Using data from the 1984-2014 General Social Survey, we employ cross classified random effects models to examine age-period-cohort changes in political tolerance by religion, incorporating religious belief, belonging, and behavior into the analyses. The results show large cohort and period based changes in political tolerance of the various religious traditions. The results also suggest that the primary driver of changes over time in political tolerance is best attributed to period effects, not cohort replacement, although there is some evidence of a cohort effect among Roman Catholics. Finally, our results demonstrate that aggregate data analyses can lead to noticeably different results and thus can mask substantial differences between groups.
AlwinDuane FKrosnickJon AAge, cohorts, and the stability of sociopolitical orientations over the life spanAmerican Journal of Sociology199197169–19510.1086/229744
2.
AlwinDuane FMcCammonRyan JRethinking generationsResearch in Human Development20074219–23710.1080/15427600701663072
3.
AndersonRobertFetnerTinaAttitudinal change in Canada and the United States, 1981-2000Public Opinion Quarterly200872311–33010.1093/poq/nfn017
4.
AltbachPhilip GLauferRobert SThe new pilgrims: Youth protest in transition1972New YorkDavid McKay
5.
BarnumDGSullivanJLAttitudinal tolerance and political freedom in BritainBritish Journal of Political Science198919136–14510.1017/S0007123400005378
6.
BeattyKathleen MurphyWalterOliverReligious preference and practice: Reevaluating their impact on political tolerancePublic Opinion Quarterly198448318–32910.1093/poq/48.1B.318
7.
Ben-Nun Bloom, Pazit, and Marie Courtemanche. 2015 Religion, morality, and tolerance: The role of disgust. In Religion and political tolerance in America: Advances in the state of the art, ed. Paul A. Djupe. Philadelphia: Temple University Press, pp. 100-118.
8.
BoboLawrenceLicariFrederickEducation and political tolerance: Testing the effects of cognitive sophistication and target group affectPublic Opinion Quarterly198953285–30810.1086/269154
9.
CaspiDanSeligsonMitchell AToward an empirical theory of tolerance: Radical groups in Israel and Costa RicaComparative Political Studies1983154385–40410.1177/0010414083015004001
10.
CutlerSKaufmanRCohort changes in political attitudes: Tolerance of ideological nonconformityPublic Opinion Quarterly19753969–8110.1086/268200
11.
DavisJames ACommunism, conformity, cohorts and categories: American tolerance in 1954 and 1972-1973American Journal of Sociology197581491–51310.1086/226105
12.
DavisJames ADid growing up in the 1960s leave a permanent mark on attitudes and values? Evidence from the general social surveyThe Public Opinion Quarterly2004682161–18310.1093/poq/nfh010
13.
DjupePaulCalfanoBrian RReligious value priming, threat, and political tolerancePolitical Research Quarterly2013664768–78010.1177/1065912912471203
14.
DjupePaul ACalfanoBrianDjupePaul AThe golden rule theory: The nature of clergy influence on congregational political toleranceReligion and political tolerance in America: Advances in the state of the art2015PhiladelphiaTemple University Press34–50
15.
DjupePaul ALewisAndrew RJelenTed GRights, reflection, and reciprocity: Implications of the same sex marriage debate for tolerance and the political processPolitics and Religion20169630–64810.1017/S1755048316000547
16.
DjupePaul AMockabeeStephen TReligious worldviews and political tolerance: Communitarianism, inclusiveness, and moral foundationsReligion and political tolerance in America: Advances in the state of the art2015PhiladelphiaTemple University Press117–132
17.
EdmundsJuneTurnerBryan SGenerations, culture and society2002Philadelphia, PAOpen University Press
18.
EisensteinMarie ARethinking the relationship between religion and political tolerance in the U.SPolitical Behavior200628327–34810.1007/s11109-006-9014-5
19.
EisensteinMarie ADjupePaul APredispositions, standing decisions, and the role of religion: An explanatory modelReligion and political tolerance in America: Advances in the state of the art2015PhiladelphiaTemple University Press165–180
20.
EisensteinMarie AClarkApril KDjupePaul AHeterogeneous religion measures and political tolerance outcomesReligion and political tolerance in America: Advances in the state of the art2015PhiladelphiaTemple University Press83–99
21.
FirebaughGlennMethods for estimating cohort replacement effectsSociological methodology198919243–26210.2307/270954
22.
FirebaughGlennDavisKenneth ETrends in antiblack prejudice, 1972-1984: Region and cohort effectsAmerican Journal of Sociology198894251–27210.1086/228991
23.
FroesePaulBaderChristopherSmithBusterPolitical tolerance and god's wrath in the United StatesSociology of Religion200869129–4410.1093/socrel/69.1.29
24.
GibsonJames LHomosexuals and the Ku Klux Klan: A contextual analysis of political intoleranceWestern Political Quarterly198740 September 427–448
25.
GibsonJames LPolitical intolerance and political repression during the McCarthy Red ScareAmerican Political Science Review1988822511–52910.2307/1957398
26.
GibsonJames LThe structure of attitudinal tolerance in the United StatesBritish Journal of Political Science1989194562–57010.1017/S0007123400005640
27.
GibsonJames LAlternative measures of political tolerance: Must tolerance be “least liked?American Journal of Political Science1992362560–57710.2307/2111491
28.
GibsonJames LThe political consequences of intolerance: Cultural conformity and political freedomThe American Political Science Review1992862338–35610.2307/1964224
29.
GibsonJames LWolfeAlanKatznelsonIraThe political consequences of religiosity: Does religion always cause political intolerance?Religion and democracy in the United States: Danger or opportunity2010Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press147–175
30.
GibsonJamesMeasuring political tolerance and general support for pro-civil liberties policiesPublic Opinion Quarterly20137721–3410.1093/poq/nfs073
31.
GibsonJames LDuchRaymond MPolitical intolerance in the USSR: The distribution and etiology of mass opinionComparative Political Studies199326286–32910.1177/0010414093026003002
32.
GibsonJames LGouwsAmandaOvercoming intolerance in South Africa: Experiments in democratic persuasion2003NewYorkCambridge University Press
33.
GreenJohn CGuthJames LKellstedtLyman ASmidtCorwin EUncivil challenges? Support for civil liberties among religious activistsThe Journal of Political Science19942225–49
34.
GreenJohn CThe faith factor: How religion influences American elections2007Westport, CTPraeger
35.
Husser, Jason Andrew. 2012. Religion and polarization in American Politics. Diss. Vanderbilt University.
36.
HutchisonMarc LGiblerDouglas MPolitical tolerance and territorial threat: A cross-national studyThe Journal of Politics200769128–14210.1111/j.1468-2508.2007.00499.x
37.
InglehartRonaldCulture shift in advanced industrial society1990Princeton, NJPrinceton University Press
38.
JelenTed GStoutDaniel ABuddenbaumJudith MCatholicism, conscience, and censorshipJudeo-christian traditions and the mass media: Religious audiences and adaptations Newbury Park1996CASage35–50
39.
JelenTed GWilcoxClydeDenominational preference and the dimensions of political toleranceSociological Analysis19905169–8010.2307/3711341
40.
JenningsM KentStokerLauraSocial trust and civic engagement across time and generationsActa Politica2004394342–37910.1057/palgrave.ap.5500077
41.
KellstedtLymanGreenJohn CGuthJames LSmidtCorwin EGreenJohn CGuthJames LSmidtCrowin EKellstedtLyman AGrasping the essentials: The social embodiment of religion and political behaviorReligion and the culture wars1996Lanham, MDRowman and Littlefield
42.
LaymanGeoffreyReligion and political behavior in the United States: The impact of beliefs, affiliations, and commitment from 1980-1994Public Opinion Quarterly1997612288–31610.1086/297796
43.
Layman, Geoffrey, and John C. Green. 1998. The changing religious voter: The political impact of belonging, believing, and behaving. In Delivered at the 1998 annual meeting of the Midwest Political Science Association (April 23-25), Chicago, IL.
44.
LoftusJeniAmerica's liberalization in attitudes toward homosexuality, 1973-1998American Sociological Review200166762–78210.2307/3088957
45.
Mannheim, Karl. [1928] 1972. The problem of generations. In The new pilgrims, ed. Philip G. Altbach and Robert S. Laufer, pp. 101-37. New York: David McKay.
46.
MarcusGeorge ESullivanJohn LTheiss-MorseElizabethWoodSandra LWith malice toward some: How people make civil liberties judgments1995CambridgeCambridge University Press10.1017/CBO9781139174046
47.
MayerWilliam GBrillAlidaThe Changing American Mind: How and Why American Public Opinion Changed Between 1960 and 19881992Ann ArborThe University of Michigan Press
48.
McCloskyHerbertBrillAlidaDimensions of tolerance1983New YorkRussell Sage
49.
McNamaraPatrick HConscience first, tradition second: A study of young American catholics albany1992New York, NYState University Press of New York
50.
MockabeeStephen TWilsonJ MatthewThe political behavior of American catholics: Continuity and changeFrom pews to polling places: Faith and politics in the American religious mosaic2007Washingon, DCGeorgetown University Press81–104
51.
MondakJeffery JSandersMitchell STolerance and intolerance, 1976-1998American Journal of Political Science2003473492–50210.1111/1540-5907.00035
52.
MuellerJohnTrends in political tolerancePublic Opinion Quarterly1988521–2510.1086/269079
53.
NieNHJunnJStehlik-BarryKEducation and democratic citizenship in America1996ChicagoUniversity of Chicago Press
54.
NunnCZCrockettHJWilliamsJJrTolerance for non-conformity1978San Francisco, CAJossey-Bass
55.
PeffleyMarkSigelmanLeeIntolerance of communists during the McCarthy Era: A general modelThe Western Political Quarterly199043193–11110.2307/448507
56.
PlochDonald RHastingsDonald WGraphic presentations of church attendance using General Social Survey dataJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion199433116–3310.2307/1386634
57.
PutnamRobert DCampbellDavid EAmerican grace: How religion unites and divides us2010New YorkSimon & Schuster
58.
RaudenbushStephen WBrykAnthony SHierarchical linear models: Applications and data analysis20022Thousand Oaks, CASage Publications Inc.
59.
RyderNorman BThe cohort as a concept in the study of social changeAmerican Sociological Review196530843–86110.2307/2090964
60.
SchaferChelsea EShawGreg MThe polls—Trends: Tolerance in the United StatesPublic Opinion Quarterly200973404–43110.1093/poq/nfp022
61.
SchwadelPhilipAge, period, and cohort effects on religious activities and beliefsSocial Sciences Research201140181–19210.1016/j.ssresearch.2010.09.006
62.
SchwadelPhilipGarneauChristopher R HAn age-period-cohort analysis of political tolerance in the United StatesThe Sociological Quarterly201455421–45210.1111/tsq.12058
63.
SearsDavid OWheelerLaddShaverPThe persistence of early political predispositions: The roles of attitude object and life stageReview of personality and social psychology19834LomdonSage79–116
64.
SmidtCorwn EPenningJames MReligious commitment, political conservatism, and political and social tolerance in the United States: A longitudinal analysisSociological Analysis198243231–24610.2307/3711258
65.
SnidermanPaul MTetlockPhilip EGlaserJames MGreenDonald PhillipHoutMichaelPrincipled tolerance and American political valuesBritish Journal of Political Science19891925–4610.1017/S0007123400005305
66.
SteenslandBrianParkJerry ZRegnerusMark DRobinsonLynn DBradford WilcoxWWoodberryRobert DThe measure of American religion: Toward improving the state of the artSocial Forces200079291–31810.1093/sf/79.1.291
67.
StetzerEdBurgeRyan PReltrad coding problems and a new repositoryPolitics and Religion201591187–19010.1017/S1755048315000929
68.
SullivanJohn LPieresonJames EMarcusGeorge EAn alternative conceptualization of political tolerance: Illusory increases 1950s-1970sThe American Political Science Review1979733781–79410.2307/1955404
69.
SullivanJohn LPieresonJamesMarcusGeorgePolitical tolerance and American democracy1982ChicagoChicago University Press
70.
SullivanJohn LShamirMichalWalshPatrickRobertsNigel SPolitical tolerance in context: Support for unpopular minorities in Israel, New Zealand, and the United States1985Boulder, COWestview Press Inc
71.
WaldKenneth DReligious elites and public opinion: The impact of the Bishops’ peace pastoralReview of Politics199254112–14310.1017/S0034670500017204
72.
WilcoxClydeJelenTed GEvangelicals and political toleranceAmerican Politics Quarterly199018125–4610.1177/1532673X9001800102
73.
WilsonThomas CTrends in tolerance toward rightist and leftist groups, 1976-1988: Effects of attitude change and cohort successionPublic Opinion Quarterly1994584539–55610.1086/269446
YangYangBayesian inference for hierarchical age-period-cohort models of repeated cross-section survey dataSociological Methodology20063639–7410.1111/j.1467-9531.2006.00174.x
76.
YangYangSocial inequalities in happiness in the United States, 1972-2004: An age-period-cohort analysisAmerican Sociological Review200873104–22610.1177/000312240807300202
77.
YangYangLandKenneth CA mixed-models approach to the age-period-cohort analysis of repeated cross-section surveys, with an application to data on trends in verbal test scoresSociological Methodology20063675–9710.1111/j.1467-9531.2006.00175.x
78.
YangYangLandKenneth CAge-period-cohort analysis of repeated cross-section surveys: Fixed or random effectsSociological Methods & Research200836297–32610.1177/0049124106292360
