Using the threshold cointegration methods, Enders-Siklos (2001) and Hansen-Seo (2002), this study finds that spot and futures prices in each of the four widely traded commodities, copper, gold, WTI oil and silver are asymmetrically co-integrated. However, the asymmetric adjustment to the long-run equilibrium differs among those commodities, reflecting different profitable opportunities. The adjustment is faster for copper after positive shocks, while it is faster for the safe havens oil, gold and silver after negative shocks. It is more the spot and not the futures price for the four commodities that focuses in its adjustment on long-run factors. In sum, the adjustments imply different trading strategies, depending on whether the faster adjustment happened from above or below the threshold.
AwokuseT. O.YangJ. (2003). “The informational role of commodity prices in formulating monetary policy: a reexamination.” Economics Letters, 219-224.
2.
BalkeN.FombyJ. (1997). “Threshold cointegration.” International Economic Review38: 627643.
3.
BorensteinS.CameronA.C.GilbertR. (1997). “Do gasoline prices respond asymmetrically to crude oil price changes?” Quarterly Journal of Economics112: 305-339.
4.
CashinP.McDormottC.ScottA. (1999). “The myth of co-moving commodity prices.” Discussion Paper # G99/9, Reserve Bank of New Zealand.
5.
ChanK. (1993). “Consistency and limiting distribution of the least squares estimator of a threshold autoregressive model.” Annals of Statistics21: 520-533.
6.
ChenL-H.FinneyF.M.KonS.L. (2005). “A threshold cointegration analysis of asymmetric price transmission from crude oil to gasoline prices.” Economics Letters89: 233-239.
7.
CinerC. (2001). “On the long-run relationship between gold and silver: a note.” Global Financial Journal12: 299-303.
8.
DebP.TrivediP.K.VarangisP. (1996). “The excess co-movement of commodity prices reconsidered.” Journal of Applied Econometrics11:, 275-91.
9.
Duffy-DenoK.T. (1996). “Retail price asymmetries in local gasoline markets.”Energy Economics 18: 81-92.
10.
ElliottG.RothenbergT.J.StockJ.H. (1996). “Efficient tests for an autoregressive unit root.” Econometrica64:813-836.
11.
EndersW.GrangerC. (1998). “Unit-root tests and asymmetric adjustment with an example using the term structure of interest rates.” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics16: 304-311.
12.
EngleR.GrangerC. (1987). “Cointegration and error-correction representation, estimation and testing.” Econometrica55: 251-2.
13.
EndersW.SiklosP.L. (2001). “Cointegration and threshold adjustment.” Journal of Business and Economic Statistics19:166-176.
14.
EwingB.HammoudehS.ThompsonM. (2006). “Examining asymmetric behavior in US petroleum futures and spot prices.” The Energy Journal27: 9-23.
15.
FattouhB. (2010). “The dynamics of crude oil price differential.” Energy Economics32:334-342.
16.
FrankM.StengosT. (1989). “Measuring the strangeness of gold and silver rates of return.” Review of Economic Studies56: 553-567.
17.
GodbyR.LintnerA. M.StengosT.WandschneiderB. (2000), “Testing for asymmetric pricing in the Canadian retail gasoline market.” Energy Economics22: 349-368.
18.
HammoudehS.EwingB.ThompsonM. (2008). “Threshold cointegration analysis of crude oil Benchmarks.” The Energy Journal29: 79-95.
19.
HammoudehS.SariR.EwingB. (2009). “Co-movements among strategic commodities, interest rate and exchange rate: a new look.” Contemporary Economic policy27: 251-269.
20.
HansenB. (1997). “Inference in TAR models.” Studies in Nonlinear Dynamics and Econometrics1: 119-131.
21.
HansenB. E.SeoB. (2002). “Testing for two regime threshold cointegration in vector-correction models.” Journal of Econometrics110: 293-318.
22.
LahartJ. (2004). “Ahead of the Tape: Dr. Copper.” WSJ, Section C, April5.
23.
LuceyB. M.TullyE. (2006). “The evolving relationship between gold and silver 1978-2002: evidence from a dynamic cointegration analysis: a note.” Applied Financial Economics Letters2: 47-53.
24.
PalaskasT. B. (1993). “Commodity prices: Implications of the co-movement and excess co-movement.” In NissakeM.HewittA. (eds.), Economic Crisis in Developing Countries: New Perspectives on Commodities, Trade and Finance, New York: printer, 89-103.
25.
PalaskasT.B.VarangisP.N. (1991). “Is there excess co-movement of primary commodity prices?” a cointegration test. Working paper series No. 758, International: Economics Department, Washington: World Bank.
26.
PindyckR.RotembergJ. (1990). “The excess co-movement of commodity prices.” Economic Journal100: 1173-89.
27.
TrivediP. K. (1995). “Tests of some hypotheses about the time series behavior of commodity prices.” InMaddalaG SPhillipsPeter C BSrinivasanT N (eds.), Advances in Econometrics and Quantitative Economics: Essays in Honor of C R Rao, Oxford: Blackwell, 382-412.
28.
ShinD. (1994), “Do product prices respond symmetrically to changes in crude oil prices?” OPEC Review18:137-157.
