Business and Industry Project-Based Capstone Courses: Selecting Projects and Assessing Learning Outcomes

Abstract

This is the first of two articles in which the author shares experiences gained from the development and delivery of a business/industry project-based capstone course. The course integrates research, proposal development and design experience based on knowledge and skills acquired in earlier coursework. The course also incorporates standards and realistic constraints. Preparing students for ‘real world’ practices is an integral part of the curriculum for many engineering and technology programmes. Such preparation can involve numerous approaches to simulate realistic experiences, including engaging students with real-world external clients who might use their work. These practices offer the challenge of identifying and selecting suitable projects as well as developing the means to evaluate effectively the learning outcomes related to students' participation in such projects. This paper has two main parts. Part 1 concerns the process of project solicitation and communication with clients during different phases of the capstone project life. The difficulties encountered and the means of reducing their negative impacts are also addressed. Part 2 includes the development of the students' learning outcomes and the tools used to measure them. The second paper, also published in this issue of Industry and Higher Education, addresses some of the key factors in enhancing student learning in teams.

Keywords

capstone projects project-based learning industry projects student learning assessment ABET Criteria 3 and 4 North Dakota State University

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

ABET (2007), ABET Criteria for Accrediting Engineering Programs, ABET, Baltimore MD, available at www.abet.org.

Atman

C.J.

Adams

R.S.

Turns

(2000), ‘Using multiple methods to evaluate a freshmen design course’, Proceedings of the Annual Frontiers in Education Conference, Kansas City, MO, 18–21 October, pp S1A6–S1A13.

Cordon

Clarke

Westra

Allen

Cunnington

Drew

Gerbus

Klein

Walker

Odom

E.M.

Rink

K.K.

Beyerlein

S.W.

(2002), ‘Shop orientation to enhance design for manufacturing in capstone projects’, Proceedings of the Annual Frontiers in Education Conference, Boston, MA, 6–9 November, p F4D-6.

Czernikowski

R.S.

(2006), ‘Contrasting a college-wide engineering capstone design project's courses with a single department's capstone design project's courses’, paper presented at the ASEE St Lawrence Section Conference, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY, 17–18 November.

Gravander

J.W.

Neeley

K.A.

Luegenbiehl

H.C.

(2004), ‘Meeting ABET Criterion 4 – from specific examples to general guidelines’, paper presented at the American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition, Salt Lake City, UT, June.

Isgrig

(1983), ‘Integration in the interdisciplinary environment of program and project management’, North Dakota State University, Fargo, ND.

Kelly

W.E.

(2004), ‘Introduction to engineering standards in capstone design’, paper presented at ASEE Middle Atlantic Section Conference, Washington, DC, 22 October.

Little

King

(2001), ‘Selection criteria for cornerstone and capstone design projects’, Vol 17, Nos 4 and 5, pp 406–409.

Lock Haven University of Pennsylvania (undated), Honors Capstone Project Guidelines, www.lhup.edu/honors/Faculty/senior_project_info.htm.

10.

Maleki

Reza A.

(2008), ‘List of companies visited’, www.ndsu.edu/ndsu/maleki/companies.pdf.

11.

Manufacturing Systems Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison (undated), ‘Capstone course – the real world experience’, http://msep.engr.wisc.edu/index.php/students/capstoneexperience.

12.

McKenzie

L. J.

Trevisan

M. S.

Davis

D. C.

Beyerlein

S. W.

(2004), ‘Capstone design courses and assessment: A national study’, paper presented at the American Society for Engineering Education Annual Conference & Exposition, Salt Lake City, UT, June.

13.

Meyer

D. G.

(2005), ‘Capstone design outcome assessment: Instruments for quantitative evaluation’, Proceedings of the 35th ASEE/IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference, Indianapolis, IN, 19–22 October, pp F4D 7–F4D 11.

14.

Moore

R.C.

(undated), ‘Capstone courses’, online article, http://users.etown.edu/m/moorerc/capstone.html.

15.

University of Kentucky Assessment Center (2007), ‘Capstone Course’, www.uky.edu/Assessment/mcap.shtml.

16.

Washington State University Engineering Education Research Center (undated), ‘Engineering capstone design assessment’, http://eerc.wsu.edu/ASA/.