Long-run Cost Functions for Electricity Transmission

Abstract

Electricity transmission has become the pivotal industry segment for electricity restructuring. Yet, little is known about the shape of transmission cost functions. Reasons for this can be a lack of consensus about the definition of transmission output and the complexitity of the relationship between optimal grid expansion and output expansion. Knowledge of transmission cost functions could help firms (Transcos) and regulators plan transmission expansion and could help design regulatory incentive mechanisms. We explore transmission cost functions when the transmission output is defined as point-to-point transactions or financial transmission right (FTR) obligations and particularly explore expansion under loop-flows. We test the behavior of FTR-based cost functions for distinct network topologies and find evidence that cost functions defined as FTR outputs are piecewise differentiable and that they contain sections with negative marginal costs. Simulations, however, illustrate that such unusual properties do not stand in the way of applying price-cap incentive mechanisms to real-world transmission expansion. doi: 10.5547/ISSN0195-6574-EJ-Vol33-No1-6

Keywords

Electricity transmission Cost function Incentive regulation Merchant investment Congestion management

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baldick

Kahn

(1993). “Network Costs and the Regulation of Wholesale Competition in Electric Power,” Journal of Regulatory Economics 1993, 5(4): 367-84.

Baldick

O’Neill

R.P.

(2009). “Estimates of comparative costs for uprating transmission capacity,” IEEE Transactions on Power Delivery 24(2): 961-969.

Bresesti

Calisti

Cazzol

M.V.

Gatti

Provenzano

Vaiani

Vailati

(2009). “The Benefits of Transmission Expansions in the Competitive Electricity Markets,” Energy 34(3): 274-280

Bushnell

J.B.

Stoft

S.E.

(1996). “Electric Grid Investment under a Contract Network Regime, Journal of Regulatory Economics 10: 61-79.

Bushnell

J.B.

Stoft

S.E.

(1997). “Improving Private Incentives for Electric Grid Investment” Resource and Energy Economics 19: 85-108.

Chao

H.P.

Peck

(1996). “A Market Mechanism for Electric Power Transmission,” Journal of Regulatory Economics 10: 25-59.

Dismukes

D.E.

Cope III

R.F.

Mesyanzhinov

(1999). “Capacity and Economies of Scale in Electric Power Transmission” Utilities Policy, 7: 155-162.

Gasmi

Kennet

D.M.

Laffont

J.-J.

Sharkey

W.W.

(2002). Cost Proxy Models and Telecommunications Policy, Cambridge, Mass., and London: MIT Press.

Green

(1997). “Electricity Transmission Pricing—An International Comparison” Utilities Policy 6(3): 177-184

10.

Green

(2003). “Cost recovery and the efficient development of the grid,” in F. Leveque (ed.), Transport Pricing of Electricity Networks, Boston: Kluwer, pp. 137-154.

11.

Hogan

(2000). “Flowgate Rights and Wrongs” Mimeo, JFK School of Government, Harvard Electricity Policy Group, Harvard University, http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

12.

Hogan

(1992). “Contract Networks for Electric Power Transmission,” Journal of Regulatory Economics 4: 211-242.

13.

Hogan

(2002a). “Financial Transmission Right Incentives: Applications Beyond Hedging” Presentation to HEPG Twenty-Eighth Plenary Session, May 31, http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

14.

Hogan

(2002b). “Financial Transmission Right Formulations” Mimeo, JFK School of Government, Harvard Electricity Policy Group, Harvard University, http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/people/whogan.

15.

Hogan

Rosellon

Vogelsang

(2010). “Toward a Combined Merchant-Regulatory Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion” Journal of Regulatory Economics 38(2): 113-143.

16.

Joskow

Tirole

(2000): “Transmission Rights and Market Power on Electric Power Networks,” RAND Journal of Economics 31: 450-487.

17.

Joskow

Tirole

(2005). “Merchant Transmission Investment,” The Journal of Industrial Economics 53: 233-264.

18.

Kattuman

P.A.

Green

R.J.

Bialek

J. W.

(2004). “Allocating Electricity Transmission Costs Through Tracing: A Game-Theoretic Rationale,” Operations Research Letters 32(2): 114-120.

19.

Kristiansen

Rosellon

(2006). “A Merchant Mechanism for Electricity Transmission Expansion”, Journal of Regulatory Economics 29: 167-193.

20.

Laffont

J.J.

Tirole

(1996). “Creating Competition Through Interconnections: Theory and Practice” Journal of Regulatory Economics 10: 227-256.

21.

Leautier

T.-O.

(2000). “Regulation of an Electric Power Transmission Company” The Energy Journal 21: 61-92.

22.

Lima

D.A.

Padilha-Feltrin

Contreras

(2009). “An Overview on Network Cost Allocation Methods,” Electric Power Systems Research 79(5): 750-758.

23.

Olmos

Perez-Arriaga

I.J.

(2009). “A Comprehensive Approach for Computation and Implementation of Efficient Electricity Transmission Network Charges”, Energy Policy 37(12): 52855295.

24.

Olmos

Perez-Arriaga

I.J.

(2007). “An Assessment of Inter-TSO Compensation Algorithms in the Internal Electricity Market of The European Union”, International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Systems 29(10): 699-712.

25.

Oren

Spiller

Varaya

(1995). Nodal Prices and Transmission Rights: A Critical Appraisal, Electricity Journal 8: 24-35.

26.

Overbye

T.J.

Cheng

Sun

(2004). A Comparison of the AC and DC Power Flow Models for LMP Calculations. Proceedings of: 37th Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, Hawaii, USA, 5-8 Jan. 2004.

27.

Perez-Arriaga

J.I.

Rubio

F.J.

Puerta Gutierrez

J.F.

Arceluz

Marin

(1995). “Marginal Pricing of Transmission Services: An Analysis of Cost Recovery,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 10(1): 546-553.

28.

Ramirez

J. C.

Rosellon

(2002). “Pricing Natural Gas Distribution in Mexico” Energy Economics 24: 231-248.

29.

Rosellon

(2007). “A Regulatory Mechanism for Electricity Transmission in Mexico” Energy Policy 35: 3003-3014.

30.

Rosellon

Weigt

(2011). “A Dynamic Incentive Mechanism for Transmission Expansion in Electricity Networks: Theory, Modeling, and Application.” The Energy Journal 32(1): 119-148.

31.

Rosellon

Mislikova

Zenon

(2011). “Incentives for Transmission Investment in the PJM Electricity Market: FTRs or Regulation (or both?)”, Utilities Policy 19(1): 3-13.

32.

Rubio-Olderiz

Perez-Arriaga

I.J.

(2000). “Marginal Pricing of Transmission Services: A Comparative Analysis of Network Cost Allocation Methods,” IEEE Transactions on Power Systems 15: 448-454.

33.

Schweppe

Fred C.

Caramanis

Michael C.

Tabors

Richard D.

Bohn

Roger E.

(1988). Spot Pricing Of Electricity. Boston, Kluwer.

34.

Stigler

Heinz

Todem

Christian

(2005). “Optimization of the Austrian Electricity Sector (Control Zone of VERBUND APG) under the Constraints of Network Capacities by Nodal Pricing” Central European Journal of Operations Research 13: 105-125.

35.

Tanaka

(2007). “Extended Price Cap Mechanism for Efficient Transmission Expansion under Nodal Pricing” Network and Spatial Economics 7: 257-275.

36.

Villasana

(1984). “Transmission Network Planning Using Linear and Linear Mixed Integer Programming,” PhD dissertation, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute.

37.

Vogelsang

(2001). “Price Regulation for Independent Transmission Companies” Journal of Regulatory Economics 20: 141-65.

38.

Vogelsang

(2006). “Electricity Transmission Pricing and Performance-based Regulation” The Energy Journal, 27: 97-126.

39.

Varaya

Spiller

Oren

(1996). “Folk Theorems on Transmission Access: Proofs and Counterexamples,” Journal of Regulatory Economics 10: 5-23.

40.

C.W.

(1999). “Long-Run Marginal Cost Based Pricing of Interconnected System Wheeling,” Electric Power Systems Research 50(3): 205-212.

41.

C.W.

David

A.K.

(1997). “Pricing Transmission Services in the Context of Industry Deregulation,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 12(1): 503-510