In anticipation of a validation program for the use of chlorine dioxide (CD) gas in the
decontamination of laminar flow biological safety cabinets, the use of Bacillus atrophaeus
(BA) and Geobacillus stearothermophilus (GS) endospores for biological indicators (BIs) of
CD gas decontaminations were studied. This work includes studies of BIs having either
paper or steel substrates. BI analyses were performed with both enumeration and
fractionation methods. Among the conclusions it was found that in using paper GS BIs,
results from enumeration analysis proved to be too variable to monitor CD
decontaminations. Targeted CD exposure levels provided significantly less than a 6-log
spore reduction of GS spores on steel substrates, but were very effective for GS BIs with
paper substrates. BA spores on paper proved to be suitable and repeatable for validation
work with either enumeration or fractionation analysis. Formaldehyde decontamination
conditions used in standard practices were largely ineffective to decontaminate the GS
indicators.
Research article
Free accessResearch articleFirst published September, 2008pp. 158-163
Peter C. B. Turnbull, Anatolio E. Reyes, Michael D. Chute , [...]
View All
Abstract
Aims:
To determine the effectiveness and limitations of ultraviolet (UV) germicidal lamps in biosafety cabinets and pass-boxes, with particular reference to anthrax spores.
Methods and Results:
An estimated 50 colony forming units (CFUs) of spores
of the Sterne strain of Bacillus anthracis were distributed on blood agar plates and on
smooth and rough plastic surfaces, glass slides, galvanized metal strips, squares of
writing paper, nitrocellulose/cellulose acetate strips, and membrane filters. After drying
these were exposed in triplicate to the UV sources of a Class 2 biosafety cabinet and a
biosafety level (BSL) 3 pass-box for various time periods. Viable B. anthracis could not
be recovered from hard surfaces at 15 minutes (the shortest time period tested) when fully
exposed to UV at intensities of ≥ 3.8 W/m2 (the lowest intensity tested) in a
Class 2 biosafety cabinet and a BSL3 pass-box. However, the penetrating ability of the UV
was found to be extremely limited with even the microstructural elements of nitrocellulose
or similar membranes able to substantially shield the spores. The UV failed totally to
penetrate thin (66 μm) paper or Petri dish plastic, although it did penetrate plastic
sandwich wrap.
Conclusions:
The UV from germicidal lamps in biosafety cabinets and pass-boxes is rapidly sporicidal for fully exposed anthrax spores on hard surfaces but is readily nullified by the slightest obstacle to direct exposure.
Significance and Impact of the Study:
The results fill a major information gap for those devising or following protocols for decontamination of items and materials in biosafety cabinets and pass-boxes. Such protocols need to be written around a full comprehension of the data presented here.
Research article
Free accessResearch articleFirst published September, 2008pp. 169-174