Public procurement is a vehicle by which governments can provide direct support to small business. The public sector market is significant and attractive to suppliers of all sizes, yet the current UK government is the latest to feel the need to implement a variety of measures in an attempt to improve the chances of success for smaller suppliers. In this context I have undertaken a critical review of the existing evidence relating to this issue. I have found support for the policy to encourage small and medium-sized enterprise suppliers but also that many barriers, some first identified twenty years ago, still remain. Whilst various remedies have been proposed, it appears that public procurers lack clear priorities and objectives. This, together with a lack of regular and comprehensive supply data, is hindering improvement.
APPSBG, 2009Report on SME Access to Public ProcurementAll Party Parliamentary Small Business Group, Association of Chartered Certified Accountants, London
2.
BannockGPeacockA, 1989Governments and Small Business (Paul Chapman, London)
3.
BERR, 2007SME Supply UpdateDepartment for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, Department for Trade and Industry, London
4.
BIS, 2012aStrengthening UK Supply Chains: Public Procurement. Tunnelling: A Capability Analysis Department for Business Innovation and Skills (The Stationery Office, London)
5.
BIS, 2012bBoosting Finance Options for Business: Government Response to the Industry Taskforce Department for Business Innovation and Skills (The Stationery Office, London)
6.
BlackburnRSmallboneD, 2011, “Policy support for SMEs”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy29571–576
7.
BovisC, 1996Public Procurement and Small and Medium Sized Enterprises in the United Kingdom and the Republic of IrelandCertified Accountants Educational Trust, London
8.
BovisC, 1998, “The regulation of public procurement as a key element of European economic law”European Law Journal4234–237
CabrasI, 2011, “Mapping the spatial patterns of public procurement: A case study from a peripheral local authority in Northern England”International Journal of Public Sector Management24187–205
13.
ClarkMIIIMoutrayC, 2004, “The future of small businesses in the US federal government marketplace”Journal of Public Procurement4450–470
14.
CRiSPS, 2006Delivering Supply Strategy: What Considerations Should Local Authorities Take into Account When Developing a Strategy to Trade with SMEsUniversity of Bath
15.
CurranJBlackburnR, 1994Small Firms and Local Economic Networks (Paul Chapman, London)
16.
DenesTA, 1997, “Do small business set-asides increase the cost of government contracting”Public Administration Review57441–444
17.
ErridgeA, 2007, “Public procurement, public value and the Northern Ireland project”Public Administration851023–1043
18.
ErridgeAFeeRMcLlroyJ, 1998, “Involvement of SMEs in public procurement”Public Procurement Law Review737–51
19.
FeeRErridgeAHennigan, 2002, “SMEs and government purchasing in Northern Ireland: Problems and opportunities”European Business Review 14 326–334
20.
FreshMinds, 2008, “Evaluating SME experiences of government procurement”, Scorecard Working Party, FreshMinds, London
21.
FSB, 2008Keep Trade Local. Public Procurement: Helping Small Business SucceedFederation of Small Business, London
22.
GershonP, 2004Releasing Resources to the Front LineHM Treasury, London
23.
GHK, 2010Evaluation of SMEs' Access to Public Procurement Markets in the EU: Final ReportDG Enterprise and Industry, European Commission, Brussels
24.
GloverA, 2008Accelerating The SME Economic Engine: Through Transparent, Simple and Strategic ProcurementHM Treasury, London
25.
HM Government, 2010The Coalition: Our Programme for GovernmentCabinet Office, London
26.
KarjalainenKKemppainenK, 2008, “The involvement of small- and medium-sized enterprises in public procurement: Impact of resource perceptions, electronic systems and enterprise size”Journal of Purchasing and Supply Management14230–240
27.
LoaderK, 2005, “Supporting SMEs through government purchasing activity”International Journal of Entrepreneurship and Innovation617–26
28.
LoaderK, 2007, “The challenge of competitive procurement: Value for money versus small business support”Public Money and Management27307–314
29.
LoaderK, 2011, “Are public sector procurement models and practices hindering small suppliers? Evidence from English local authorities”Public Money and Management31287–294
30.
MacManusS, 1991, “Why businesses are reluctant to sell to governments”Public Administration Review51328–344
31.
McQuaidR W, 2002, “Entrepreneurship and ICT industries: Support from regional and local policies”Regional Studies36909–919
32.
MichaelisCMcGuireMFergusonL, 2003SBS Diversity in Public Sector Procurement Survey: Final ReportDatabuild, Birmingham
33.
MorandP, 2003, “SMEs and public procurement policy”Review of Economic Design8301–318
34.
MunozS, 2009, “Social enterprise and public sector voices on procurement”Social Enterprise Journal569–82
NERA Economic Consulting, 2005, “A study of the benefits of public sector procurement from small businesses”, report prepared for the Small Business Service, Department of Trade and Industry, London
37.
O'BrienG, 1993, “Public procurement and the small or medium sized enterprise”Public Procurement Law Review282–92
38.
OGC, 2003Delivering your AgendaOffice of Government Commerce (The Stationery Office, London)
39.
OGC, SBS, 2001Smaller Supplier … Better Value? Office of Government Commerce and Small Business Service (HMSO, London)
40.
PeckFCabrasI, 2011, “The impact of local authority procurement on local economies: The case of Cumbria, North West England”Public Policy and Administration26307–331
41.
PickemellDKayAPackhamGMillerC, 2011, “Competing agendas in public procurement: An empirical analysis of opportunities and limits in the UK for SMEs”Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy29641–658
42.
PreussL, 2011, “On the contribution of public procurement to entrepreneurship and small business policy”Entrepreneurship and Regional Development23787–814
43.
PWC, 2011, “Understanding commissioning behaviours: Commissioning and competition in the public sector”, report for the Office of Fair Trading, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP, London
44.
QuayleMQuayleS, 2000, “The impact of strategic procurement in the UK further and higher education sectors”The International Journal of Public Sector Management13260–284
45.
ReedTLunaPPikeW, 2005, “Balancing socioeconomic and public procurement reform goals: Effective metrics for measuring small business participation in public procurement”, in Challenges in Public Procurement: An International Perspective Eds ThaiKAraujoACarterRCallenderGDrabkinDGrimmREjlskovKLloydRMcCueCTelgenJ (PrAcademics Press, Boca Raton, FL) pp 81–100
46.
SmallboneDNorthD, 1994, “Targeting established SMEs: Does their age matter?”International Small Business Journal1347–64
47.
SmithPHobbsA, 2002, “SMEs and public sector procurement, research report prepared for the Small Business Service by Shreeveport Management Consultancy, London
48.
StartE, 2003Small Business and Public ProcurementFederation of Small Businesses, Blackpool
49.
StoreyD J, 1994Understanding the Small Business Sector (Routledge, London)
50.
TemponiCCuiW, 2008, “Factors impacting participation of Hispanic small businesses in government contracting in the USA”Journal of Small Business and Enterprise Development15504–526
51.
WalkerHPreussL, 2008, “Fostering sustainability through sourcing from small businesses: Public sector perspectives”Journal of Cleaner Production161600–1609
