Overview + Detail in a Tomahawk Mission-to-Platform Assignment Tool: Applying Information Visualization in Support of an Asset Allocation Planning Task

Abstract

Information visualization techniques such as overview + detail displays have traditionally been applied and studied in domains with static data sets supporting information retrieval tasks. This study examines how these techniques can be extended to the design of interfaces for decision support systems (DSSs). Specifically, we developed a computerized decision support tool to assist Naval Tomahawk Strike Coordinators in the complex process of assigning a set of planned missions to a set of available launch platforms based on a number of different constraints and objectives, and compared user performance on two realistic scenarios (a within-subjects factor) across two versions of this tool (a between-subjects factor). The first version of the Mission-to-Platform Assignment Tool provided users with only a set of detail displays when assigning missions, whereas the second version had an additional, abstracted ‘overview’ display that allowed users to see the effect of early decisions on later decisions. The results showed that subjects performing this planning task with the overview + details display version completed scenarios, on average, 21% faster, with 22% fewer errors and with 74% fewer required workspace navigation activities than a comparable group using just the detail displays version. Subjects in the former group also rated their situational awareness 14% higher than those subjects without the overview display.

Keywords

Overview + detail display decision support system (DSS)information visualization planning asset allocation command and control

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Card

Mackinaly

Shneiderman

. Readings in Information Visualization: Using Vision to Think. Morgan Kaufmann: San Francisco, CA, 1999.

Sedig

Rowhani

Morey

Liang

. Application of information visualization techniques to the design of a mathematical mindtool: A usability study. Information Visualization 2003; 3: 142–159.

Card

. Information visualization. In: Jacko

Sears

(Eds). The Human-Computer Interaction Handbook: Fundamentals, Evolving Technologies, and Emerging Applications. Erlbaum: Mahwah, NJ, 2003.

Rouse

. Human-computer interaction in the control of dynamic systems. Computing Surveys 1981; 13: 71–99.

Greene

Marchionini

Plaisant

Shneiderman

. Previews and overviews in digital libraries: Designing surrogates to support visual information seeking. Journal of the American Society for Information Science 2000; 51: 380–393.

Suh

Woodruff

Rosenholtz

Glass

. Popout prism: adding perceptual principles to overview+detail document interfaces. Proceedings of ACM CHI 2002 Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems, 2002. Minneapolis, MN, 251–258.

Munzner

. Exploring large graphs in 3D hyperbolic space. IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications 1998; 18: 18–23.

Baudisch

Good

Stewart

. Focus plus context screens: combining display technology with visualization techniques. Proceedings of the ACM Symposium on User Interface Software and Technology, 2001. Orlando, FL, 31–40.

Flider

Bailey

. An evaluation of techniques for controlling focus+context screens. 2004 Conference on Graphics Interface 2004, (London, Ontario, Canada) 135–144.

10.

Shneiderman

. The eyes have it: a task by data type taxonomy for information visualizations. 7996 IEEE Symposium on Visual Languages 1996, (Boulder, CO), IEEE, New York, 1996 336–343.

11.

North

Shneiderman

. A taxonomy of multiple window coordinations, 1997, University of Maryland. CS-TR-3854.

12.

Guerlain

Smith

. Decision support in medical systems. In: Parasuraman

Mouloua

(Eds). Automation and Human Performance. Theory and Applications. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates: Mahwah, NJ, 1996; 385–406.

13.

Roth

Patterson

Mumaw

. Cognitive engineering: Issues in user-centered system design. In: Marciniak

(Ed). Encyclopedia of Software Engineering. Wiley-Interscience, John Wiley St Sons: New York, 2002; 163–179.

14.

Björk

Holmquist

Redström

. A Framework for Focus+Context Visualization. IEEE Information Visualization, IEEE Press: New York, 1999.

15.

Andrienko

. Informed spatial decisions through coordinated views. Information Visualization 2003; 2: 270–285.

16.

Woods

Roth

Stubler

Mumaw

. Navigating through large display networks in dynamic control applications. Proceedings of the Human Factors Society 34th Annual Meeting 1990, (Orlando, FL), Human Factors Society (Santa Monica, CA) 2001 396–399.

17.

Burns

. Putting it all together: Improving display integration through ecological displays. Human Factors 2000; 42: 226–241.

18.

Hornbæk

Bederson

Plaisant

. Navigation patterns and usability of zoomable user interfaces with and without an overview. ACM Transactions on Computer-Human Interaction 2002; 9: 362–389.

19.

Plaisant

Carr

Shneiderman

. Image-browser taxonomy and guidelines for designers. IEEE Software 1995; 12: 21–32.

20.

Guerlain

Jamieson

Bullemer

Blair

. The MPC elucidator: A case study in the design for human-automation interaction. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics – Part A: Systems and Humans 2002; 32: 25–40.

21.

Jamieson

Guerlain

. Operator interaction with model-based predictive controllers in petrochemical refining. Human Performance, Situation Awareness and Automation: User-Centered Design for the New Millenium 2000, (Savannah, GA) 172–177.

22.

Smoot

Bass

Guerlain

Pearson

. Visualizations of near-optimal protein sequence alignments. Information Visualization 2005; 4: 224–237.

23.

Allen

, Interface Design and Team Structure in a Collaborative Environment. Master's Thesis, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia: Charlottesville, VA 2004.

24.

Cummings

Guerlain

. Developing operator capacity estimates for supervisory control of autonomous vehicles. Human-Factors (accepted for publication).

25.

Cummings

, Designing decision support systems for a revolutionary command and control domains. Doctoral Dissertation, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia: Charlottesville, VA 2003.

26.

O'Hargan

, Design of a Resource Allocation Planning System (RAPS). Master's Thesis, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia: Charlottesville, VA 2005.

27.

Willis

, Tactical Tomahawk weapon control system user interface analysis and design. Master's Thesis, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia: Charlottesville, VA 2001.

28.

Cushing

, A measurement of the effectiveness of an overview display for the mission to launch platform assignment process essential to the Tomahawk strike coordinator. Master's Thesis, Department of Systems and Information Engineering, University of Virginia: Charlottesville, VA 2003.

29.

North

Shneiderman

. Snap-together visualization: Can users construct and operate coordinated visualizations? International journal of Human Computer Studies 2000; 53: 715–739.

30.

Rivera

Chignell

Davey

. Effect of overview displays on situation assessment. Human Factors and Ergonomics Society 42nd Annual Meeting 1998 (Chicago, IL), Human Factors and Ergonomics Society (Santa Monica, CA) 1998, 258–262.