The UK Department for International Development's White Paper and Strategies for Achieving the International Development Targets recognize that knowledge and technology underpin development and that the elimination of poverty, improved economic growth and protection of the environment can be achieved through support for research and development that enhances the sustainable livelihoods of poor people. This philosophy is also the foundation of the Consultative Group on International Agricultural Research (CGIAR) future strategy, A New Vision for 2010. The DFID Crop Protection Programme (CPP) is committed to the development and promotion of socially and environmentally acceptable management technologies to reduce crop losses from pests in developing countries. Improved pest management is an essential part of a holistic approach to crop improvement, substantially contributing to poverty elimination, enhanced livelihood security and reduced environmental degradation. This article reports the progress being made in the development, application and promotion of a broad range of pest management technologies that farmers are adopting, especially in South Asia and Sub-Saharan Africa, home to most of the world's poorest people. Without the advances made by agricultural research, including crop protection technologies, during the past 30–40 years, the effects of poverty would have been far worse. Further support is essential to meet the challenges of producing even more food from even less land using technologies that have minimal adverse environmental impacts and that contribute to poverty elimination. Technologies such as host plant resistance, judicious use of pesticides, biological control and integrated pest management will have an increasingly important role to play in the future.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
DFID, The White Paper: Eliminating World Poverty: A Challenge for the 21st Century, DFID, London, 1997; DFID, Strategies for Achieving the International Development Targets: Environmental Sustainability and Eliminating Poverty, DFID, London, 2000.
2.
TAC, Charting the CGIAR's Future — A New Vision for 2010, TAC, Rome, May 2000.
3.
The term ‘pest’ is used sensu lato throughout the article. It refers to the complex of insect, nematode and vertebrate pests; fungal, bacterial, viral and phytoplasma pathogens; and weeds that affect crops. The term is qualified when it is used to specify a particular group of pests.
4.
UNDP, ‘Poverty in the human development perspective: Concept and measurement’, in UNDP Human Development Report, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1997, pp 15–23.
5.
CarneyD., Sustainable Rural Livelihoods — What Contribution Can We Make?DFID, London, 1998.
6.
CoxA.FarringtonJ. and GillingJ., ‘Developing a framework to assess the poverty impact of NR Research’, Final Draft to Steering Group, ODI/OPM, London, 1998.
7.
LiptonM. and LonghurstR., New Seeds and Poor People, Unwin Hyman, London, 1989; LiptonM. and RavallionM., ‘Poverty and policy’, in BehrmanJ. and SrinivasanT.N., eds, Handbook of Development Economics, Vol III, Elsevier Science, Oxford, 1995, pp 2552–2657.
8.
BaulchB., ‘Neglected trade-offs in poverty measurement’, IDS Bulletin, Vol 27, 1996, pp 36–55; UNDP, Poverty Eradication: A Policy Framework for Country Strategies, UNDP, 1998.
9.
UNDP, op cit, Ref 8.
10.
HazellP.B.K., ‘Agricultural growth, poverty alleviation and environmental sustainability: Having it all’, 2020 Vision Briefing, IFPRI, Washington, DC, March 1999a.
11.
Carney, op cit, Ref 5.
12.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7.
13.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7.
14.
Pinstrup-AndersenP.Pandya-LorchR. and RosengrantM.W., ‘The world food situation: Recent developments and emerging issues and long-term prospects’, 2020 Vision Food Policy Report, IFPRI, Washington, DC, 1997.
15.
Pinstrup-AndersenP.Pandya-LorchR. and RosengrantM.W., ‘World food prospects: Critical issues for the early 21st century’, 2020 Vision Food Policy Report, IFPRI, Washington, DC, 1999.
16.
IITA, ‘Towards sustainable development in Africa’, Medium Term Plan 1999–2001, Ibadan, Nigeria, 1998; WARDA, Medium Term Plan, 2000–2002, WARDA, Buoake, Cote d'Ivoire, 1998.
17.
HaddadL.RuelM. and GarrettJ., ‘Are urban poverty and undernutrition growing? Some newly assembled evidence’, FCND Discussion Paper No. 63, IFPRI, Washington, DC, 1999.
18.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7.
19.
OsmaniS.R., ‘Did the Green Revolution hurt the poor? A reexamination of the early critique’, in PingaliP.L. and HossainM., eds, Proceedings of the International Conference on the Impact of Rice Research, TDRI, Bangkok, and IRRI, Manila, 1998, pp 193–212.
20.
IRRI, Partners — Making a Difference, IRRI, Manila, 1997a.
21.
HazellP.B.K., ‘The impact of agricultural research on the poor’, paper presented at the CIAT Workshop on the Impact of Agricultural Research on Poverty Reduction, San José, Costa Rica, September 1999.
22.
Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 14.
23.
HossainM., ‘Rice research, technological progress, and the impact of rice research on the rural economy: The Bangladesh case’, in PingaliP.L. and HossainM., eds, Impact of Rice Research, Proceedings of the International Conference on the Impact of Rice Research, TDRI, Bangkok, and IRRI, Manila, 1998, pp 311–342; HossainM. and ShahabuddinQ., ‘Sustainable agricultural development in Bangladesh: Challenges and issues’, in BhuiyanS.I. and KarimA.N.M.R., eds, Increasing Rice Production in Bangladesh: Challenges and Strategies, IRRI, Manila, and BRRI, Dhaka, 1999, pp 53–63.
24.
Osmani, op cit, Ref 19.
25.
SenS., Reaping the Green Revolution: Food and Jobs for all, Tata McGraw-Hill, New Delhi, 1975.
26.
TrippR., ‘Biodiversity and modern crop varieties: Sharpening the debate’, Agriculture and Human Values, Vol 13, 1996, pp 48–63.
27.
FanS.HazellP., and ThoratS., ‘Link-ages between government spending, growth and poverty in rural India’, IFPRI Research Report, No 110, IFPRI, Washington, DC, 1999.
28.
Ibid.
29.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7; ConwayG., The Doubly Green Revolution: Food for All in the 21st Century, Penguin, London, 1997; EvansL.T., Feeding the Ten Billion: Plants and Population Growth, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998.
LargeC.E., The Advance of the Fungi, Jonathan Cape, London, 1940; CarefootG.L. and SprottE.R., Famine on the Wind, Angus and Robertson, London, 1969.
33.
Carefoot and Sprott, op cit, Ref 32.
34.
Large, op cit, Ref 32; SafeeulaS., ‘Genetic vulnerability: The basis of epidemics in India’, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, Vol 287, 1977, pp 72–85.
35.
PadmanabhanA., ‘The great Bengal rice famine’, Annual Review of Phytopathology, Vol 11, 1973, pp 11–26.
36.
NaiduR.A.BottenbergH.SubrahmanyamP.KimminsF.M.RobinsonD.J. and ThreshJ.M., ‘Epidemiology of groundnut rosette disease: Current status and future research needs’, Annals of Applied Biology, Vol 132, 1998, pp 525–548.
37.
Otim-NapeG.W.BuaA.ThreshJ.M.BagumaY.OgwalS.SemakulaG.N.ByabakamaB. and MartinA., Cassava Mosaic Disease in Uganda, The University of Greenwich, London, 1997.
38.
BandyopadhyayR.FredericksonD.E.McLarenN.W.OdvodyG.N. and RyleyM.J., ‘Ergot, a new disease threat to sorghum in the Americas and Australia’, Plant Disease, Vol 82, 1998, pp 356–367.
39.
MaxwellF. and JenningsP.J., Breeding for Insect Resistance in Crops, Macmillian, London, 1975.
40.
PingaliP.L. and GerpachioR.V., ‘Living with reduced pesticide use in tropical rice’, Food Policy, Vol 22, 1997, pp 107–118.
41.
HerrenH.R. and NeuenschwanderP., ‘Biological control of cassava pests in Africa’, Annual Review of Entomology, Vol 36, 1991, pp 257–283; Otim-Nape, op cit, Ref 37.
42.
OerekeE.C.DehneH.W.SchonbeckF. and WeberA., Crop Production and Crop Protection: Estimated Losses in Major Food and Cash Crops, Elsevier, London, 1994.
43.
TerryP.J., ‘The use of herbicides in the agriculture of developing countries’, Proceedings of Second International Weed Control Congress, Copenhagen, 1996, pp 601–609.
44.
HillocksR.J.LoganJ.W.M.RichesC.R.Russell-SmithA. and ShaxsonL.J., ‘Soil pests in traditional farming systems in Sub-Saharan Africa — a review. Part 1. Problems’, International Journal of Pest Management, Vol 42, 1996, pp 241–251.
45.
GresselT., ‘Plant biotechnology can quickly offer solutions to hunger in Africa’, The Scientist, Vol 19, 1996, p 10.
46.
RichesC.R.TwomlowS.J. and DhliwayoH., ‘Low-input weed management and conservation tillage in semi-arid Zimbabwe’, Experimental Agriculture, Vol 33, 1997, pp 173–187.
47.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7.
48.
WarburtonH. and MartinA.M., ‘Pest management and poor people's livelihoods’, in 1999 BCPC Symposium Proceedings No. 73: International Crop Protection: Achievements and Ambitions, BCPC, Farnham, 1999, pp 33–55.
49.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7; IFPRI, op cit, Ref 31.
50.
ThurstonH.D., Sustainable Practices for Pest Management in Traditional Farming Systems, Westview Press, Boulder, CO, 1992.
51.
ChibnikM., ‘Small farmer risk aversion: Peasant reality or policymakers' rationalization’, Culture and Agriculture, Vol 10, 1981, pp 1–5.
52.
HeiseyP.W.SmaleM.ByerleeD. and SouzaE., ‘Wheat rusts and the costs of genetic diversity in the Punjab of Pakistan’, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol 79, 1997, pp 726–737.
53.
Safeeula, op cit, Ref 34.
54.
NagarajanS. and JoshiL.M., ‘An historical account of the wheat rust epidemics in India and their significance’, Cereal Rusts Bulletin, Vol 3, 1975, pp 29–33.
55.
RajaramS.SinghR.P. and TorresE., ‘Current CIMMYT approaches in breeding wheat for rust resistance’, in SimmondsN.W. and RajaramS., eds, Breeding Strategies for Rusts of Wheat, CIMMYT, Mexico, 1988, pp 101–118; Heisey, op cit, Ref 52.
56.
Heisey, op cit, Ref 52.
57.
IRRI, Medium Term Plan. IRRI, 1998–2002, Manila, 1997b.
58.
OtsukaK.GasconF. and AsanoS., ‘Second-generation MVs and the evolution of the Green Revolution: The case of Central Luzon, 1966–1990’, Agricultural Economics, Vol 10, 1994, pp 283–295.
59.
MorrisM.L.DubinH.J. and PokhrelT., ‘Returns to wheat breeding research in Nepal’, Agricultural Economics, Vol 10, 1994, pp 269–282.
60.
SmaleM.SinghR.P.SayreK.PingaliP.RajaramS. and DubinH.J., ‘Estimating the economic impact of breeding nonspecific resistance to leaf rust in modern bred varieties’, Plant Disease, Vol 82, 1998, pp 1055–1061.
61.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7; Tripp, op cit, Ref 26.
62.
CIMMYT, Annual Report, CIMMYT, Mexico, 1995; HarringtonL., ‘Diversity by design’, CGIAR News, Vol 4, 1997, pp 5–8; GreenlandD.J., The Sustainability of Rice Farming, CAB International, Wallingford, and IRRI, 1997; PingaliP.L. and HossainM., Impact of Rice Research. Proceedings of the International Conference on the Impact of Rice Research, 3–5 June, Bangkok, TDRI, Bangkok, IRRI, Manila, 1998; SmaleM.HartellJ.HeiseyP.W. and SenauerB., ‘The contribution of genetic resources and diversity to wheat production in the Punjab of Pakistan’, American Journal of Agricultural Economics, Vol 80, 1998, pp 482–493.
63.
BantilanM.C. and JoshiN.K., ‘Returns to research and diffusion: Investments in wilt resistance in pigeon pea’, Impact Series, No 1, ICRISAT, India, 1996.
64.
ICRISAT, ‘A triple alliance towards prosperity’, Food from Thought, No 6, ICRISAT, India, 1997.
65.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40; RolaA.C. and PingaliP.L., Pesticides, Rice Productivity and Farmers Health: an Economic Assessment, World Resources Institute, and IRRI, Manila, 1993.
66.
RohrbachD.D.LechnerW.R.IpingeS.A. and MonyoE.S., ‘The impact from investments in crop breeding: The case of Okashana 1 in Namibia’, Impact Series, No 4, ICRISAT, India, 1999.
67.
YapiA.M.DebrahS.K.DehalaG. and NjomahaC., ‘Impact of germplasm research spillovers: The case of sorghum variety S35 in Cameroon and Chad’, Impact Series, No 3, ICRISAT, India, 1999; YapiA.M.DehalaG.NgawaraK. and IssakaA., ‘Assessment of the economic impact of sorghum variety S35 in Chad’, Impact Series, No 6, ICRISAT, India, 1999.
IITA, op cit, Ref 16; CIMMYT, People and Partnerships. Medium Term Plan 1999–2001, CIMMYT, Mexico, 1998.
70.
Otim-Nape, op cit, Ref 37.
71.
KenmoreP.E.CariñoF.O.PerezC.A.DyckV.A. and GutierrezA.P., ‘Population regulation of the rice brown planthopper within rice fields in the Philippines’, Philippine Journal of Plant Protection in the Tropics, Vol 1, 1984, pp 19–37; JoshiR.C.ShepherdB.M.KenmoreP.E. and LydiaR., ‘Insecticide induced resurgence of the brown planthopper, BPH, on IR62’, International Rice Research Newsletter, Vol 17, 1992, pp 9–10; SchoenlyK.D.CohenJ.E.HeongK.L.AridaG.BarrionA.T. and LitsingerJ.A., ‘Quantifying the impact of insecticides on food web structure of rice-arthropod populations in Philippine farmers' irrigated fields: A case study’, in PolisG. and WinemillerK., eds, Food Webs: Integration of Patterns and Dynamics, Chapman Hall, New York, 1996, pp 343–351.
72.
PerfectT.J., ‘Brown planthopper: Threat to the Green Revolution’, inaugural professorial lecture, University of Greenwich and the Natural Resources Institute, Chatham Maritime, 27 May 1998.
73.
Ibid.
74.
Perfect, op cit, Ref 72.
75.
ThomasM. and WaageJ., Integration of Biological Control and Host Plant Resistance Breeding: Scientific and Literature Review, CTA publication, Wageningen, 1996.
76.
Ibid.
77.
RussellD.A., ‘The impact of IPM research’, paper presented at the DFID NR Advisors' Conference, Sparsholt, UK, July 1997.
78.
JonesK.A., ‘IPM in developing countries — the Sri Lanka Experience’, Pesticide News, Vol 31, 1996, pp 4–5.
79.
NichollsC.I. and AltieriM.A., ‘Conventional agricultural development models and the persistence of the pesticide treadmill in Latin America’, International Journal of Sustainable Development and World Ecology, Vol 4, 1997, pp 93–111.
80.
Russell, op cit, Ref 77.
81.
ICRISAT, ‘Integrated management of a groundnut pest on India's eastern coast’, Food from Thought, No 1, ICRISAT, India, 1995.
82.
KARI, unpublished data.
83.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40.
84.
WarburtonH.PalisF.G. and PingaliP.L., ‘Farmer perceptions, knowledge and pesticide use practices’, in PingaliP.L. and RogerP.A., eds, Impact of Pesticides on Farmer Health and the Rice Environment, Kluwer Academic Publishers, and IRRI, Manila, 1995.
85.
Agrow, 277, 1997, p 18.
86.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40.
87.
LoevinsohnM., ‘Insecticide use and increased mortality in rural Central Luzon, Philippines’, The Lancet, Vol 8546, 1987, pp 1359–1362.
88.
FAO, Programma de Cooperacion de la Organizacion de las Naciones Unidas para la Agricultura y la Alimentacion (FAO) y el Gobierno de Bolivia, Documento del Proyecto, Enero, 1997.
89.
Ibid.
90.
‘The costs of pesticides’, Pesticide News, Vol 39, 1998.
91.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40.
92.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40.
93.
Gressel, op cit, Ref 45.
94.
PingaliP.L. and MarquezC.B., ‘Herbicides and rice farmer health. A Philippine study’, in NaylorR., ed, Herbicides in Asian Rice: Transitions in Weed Management, Stanford University, and IRRI, Manila, 1997.
95.
IITA, op cit, Ref 16; Herren and Neuenschwander, op cit, Ref 41.
96.
Thomas and Waage, op cit, Ref 75; WayM.J. and HeongK.L., ‘The role of biodiversity in the dynamics and management of insect pests of tropical irrigated rice — a review’, Bulletin of Entomological Research, Vol 84, 1994, pp 567–587.
97.
SettleW.H.AriawanH.AstutiE.T.CahayanaW.HakimA.L.HindayanaD.LestariA.Sri and Pajarningsih, ‘Managing tropical rice pests through conservation of generalist natural enemies and alternative prey’, Ecology, Vol 77, 1996, pp 1975–1988.
98.
Way and Heong, op cit, Ref 96; SchoenlyK.MewT.W. and ReichardtW., ‘Biological diversity in rice landscapes’, in DowlingN.G.GreenfieldS.M. and FischerK.S., eds, Sustainability of Rice in the Global Food System, Pacific Basin Study Centre, and IRRI, Davis, CA, 1998, pp 285–299.
99.
HazellP.B.K., ‘Changing patterns of variability in world cereal production’, in AndersonJ.R. and HazellP.R., eds, Variability in Grain Yields: Implications for Agricultural Research and Policy in Developing Countries, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MA, 1989; WoodD., ‘The benign effect of some agricultural specialization on the environment’, Ecological Economics, Vol 19, 1996, pp 107–111.
100.
Wood, op cit, Ref 99.
101.
Smale, op cit, Ref 60; Smale, op cit, Ref 62; RejesusR.M.SmaleM. and van GinkelM., ‘Wheat breeders' perspectives on genetic diversity and germplasm use: Findings from an international survey’, Plant Varieties and Seeds, Vol 9, 1996, pp 129–147.
102.
Otsuka, op cit, Ref 58; Greenland, op cit, Ref 62; Pingali and Hossain, op cit, Ref 62.
103.
Op cit, Ref 62.
104.
Conway, op cit, Ref 29.
105.
Harrington, op cit, Ref 62.
106.
Padmanabhan, op cit, Ref 35; SwaminathanM. S., ‘Plant protection for global food security’, Proceedings of the 10th Plant Protection Congress, Brighton, November 1983, pp 5–12.
107.
SenA., Poverty and Famines: an Essay on Entitlement and Deprivation, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1981.
108.
Ibid.
109.
Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 15.
110.
SchuhG.E., ‘The household: The neglected link in research and programmes for poverty alleviation’, Food Policy, Vol 25, 2000, pp 233–241.
111.
Harrington, op cit, Ref 62.
112.
KrattigerA., ‘The importance of ag-biotech to global prosperity’, ISAAA Briefs, No 6, 1998.
113.
ThompsonR.L., ‘Viewpoint: Public policy for sustainable agriculture and rural equity’, Food Policy, Vol 23, 1998, pp 1–7.
114.
Harrington, op cit, Ref 62.
115.
BorlaugN.E., Food Security, Plant Pathology and Quarantine, Public Forum Discussion on the Role of Plant Pathology in Global Food Security, 7th International Congress of Plant Pathology, Edinburgh, August 1998.
116.
Ibid.
117.
Hossain, op cit, Ref 23.
118.
Byerlee and Eicher, op cit, Ref 68.
119.
WoodD. and LennéJ.M., Agrobiodiversity: Characterization, Utilization and Management, CABI, UK, 1999.
120.
Lipton and Longhurst, op cit, Ref 7.
121.
Tripp, op cit, Ref 26.
122.
Pingali and Gerpachio, op cit, Ref 40.
123.
Pingali and Marquez, op cit, Ref 94.
124.
WARDA, op cit, Ref 16.
125.
IRRI, op cit, Ref 20.
126.
Thompson, op cit, Ref 113.
127.
Carney, op cit, Ref 5; AshleyC. and CarneyD., Sustainable Livelihoods: Lessons from Early Experience, DFID, London, 1999.
128.
Warburton and Martin, op cit, Ref 48.
129.
KerrJ. and KovalliS., ‘Impact of agricultural research on poverty alleviation: conceptual framework with illustrations from the literature’, paper prepared for the IAEG by IFPRI, Washington, DC, 1999.
130.
Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 14; Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 15.
131.
UNDP, op cit, Ref 8.
132.
Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 14; Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 15.
133.
UNDP, op cit, Ref 8; Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 15.
134.
Pinstrup-Andersen, op cit, Ref 15.
135.
BigmanD. and LoevinsohnM., ‘Targeting agricultural research and development for poverty reduction: general principles and an illustration from Sub-Saharan Africa’, paper presented at the CIAT Workshop on the Impact of Agricultural Research on Poverty Reduction, San José, Costa Rica, September 1999.
