In times of tourism uncertainty, practitioners need short-term forecasting methods. This study compares the forecasting accuracy of the basic structural method (BSM) and the neural network method to find the best structure for neural network models. Data for arrivals to Singapore are used to test the analysis while the naïve and Holt-Winters methods are used for base comparison of simpler models. The results confirm that the BSM remains a highly accurate method and that correctly structured neural models can outperform BSM and the simpler methods in the short term, and can also use short data series. These findings make neural methods significant candidates for future research.
AikenM. (1999), ‘Using a neural network to forecast inflation’, Industrial Management + Data Systems, Vol 99, No 7, pp 296–301.
2.
AnsujA.P.CamargoM.E.RadharamananR.PetryD.G. (1996), ‘Sales forecasting using time series and neural networks’, Computers & Industrial Engineering, Vol 31, No 1, pp 421–424.
3.
ArmstrongJ.S. (2001), ‘Evaluating forecasting methods’, in ArmstrongJ.S., ed, Principles of Forecasting, Kluwer, Dordrecht.
4.
AthiyamanA.RobertsonR.W. (1992), ‘Time series forecasting techniques: Short-term planning in tourism’, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol 4, No 1, pp 8–11
5.
Bar OnR. (1979), ‘Forecasting tourism - theory and practice’, Proceedings of TTRA Tenth Annual Conference, College of Business, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT.
6.
BishopC. (1995), Neural Networks for Pattern Recognition, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
7.
BoxG.E.P.TiaoG.C. (1975), ‘Intervention analysis with applications to economic and environmental problems’, Journal of the American Statistical Association, Vol 70, No 349, pp 70–79.
8.
BroomheadD.S.LoweD. (1989), Multivariate Functional Interpolation and Adaptive Networks, RSRE Memorandum No 4341, Royal Signals and Radar Establishment, Malvern.
9.
BurgerC.J.S.C.DohnalM.KathradaM.LawR. (2001), ‘A practitioner's guide to time series methods for tourism demand forecasting – a case study of Durban, South Africa’, Tourism Management, Vol 22, pp 403–409.
10.
CalantoneR.J.Di BenedettoC.A.BojanicD. (1987), ‘A comprehensive review of the tourism forecasting literature’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 26, No 2, pp 28–39.
ChanY.M.HuiT.K.YuenE. (1999), ‘Modelling the impact of sudden environmental changes on visitor arrival forecasts: The case of the Gulf War’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 37, pp 391–394.
13.
ChengB.TitteringtonD.M. (1994), ‘Neural networks: A review from a statistical perspective’, Statistical Science, Vol 9, No 1, pp 2–54.
14.
ChengW.McClainB.W.KellyC. (1997), ‘Artificial neural networks make their mark as a powerful tool for investors’, Review of Business, Vol 18, No 4, pp 4–9.
15.
ChiangW.C.UrbanT.L.BaldridgeG.W. (1996), ‘A neural network approach to mutual fund net asset value forecasting’, Omega, Vol 24, No 2, p 205.
16.
ChuF.L. (1998), ‘Forecasting tourism demand in Asian–Pacific countries’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 25, No 3, pp 597–615.
17.
CrouchG.I. (1994), ‘The study of international tourism demand: A survey of practice’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 32, No 2, pp 41–55.
18.
CrouchG.I.ShawR.N. (1990), ‘Determinants of international tourist flows: Findings from 30 years of empirical research’, paper presented at 21st Annual Conference of the Travel and Tourism Research Association, New Orleans, LA.
19.
CrouchG.I.SchultzL.ValerioP. (1992), ‘Marketing international tourism to Australia: A regression analysis’, Tourism Management, Vol 13, No 2, pp 196–208.
20.
CuthbertsonK.HallS.G.TaylorM.P. (1992), Applied Econometric Techniques, Simon & Schuster, New York.
21.
CybenkoG. (1989), ‘Approximation by superpositions of a sigmoid function’, Mathematics of Control Signals and Systems, Vol 2, pp 303–314.
22.
DavidsonR. (1994), Business Travel, Pitman, London.
23.
DharmaratneG.S. (1995), ‘Forecasting tourist arrivals in Barbados’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 22, No 4, pp 804–818.
24.
EngleR.F. (1978), ‘Estimating structural models of seasonality’, in ZellnerA., ed, Seasonal Analysis of Economic Time Series, Bureau of the Census, Washington, DC, pp 281–308.
25.
FadlallaA.LinL. (2001), ‘An analysis of the applications of neural networks in finance’, Interfaces, Vol 31, No 4, pp 112–122.
26.
FalhmanS. (1989), ‘Faster-learning variations of back-propagation: An empirical study’, in TouretzkyD.HintonG.SejnowskiT., eds, Proceedings of the 1988 Connectionist Models Summer School, Morgan-Kaufman, San Mateo, CA, pp 38–51.
27.
FausettL. (1994), Fundamentals of Neural Networks, Prentice Hall, New York.
28.
FernandoH.TurnerL.W.ReznikL. (1999), ‘Neural networks to forecast tourist arrivals to Japan from the USA’, paper presented at Third International Data Analysis Symposium, Aachen, 17 September.
FunahashiK. (1989), ‘On the approximate realisation of continuous mappings by neural networks’, Neural Networks, Vol 2, pp 183–192.
32.
GeurtsM.D.IbrahimI.B. (1975), ‘Comparing the Box–Jenkins approach with the exponentially smoothed forecasting model: Application to Hawaii tourists’, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol 12, pp 182–188.
33.
GohC.LawR. (2002), ‘Modelling and forecasting tourism demand for arrivals with stochastic nonstationary seasonality and intervention’, Tourism Management, Vol 23, No 5, pp 499–510.
34.
GonzalezP.MoralP. (1996), ‘Analysis of tourism trends in Spain,’Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 23, pp 739–754.
35.
GorrW.L. (1994), ‘Research prospective on neural network forecasting’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 10, pp 1–4.
36.
GorrW.L.NaginD.SzczypulaJ. (1994), ‘Comparative study of artificial neural network and statistical methods for predicting student grade point averages’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 10, pp 17–34.
37.
GreenidgeK. (2001), ‘Forecasting tourism demand: An STM approach’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 28, No 1, pp 98–112.
38.
HallC.M. (1994), Tourism and Politics: Policy, Power and Place, Belhaven, London.
39.
HarveyA.C. (1989), Forecasting, Structural Time Series Models and the Kalman Filter, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
40.
HarveyA.C.ToddP.H.J. (1983), ‘Forecasting economic time series with structural and Box–Jenkins models: A case study’, Journal of Business and Economic Statistics, Vol 1, No 4, pp 299–315.
41.
HaykinS. (1994), Neural Networks: A Comprehensive Foundation, Macmillan, New York.
42.
Hecht-NelsonR. (1989), ‘Theory of the back-propagation neural network’, Proceedings of the International Joint Conference on Neural Networks, Washington, DC, Vol I, pp 593–605.
43.
HillT.RemusW. (1994), ‘Neural network models for intelligent support of managerial decision making’, Decision Support Systems, Vol 11, pp 449–459.
44.
HillT.MarquezL.O'ConnorM.RemusW. (1994), ‘Artificial neural network models for forecasting and decision making’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 10, No 1, pp 5–16.
45.
HillT.O'ConnorM.RemusW. (1996), ‘Neural network models for time series forecasts’, Management Science, Vol 42, No 7, pp 1082–1092.
46.
HillT.O'ConnorM.RemusW. (1992), ‘Neural networks for time series forecasting’, Working Papers in Economics, University of Hawaii, Honolulu.
JacobsR.A. (1988), ‘Increased rates of convergence through learning rate adaptation’, Neural Networks, Vol 1, No 4, pp 295–308.
49.
JengJ.M.FesenmaierD.R. (1996), ‘A neural network approach to discrete choice-modelling’, Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing, Vol 5, pp 119–144.
50.
KalmanR.E. (1960), ‘A new approach to linear filtering and prediction problems’, Transactions ASME Journal of Basic Engineering, D 82, pp 35–42.
51.
KalmanR.E.BucyR.S. (1961), ‘New results in linear filtering and prediction theory’, Transactions ASME Journal of Basic Engineering, D 83, pp 95–108.
52.
KendallM.OrdJ.K. (1990), Time Series, 3rd edition, Edward Arnold, London.
53.
KitagawaG. (1981), ‘A nonstationary time series model and its fitting by a recursive filter,’Journal of Time Series Analysis, Vol 2, pp 103–116.
54.
KolarikT.RudorferG. (1994), ‘Time series forecasting using neural networks’, APL Quote Quad, Vol 25, pp 86–94.
55.
KosterA.SondakN.BourdiaW. (1990), ‘A business application of artificial neural network systems,’Journal of Computer Information Systems, Vol 31, No 3, pp 3–10.
56.
LapedesA.FarberR. (1987), Nonlinear Signal Processing Using Neural Networks: Prediction and System Modelling, Technical Report LA-UR-87-2662, Los Almos National Laboratory, Los Almos, NM.
57.
LawR. (2000), ‘Back-propagation learning in improving the accuracy of neural network-based tourism demand forecasting,’Tourism Management, Vol 21, pp 331–340.
58.
LawR.AuN. (1999), ‘A neural network model to forecast Japanese demand for travel to Hong Kong’, Tourism Management, Vol 20, No 1, pp 89–97.
59.
LeonardJ.A.KramerM.A.UngarL.H. (1992), ‘Using radial basis functions to approximate a function and its error bounds’, IEEE Transactions on Neural Networks, Vol 3.
60.
LimC. (1997), ‘An econometric classification and review of international tourism demand models’, Tourism Economics, Vol 3, No 1, pp 69–81.
61.
LimC.McAleerM. (2001), ‘Forecasting tourist arrivals’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 28, No 4, pp 965–977.
62.
LimC.McAleerM. (2002), ‘Time series forecasts of international travel demand for Australia’, Tourism Management, Vol 23, No 4, pp 389–396.
63.
LippmanR.P. (1987), ‘An introduction to computing with neural nets’, IEEE ASSP Magazine, April, pp 4–22.
64.
MahmoudE. (1984), ‘Accuracy in forecasting: A survey’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 3, pp 139–159.
65.
MakridakisS.AndersonA.CarboneR.FidesR.HibdonM.LewandowskiR.NewtonJ.ParzenE.WinklerR. (1982), ‘The accuracy of extrapolation (time series) methods: Results of a forecasting competition’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 1, pp 111–153.
66.
MakridakisS.WheelwrightS.C.HyndmanR.J. (1998), Forecasting: Methods and Applications, Wiley, New York.
67.
MarquezL.HillT.RemusW.WorthleyR. (1991), ‘Neural network models as an alternative to regression’, in TurbanE.TrippiR., eds, Neural Network Applications in Investment and Financial Services, Probus, Chicago, IL, pp 145–161.
68.
MartinC.A.WittS.F. (1989), ‘Forecasting tourism demand: A comparison of the accuracy of several quantitative methods’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 5, No 1, pp 1–13.
69.
MeinholdR.J.SingpurwallaN.D. (1983), ‘Understanding the Kalman filter’, American Statistician, Vol 37, pp 123–127.
70.
MoodyJ.E.DarkenC.J. (1989), ‘Fast learning in networks of locally-tuned processing units’, Neural Computation, Vol 1.
71.
MorleyC.L.SutiknoH. (1991), ‘Economic factors in the demand for business travel to Australia’, Regional Journal of Social Issues, Vol 25, pp 22–29.
72.
MoshiriS.CameronN. (2000), ‘Neural network versus econometric models in forecasting inflation’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 19, No 3, pp 201–217.
73.
NelsonM.HillT.RemusW.O'ConnorM. (1999), ‘Time series forecasting using neural networks: Should the data be deseasonalized first?’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 18, pp 359–367.
74.
NerloveM.GretherD.M.CarvalhoJ.L. (1979), Analysis of Economic Time Series, Academic Press, New York.
PattieD.C.SnyderJ. (1996), ‘Using a neural network to forecast visitor behaviour’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 23, No 1, pp 151–164.
77.
QiM. (1996), ‘Financial applications of artificial neural networks,’ in MaddalaG.S.RaoC.R., eds, Handbook of Statistics, Statistical Methods in Finance, North-Holland, Elsevier Science, Amsterdam, pp 529–552.
78.
QiM.ZhangG.P. (2001), ‘An investigation of model selection criteria for neural network time series forecasting’, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol 132, No 3, August, pp 666–680.
79.
RefenesA. N.ZapranisA.FrancisG. (1994), ‘Stock performance modelling using neural networks: A comparative study with regression models’, Neural Networks, Vol 7, No 2, pp 375–388.
80.
RefenesA.P. (1995), Neural Networks in the Capital Markets, Wiley, Chichester.
81.
RemusW.O'ConnorM. (2001), ‘Neural network models for time series forecasting,’ in ArmstrongJ.S., ed, Principles of Forecasting, Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 245–256.
82.
RipleyB.D. (1993), ‘Statistical aspects of neural networks’, in Barndorff-NielsenO.E.JensenJ.L.KendallW.S., eds, Networks and Chaos – Statistical and Probabilistic Aspects, Chapman and Hall, London, pp 44–123.
83.
RojasR. (1996), Neural Networks – a Systematic Introduction, Springer-Verlag, Berlin.
84.
RumelhartD.E.McClellandJ.L. (1996), Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the Microstructure of Cognition, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA.
85.
RumelhartD.E.HintonG.E.WilliamsR.J. (1986), ‘Learning representations by backpropagating errors,’Nature, pp 322, 533–536.
86.
SheldonP.J. (1993), ‘Forecasting tourism: Expenditures and arrivals’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 32, No 1, pp 13–20.
87.
SheldonP.J.VarT. (1985), ‘Tourism forecasting: A review of empirical research’, Journal of Forecasting, Vol 4, No 2, pp 183–195.
SmithK.A.GuptaJ.N.D. (2002), Neural Networks in Business: Techniques and Applications. Idea Group Publishing, Hershey, PA.
90.
SongH.WittS.F. (2000), Tourism Demand Modelling and Forecasting: Modern Econometric Approaches, Pergamon, Oxford.
91.
SongH.WittS.F.JensenT. (1999), ‘Forecasting performance of tourism demand models: The case of Denmark’, paper presented at 19th International Symposium on Forecasting, Washington, DC, 27–30 June.
92.
TkaczG. (2001), ‘Neural network forecasting of Canadian GDP growth’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 17, No 1, pp 57–69.
93.
TsaurY. C.ChiuY.C.HuangC.H. (2002), ‘Determinants of guest loyalty to international tourist hotels – a neural network approach’, Tourism Management, Vol 23, No 4, pp 397–405.
94.
TurbanE. (1995), Decision Support Systems and Expert Systems, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
95.
TurnerL.KulendranN.FernandoH. (1997a), ‘The use of composite national indicators for tourism forecasting’, Tourism Economics, Vol 3, No 4, pp 309–317.
96.
TurnerL.KulendranN.FernandoH. (1997b), ‘Univariate modelling using periodic and non-periodic analysis: Inbound tourism to Japan, Australia and New Zealand compared’, Tourism Economics, Vol 3, No 1, pp 39–56.
97.
TurnerL.W.KulendranN. (1993), ‘International tourism arrivals to Australia and the use of modern forecasting methodology’, Regional Journal of Social Issues, Vol 24, pp 33–63.
98.
TurnerL.W.WittS.F. (2001), ‘Forecasting tourism using univariate and multivariate structural time series models’, Tourism Economics, Vol 7, No 2, pp 135–147.
99.
TurnerL.W.WittS.F. (2003), Pacific Asia Tourism Forecasts 2003–2005, Pacific Asia Travel Association, Bangkok.
100.
TurnerL.W.KulendranN.FernandoH. (1995b), ‘Forecasting tourism to Australia and New Zealand: A comparative study using ARIMA and structural time series models with intervention variables’, Working Paper, National Tourism and Hospitality Conference, Melbourne, 16–17 February.
101.
TurnerL.W.KulendranN.PergatV. (1995a), ‘Forecasting New Zealand tourism demand with disaggregated data’, Tourism Economics, Vol 1, No 1, pp 51–69.
102.
TurnerL.W.ReisingerY.WittS.F. (1998), ‘Tourism demand analysis using structural equation modelling’, Tourism Economics, Vol 4, No 4, pp 301–323.
103.
UysalM.CromptonJ. L. (1985), ‘An overview of approaches used to forecast tourism demand’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 23, No 4, pp 7–15.
104.
UysalM.RoubiM.S. (1999), ‘Artificial neural networks versus multiple regression in tourism demand analysis’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 38, pp 111–118.
105.
Van DoornJ.W.M. (1984), ‘Tourism forecasting and the policymaker: Criteria of usefulness,’Tourism Management, Vol 5, pp 24–39.
106.
WalczakS. (2001), ‘An empirical analysis of data requirements for financial forecasting with Neural Networks’, Journal of Management Information Systems, Vol 17, No 4, pp 203–222.
107.
WarnerB.MisraM. (1996), ‘Understanding neural networks as statistical tools’, The American Statistician, Vol 50, No 4, pp 284–293.
108.
WassermanP.D. (1989), NeuroComputing: Theory and Practice, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York.
109.
WheelwrightS.MakridakisS. (1985), Forecasting Methods for Management, 4th edition, Wiley, New York.
110.
WhiteH. (1989), ‘Learning in artificial neural networks: A statistical perspective’, Neural Computation, Vol 1, pp 425–464.
111.
WhiteH.HornikK.StinchcombeM. (1992), ‘Universal approximation of an unknown mapping and its derivatives’, in WhiteH., ed, Artificial Neural Networks: Approximations and Learning Theory, Blackwell, Oxford, UK.
112.
WidrowR.RumelhartD.E.LehrM.A. (1994), ‘Neural networks: Applications in industry, business and science’, Communications of the ACM, Vol 37, No 3, pp 93–95.
113.
WittC.A.WittS.F.WilsonN. (1994), ‘Forecasting international tourist flows’, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol 21, No 3, pp 612–628.
114.
WittS.F. (1989a), ‘Forecasting international tourism demand: The econometric approach’, in WittS.F.MoutinhoL., eds, Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice-Hall, London, pp 163–167.
115.
WittS.F. (1989b), ‘Forecasting international tourism demand: Univariate time series methods’, in WittS.F.MoutinhoL., eds, Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice-Hall, London, pp 169–174.
116.
WittS.F. (1994), ‘Econometric demand forecasting’, in WittS.F.MoutinhoL., eds, Tourism Marketing and Management Handbook, Prentice-Hall, London, pp 516–520.
117.
WittS.F.WittC.A. (1995), ‘Forecasting tourism demand: A review of empirical research’, International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 11, No 3, pp 447–475.
118.
WittS.F.NewbouldG.D.WatkinsA. J. (1992), ‘Forecasting domestic tourism demand: Application to Las Vegas arrivals data’, Journal of Travel Research, Vol 31, No 1, pp 36–41.
119.
WittS.F.SykesA.M.DartusM. (1995), ‘Forecasting international conference attendance’, Tourism Management, Vol 16, No 8, pp 559–570.
120.
WongB.K.JiangL.LamJ. (2000), ‘A bibliography of neural network business application research: 1994–1998’, Computers and Operations Research, Vol 27, No 11, pp 1045–1076.
121.
YaoJ.T.TanC.L. (2000), ‘A case study on using neural networks to perform technical forecasting of forex’, Neurocomputing, Vol 34, No 1, pp 79–98.
122.
ZhangG.HuM.Y. (1998), ‘Neural network forecasting of the British pound/US dollar exchange rate’, Omega, Vol 26, No 4, pp 495–506.
123.
ZhangG.PutuwoB.E.HuM.Y. (1998), ‘Forecasting with artificial neural networks: The state of the art,’International Journal of Forecasting, Vol 14, pp 35–62.
