In 2006, Alaskans voted to pass an initiative, Ballot Measure 2, which, among several provisions, levied a head tax on every visiting cruise ship passenger per voyage. Money collected from the head tax was to be appropriated by the legislature to municipalities to defray their cost of providing public services to cruise tourism. This paper develops a simple model which treats the cruise ship passenger tax as a lump-sum tax and analyses how this tourist tax might influence consumer behaviour and the likely effects on the tourist industry, state and local governments and the residents of Alaska. The analytical framework can be adapted easily for use in other destinations where lawmakers contemplate the merits of levying head taxes on tourists.
Alaska Division of Elections (2006a), For an Act Providing for Taxation of Certain Commercial Ship Vessels, Pertaining to Certain Vessel Activities and Related to Ship Vessel Operations Taking Place in the Marine Waters of the State of Alaska, posted 13 July 2006, petition ID: 03CTAX, available online at http://www.elections.state.ak.us/petitions/03ctax.htm.
3.
Alaska Division of Elections (2006b), Primary Election Voter Pamphlet, Primary Election 22 August 2006, Juneau.
4.
AlaskaLegislature.com (2002), full text of Governor Knowles's State of the State speech, 11 January 2002.
Alaska State Legislature (2005), House Community and Regional Affairs Standing Committee, Hearing on House Bill No 2 – an Act relating to taxes regarding certain commercial passenger vessels operating in the state; and providing for an effective date, 5 April 2005, 20 pp.
BonhamC.FujiiE.ImE.MakJ. (1992), ‘The impact of the hotel room tax: An interrupted time series approach’, National Tax Journal, Vol 45, No 4, December, pp 433–442.
12.
BruceN. (1998), Public Finance and the American Economy, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA.
13.
Business Research and Economic Advisors (2006), The Contribution of the North American Cruise Industry to the US Economy in 2005, prepared for the International Council of Cruise Lines, Exton, PA.
CohenG.GeldhofJ. (2006), Statement in Support, Cruise Ship Taxation, Regulation, and Disclosure Initiative, Primary Ballot Measure #2–03 CTAX, July, available online at http://www.elections.state.ak.us/ballot_measures.php.
17.
CordesJ. (2005a), ‘Head tax’, in CordesJ.J.EbelR.D.GravelleJ.G., eds, Encyclopedia of Taxation and Tax Policy, Urban Institute Press, Washington, DC, p 175.
18.
CordesJ. (2005b), ‘Lump sum tax’, in CordesJ.J.EbelR.D.GravelleJ.G., eds, Encyclopedia of Taxation and Tax Policy, Urban Institute Press, Washington, DC, p 245.
19.
CorsoJ.R. (2003), ‘Port fees; federal law’, CBJ Law Department Memorandum, City and Borough of Juneau, April 18.
KleinR.A. (2005), Playing Off the Ports, BC and the Cruise Tourism Industry, Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives (CCPA), August, Vancouver.
28.
LitvinS.W.BrottsJ.C.BlackwellC.StylesA.K. (2006), ‘Expenditures of accommodations tax revenue: A South Carolina study’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 45, No 2, November, pp 150–157.
29.
MakJ. (1988), ‘Taxing hotel room rentals in the US’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 27, No 1, Summer, pp 10–15.
30.
MakJ. (2004), Tourism and the Economy, Understanding the Economics of Tourism, University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu, HI.
31.
MakJ. (2005), ‘Tourist taxes,’ in CordesJ.J.EbelR.D., and Gravelle. J.G., eds, The Encyclopedia of Taxation and Tax Policy, The Urban Institute Press, Washington, DC, pp 441–443.
32.
MakJ. (2006), ‘Taxation of travel and tourism’, in DwyerL.ForsythP., eds, International Handbook on the Economics of Tourism, Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc, Northhampton, MA, pp 251–265.
33.
MakJ. (2008), Developing a Dream Destination: Tourism and Tourism Policy Planning in Hawaii, University of Hawaii Press, Honolulu, HI.
34.
MakJ.NishimuraE. (1979), ‘The economics of a hotel room tax’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol XVII, No 4, Spring, pp 2–6.
35.
Mathematica, Inc (1970), The Visitor Industry and Hawaii's Economy: A Cost–Benefit Analysis, Mathematica, Inc, Princeton, NJ.
36.
GroupMcDowell (1998a), An Assessment of the Effects of the Cruise Industry on Local Government Revenues and Expenditures, Executive Summary with Supplemental Juneau Results, February, Juneau, AK.
37.
GroupMcDowell (1998b), Cruise Industry Impacts on Local Governments in Southeast Alaska, prepared for the South-East Conference, February, Juneau, AK.
38.
McDowell Group (2004), The Economic Impacts of the Cruise Industry in Alaska, 2003, Final Report, prepared for the North West CruiseShip Association, September, Juneau, AK.
39.
McDowell Group (2006), The Economic Impacts of the Cruise Industry in Alaska, 2005 Update, Executive Summary, April, Juneau, AK.
40.
MitchellF. (1970), ‘The value of tourism in East Africa’, Eastern Africa Economic Review, Vol 2, No 1, June, pp 1–21.
R.M. Towill Corporation (2004), Baseline Modeling Report, Analytical Tools and Methodologies, Environmental Modeling Study, Planning for Sustainable Tourism in Hawaii, final version, 25 July, prepared for the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism, Research and Economic Analysis Division, State of Hawaii.
45.
ReganW.M.PrisloeM.R. (2004), The Economic Impact of a Cruise Ship Visit on Connecticut's Economy, 19 March, Department of Economic and Community Department, Hartford, CT.
46.
SimonsJ.J. (2002), Merger Enforcement at the FTC, Keynote Address to the Tenth Annual Golden State Antitrust and Unfair Competition Law Institute, presented by the Antitrust and Unfair Competition Law Section of the State Bar of California, Santa Monica, CA, 24 October, available online at http://www.ftc.gov/speeches/other/021024mergerenforcement.htm.
SloanG. (2006), ‘Alaska's $50 “head tax” is a sign of the times’, USA Today, 1 September.
49.
SwopeR. (2004), FY05 Passenger Fee Proceeds, Memorandum to the Finance Committee, City and Borough of Juneau, 4 March. Also, Memoranda dated 6 May 2003, 23 March 2005 and 27 February 2006.
50.
TisdellC.A. (1983), ‘Public finance and the appropriation of gains from international tourism: Some theory with ASEAN and Australian illustrations’, Singapore Economic Review, 28, pp 3–20.
51.
Travel Weekly Daily Bulletin (2005), ‘The leisure travel planning: How consumers make travel decisions’, 27 June, Article ID#47244.
World Bank, Environment Department (2000), Tourism and the Environment in the Caribbean: An Economic Framework, Report No 20453-LAC, June, The World Bank, Washington, DC.
