Abstract
Objective
To review reported bites by venomous snakes in pregnant women.
Methods
This is a review of Medline/PubMed articles on venomous snakebites occurring during pregnancy reported in the English literature from 1966 to May 2009.
Results
Two hundred thirteen venomous snakebites were reported in pregnant women. The overall case-fatality rate in the pregnant females was approximately 4%, and the fetal loss rate was approximately 20%.
Conclusions
Although rare, venomous bites and stings during pregnancy may have a significant adverse effect on the fetus as well as the mother.
Introduction
Millions of people are bitten or stung by venomous animals yearly throughout the world. 1 Estimates of snakebites range from 1.2 million to 5.5 million annually with envenomation occurring in 420 000 to 1 841 000 resulting in 20 000 to 94 000 deaths. 2 Other estimates suggest that more than 150 000 deaths may occur annually. 3 Most fatalities occur in developing countries where venomous snakes are plentiful, human populations are dense, and rapid transport and intensive medical treatment facilities are lacking. However, the English literature on snakebite envenomation of pregnant females is limited. In studies from South Africa, India, and Sri Lanka, pregnant women have accounted for 0.4% to 1.8% of hospitalized snakebite victims. 4 Venomous snakebite in the pregnant female may lead to a poor outcome in both the mother and the fetus. Previous literature reviews found overall fetal deaths ranging from 38% to 43%5,6 with maternal deaths of approximately 10% after a venomous snakebite.
Snake venoms are primarily composed of mixtures of proteins and polypeptides with various properties. Many proteins have enzymatic activities, whereas others produce toxic cellular effects. Actions of snake venoms can be broadly classified as inflammatory, cytotoxic, neurotoxic, and hemotoxic. The composition of venom varies with the species of snake, age of the snake, geographic locality, and time of year. 7 Other factors influencing the effect of venom on humans include the amount of venom injected and the age and health of the victim. 8 It is not surprising then that the effect of a venomous snakebite on a pregnant female would differ by species of snake.
Antivenoms, which may be used in the treatment of the envenomed expectant mother, can cause anaphylactic reactions that may have an adverse effect on the mother or fetus. 4 The fetal death rate has been reported to be up to 55% to 58% in mothers given antivenom.5,6 This review updates and discusses maternal and fetal outcomes in pregnant humans that suffered a venomous snakebite.
Materials and methods
A search of the U.S. National Library of Medicine Medline/PubMed database for articles on venomous animal bites and stings and pregnancy worldwide for the years 1966 through May 2009 was conducted (
Results
There were 213 cases of snakebite in pregnant females identified in this literature review. As shown in Table 1, at least 87 taxa of snakes involved in bites were reported. In an additional 38 cases, a common name of the snake or general description (eg, viper) was reported, and in 88 cases, the identity of the snake causing the envenomation was unknown or not reported. Due to the variation in venom composition and possible differences in outcome by species of snake, Table 2 shows maternal and fetal outcome when a specific genus or species was provided in the literature. In the majority of cases of fetal death, the snake species was unidentified or not reported.
Snakebite reported during pregnancy
NR, not reported or no information.
Presumed received antivenom.
Death attributed to supine hypotensive syndrome.
Malformations and died a few days after birth.
Mother developed serum sickness from antivenom.
May include cases reported by Barry from 2001 to 2005.
Reports from 2006 and 2007 only, 4 additional rattlesnake cases reported in Seifert.
Taxa of snake involved in envenomation during pregnancy
When reported (99 cases), victims ranged in age from 14 to 46 years with an average age of 26 years. In most cases, no information on race was reported. The gestational age of the mother (in weeks) at time of envenomation was reported in 112 cases. The gestational age averaged 22.1 weeks with a range of 6 to 37 weeks at time of bite. In an additional 87 cases, only the trimester of pregnancy was reported: 29 in the first trimester, 35 in the second trimester, and 23 in the third trimester.
Of the envenomations, there were 9 maternal deaths (9 of 213) reported. The case-fatality rate was approximately 4.2%. No maternal deaths from a native U.S. species were reported. There were 41 deaths of the fetus or neonate reported. The vast majority were in utero fetal deaths. The deaths in the neonates occurred from 30 minutes to 8 days after birth. The case-fatality rate was approximately 19.2%.
In most cases, there is no mention of the specific details underlying the cause of death or autopsy reports in either the mother or fetus. However, abruptio placentae were reported to have occurred in 8 cases, with fetal deaths noted in 6 of these cases. Malformations were reported in 3 cases: a case of hydrocephalus and polydactyly; a case of dilatation of the cerebral ventricles and intracranial hemorrhage; and a case of hydrocephalus with nonspecified multiple malformations. Where reported (26 cases), in the cases of fetal death the average maternal age was 27.4 years compared with 25 years in cases (67 cases) with no fetal deaths. The average gestational age (28 cases) at time of fetal death was 20.2 weeks compared with 22.6 weeks in cases (67 cases) without fetal death. Eleven fetal deaths occurred during the first trimester, 7 during the second trimester, and 10 during the third trimester.
Ninety-six mothers received antivenom treatment. Of these cases, 2 (2.1%) mothers died. Twenty-nine (30.2%) fetuses/neonates died from mothers that had received antivenom. In 106 cases where no antivenom was reported being given or unknown if given to the mother, 7 (6.6%) mothers and 12 (11.3%) fetal/neonatal deaths were reported. There was 1 case of serum sickness reported in a 46-year-old mother that received antivenom at 14 weeks gestation, but she delivered a healthy child at term.
Discussion
Few reviews of pregnant women bitten by snakes have been published. Dunnihoo et al 5 reviewed the literature and found 50 cases, but details were only available for 30 of the victims. Pantanowitz and Guidozzi 9 reported 12 additional cases, 9 found in the literature and 3 cases reported by personal communication (R.S.M. Blaylock, 1996). Following these two literature reviews, Seneviratne et al 4 reported snakebites in 39 pregnant women treated at 2 medical centers in Sri Lanka from 1997 to 1999 at one hospital and from 1996 to 2001 at another. Langley 6 reviewed the literature from 1996 to 2002 and noted 85 cases had been reported in the English literature with 8 maternal deaths and 32 fetal/infant deaths. In a recent report, Seifert et al 10 briefly discuss 65 cases of snake envenomations during pregnancy reported to the American Association of Poison Control Centers from 2001 to 2005.
From a review of the limited literature, abortions and deaths in fetuses/infants after a mother has been bitten by a venomous snake are not unusual. Seneviratne et al 4 reported that nearly 30% of the envenomated pregnant mothers had a spontaneous abortion. Malz 11 reported that 3 of 14 (21%) snakebites resulted in abortion or infant death. Dunnihoo et al 5 noted that of 30 reports with some detailed information available, 6 spontaneous abortions, 7 fetal deaths, and 1 elective abortion occurred, a 43% fetal loss occurrence (excluding the elective abortion). Reid et al 12 reported 1 of 5 (20%) women aborted after a venomous bite. Dao et al 13 reported 4 snakebites in pregnant women leading to fetal death or abortion in 3 of them. One mother was in her fifth month of pregnancy and aborted 2 days later, and another was at term when snakebite resulted in death of the fetus.
The average age of the mothers where age was reported was 26 years. The mean gestational age was 22.1 weeks. The average age of the mothers that aborted or had fetal demise was slightly older than that of mothers that did not have fetal demise. The average length of gestation at the time of fetal demise or abortion was 20.2 weeks. Whereas some studies report the risk of poor fetal outcomes to be more common if envenomed in the first trimester, 4 this review found nearly the same number of fetal deaths occurred in pregnant females bitten in either the first or third trimesters. However, in many cases the gestational age was not reported, so it is not possible to state whether the length of gestation at time of envenomation is a risk factor.
Of the 213 cases identified, limited information on the type of envenomating snake was provided in 125 cases; however, an exact identification was provided in much fewer. Without the correct identification of the species of snake, it is unclear, but likely, that certain species are more likely to cause adverse harm to the mother and fetus. For example, in the report by Seifert et al, moderate or major adverse effects were reported in 70% of rattlesnake bites and were the only snake group coded with major adverse outcomes. 10 As seen in Table 2, almost half of the victims bitten by a Russell's viper had fetal demise. However, how soon the patient is seen and treated after the snakebite may have a more significant impact on maternal and/or fetal outcome than the species of snake involved in the envenomation. There were no maternal deaths reported from envenomation by U.S. native species and only 2 fetal deaths reported. 10 ,14,15 This may reflect more rapid access to health care and availability of antivenom in the United States or possibly less venomous species.
Several mechanisms have been proposed to explain fetal deaths or abortions after snakebite including fetal anoxia associated with maternal shock after envenomation, direct effect of the venom on the fetus, hemorrhages into the placenta and uterine wall causing abruptio placentae, premature uterine contractions initiated by the venom, pyrexia and cytokine release after tissue damage, maternal hemorrhage with acute fetal anemia causing in utero fetal death, supine hypotension syndrome, and potential maternal anaphylaxis to antivenom. 9 ,13–17 Eight cases of abruptio placentae were found in this review. It has been reported that in a few cases, mothers had systemic envenomation without signs of local envenomation. 18
Venom from various species of snakes has been shown to cause uterine contractions in animals and in isolated uterine tissue. Venoms may act directly on uterine muscle or may act indirectly by causing the release of or potentiating the effect of bradykinins on uterine muscle. 19 –23 Venom components may exert a direct toxic effect on parts of the placenta. 24 Some components may cross the placenta and adversely affect the fetus in the absence of, or before, seriously affecting the mother. 18
Malformations were noted in 3 cases. Senevirante et al
4
described a woman bitten by a Russell's viper during her 16th week of pregnancy who later gave birth to a child with hydrocephalus and polydactyly. Malz
11
reported a woman bitten by a viper in her 12th week that 6 months later delivered a child with multiple malformations and hydrocephalus who died a few days later. Entman and Moise
15
report a woman with copperhead envenomation and apparent anaphylaxis to antivenom therapy in her 28th week of gestation. She was treated with epinephrine, isoproterenol, methylprednisolone, and diphenhydramine. Six weeks later, she had spontaneous rupture of the membranes and delivered an infant with low Apgar scores. Ultrasound of the baby's head disclosed dilatation of the ventricles and echogenic changes consistent with intracranial hemorrhage. The infant died 4 days later. Though the cause-effect relationship between envenomation and malformations in these 3 cases is unknown, it is possible that snake venom can cause embryotoxic and teratogenic effects. The venom of
Antivenom is the required treatment for severe snakebite envenomations. Of the 213 cases, 96 mothers received antivenom. Two mothers that received antivenom died. The effect of antivenom on the fetus remains unclear. Senevirante et al 4 reported 10 abortions and 1 malformation in 11 of 17 (64.7 %) patients treated with antivenom. However, they did not find the administration of antivenom to be an independent risk factor for adverse fetal outcome. Poor fetal outcome was associated with symptoms of systemic envenomation, and the period of amenorrhea was 18 weeks or less in all cases where the mother aborted. Senevirante et al 4 noted that in many instances, details on the type of antivenom administered or the circumstances of treatment was lacking. In this updated literature review, of 96 women that received antivenom, 29 fetal deaths occurred. Only 2 (2.1%) maternal deaths have been reported in mothers that received antivenom. This is in contrast with 7 (6.6%) maternal deaths in cases that did not receive antivenom. Whereas acute adverse effects from the use of antivenom have been reported in the mothers, 2 only 1 case of serum sickness has been reported in a pregnant person. 28 From the limited number of cases reported, it appears likely that antivenom is effective in preventing maternal deaths, that adverse reactions in the mother can be readily managed, and that delayed serum sickness is rare. Although the fetal death rate was higher in cases where the mother received antivenom (30.2% vs11.3%), this may reflect more significant envenomation, and the mother (and fetus) may have been more likely to die if antivenom was withheld. While the safety of antivenom in pregnancy is unclear, the risks of withholding likely outweigh the risks of administering in correct clinical scenarios. If the mother develops an acute anaphylactic reaction to the antivenom, ephedrine or phenylephrine may be preferred over epinephrine as epinephrine may adversely affect placental blood flow properties.15,29
Limitations of this study include a retrospective review of case reports of variable quality and likely underestimates the incidence of snakebites in pregnancy, as nonvenomous snakebites or dry bites or venomous snakebites causing minimal symptoms are often not reported. There may also be an overestimate of the severity of snakebite in pregnancy as the more sensational cases or ones that lead to death are more likely to be published. Many reports also do not identify the species of snake or used generic terms such as
Conclusion
Venomous animal bites and stings during pregnancy are rarely reported. Unfortunately, among previously documented cases of snakebite during pregnancy, the occurrences of fetal and maternal deaths were high (38% to 43% and 10%, respectively). However, the more recent literature seems to show an improvement in both the maternal and the fetal outcomes. With inclusion of the most recent case reports, the overall rate of fetal loss is now around 20% and maternal case-fatality rate is about 4% to 5%. Envenomations during pregnancy should be reported so that additional information on medical management and fetal outcomes can be evaluated. More animal studies and human investigations are needed to evaluate the effect of snake antivenom on pregnant mothers, embryos, and fetuses.
