The Long-Run Efficiency of Real-Time Electricity Pricing

Abstract

Retail real-time pricing (RTP) of electricity - retail pricing that changes hourly to reflect the changing supply/demand balance - is very appealing to economists because it “sends the right price signals" Economic efficiency gains from RTP, however, are often confused with the short-term wealth transfers from producers to consumers that RTP can create. Abstracting from transfers, I focus on the long-run efficiency gains from adopting RTP in a competitive electricity market. Using simple simulations with realistic parameters, I demonstrate that the magnitude of efficiency gains from RTP is likely to be significant even if demand shows very little elasticity. I also show that “time-of-use" pricing, a simple peak and off-peak pricing system, is likely to capture a very small share of the efficiency gains that RTP offers.

Keywords

Electricity real-time pricing (RTP)time-of-use pricing (TOU)welfare

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Barbose

Goldman

Charles

Neenan

Bernie

(2004). “A Survey of Utility Experience with Real-Time Pricing,” Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory Working Paper No. LBNL-54238, December 2004. Available at http://eetd.lbl.gov/ea/ems/reports/54238.pdf .

Borenstein

(forthcoming). “Time-Varying Retail Electricity Prices: Theory and Practice,” in Griffin and Puller , eds., Electricity Deregulation: Choices and Challenges, Chicago: University of Chicago Press, forthcoming.

Borenstein

Bushnell

James B.

(1999), “An Empirical Analysis of Market Power in a Deregulated California Electricity Market,” Journal of Industrial Economics 47: 285-323.

Severin

Borenstein

Holland

Stephen P.

(2003). “Investment Efficiency in Competitive Electricity Markets With and Without Time-Varying Retail Prices,” Center for the Study of Energy Markets Working Paper No. 106, University of California Energy Institute, revised July. Available at http://www.ucei.org/PDF/csemwp106.pdf .

Borenstein

Holland

Stephen P.

(forthcoming). “On the Efficiency of Competitive Electricity Markets With Time-Invariant Retail Prices,” RAND Journal of Economics.

Bushnell

James B.

(forthcoming) “Looking for Trouble: Competition Policy in the U.S. Electricity Industry,” in Griffin and Puller , eds., Electricity Deregulation: Choices and Challenges, Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Braithwait

Steven D.

O’Sheasy

Michael

(2002). “RTP Customer Demand Response - Empirical Evidence on How Much Can You Expect,” in Faruqui and Eakin eds. Electricity Pricing in Transition, Boston, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.

Holland

Stephen P.

Mansur

Erin T.

(2005) “The Distributional and Environmental Effects of Time-Varying Prices in Competitive Electricity Markets,” Center for the Study of Energy Markets Working Paper No. 140, University of California Energy Institute, October. Available at http://www.ucei.org/PDF/csemwp140.pdf .

Mansur

Erin T.

(2003). “Vertical Integration in Restructured Electricity Markets: Measuring Market Efficiency and Firm Conduct,” Center for the Study of Energy Markets Working Paper No. 117, University of California Energy Institute, October. Available at http://www.ucei.org/PDF/csemwp117.pdf .

10.

Patrick

Robert H.

Wolak

Frank A.

(1997). “Estimating the Customer-Level Demand for Electricity Under Real-Time Market Prices,” Stanford University Working Paper. Available at ftp://zia.stanford.edu/pub/papers/rtppap.pdf.

11.

Ruff

Larry E.

(2002). “Demand Response: Reality versus ‘Resource’,” The Electricity Journal, 15(10):10-23.

12.

Steiner

Peter O

(1957). “Peak Loads and Efficient Pricing,” Quarterly Journal of Economics 72: 585-610.