Load Shifting Under Voluntary Residential Time-of-Use Rates

Abstract

Time-of-use (TOU) pricing has emerged in recent years as a popular rate program, offering utilities both a more efficient pricing mechanism and a tool for load management. Initial experiments with TOUpricing were generally designed to provide evidence on customer response to mandatory TOU rates, while residential TOU rates are currently being applied on a voluntary basis. In this paper evidence is provided on customer response in Pacific Gas and Electric ‘s voluntary TOUrate experiment. Comparing the results to those obtained in earlier mandatory experiments, volunteers are found to have a greater ability to shift usage in response to TOU rates than comparable customers on mandatory rates.

Keywords

Electriic utilities Load shifting TOU rates

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aigner

D. J.

(1984). “The Welfare Econometrics of Peak-Load Pricing for Electricity: Editor ‘s Introduction.” Journal of Econometrics, 26:1-15.

Aigner

D. J.

Ghali

. (1987). “Self-Selection in the Residential Electricity Time-of-Use Pricing of Experiments.” MRG Working paper #M8737, October.

Aigner

D. J.

Hausman. (1980). “Correcting for Truncation Bias in the Analysis of Experiments in Titne-of-Day Pricing of Electricity.” Bell Journal of Econometrics, 11: 131-142.

Aigner

D. J.

Learner

E. E.

. (1984). “Estimation of Time-of-Use Pricing Response in the Absence of Experimental Data.” Journal of Econometrics, 26:205-227.

Arrow

E. J.

Chenery

H. B.

Minhas

B. S.

Solow

R. M.

. (1961). “Capital Labor Substitution and Economic Efficiency.” Review of Economics and Statistics, 63:225-250.

Caves

D. W.

Christensen

L. R.

. (1980a). “Econometric Analysis of Residential Time-of-Use Electricity Pricing Experiments. Journal of Econometrics, 14: pp. 287-306.

Caves

D. W.

Christensen

L. R.

. (1980b). “Residential Substitution of Off-Peak for Peak Electricity Usage Under Time-of-Use Pricing.” The Energy Journal, 1(2):85-142.

Caves

D. W.

Christensen

L. R.

Herriges

J. A

(1984a). “Consistency of Residential Customer Response in Time-of-Use Electricity Pricing Experiments.” Journal of Econometrics, 26:179-203.

Caves

D. W„

Christensen

L. R.

Herriges

J. A

(1984b). “Residential Response to Time-of-Use Rates,” prepared by Christensen Associates for the Electric Power Research Institute, EA-3560, Research Project 1956-1 (June).

10.

Caves

D. W.

Christensen

L. R.

Herriges

J. A

(1987). “The Neoclassical Model of Consumer Demand with Identically Priced Commodities, with an Application to Time-of-Use Electricity Pricing.” The Rand Journal of Economics, Wintcr564-580.

11.

Caves

D. W.

Herriges

I. A

Kuester

K. A

(1985). “Analysis of the Pacific Gas and Electric Company Voluntary Time-of-Use Pricing Experiment for Residential Customers,” prepared by Christensen Associates for the Pacific Gas and Electric Company (December).

12.

Caves

D. W.

Herriges

J. A.

Kirsch

. (1987). “Voluntary Time-of-Use Rales and Involuntary Revenue Erosion.” Christensen Associates working paper (December).

13.

Hausman

J. A.

Trimble

. (1984). “Appliance Purchase and Usage Adaptation to a Permanent Titne-of-Day Electricity Rate Schedule.” Journal of Econometrics, 26:115-139.

14.

Heckman

J. J.

(1976). “The Common Structure of Statistical Models of Truncation, Sample Selection and Limited Dependent Variables and a Simple Estimator for Such Models.” Annals of Economic and Social Measurement, 5/4:475-492.

15.

Kohler

D. F.

Mitchell

B. M.

. (1984). “Response to Residential Time-of-Use Electricity Rates: How Transferable Are the Findings?” Journal of Econometrics, 26:141-177.

16.

Kuester

K. A

(1986). “Analysis of Customer Response to Electricity Rate Structures Which Create an Endogenous Electricity Price.” Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation. University of Wisconsin, Madison.

17.

Manning

W. G.

Acton

J. P.

. (1980). “Residential Electricity Demand Under Time-of-Day Pricing: Exploratory Data Analysis for the Los Angeles Rate Study.” Report to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power, Rand Corporation, California.

18.

Mitchell

B. M.

Acton

J. P.

. (1980). “Electricity Consumption by Time-of-Use in a Hybrid Demand System.” Report to the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and the John A Hartford Foundation, Rand Corporation, California.

19.

Pacific Gas and Electric Company . (1983). “Residential Time-of-Use Program: Semiannual Report, Volume 1.” Rate Department (December).

20.

Pacific Gas and Electric Company . (1984). “Residential Time-of-Use Program: Third Semiannual Report.” (July).

21.

Parks

R. W.

Weitzel

. (1984). “Measuring the Consumer Welfare Effects of Time-Differentiated Electricity Prices.” Journal of Econometrics, 26:35-64.

22.

Roy

(1942). Del I ‘Utilite: Contribution a la Théorie des Choix, Paris: Hermann, et Cie.