Strategic Implications of Benchmarking for Agricultural Cooperatives and Farmer-Controlled Enterprises in Wales

Abstract

This paper describes an empirical investigation of the application of benchmarking to cooperative enterprises in Wales to determine whether it was technically feasible, at what cost, and with what results. This entailed close sustained fieldwork with actual cooperatives, which was achieved by investigating the two largest farmer-controlled enterprises (FCEs) in Wales — Clynderwen and Cardiganshire Farmers Ltd, and Wynnstay and Clwyd Farmers Plc, who also collaborated in subsequent management appraisal and remedial action. The paper concludes that benchmarking is strategically feasible, that it has a favourable impact on the perceptions and attitudes of staff and members of participating cooperatives, and that it yields workable priorities and management recommendations, which can be implemented. Wider adoption of the technique by cooperatives is therefore recommended as a viable survival strategy — an alternative to the recent preference for abandonment of cooperative status. This is of particular significance for the marketing/entrepreneurship interface of FCEs in Wales.

Keywords

benchmarking agricultural cooperatives FCEs

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Al-Hasan

, and Haines

(1999), ‘The use of internal benchmarking in the co-operative sector’, The World of Cooperative Enterprise, Plunkett Foundation, Oxford.

Bendell

Boulter

, and Kelly

(1993), Benchmarking for Competitive Advantage, Pitman in association with the Financial Times, London.

Camp

(1989), The Search for Industry Best Practices that Lead to Superior Performance, American Society for Quality Control (ASQC), Quality Press, Milwaukee, WI.

Commission of the European Communities (1998), Good Practice in Technology Transfer, DGXIII Telecommunications, Information Market and Exploitation of Research, EU, Luxembourg.

Haines

(1999), Marketing for Farm and Rural Enterprise, Farming Press, Ipswich.

Haines

, and Al-Hasan

(1997), ‘Benchmarking: A case study of Welsh co-operative performance’, in Scheifer

, and Helbig

, eds, Quality Management and Process Improvement, Universitat Bonn-ILB, Bonn, pp 69–84.

Haines

, and Al-Hasan

(1998), ‘Benchmarking and the evaluation of co-operative performance’, The World of Cooperative Enterprise, Plunkett Foundation, Oxford.

Laidlaw

(1980), Co-operatives in the Year 2000, Co-operative Union of Canada, Ottawa.

Leppard

, and Molyneux

(1994), Auditing Your Customer Services, Routledge, London.

10.

Mann

R. S.

, and Adebanjo

O. A.

(1997), Business Excellence in the Food and Drink Industry — Practical Ways to Improve Performance, FT Management Report, Financial Times Retail & Consumer Publishing, London.

11.

Zeithaml

Parasurman

, and Leonard

(1990), Delivering Quality Service, Free Press, New York.