High fossil fuel prices have rekindled interest in nuclear power. This paper identifies specific characteristics making nuclear power unattractive to merchant generators in liberalized electricity markets, and argues that non-fossil fuel technologies have an overlooked ‘option value’ given fuel and carbon price uncertainty. Stochastic optimization estimates the company option value of keeping open the choice between nuclear and gas technologies. The merchant option value decreases sharply as the correlation between electricity, gas, and carbon prices rises, casting doubt on whether merchant investors have adequate incentives to choose socially efficient diversification in liberalized electricity markets.
AwerbuchS.BergerM. (2003). “Energy Security and Diversity in the EU: A Mean-Variance Portfolio Approach.” International Energy Agency Research Paper, Paris, February2003.
2.
AwerbuchS.SauterR. (2005). “Exploiting the Oil-GDP Effect to Support Renewables Deployment.” Energy Policy, in Press.
3.
AverchH.JonhnsonL. (1962). “Behavior of the Firm under regulatory constraint.” American Economic Review52: 1053-69.
4.
Canadian Energy Research Institute (2004). Levelized Unit Electricity Cost Comparison of Alternate Technologies for Baseload Generation in Ontario. Calgary, CERI.
5.
Department of Energy (2006). Energy Information Administration (EIA). “Annual Energy Outlook”. DOE/EIA-0383(2006). January2006.
6.
DeutchJ.MonizE.AnsolabehereS.DriscollM.GrayP.HoldrenJ.JoskowP.LesterR.TodreasN.(2003). The Future Of Nuclear Power. An MIT Interdisciplinary Study, http://web.mit.edu/nuclearpower.
7.
Department of Trade and Industry (2005). Quarterly Energy Prices (Dec. 2005). www.dti.gov.uk/energy.
8.
DGEMP/Dideme (2003). “Coûts de référence de la production électrique”, December2003, Paris. www.industrie.gouv.fr/energie
9.
DixitA.PindyckR.(1994). Investment Under Uncertainty. Princeton University Press.
10.
European Commission (2000). Towards a European strategy for the security of energy supply DG Energy and Transport Green Paper COM (2000). 769 final. Adopted on 29November2000.
11.
FordA. (1999). “Cycles in competitive electricity markets: a simulation study of the western United States.” Energy Policy27(11): 637-658.
12.
FordA. (2001). “Waiting for the Boom: A Simulation Study of Plant Construction in California.” Energy Policy29(11): 847-869.
13.
GemanH.(2005). Commodities and Commodity Derivatives - Modelling and Pricing for Agricultur-als, Metals and Energy. John Wiley and Sons Ltd.
14.
GollierC.ProultD.ThaisF.WalgenwitzG.(2005). “Choice of nuclear power investments under price uncertainty: Valuing modularity.” Energy Economics27(4): 667-685.
15.
International Energy Agency and Nuclear Energy Agency (2000). Reduction of Capital Costs of nuclear power plants. OECD publication, Paris.
16.
International Energy Agency and Nuclear Energy Agency (2005). Projected costs of generating electricity, 2005 update. OECD publication, Paris.
17.
LiY.FlynnP. (2004). “Deregulated power prices: comparison of volatility.” Energy Policy32: 1591-1601.
18.
MurtoP.NeseG. (2002). “Input price risk and optimal timing of energy investment: choice between fossil- and biofuels.” Working Paper No. 25/02, Institute for Research in Economics and Business Administration, Bergen, May2002. http://ugle.svf.uib.no
19.
Nuclear Energy Agency (2000). Reduction of Capital Costs of Nuclear Power Plants. OECD publication, Paris.
20.
NewberyD.GreenR.(1996). “Regulation, public ownership, and privatisation of the English electricity industry.” InGilbertR.J.KahnE.P. eds., International Comparisons of Electricity Regulation, Cambridge University Press, pp. 25-81.
21.
NuttallW.J (2004). Nuclear Renaissance: Technologies and Policies for the Future of Nuclear Power. Bristol: Institute of Physics Publishing.
22.
OlsinaF.GarcesF.HaubrichH.-J. (2006). “Modelling long-term dynamics of electricity markets.” Energy Policy34(12): 1411-1433.
23.
PindyckR. (1993). “Investments of uncertain cost.” Journal of Financial Economics34: 53-76.
24.
Platts (2006a), European Power Daily. “Centrica Energy hopes to up power capacity”. 16March2006.
25.
Platts (2006b), European Power Daily. “UK’s Centrica ins coal-priced deal with Drax”. 12April2006.
26.
RoquesF.NewberyD.NuttallW. (2006). “Fuel mix diversification incentives in liberalised electricity markets: a Mean-Variance Portfolio Theory Approach.” Electricity Policy Research Group Working Paper, Cambridge, www.electricitypolicy.org.uk.
27.
RothwellG. (2006). “A Real Options Approach to Evaluating New Nuclear Plants.” The Energy Journal27 (1): 37-54.
28.
Royal Academy of Engineering (2004). The Cost of Generating Electricity. A study carried out by PB Power for the Royal Academy of Engineering, London.
29.
Scully Capital (2002). “Business Case for New Nuclear Power Plants: Bringing Public and Private Resources together for Nuclear Energy.” July2002.
30.
StenzelT. (2003). “Keeping the nuclear Option Open.” UK Parliamentary Office of Science and Technology Note 208.
31.
StirlingA. (2001). “Science and precaution in the appraisal of electricity supply options.” Journal of Hazardous Materials86: 55-75.
32.
TarjanneR.RissanenS(2000). “Nuclear power: least cost option for base-load electricity in Finland.” The Uranium Institute 25th Annual Symposium, 30 August-1September2000, London.
33.
TIACT (Texas Institute for the Advancement of Chemical Technology) (2005). NP2010 Texas Gulf Coast Nuclear Feasibility Study Final Report. U.S. DOE.
34.
TolleyG.JonesD.(2004). The Economic Future Of Nuclear Power. A Study Conducted at The University of Chicago, www.ne.doe.gov/reports/NuclIndustryStudy.pdf
35.
Uranium Information Center (2004). “Uranium Markets.” Nuclear Issues Briefing Paper 36, October2004. www.uic.com.au
36.
CongressU.S.(2005). Energy Policy Act of2005, Conference Report. House Report 109-190. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office.
37.
von der FehrN.-H.AmundsenE.BergmanL.(2005). “The Nordic Market: Signs of Stress?” The Energy Journal, Special Issue, European Electricity Liberalisation, edited by NewberyDavid, 26 (4): 71-99.
38.
World Nuclear Association (2005). “Plans for new reactors worldwide. ” April2005. www.world-nuclear.org/info/info.htm
