A common assumption in the literature is that ineffective relationships and conflict between Marketing Managers and Sales Managers and their respective departments is endemic. This article challenges that assumption via an exhaustive review of the large sample quantitative studies of this important working relationship. The analysis reveals that the assumption is unsustainable in the light of the evidence, and that Marketing Manager/Sales Manager relationships are generally effective. This is encouraging news for these managers and their firms, as recent work has established that effective Marketing/Sales relationships are positively associated with superior value creation and market performance.
AgyrisC.A.Litigation mentality and organizational learningSitkinS.B.BiesR.J.The Legalistic Organization1994SageThousand Oaks, CA
2.
AmasonA.C.Distinguishing the effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict on strategic decision making: resolving a paradox for top management teamsAcademy of Management Journal3921996123–148
3.
BiemansW.G.BrenčičM.M.Designing the marketing-sales interface in B2B firmsEuropean Journal of Marketing413/42007257–273
4.
ButlerS.L.StroutE.Happy TogetherSales and Marketing Management1554200351
5.
CarpenterP., 1992. Bridging the gap between marketing and sales. Sales & Marketing Management, 29–31.
6.
CespedesF.V.Beyond teamwork: how the wise can synchronizeMarketing Management51199625–37
7.
ChangJ.It takes twoSales and Marketing Management15512200322
8.
DawesP.L.MasseyG.R.Antecedents of conflict in marketing's cross-functional relationship with salesEuropean Journal of Marketing3911–1220051327–1344
9.
DawesP.L.MasseyG.R.A study of relationship effectiveness between marketing and sales managers in business marketsJournal of Business and Industrial Marketing2162006346–360
10.
De DreuC.K.W.Productive conflict: the importance of conflict management and conflict issuesDe DreuC.K.W.Van De VliertE.Using Conflict in Organizations1997SageLondon9–22
11.
De DreuC.K.W.WeingartL.R.Task versus relationship conflict, team performance, and team member satisfaction: a meta analysisJournal of Applied Psychology8842003741–749
12.
DewsnapB.JobberD.The sales–marketing interface in consumer packaged-goods companies: a conceptual frameworkJournal of Personal Selling and Sales Management2022000109–119
13.
DewsnapB.JobberD.A social psychological model of relations between marketing and salesEuropean Journal of Marketing367/82002874–894
14.
DewsnapB.JobberD.An exploratory study of sales- marketing integrative devicesEuropean Journal of Marketing437/82009985–1007
15.
DoughertyD.Interpretive barriers to successful product innovation in large firmsOrganization Science321992179–202
16.
ErnstH.HoyerW.D.RübsaamenC.Sales, marketing, and research and development cooperation across new product development stages: Implications for successJournal of Marketing74201080–92
17.
FilleyA.Committee management: guidelines from social science researchCalifornia Management Review13197013–21Fall
18.
GriffinA.HauserJ.R.Integrating R&D and marketing: a review and analysis of the literatureJournal of Product Innovation Management131996191–215
19.
GuenziP.TroiloG.Developing marketing capabilities for customer value creation through marketing–sales integrationIndustrial Marketing Management352006974–988
20.
GuenziP.TroiloG.The joint contribution of marketing and sales to the creation of superior customer valueJournal of Business Research602200798–107
21.
HomburgC.JensenO.The thought worlds of marketing and sales: which differences make a difference?Journal of Marketing71July2007124–142
22.
HomburgC.JensenO.KrohmerH.Configurations of marketing and sales: a taxonomyJournal of Marketing722008133–154
23.
HullandJ.S.NenkovG.Y.BarclayD.W.Perceived marketing/sales relationship effectiveness: a matter of justiceJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science4032012450–467
24.
JaworskiB.J.KohliA.K.Market orientation: antecedents and consequencesJournal of Marketing572199353–70
25.
JehnK.A.A qualitative analysis of conflict types and dimensions in organizational groupsAdministrative Science Quarterly4231997530–557
26.
KahnK.B.Interdepartmental integration: a definition with implications for product development performanceJournal of Product Innovation Management1321996137–151
27.
KotlerP., RackhamN., KrishnaswamyS., 2006. Ending the war between sales and marketing. Harvard Business Review, 68–78.
28.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.LaneN.Collaboration between sales and marketing, market orientation and business performance in business-to-business organisationsJournal of Strategic Marketing173–42009291–306
29.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.MasseyG.R.The importance of effective working relationships between sales and marketingCravensD.W.Le Meunier-FitzHughK.PiercyN.F.The Oxford Handbook of Strategic Sales and Sales Management2011Oxford University PressOxford539–570
30.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.MasseyG.R.PiercyN.F.The impact of aligned rewards and senior manager attitudes on conflict and collaboration between sales and marketingIndustrial Marketing Management4020111161–1171
31.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.PiercyN.Does collaboration between sales and marketing affect business performance?Journal of Personal Selling and Sales Management2732007201–220
32.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.PiercyN.Drivers of sales and marketing collaboration in business-to-business selling organisationsJournal of Marketing Management255/62009611–633
33.
Le Meunier-FitzHughK.PiercyN.Exploring the relationship between market orientation and sales and marketing collaborationJournal of Personal Selling and Sales Management3132011287–296
34.
LewisJ.D.WeigertA.Trust as a social realitySocial Forces631985967–985
35.
LorgeS.Marketers are from Mars, salespeople are from VenusSales & Marketing Management151April199927–33
36.
MaltzE.KohliA.K.Reducing marketing's conflict with other functions: the differential effects of integrating mechanismsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2842000479–492
37.
MasseyG.R.DawesP.L.Personal characteristics, trust, conflict, and effectiveness in marketing/sales working relationshipsEuropean Journal of Marketing419/1020071117–1145
38.
MasseyG.R.DawesP.L.The antecedents and consequence of functional and dysfunctional conflict between marketing managers and sales managersIndustrial Marketing Management3620071118–1129
39.
MasseyG.R.KyriazisE.Interpersonal trust between marketing and R&D during new product development projectsEuropean Journal of Marketing419/1020071146–1172
40.
McAllisterD.J.Affect- and cognitive trust as foundations for interpersonal cooperation in organizationsAcademy of Management Journal381199524–59
41.
MenonA.BharadwajS.G.HowellR.The quality and effectiveness of marketing strategy: effects of functional and dysfunctional conflict in intraorganizational relationshipsJournal of the Academy of Marketing Science2441996299–313
RuekertR.W.WalkerO.C.Marketing's interaction with other functional unitsJournal of Marketing5119871–19
44.
SitkinS.B.RothN.L.Explaining the limited effectiveness of legalistic remedies for trust/distrustOrganization Science431993367–392
45.
StrahleW.M.SpiroR.L.AcitoF.Marketing and sales: strategic alignment and functional implementationJournal of Personal Selling and Sales Management1619961–20Winter
46.
TjosvoldD.Cooperative and competitive interdependence. Collaboration between departments to serve customersGroup and Organization Studies131988274–289
47.
TjosvoldD.Conflict within interdependence. Its value for productivity and individualityDe DreuC.K.W.Van De VliertE.Using Conflict in Organizations1997SageLondon23–37
48.
TjosvoldD.WedleyW.C.FieldR.H.G.Constructive controversy, the Vroom-Yetton Model, and managerial decision makingJournal of Occupational Behaviour71986125–138
49.
TroiloG.De LucaL.M.GuenziP.Dispersion of influence between marketing and sales: its effects on superior customer value and market performanceIndustrial Marketing Management382009872–882
50.
TurnerM.E.PratkanisA.R.Social identity maintenance prescriptions for preventing groupthink: reducing identity protection and enhancing intellectual conflictInternational Journal of Conflict Management51994207–304
51.
Van de VenA.On the nature, formation, and maintenance of relations among organizationsAcademy of Management Review4197624–36
52.
WeberM., 1924. The theory of social and economic organization. In: HendersonA.H., ParsonsT., (Trans), The Free Press, New York (1947), (First published in German in 1924).
