Transplant professionals need to gain a better understanding of the factors that facilitate willingness to donate a family member's organs, in order to increase the rate of organ donation.
Objective
To conduct an integrated analysis of demographic data relating to key family members, so as to help transplant professionals predict the likelihood that family members would be willing to donate organs.
Method
Demographic variables were collected on 753 brain-dead patients and 995 first-degree relatives in 20 Israeli hospitals from 2004 to 2009. The data were recorded by transplant coordinators who used a uniform format to document meetings with next of kin. The data were analyzed by using the Chaid Statistical Test from the SPSS statistical package.
Results
In this total study population, the most significant factor affecting the decision to donate was religion. With increasing religiousness, the likelihood of consent decreased. A large disparity was apparent among Moslems, Christians, and Jews. Within the religious groups, education (Jews), familial proximity to the deceased (Christians and Moslems), and the quality of relationships with the medical staff (Moslems) were the main predictors of consent.
Summary
Most countries have Christian, Moslem, and Jewish residents, so the conclusions of this study and its implications for practice should be relevant for transplant coordinators anywhere. The recommendations, which stem from the results of this study, relate to activities of transplant coordinators before and during their interaction with families, before the request for organ donation.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AshkenaziT.Factors That Facilitate or Inhibit Willingness to Donate Organs—Marketing Implications [master's thesis; in Hebrew].Tel Aviv, Israel: University of Tel Aviv; 2001.
2.
BrownCVFoulkrodK.H.DworaczykS. Barriers to obtaining family consent for potential organ donors. J Trauma.2010;68(2):447–451.
3.
KasiskeBLNeylanJFRiggioRR. The effect of race on access and outcome in transplantation. N Engl J Med.1991; 324(5):302–307.
4.
ParisiNKatzI.Attitudes toward posthumous organ donation and commitment to donate. Health Psychol.1986;5(6):565–580.
5.
PessemierEABemmaorACHanssensDM. Willingness to supply human body parts: Some empirical results. J Consum Res.1977;4(3):131–140.
6.
AshkenaziT.The Ramifications of Child Organ and Tissue Donations for the Mourning Process and Parents' Adjustment to Loss: A Comparative Study of Parents Choosing/Refusing to Donate Organs [dissertation; in Hebrew].Tel Aviv, Israel: University of Tel Aviv; 2010.
7.
BaranDLangevinSLebeauC.Organ donation: A portrait of family refusal in Québec. Transplant Proc.2009;41(8):3281–3283.
8.
WongLP. Knowledge, attitudes, practices and behaviors regarding deceased organ donation and transplantation in Malaysia's multi-ethnic society: A baseline study. Clin Transplant.2011; 25(1):E22–31.
9.
ClevelandSEJohnsonDL. Motivation and readiness of potential human tissue donors and nondonors. Psychosom Med.1970; 32(3):225–231.
10.
Gallup Organization. The American Public's Attitudes Toward Organ Donation and Transplantation.Boston, MA: The Partnership for Organ Donation; 1993.
11.
KeggieJ.Public attitudes towards organ transplantation in the United Kingdom. EDTNA-ERCA J.1996;22(2):18–20.
12.
RodrigueJRCornellDLHowardRJ. Does family disagreement affect donation decisions by next of kin?Prog Transplant.2008;18(3):179–184.
13.
NewtonJD. How does the general public view posthumous organ donation? A meta-synthesis of the qualitative literature. BMC Pub Health.2011;11:791.
McKenzieDPMcGorryPDWallaceCSLowLHCopolovDLSinghBS. Constructing a minimal diagnostic decision tree. Methods Inf Med.1993;32(2):161–166.
16.
AshkenaziTBermanMAmiBen SFadilaAAravotD.A bridge between hearts: Mutual organ donation by Arabs and Jews in Israel. Transplantation.2004;77(1):151–155, 156–157.
17.
CooperMLTaylorGJ, eds. Organ and Tissue Donation: A Reference Guide for Clergy.4th ed.Richmond, VA: United Network for Organ Sharing; 2000.
18.
WakefieldCEReidJHomewoodJ.Religious and ethnic influences on willingness to donate organs and donor behavior: An Australian perspective. Prog Transplant.2011; 21(2):161–168.
19.
SaleemTIshaqueSHabibN. Knowledge, attitudes and practices survey on organ donation among a selected adult population of Pakistan. BMC Med Ethics.2009;10:5.
20.
BasuPKHazariwalaKMChipmanML. Public attitudes toward donation of body parts, particularly the eye. Can J Ophthalmol.1989;24(5):216–220.
21.
PearlAJ. Get yourself a new heart: Judaism and the organ transplantation issue. Can Med Assoc J.1990;143(12):1365–1369.
22.
WooKT. Social and cultural aspects of organ donation in Asia. Ann Acad Med Singapore.1992;21(3):421–427.
23.
ExleyMWhiteNMartinJH. Why families say no to organ donation. Crit Care Nurse.2002;22(6):44–51.
24.
BurroughsTEHongBAKappelDFFreedmanBK. The stability of family decisions to consent or refuse organ donation: Would you do it again?Psychosom Med.1998;60 (2):156–162.
25.
MartinezJMLopezJSMartinAMartinMJScandroglioBMartinJM. Organ donation and family decision-making within the Spanish donation system. Soc Sci Med.2001; 53(4):405–421.
26.
SiminoffLAGordonNHewlettJArnoldRM. Factors influencing families' consent for donation of solid organs for transplantation. JAMA.2001;286(1):71–77.
27.
ManninenDLEvansRW. Public attitudes and behavior regarding organ donation. JAMA.1985;253(21):3111–3115.
28.
CallendarCOHallLEYeagerCLBarberJBDunstonGMPinn-WigginsVW. Organ donation and blacks: A critical frontier. N Engl J Med.1991;325(6):442–444.
29.
ShanteauJHarrisRJ. Why psychological research on organ donation? In: ShanteauJHarrisRJ, eds. Organ Donation and Transplantation: Psychological and Behavioral Factors.Washington, DC: American Psychological Association; 1992:1–10.
30.
MoraesBNBacalFTeixeiraMC. Behavior profile of family members of donors and nondonors of organs. Transplant Proc.2009;41(3):799–801.
31.
DejongWFranzHGWolfeSM. Requesting organ donation: An interview study of donor and nondonor families. Am J Crit Care.1998;7(1):13–23.
32.
IsraeliAAdmonDHiteYWoolfsonNIsraeliNAyalonA.Factors influencing consent to organ donation among Israeli families. Transplant Proc.1996;28(5):2991–2996.
33.
StroebeWStroebeM.Determinants of adjustment to bereavement in younger widows and widowers. In: StroebeMStroebeWHanssonRO, eds. Handbook of Bereavement: Theory, Research, and Intervention.New York, NY: Cambridge University Press; 1993:208–226.
34.
Videka-ShermanL.Coping with the death of a child: A study over time. Am J Orthopsychiatr.1982;52(4):688–698.
35.
Videka-ShermanLLiebermanM.The effects of self-help and psychotherapy intervention on child loss: The limits of recovery. Am J Orthopsychiatr.1985;55(1):70–82.
36.
PerkinsKA. The shortage of cadaver donor organs for transplantation—can psychology help?Am Psychol.1987;42(10): 921–930.
37.
BellaliTPapazoglouIPapadatouD.Empirically based recommendations to support parents facing the dilemma of paediatric cadaver organ donation. Intensive Crit Care Nurs.2007; 23(4):216–225.
38.
FultonJFultonRSimmonsR.The cadaver donor and the gift of life. In: SimmonsRGMarineSKSimmonsRL, eds. Gift of Life: The Effect of Organ Transplantation on Individual, Family, and Societal Dynamics.New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers; 1987:338–377.
