Bt Cotton Performance and Constraints in Central India

Abstract

Field data collected in central India over a two-year period showed that Bt cotton hybrids reduced plant protection costs by Rs1,268/ha (Rs41 = US$1), raised the crop yield by 2.01 q/ha, worth Rs6,394/ha, and reduced the time spent by the crop in the field by 15–20 days. Cultivation of Bt cotton involved an additional cost of Rs3,720/ha, but increased the net returns by Rs2,674/ha over conventional hybrids. The higher price of seed, high risks, poor refuge management, incidence of wilt, high rates of discontinuance and poor monitoring were the major constraints reported by growers. The impact would be greater if the technology were embodied in the commonly grown hybrids. Development of transgenic varieties is one of the prime ways of reducing crop costs for the resource-poor conditions of rainfed central India.

Keywords

transgenic cotton hybrid refuge discontinuance partial budgeting India

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Edens

E. R.

Slinsky

Lenson

J. A.

Roberts

R. K.

, and Lantz

G. L.

(1998), ‘Economic analysis of genetically engineered Bt cotton for tobacco budworm and boll worm control’, Proceedings of Beltwide Cotton Conference, Vol 1, 5–9 January, National Cotton Council of America, San Diego, CA.

Edge

J. M.

Benedict

J. H.

Carroll

J. P.

, and Reding

H. K.

(2001), ‘Bollgard cotton: An assessment of global economic, environmental and social benefits’, The Journal of Cotton Science, Vol 5, pp 121–136.

International Cotton Advisory Committee – ICAC (2003), ‘Factors affecting adoption of Bt cotton’, The ICAC Recorder, Vol XXI, No 2, June, Technical Information Section, ICAC, Washington, DC.

Qaim

, and de Janvry

(2003), ‘Bt cotton, pesticide use and resistance development’, paper presented at the Annual Conference of the International Consortium of Agricultural Biotechnology Research (ICABR), 29 June–3 July, Revello, Italy.

Ramasundaram

Ingle

R. K.

, and Gajbhiye

H. L.

(2004), ‘Performance and constraints in Bt (MECH hybrids) cotton cultivation in farmers fields’, Abstract, Proceedings of National Symposium on Changing World Order – Cotton Research, Development and Policy in Context, 10–12 August, Hyderabad.

Steffey

K. L.

(2003), ‘Bt corn and insect resistance management: Whither refuges?’ Pest Management and Crop Development, Website: http://www.ag.uviuc.edu/cespubs/pest/articles/200323e.html.