In this study, preservice teachers viewed clips from three documentary films that presented multiple experiences of contemporary immigrants and refugees. Our focus in the study was how preservice teachers analyzed the three films. Specifically, we examined how elementary, middle grades, and secondary preservice teachers analyzed, both from a cognitive and affective stance, clips of documentary films about the difficult topic of contemporary immigration.
BarteldsH.SavenijeG.M.van BoxtelC.Students’ and teachers’ beliefs about historical empathy in secondary history educationTheory & Research in Social Education4842020529–551
2.
BartonK.C.LevstikL.S.Teaching history for the common good. Lawrence Earlbaum Associates2004
3.
BolerM.Feeling power: Emotions and education1999Routledge
4.
BritzmanD.P.Lost subjects, contested objects: Toward a psychoanalytic inquiry of learning1998State university of New York press
5.
BuchananL.B.HilburnJ.Riding la Bestiá: Preservice teachers’ responses to documentary counter-narratives of U.S. immigrationJournal of Teacher Education6752016408–42310.1177/0022487116660153
6.
BuchananL.B.From Freedom Riders to The Children's March: Civil rights documentaries as catalysts for historical empathySocial Education782201491–95
7.
BuchananL.B.Elementary preservice teachers’ navigation of racism and whiteness through inquiry with historical documentary filmJournal of Social Studies Research4022015137–15410.1016/j.jssr.2015.06.006
8.
EndacottJ.L.Reconsidering affective engagement in historical empathyTheory & Research in Social Education38120106–49
9.
EndacottJ.L.BrooksS.An updated theoretical and practical model of historical empathySocial Studies Research and Practice8201341–58
10.
EpsteinT.PeckC.L.Teaching and learning difficult histories in international contexts2018Routledge
11.
FitchettP.G.SalasS.“You lie—that's not true”: Immigration and preservice teacher educationAction in Teacher Education32201096–104
12.
GarrettH.J.The routing and re-routing of difficult knowledge: Social studies teachers encounter when the Levees BrokeTheory & Research in Social Education392011320–347
13.
GarrettH.J.Learning to be in the world with others: Difficult knowledge and social studies education2017Peter Lang
14.
GarrettH.J.AlveyE.Exploring the emotional dynamics of a political discussionTheory & Research in Social Education49120211–26
15.
GarrettH.J.KerrS.L.Theorizing the use of aesthetic texts in social studies educationTheory & Research in Social Education442016505–531
16.
GlaserB.G.StraussA.L.The discovery of grounded theory1967Aldine
17.
GrossM.H.TerraL.Teaching and learning the difficult past: Comparative perspectives2019Routledge
18.
HelmsingM.E.Virtuous subjects: A critical analysis of the affective substance of social studies educationTheory & Research in Social Education4212014127–140
19.
HessD.From “Banished” to “Brother Outsider,” “Miss Navajo” to “An InconvenientTruth”: Documentary films as perspective-laden narrativesSocial Education7142007194–199
20.
Hilburn, J., Buchanan, L.B., & Journell, W. (in press). Discourses of immigration and the mediating influence of documentary film.. Action in Teacher Education. doi:https://doi.org/10.1080/01626620.2021.1883151.
21.
HilburnJ.JournellW.BuchananL.B.A content analysis of immigration in traditional, new, and non-gateway state standards for U.S. History and CivicsThe High School Journal9932016234–25110.1353/hsj.2016.0008
22.
HuijgenT.van BoxtelC.van de GriftW.HolthuisP.Toward historical perspective taking: Students’ reasoning when contextualizing the actions of people in the pastTheory & Research in Social Education4512017110–114
23.
JournellW.Framing controversial identity issues in schools: The case of HB2, bathroom equity, and transgender studentsEquity & Excellence in Education5042017339–35410.1080/10665684.2017.1393640
24.
KleinS.Preparing to teach a slavery past: History teachers and educators as navigators of historical distanceTheory & Research in Social Education45201775–10910.1080/00933104.2016.1213677
25.
(Producers and Directors.)MalpasC.KnottL.Refugee [motion picture]. United kingdom: Netflix2016
26.
MarcusA.S.It is as it was: Feature film in the history classroomThe Social Studies962200561–67
27.
MarcusA.S.MetzgerS.A.PaxtonR.J.StoddardJ.Teaching history with film: Strategies for secondary social studies2nd ed.2018Routledge
28.
MarcusA.S.StoddardJ.D.Tinseltown as teacher: Hollywood film in the high school history classroomThe History Teacher4032007303–330
29.
MarcusA.S.StoddardJ.D.The inconvenient truth about teaching history with documentary film: Strategies for presenting multiple perspectives and teaching controversial issuesThe Social Studies10062009279–284
30.
(Producer & Director)MazzioM.Underwater dreams [motion picture]. United States: 50 eggs2014
31.
McGrewS.BreakstoneJ.OrtegaT.SmithM.WineburgS.Can students evaluate online sources? Learning from assessments of civic online reasoningTheory & Research in Social Education4622018165–193
32.
MetzgerS.A.SuhY.Significant or safe? Two cases of instructional uses of history feature filmsTheory & Research in Social Education361200888–109
33.
National Council for the Social StudiesCollege, career, and civic life C3 framework for social studies state standards. Author2013
34.
PaxtonR.J.MarcusA.S.Film media in history teaching and learningMetzgerS.A.HarrisL.A.The Wiley international handbook of history teaching and learning2018Wiley Blackwell579–601
35.
PittA.BritzmanD.Speculations on qualities of difficult knowledge in teaching and learning: An experiment in psychoanalytic researchInternational Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education1662003755–776
36.
SeixasP.MortonT.The big six: Historical thinking concepts2013Nelson
37.
SheppardM.KatzD.GroslandT.Conceptualizing emotions in social studies educationTheory & Research in Social Education4322015147–178
38.
SolórzanoD.G.YossoT.J.Critical race methodology: Counter-storytelling as an analytical framework for educational researchQualitative Inquiry8200223–44
39.
SondelB.BaggettH.C.DunnA.H.“For millions of people, this is real trauma”: A pedagogy of political trauma in the wake of the 2016 U.S. Presidential electionTeaching and Teacher Education702018175–185
40.
StoddardJ.D.The ideological implications of using “educational” film to teach controversial eventsCurriculum Inquiry392009407–433
41.
StoddardJ.D.MarcusA.More than “showing what happened”: Exploring the potential of teaching with filmHigh School Journal932201083–90
42.
(Producer & Director)VargasJ.A.Documented [motion picture]. United States: CNN films2013
43.
WalshB.HicksD.van HoverS.Difficult history means difficult questions: Using film to reveal the perspective of “the other” in difficult history topicsStoddardJ.MarcusA.S.HicksD.Teaching difficult history through film2017Routledge17–36
44.
WineburgS.Historical thinking and other unnatural acts2001Temple University Press
45.
WineburgS.MartinD.Monte-SanoC.Reading like a historian: Teaching literacy in middle and high school classrooms2013Teachers College Press
46.
ZembylasM.Theory and methodology in researching emotions in educationInternational Journal of Research and Method in Education301200757–72
