The Relative Returns to Graduating from a Historically Black College/University: Propensity Score Matching Estimates from the National Survey of Black Americans
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2011
The Relative Returns to Graduating from a Historically Black College/University: Propensity Score Matching Estimates from the National Survey of Black Americans
This paper considers the returns to earning a baccalaureate degree from a Historically Black College/University (HBCU) relative to a non-HBCU for black Americans. With data from the National Survey of Black Americans, we use propensity score matching estimators to estimate the treatment effect of graduating from an HBCU on direct labor market outcomes, and on psychological outcomes that indirectly increase wages. We find that the treatment effect of graduating from an HBCU relative to a non-HBCU is positive with respect to labor market and psychological outcomes across three decades. As our direct labor market outcome measure reflects permanent earnings, our results suggest that as HBCUs afford graduates relatively superior long-run returns they continue to have a compelling educational justification, as the labor market outcomes of their graduates are superior to what they would have been had they graduated from a non-HBCU.
AbadieA., DrukkerD., Leber HerrJ., ImbensG.W.Implementing matching estimators for average treatment effects in stata. Stata J2001; 1: 1–18.
2.
AkerlofG.A., KrantonR.E.Identity and schooling: some lessons for the economics of education. J Econ Lit2002; 40: 1167–1201.
3.
AugurzkyB., KluveJ.Assessing the performance of matching estimates when selection into treatment is strong. J Appl Econ2007; 22: 533–557.
4.
BarnowB.S., CainG.G., GoldbergerA.S.Issues in the analysis of selectivity bias. Eval Stud1980; 5: 42–59.
5.
BlackD., HavilandA., SandersS., TaylorL.Why do minority men earn less? A study of wage differential among the highly educated. Rev Econ Stat2006; 88: 300–313.
6.
BlackS.E., DevereuxP.J., SalvanesK.G.The more the merrier? The effects of family size and birth order on children's education. Q J Econ2005; 120: 669–700.
7.
BowenW.G., BokD.The shape of the river: long-term consequences of considering race in college and university admissions.Princeton: Princeton University Press; 1998.
8.
BoydR.L.Historically black colleges and universities and the black business elite. Sociol Perspect2007; 50: 545–560.
9.
BrandJ.E., HalabyC.N.Regression and matching estimates of the effects of elite college attendance on educational and career achievement. Soc Sci Res2006; 35: 749–770.
10.
BrewerD.J., EideE.R., EhrenbergR.G.Does it pay to attend an elite private college? Cross-cohort evidence on the effects of college type on earnings. J Hum Resour1999; 34: 104–123.
11.
BurnimM.L.The earnings effect of black matriculation in predominantly white colleges. Ind Labor Relat Rev1980; 33: 518–524.
12.
ChiswickB.R.Jacob Mincer, experience and the distribution of earnings. Discussion Paper No. 847, The Institute for the Study of Labor (IZA), Bonn Germany; 2003.
13.
ConstantineJ.The effect of attending historically black colleges and universities on future wages of black students. Ind Labor Relat Rev1995; 48: 531–546.
14.
CookP.J., LudwigJ.Weighing the burden of ‘Acting White’: are there race differences in attitudes toward education?J Policy Anal Manage1997; 16: 256–278.
15.
DaleS., KruegerA.B.Estimating the return to college selectivity over the career using administrative earning data. Working paper No. 563. Princeton: Princeton University Industrial Relations Section; 2011.
16.
DarityW.A., MasonP.L., StewartJ.B.The economics of identity: the origin and persistence of racial identity norms. J Econ Behav Organ2006; 60: 283–305.
17.
DuncanO.D.A socioeconomic index for all occupations. In: ReisA.J., editor. Occupations and social status.New York: Free Press; 1961. pp. 109–138.
18.
DuncanO.D., FeathermanD.L., DuncanB.Socioeconomic background and achievement.New York: Seminar Press; 1972.
19.
EhrenbergR.G., RothsteinD.S.Do historically black institutions of higher education confer unique advantages on black students? An initial analysis. In: EhrenbergR., editor. Choices and consequences: contemporary policy issues in education.Ithaca: ILR Press, School of Industrial and Labor Relations, Cornell University; 1994. pp. 89–147.
20.
FryerR.G., GreenstoneM.The changing consequences of attending historically black colleges and universities. AEJ: Applied Economics2010; 2: 116–148.
21.
GaviriaA., RaphaelS.School based peer effects and juvenile behavior. Rev Econ Stat2001; 83: 257–268.
22.
GoldsmithA.H., VeumJ.R., DarityW.Jr.The impact of psychological and human capital on wages. Econ Inq1997; 35: 815–829.
23.
ImbensG.Nonparametric estimation of average treatment effects under exogeneity: a review. Rev Econ Stat2004; 86: 4–29.
24.
JacksonJ.S., GurinG.National survey of black Americans, waves 1–4 1979–1980, 1987–1988, 1988–1989, 1992 [Computer File] Conducted by University of Michigan, Survey Research Center. ICPSR version Ann Arbor MI: Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research; 1997.
25.
JonesC.C.National longitudinal study of the high school class of 1972: postsecondary education transcript study, data file user's manual.Washington DC: United States Government Printing Office; 1986.
26.
LouryL.D.Am i still too black for you? Schooling and secular change in skin tone effects. Econ Educ Rev2009; 28: 428–433.
27.
MincerJ.Investment in human capital and personal income distribution. J Polit Econ1958; 66: 281–302.
28.
MykereziE., MillsB.F.The wage earnings impact of historically black colleges and universities. South Econ J2008; 75: 173–187.
29.
MykereziE., MillsB.F.Education and economic well-being in racially diverse rural counties: the role of historically black colleges and universities. Rev Reg Stud2004; 34: 303–319.
30.
PalmerR., GasmanM.It takes a village to raise a child: social capital and academic success at historically black colleges and universities. J Coll Stud Dev2008; 49: 52–70.
31.
ReddK.E.Historically black colleges and universities: making a comeback. In: MerisoticJ.P., O'BrienC.T., editors. Minority-servinginstitutions: distinct purposes, common goals.San Francisco: Jossey-Bass; 1998.
32.
RillingJ.K., GoldsmithD.R., GriffinA.L., JairamM.R., ElfenbeinH.A., DagenaisJ.E., MurdockC.D., PagnoniG.The neural correlates of the affective response to unreciprocated cooperation. Neuropsychologia2008; 46: 1256–1266.
33.
RobinsonB., AlbertA.HBCU's institutional advantage: returns to teacher education. In: GasmanM., BaezB., Sotello ViernesC., editors. Understanding minority-serving institutions.Albany: State University of New York Press; 2008.
34.
RoebuckJ.B., MurtyK.S.Historically black colleges and universities: their place in american higher education.Westport: Prager; 1993.
35.
RosenS.Human capital: a survey of empirical research. In: EhrenbergR., editor. Research in labor economics, vol. 1. Greenwich: JAI Press; 1977.
36.
SavilleD.J., WoodG.R.Statistical methods: the geometric approach.New York: Springer-Verlag; 1991.
37.
SobelJ.Can we trust social capital?J Econ Lit2002; 40: 139–154.
38.
SolnickL.M.Black college attendance and job success of black college graduates. Econ Educ Rev1990; 9: 135–148.
39.
StrayhornT.L.Influences on labor market outcomes of african american college graduates: a national study. J High Educ2008; 79: 27–57.
40.
SullowayF.J.Born to rebel: birth order, family dynamics, and creative lives.New York: Pantheon; 1996.
41.
WildeE.T., HollisterR.How close is close enough? Evaluating propensity score matching using data from a class size reduction experiment. J Policy Anal Manage2007; 3: 455–477.
42.
WilsonV.R.The effect of attending an HBCU on persistence and graduation outcomes of African-American college students. Rev Black Polit Econ2007; 34: 11–52.
43.
WineJ.S., CominoleM.B., WheelessS., DudleyK., FranklinJ.1993/03 Baccalaureate and beyond longitudinal study (B&B: 93/03). NCES 2006–166, U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics, Washington DC; 2005.
44.
ZhaoZ.Using matching to estimate treatment effects: data requirements, matching metrics, and Monte Carlo evidence. Rev Econ Stat2004; 86: 91–107.
45.
ZimmermanD.J.Regression toward mediocrity in economic status. Am Econ Rev1992; 82: 409–429.
