2009). Mentoring college students: A critical review of the literature between 1990 and 2007. Research in Higher Education, 50, 525–545.
20.
CrossJ. J. (1989, January). A behavioural approach to class and pupil management in the comprehensive school. Educational Psychology in Practice: Theory, Research and Practice in Educational Psychology, 4, 198–204.
21.
CunninghamJ.HillierE. (2013). Informal learning in the workplace: Key activities and processes. Education + Training, 55, 37–51.
22.
EdwardsA. (2005). Let’s get beyond community and practice: The many meaning of learning by participating. Curriculum Journal, 16, 49–65.
23.
EhrichL.HansfordB.TennantL. (2004). Formal mentoring programmes in education and other professions: A review of the literature. Educational Administration Quarterly, 40, 518–540.
24.
EngeströmY. (1991). Developmental work research: Reconstructing expertise through expansive learning. In NurminenM.WeirG. (eds.), Human jobs and computer interfaces (pp. 265–290). New York, NY: North-Holland.
25.
ErautM. (2004, July). Informal learning in the workplace. Studies in Continuing Education, 26, 247–273.
26.
FowlerJ. L. (2017). Academics at work: Mentoring in research, teaching, and service. International Journal for Academic Development, 22, 319–330.
27.
FullerA. (2007). Critiquing theories of learning and communities of practice, Chapter 2 in. In HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (eds.), Communities of practice: Critical perspectives (pp. 17–29). London: Routledge.
28.
FullerA.UnwinL. (2003, December). Learning as apprentices in the contemporary UK workplace: Creating and managing expansive and restrictive participation. Journal of Education and Work, 16, 407–426.
29.
HansmanC. A. (2002). Mentoring: From Athena to the 21st century, Chapter 1. In HansmanC. A. (ed.), Critical perspectives on mentoring: Trends and issues. Information series no. 388 (pp. 1–5). Columbus, OH: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult, Career, and Vocational Education.
30.
HarlandT.StaniforthD. (2003, May/November). Academic development as academic work. International Journal of Academic Development, 8, 25–35.
31.
HemmingsB.HillD.SharpJ. G. (2013). Critical interactions shaping early academic career development in two higher education institutions. Issues in Educational Research, 23, 35–51.
32.
HodkinsonF. A.HodkinsonH.UnwinL. (2005, February). Learning as peripheral participation in communities of practice: A reassessment of key concepts in workplace learning. British Educational Research Journal, 31, 49–68.
33.
HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (2007). Introduction. communities of practice: A contested concept in flux, Chapter 1. In HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (eds.), Communities of practice: Critical perspectives (pp. 1–16). London: Routledge.
34.
IrbyB. J. (2013). Editor’s overview: Defining developmental relationships in mentoring for mentor/mentee dyads, for mentors, and for mentoring programs. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 21, 333–337.
35.
JamesN. (2007). The learning trajectories of ‘old-timers’: Academic identities and communities of practice in higher education, Chapter 11. In HughesJ.JewsonN.UnwinL. (eds.), Communities of practice: Critical perspectives (pp. 131–143). London: Routledge.
36.
JamesN.BusherH.SuttillB. (2015). We all know why we’re here’: Learning as a community of practice on access to HE courses. Journal of Further and Higher Education, 4, 765–779.
37.
JawitzJ. (2007, April). New academics negotiating communities of practice: Learning to swim with the big fish. Teaching in Higher Education, 12, 185–197.
38.
KislovR.HarveyG.WalsheK. (2011). ‘Collaborations for leadership in applied health research and care: Lessons from the theory of communities of practice’, Implementation Science, 6, (accessed15October2015). http://www.implementationscience.com/content/6/1/64
39.
KnightP. T.TrowlerP. R. (1999). It takes a village to raise a child: Mentoring and the socialisation of new entrants to the academic professions. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 7, 23–34.
LeathwoodC.ReadB. (2013). Research policy and academic performativity: Compliance, contestation and complicity. Studies in Higher Education, 38, 1162–1174.
42.
Leont’evA. N. (2009). The Development of Mind. Kettering, OH: Erythrós Press.
43.
LokhtinaI. (2016, July). Promoting academics’ development in multiple communities through creating an ‘expansive’ workplace learning environment (Cypriot case study). In JamesN. ed., Proceeding of the 45th SCUTREA conference: Adult education in Austere times (pp. 172–180). Leicester: Vaughan Centre for Lifelong Learning, University of Leicester.
44.
MathiasH. (2005, November). Mentoring on a programme for new university teachers: A partnership in revitalizing and empowering collegiality. International Journal for Academic Development, 10, 95–106.
45.
McKinseyE. (2016). Faculty mentoring undergraduates: The nature, development, and benefits of mentoring relationships. Teaching & Learning Inquiry, 4, (accessed 21 September 2017). http://dx.doi.org/10.20343/teachlearninqu.4.1.5.
46.
MeghnagiS. (2004). Work organization, ‘fields of activities’ and workers’ competence: The case of Italian small firms, Chapter 4. In RainbirdH.FullerA.MunroA. (eds.), Workplace learning in context (pp. 54–70). London & New York, NY: Routledge.
47.
NgL. L.PembertonJ. (2013). Research-based communities of practice in UK higher education. Studies in Higher Education, 38, 1522–1539.
48.
NoeR. A.GreenbergerD. B.WangS. (2002). Mentoring: What we know and where we might go. Research in Personnel and Human Resources Management, 21, 129–174.
49.
OttenM. (2009, October). Academicus interculturalis? Negotiating interculturality in academic communities of practice. Intercultural Education, 20, 407–417.
50.
PalmerR. J.HuntA. N.NealM.WuetherickB. (2015). Mentoring, undergraduate research, and identity development: A conceptual review and research agenda. Mentoring & Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 23, 411–426.
51.
PavlovI. P. (1927). Conditioned Reflexes. An Investigation of Physiological Activity of Cerebral Cortex. Oxford: University Press.
52.
RaginsB. R.CottonJ. (1991). Easier said than done: Gender differences in perceived barriers to gaining a mentor. Academy of Management Journal, 34, 939–951.
53.
RaginsB. R.KramK. E. (2007). The roots and meaning of mentoring. In RaginsB. R.KramK. E. (Eds.), The handbook of mentoring at work: Theory, research, and practice (pp. 3–15). Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.
RobertsB. (2002). Biographical research. Buckingham, PH: Open University Press.
56.
SkinnerB. F. (1974). About behaviorism. New York, NY: Random House, Inc.
57.
SfardA. (1998, March). On two metaphors for learning and the dangers of choosing just one. Educational Researcher, 27, 4–13.
58.
ShanahanJ. O.Ackley-HolbrookE.HallE.StewardK.WalkingtonH. (2015). Ten salient practices of undergraduate research mentors: A review of the literature. Mentoring and Tutoring: Partnership in Learning, 23, 359–376.
59.
TrowlerP.KnightP. T. (2000). Coming to know in higher education: Theorising faculty entry to new work contexts. Higher Education Research & Development, 19, 27–42.
60.
TummonsJ. (2012, June). Theoretical trajectories within communities of practice in higher education research. Higher Education Research & Development, 31, 299–310.
61.
TummonsJ.InglebyE. (2012, January-March). The problematics of mentoring, and the professional learning of trainee teachers in the english further education sector. International Journal of Adult Vocational Education and Technology, 3, 29–39.
62.
UnderhillC. M. (2006). The effectiveness of mentoring programmes in corporate settings: A meta-analytical review of the literature. Journal of Vocational Behaviour, 68, 292–307.
63.
ValsanC.SprouleR. (2008, December). The invisible hands behind the student evaluation of teaching: The rise of the new managerial elite in the governance of higher education. Journal of Economic Issues, 42, 939–958.
64.
ViskovicA. R. (2005). Community of practice’ as a framework for supporting tertiary teachers’ informal workplace learning’. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 57, 389–410.
65.
VygotskyL. S. (1978). Mind in Society: the Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
66.
WarhurstR. P. (2008, August). Cigars on the flight-deck’: New lecturers’ participatory learning within workplace communities of practice. Studies in Higher Education, 33, 453–467.
67.
WengerE. (1998). Communities of Practice: Learning meaning and identity. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
68.
WengerE.WhiteN.SmithJ. D. (2009). Digital Habitats: Stewarding technology for communities. Portland, OR: CPsquare.
69.
WilesR.CrowG.HeathS.CharlesV. (2008, December). The management of confidentiality and anonymity in social research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 11, 417–428.
70.
WilkinsC.BusherH.KakosM.MohamedC.SmithJ. (2012, February). Crossing borders: New teachers co-constructing professional identity in performative times. Professional Development in Education, 38, 65–77.
71.
YandellJ.TurveyA. (2007, August). Standards or communities of practice? Competing models of workplace learning and development. British Educational Research Journal, 33, 533–550.
