This paper examines Thomas Courchene's argument that Senator Kirby was closer to the truth than Commissioner Romanow when Kirby argued that Canada's healthcare system is only sustainable though introducing more private investment. The paper finds that Romanow's position, and indeed the nature of Canada's healthcare system, have been misrepresented by those seeking a larger private market share. The paper concludes the balance of evidence supports Romanow, not Kirby.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
CourcheneTJ. Medicare as a Moral Enterprise: The Romanow and Kirby Perspectives. Kingston: Institute for Research on Public Policy. Policy Matters October2003; 4(1).
2.
RomanowRJ. Building on Values: The Future of Health Care in Canada. Ottawa: Commission of the Future of Health Care in Canada; 2002.
3.
KirbyM. The Health of Canadians — the Federal Role. Final Report, volume Six: Recommendations for Reform. Ottawa: Senate Standing Committee on Social Affairs, Science and Technology; October 2002.
4.
Provinces did under invest in hospital capital equipment in the 1990s due to the fiinancial squeeze they were unde resulting from federal approaches to defiicit management Both levels of government recognized that, and additional funds have now been made available to at least partially redress the imbalance. There is no evidence in the health research literature to suggest that it is impossible for government to adequately equip hospitals, although it is plain they do not always do so.
5.
DruckettS. Does it matter who owns health facilities?Journal of Health Services Research and Policy January2001; 6(1): 59–62.
6.
MaystonD. Private fiinance initiative in the National Healt Service: An unhealthy development in new public management?Financial Accountability and Management August/November1999; 15(3/4): 249–274.
7.
PropperC. Death and the Market: The questionable impact of competition on health care quality. Market and Public Organization January2003; 8: 7–11.
8.
DombergerSJensenP. Contracting out by the public sector: Theory, evidence, prospects. Oxford Review of Economic Policy1997; 13(4): 67–78.
9.
ViningAGlobermanS. Contracting out health care services: A conceptual framework. Health Policy1999; 46(2): 77–96.
10.
It is one of the many paradoxes that Canadians' opinion of the healthcare system is declining while their opinion of the care they receive as patients is actually improving. See: HealthMcMurchy D.Insider December 2002. Toronto: IBM Business Consulting Services: p. 4.
11.
CummingJMaysN. Reform and counter-reform: How sustainable is New Zealand's latest health system restructuring?Journal of Health Services Research and Policy July2002; 7(Suppl 1): 46–55.
12.
ButlerJ. Patients, Policies and Politics. Buckingham: Open University Press; 1992.
13.
KleinR. Big Bang Health Care Reform — Does it Work? The case of Britain's 1991 National Health Service's reforms. Milbank Quarterly1995; 73(3): 299–337.
14.
BusseRvan der GrintenTSvenssonPG. Regulating entrepreneurial behaviour in hospitals: Theory and practice. In: SaltmanSBusseRMozzialesE, eds. Regulating entrepreneurial behaviour in European health care systems. Buckingham: Open University Press; 2003: Pp. 126–145.
15.
Le GrandJ. Motivation, Agency and Public Policy: Of knights and knaves, pawns and queens. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2003.
