A recent manifest content analysis of manuscripts in leading U.S. adult education journals found a discrepancy between how often academics used meaning making language and how often practitioners and policy makers did. It was suggested this was due to the language being unhelpful to practitioner and policy makers’ work. A follow up latent content analysis of a subset of this sample was conducted to test this hypothesis and reveal authors’ intentions and meanings. Findings showed inconsistencies and contradictions in usage and no collective sense of what meaning making terms mean. A functional taxonomy of meaning construction was then proposed to broaden the language's usefulness among practitioners and further the possibilities of interdisciplinary research with scientific fields.
AdamsonC. W., & BailieJ. W. (2012). Education versus learning: Restorative practices in higher education. Journal of Transformative Education, 10(3), 139–156.
2.
AllenS. R. (2012). What matters in (naturalized) metaphysics?Essays in Philosophy, 13(1), 211–241.
3.
AusubelD. P. (1963). The psychology of meaningful verbal learning. New York, NY: Grune& Stratton.
4.
AzevedoN. R., & GonçalvesM. J. (2012). Writing and reading with art: Adult Literacy, transformation, and learning. Adult Learning, 23(2), 69–75.
5.
BailyS., StiblingS. M., & McGowanC. L. (2014). Experiencing the “growing edge”: Transformative teacher education to foster social justice perspectives. Journal of Transformative Education, 12(3), 248–265.
6.
BargR. (2009). One foot on the dock and one foot in the canoe: How does a feminist academic fit into fire service education?Adult Education Quarterly, 59(2), 99–117.
7.
BeerL. E., RodriquezK., TaylorC., Martinez–JonesN., GriffinJ., SmithT. R.AnayaR. (2015). Awareness, integration and interconnectedness: Contemplative practices of higher education professionals. Journal of Transformative Education, 13(2), 161–185.
8.
BergerJ. G. (2004). Dancing on the threshold of meaning: Recognizing and understanding the growing edge. Journal of Transformative Education, 2(4), 336–351.
9.
BieremaL. L. (2011). Reflections on the profession and professionalization of adult education. PAACE Journal of Lifelong Learning, 20, 21–36.
10.
BoerenE. (2018). The methodological underdog: A review of quantitative research in the key adult education journals. Adult Education Quarterly, 68(1), 63–79.
11.
BrendelW. (2009). A framework for narrative–driven transformative learning in medicine. Journal of Transformative Education, 7(1), 26–43.
12.
BridwellS. D. (2013). Developmental perspective on the transformative learning of adults marginalized by race, class, and gender. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(2), 127–146.
13.
BrightL. K., & MahdiG. S. (2010). Out of crisis: Reflections of an Iraqi and an American on advocacy for andragogy. Adult Learning, 21(1–2), 37–40.
14.
BuikemaJ. L., & GravesM. F. (1993). Teaching students to use context cues to infer word meaning. Journal of Reading, 36(6), 450–457.
15.
BurnsH. L. (2015). Transformative sustainable pedagogy: Learning from ecological systems and indigenous wisdom. Journal of Transformative Education, 13(3), 259–276.
16.
BurtonA. J. (2000). Reflection: Nursing's practice and education panacea?Journal of Advanced Nursing, 31, 1009–1017.
17.
CainK., OakhillJ., & LemmonK. (2004). Individual differences in the inference of word meanings from context: The influence of reading comprehension, vocabulary knowledge, and memory capacity. Journal of Educational Psychology, 96(4), 671–681.
18.
CampbellT., ParrM., & RichardsonC. (2009). From implicit intention to exquisite expression: Finding metaphors for who we are and what we do. Journal of Transformative Education, 7(3), 209–229.
19.
CarnineD., KameenuiE. J., & CoyleG. (1984). Utilization of contextual information in determining the meaning of unfamiliar words. Reading Research Quarterly, 19(2), 188–204.
20.
CaudleL. A. (2013). Using a sociocultural perspective to establish teaching and social presences within a hybrid community of mentor teachers. Adult Learning, 24(3), 112–120.
21.
ChoyS. (2009). Transformational learning in the workplace. Journal of Transformative Education, 7(1), 64–84.
22.
CloverD. E. (2006). Out of the dark room: Participatory photography as a critical, imaginative, and public aesthetic practice of transformative education. Journal of Transformative Education, 4(3), 275–290.
23.
CloverD. E. (2010). A contemporary review of feminist aesthetic practices in selective adult education journals and conference proceedings. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(3), 233–248.
24.
CoadyM. (2013). Adult health learning and transformation: A case study of a Canadian community–based program. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(4), 321–337.
CornsfordI. R. (2002). Reflective teaching: Empirical research findings and some implications for teacher education. Journal of Vocational Education and Training, 54(2), 219–235.
27.
CoryellJ. E. (2013). Collaborative, comparative inquiry and transformative cross–cultural adult learning and teaching: A western educator metanarrative and inspiring a global vision. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(4), 299–320.
28.
DaleyB. J., MartinL. G., & RoessgerK. M. (2018). A call for methodological plurality: Reconsidering research approaches in adult education. Adult Education Quarterly, 68(2), 157–169.
29.
DeanG. J. (1999). Reality and research in adult education: Do opposites really attract?PAACEJournal of Lifelong Learning, 8, 21–30.
30.
DennettD. C. (2013). Intuition pumps and other tools for thinking. New York, NY: Norton.
31.
DirkxJ. M. (2012). Self–formation and transformative learning: A response to “Calling transformative learning into question: Some mutinous thoughts,” by Michael Newman. Adult Education Quarterly, 62(4), 399–405.
32.
DirkxJ. M., MezirowJ., & CrantonP. (2006). Musings and reflections on the meaning, context, and process of transformative learning: A dialogue between John M. Dirkx and Jack Mezirow. Journal of Transformative Education, 4(2), 123–139.
ErichsenE. A. (2011). Learning for change: Transforming international experience as identity work. Journal of Transformative Education, 9(2), 109–133.
35.
EricksonD. M. (2007). A developmental re–forming of the phrases of meaning in transformational learning. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(1), 61–80.
36.
FejesA., & NylanderE. (2015). How pluralistic is the research field on adult education? Dominating bibliometrical trends, 2005–2012. European Journal for Research on the Education and Learning of Adults, 6, 103–123.
37.
FangJ. T. Y., & YusofQ. (2014). Surviving women's learning experiences from the tsunami in Aceh. Adult Learning, 25(1), 20–27.
38.
FeinsteinB. C. (2004). Learning and transformation in the context of Hawaiian traditional ecological knowledge. Adult Education Quarterly, 54(2), 105–120.
39.
FetherstonB., & KellyR. (2007). Conflict resolution and transformative pedagogy: A grounded theory research project on learning in higher education. Journal of Transformative Education, 5(3), 262–285.
40.
FoxE. J. (2006). Constructing a pragmatic science of learning and instruction with functional contextualism. Educational Technology Research and Development, 54(1), 5–36.
41.
FukkinkR. G., & de GlopperK. (1998). Effects of instruction in deriving word meaning from context: A meta–analysis. Review of Educational Research, 68(4), 450–469.
42.
GalbraithM. W. (2003). Celebrating mentoring. Adult Learning, 14(1), 2–3.
43.
Gilpin–JacksonY. (2014). Resonance as transformative learning moment: The key to transformation in sociocultural and posttrauma contexts. Journal of Transformative Education, 12(1), 95–119.
44.
GoulahJ. (2007). Toward pax terra–humana: Cultural transformative learning and a planetary literacy in the foreign language classroom. Journal of Transformative Education, 5(2), 163–176.
45.
GrandI. J. (2006). Ascending to the concrete: Teaching complexity in a counseling psychology program. Journal of Transformative Education, 4(2), 157–174.
46.
GrillJ. C. (2003). Natural settings, restorative environments, and American Association for Adult and Continuing Education. Adult Learning, 14(3), 20–23.
47.
GuarinoE. A. (1960). An investigation of the effectiveness of instruction designed to improve the reader's skill in using context clues to derive word meaning (Doctoral dissertation). Retrieved from ProQuest Dissertations and Theses A&I Database. (Document ID No. 301921220).
48.
GumL., GreenhillJ., & DixK. (2011). Sim TRACT™: A reflective conceptual framework for simulation debriefing. Journal of Transformative Education, 9(1), 21–41.
49.
GunnlaugsonO. (2005). Toward integrally informed theories of transformative leaning. Journal of Transformative Learning, 3(4), 331–353.
50.
GunnlaugsonO. (2007). Shedding light on the underlying forms of transformative learning theory: Introducing three distinct categories of consciousness. Journal of Transformative Education, 5(2), 134–151.
51.
HayesE. R., & WilsonA. L. (2003). From the editors: Making meaning of meaning making. Adult Education Quarterly, 53(2), 77–80.
52.
HelyerR. (2015). Learning through reflection: the critical role of reflection in work–based learning (WBL).Journal of Work–Applied Management, 7(1), 15–27.
HogganC. (2014). Insights from breast cancer survivors: The interplay between context, epistemology, and change. Adult Education Quarterly, 64(3), 191–205.
57.
HogganC., & CrantonP. (2015). Promoting transformative learning through reading fiction. Journal of Transformative Education, 13(1), 6–25.
58.
HsiehH.–F., & ShannonS. E. (2005). Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qualitative Health Research, 15, 1277–1288.
59.
HuntC. (2005). Meaning making. In EnglishL. M. (ed.), International Encyclopedia of Adult Education (pp. 391–395). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
60.
JarvisC., & BurrV. (2011). The transformative potential of popular television: The case of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Journal of Transformative Education, 9(3), 165–182.
61.
JordiR. (2011). Reframing the concept of reflection: Consciousness, experiential learning, and reflective learning practices. Adult Education Quarterly, 61(2), 181–197.
62.
KarpiakI. E. (2003). The ethnographic, the reflective, and the uncanny: Three “tellings” of autobiography. Journal of Transformative Education, 1(2), 99–116.
63.
KaslE., & YorksL. (2010). “Whose inquiry is this anyway?” Money, power, reports, and collaborative inquiry. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(4), 315–338.
64.
KaswormC. (2005). Adult student identify in an intergenerational community college classroom. Adult Education Quarterly, 56(1), 3–20.
65.
KaswormC. (2010). Adult learners in a research university: Negotiating undergraduate student identity. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(2), 143–160.
66.
KeganR. (1994). In over our heads: The mental demands of modern life. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
67.
KeganR. (2000). What “forms” transforms? A constructive–developmental approach to transformative learning. In J. Mezirow & Associates (Eds.), Learning as transformation: Critical perspectives on a theory in progress (pp. 35–69). San Francisco: Jossey–Bass.
68.
KokkosA. (2014). Could transformative learning be appreciated in Europe?Journal of Transformative Education, 12(2), 180–196.
69.
KreberC., KlampfleitnerM., McCuneB., BayneS., & KnottenbeltM. (2007). What do you mean by “authentic”? A comparative review of the literature on conceptions of authenticity in teaching. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(1), 22–43.
70.
KucukaydinI. (2010). Counter–learning under oppression. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(3), 215–232.
71.
KucukaydinI., & CrantonP. (2013). Critically questioning the discourse of transformative learning theory. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(1), 43–56.
72.
Le CornuA. (2009). Meaning, internalization, and externalization: Toward a fuller understanding of the process of reflection and its role in the construction of the self. Adult Education Quarterly, 59(4), 279–297.
73.
MackintoshC. (1998). Reflection: A flawed strategy for the nursing profession. Nurse Education Today, 18, 553–557.
74.
MälkkiK. (2012). Rethinking disorienting dilemmas within real–life crises: The role of reflection in negotiating emotionally chaotic experiences. Adult Education Quarterly, 62(3), 207–229.
75.
MälkkiK., & GreenL. (2014). Navigational aids: The phenomenology of transformative learning. Journal of Transformative Education, 12(1), 5–24.
76.
MamedeS., SchmidtH. G., & RikersR. (2006). Diagnostic errors and reflective practice in medicine. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice, 13, 138–145.
77.
MannK., GordonJ., & MacLeodA. (2009). Reflection and reflective practice in health professions education: A systematic review. Advances in Health Science Education, 14, 595–621.
78.
MantasK., & SchwindJ. K. (2014). Fostering transformative learning through cocreative artmaking process and emerging artful forms: Two educators reflect on and dialogue about a shared arts–based workshop experience. Journal of Transformative Education, 12(1), 74–94.
79.
McGregorC. (2004). Care(full) deliberation: A pedagogy for citizenship. Journal of Transformative Education, 2(2), 90–106.
80.
MerriamS. B. (2008). Adult learning theory for the twenty–first century. In Merriam'sS. B. (Ed.), New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education: Third Update on Adult Learning Theory (vol. 119, pp. 93–98). San Francisco: Wiley.
81.
MerriamS. B., & BieremaL. L. (2014). Adult learning: Linking theory to practice. SanFrancisco, CA: Jossey–Bass.
82.
MerriamS. B., CaffarellaR., & BaumgartnerL. (2007). Learning in adulthood: A comprehensive guide (3rd ed.). San Francisco: Jossey–Bass.
83.
MerriamS. B., & CourtenayB., & BaumgartnerL. (2003). On becoming a witch: Learning in a marginalized community of practice. Adult Education Quarterly, 53(3), 170–188.
84.
MerriamS. B., & NtseaneG. (2008). Transformational learning in Botswana: How culture shapes the process. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(3), 183–197.
85.
MezirowJ. (1990). How critical reflection triggers transformative learning. In J. Mezirow & Associates (Eds.), Fostering critical reflection in adulthood: A guide to transformative and emancipatory learning (pp. 1–20). San Francisco, CA: Jossey–Bass.
86.
MezirowJ. (1991). Transformative dimensions of adult learning. San Francisco, CA: Jossey–Bass.
87.
MezirowJ. (1998). On critical reflection. Adult Education Quarterly, 48(3), 185–198.
88.
MichelsonE. (2011). Autobiography and selfhood in the practice of adult learning. Adult Education Quarterly, 61(3), 3–21.
89.
MichelsonE. (2013). If the self is a text, what genre is it? Structure and ideology in narratives of learning. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(3), 199–214.
90.
MisakC. (2007). New Pragmatists. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
91.
MonkD. F. (2013). John Dewey and adult learning in museums. Adult Learning, 24(2), 63–71.
92.
MoonP. J. (2011). Bereaved elders: Transformative learning in late life. Adult Education Quarterly, 61(1), 22–39.
93.
MooreJ. (2005). Is higher education ready for transformative learning?: A question explored in the study of sustainability. Journal of Transformative Education, 3(1), 76–91.
94.
MorganG. (1997). Images of organization. London: Sage.
95.
MorganP. F. (2012). Following contemplative education students’ transformation through their “ground–of–being” experiences. Journal of Transformative Education, 10(1), 42–60.
96.
MorriceL. (2013). Learning and refugees: Recognizing the darker side of transformative learning. Adult Education Quarterly, 63(3), 251–271.
97.
NakagawaK., & ArzubiagaA. E. (2014). The use of social media in teaching race. Adult Learning, 25(3), 103–110.
NicolaidesA., & McCallumD. C. (2013). Inquiry in action for leadership in turbulent times: Exploring the connections between transformative learning and adaptive leadership. Journal of Transformative Education, 11(4), 246–260.
101.
NitschkeP., & MalviciniP. (2013). Drawing toward transformation and action in a forgotten barrio: Cultivating a learning and planning community. Journal of Transformative Education, 11(2), 127–144.
102.
NtseaneP. G. (2011). Culturally sensitive transformational learning: Incorporating the Afrocentric paradigm and African feminism. Adult Education Quarterly, 61(4), 307–323.
103.
OstromC. S., & MartinW. J., & ZacharakisJ. (2008). Autopoiesis and the cosmology of postmodern adult education. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(4), 299–317.
104.
PanasukR. M., & LewisS. (2012). Constructivism: Constructing meaning of making sense?International Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 2(20), 1–11.
105.
ParkC. L. (2010). Making sense of the meaning literature: An integrative review of meaning making and its effects on adjustments to stressful life events. Psychological Bulletin, 136(2), 257–301.
106.
PerryW. G. (1970). Forms of intellectual and ethical development in the college years: A scheme. New York, NY: Holt, Rinehart, and Winston.
107.
PfahlN. L., & WiessnerC. A. (2007). Creating new directions with story: Narrating life experience as story in community adult education contexts. Adult Learning, 18(3–4), 9–13.
108.
PiagetJ. (1950). The psychology of intelligence. London, England: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
PoutiatineM. I. (2009). What is transformation?: Nine principles toward an understanding of the transformational process for transformational leadership. Journal of Transformative Education, 7(3), 189–208.
111.
PreeceJ. (2003). Education for transformative leadership in Southern Africa. Journal of Transformative Education, 1(3), 245–263.
112.
RoessgerK. M. (2014). The effect of reflective activities on instrumental learning in adult work–related education: A critical review of the empirical research. Educational Research Review, 13, 17–34.
113.
RoessgerK. M. (2017a). From theory to practice: A quantitative content analysis of adult education's language on meaning making. Adult Education Quarterly, 67(3), 209–227.
114.
RoessgerK. M. (2017b). Establishing a functional conceptualization of reflection's meaning making criterion. Studies in the Education of Adults, 49(1), 75–91.
115.
RoseA. D. (2011). Perspectives on adult education: Reflections on the 2010 handbook of adult and continuing education. Adult Learning, 22(2), 43–44.
116.
RosenthalS. B., & BourgeoisP. L. (1977). Pragmatism, scientific method, and the phenomenological return to the lived experience. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, 38(1), 56–65.
117.
RuleP., & ModipaT. R. (2012). “We must believe in ourselves”: Attitudes and experiences of adult learners with disabilities in KwaZulu–Natal, South Africa. Adult Education Quarterly, 62(2), 138–158.
118.
Ruth–SahdL. A., & TisdellE. J. (2007). The meaning and use of intuition in novice nurses: A phenomenological study. Adult Education Quarterly, 57(2), 114–140.
119.
TaylorE. W. (2003). Attending graduate school in adult education and the impact on teaching beliefs: A longitudinal study. Journal of Transformative Education, 1(4), 349–367.
120.
TennantM. (1998). Adult education as a technology of the self. International Journal of Lifelong Education, 17(6), 364–376.
121.
TomesonM. A., & AarnoutseC. A. J. (1998). Effecten van een instructieprogramma voor het afleiden van woordbetekenissen [Effects of a training program in deriving word meanings]. Pedagogische Studiën, 75, 1–16.
SandsD., & TennantM. (2010). Transformative learning in the context of suicide bereavement. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(2), 99–121.
124.
Sealey–RuizY. (2007). Wrapping the curriculum around their lives: Using a culturally relevant curriculum with African American adult women. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(1), 44–60.
125.
SimsL., & SinclairJ. A. (2008). Learning through participatory resource management programs: Case studies from Cost Rica. Adult Education Quarterly, 58(2), 151–168.
126.
SmithJ. E. (2009). The meaning depends: Learning about me and my learning. Adult Learning, 20(2), 26–29.
127.
SmithR. O. (2005). Working with difference in online collaborative groups. Adult Education Quarterly, 55(3), 182–199.
128.
SodhiM. K., & CohenH. L. (2012). The manifestation and integration of embodied knowing into social work practice. Adult Education Quarterly, 62(2), 120–137.
129.
SteinnesJ. (2004). Transformative education in a poststructuralist perspective. Journal of Transformative Education, 2(4), 261–275.
StewartI., & RocheB. (2013). Relational frame theory: An overview. In DymondS. & RocheB. (Eds.), Advances in relational frame theory (pp. 52–71). Oakland, CA: New Harbinger.
132.
StuckeyH. L. (2009). Creative expression as a way of knowing in diabetes adult health education: An action research study. Adult Education Quarterly, 60(1), 46–64.
133.
WangV. C. X., & KingK. P. (2008). Transformative learning and ancient Asian educational perspectives. Journal of Transformative Education, 6(2), 136–150.
134.
WangV. C. X., & SarboL. (2004). Philosophy, role of adult eductators, and learning: How contextually adapted philosophies and the situational role of adult educators affect learners’ transformation and emancipation. Journal of Transformative Education, 2(3), 204–214.
135.
WangM., & YorksL. (2012). Behind the resume: A holistic approach to deepen self–awareness. Journal of Transformative Education, 10(3), 157–176.
136.
WernerT. P., & RogersK. S. (2013). Scholar–craftsmanship: Question–type, epistemology, culture of inquiry and personality–type in dissertation research. Adult Learning, 24(4), 159–166.
137.
WilsonA. L., & CerveroR. M. (2011). Program Planning. In RubensonK. (Ed.), Adult learning and education (pp. 88–94). Oxford: Elsevier.
138.
WittmanP., VeldeB. P., CarawanL., PokornyM., & KnightS. (2008). A writer's retreat as a facilitator for transformative learning. Journal of Transformative Education, 6(3), 201–211.
139.
WrightR. R., CoryellJ. E., MartinezM., HarmonR. H., & KeehnS. (2010). Rhyme, response, and reflection: An investigation of the possibilities for critical transformative learning through adult poetry reading. Journal of Transformative Education, 8(2), 103–123.
140.
WrightR. R., & SandlinJ. A. (2009). Cult TV, hip hop, shape–shifters, and vampire slayers: A review of the literature at the intersection of adult education and popular culture. Adult Education Quarterly, 59(2), 118–141.
141.
YorksL., & KaslE. (2006). I know more than I can say: A taxonomy for using expressing ways of knowing to foster transformative learning. Journal of Transformative Education, 4(1), 43–64.
142.
ZettleR. D., HayesS. C., Barnes–HolmesD., & BiglanA. (2016). The Wiley handbook of contextual behavioral science. Malden, MA: John Wiley & Sons.
143.
ZhaoK., & BiestaG. (2012). The moral dimension of lifelong learning: Giddens, Taylor, and the “Reflexive Project of the Self.”Adult Education Quarterly, 62(4), 332–350.
144.
ZieglerM. F., PaulusT. M., & WoodsideM. (2006). This course is helping us all arrive at new viewpoints, isn't it?: Making meaning through dialogue in a blended environment. Journal of Transformative Education, 4(4), 302–319.
