To compare the effects of different implant placement and loading protocols on the marginal bone loss (MBL) in beagles by intraoral radiography.
Methods and materials
61 dental implants were inserted on 9 beagle dogs at bilateral lower posteriors according to 8 different protocols: immediate implant placement and immediate loading for 3 months (IIP + IL3) or 6 months (IIP + IL6) and unloading (IIP + UL), immediate implant placement and delayed loading for 3 months (IIP + DL3) or 6 months (IIP + DL6), delayed implant placement and immediate loading for 3 months (DIP + IL3) or delayed loading for 3 months (DIP + DL3) and unloading (DIP + UL). Intraoral radiography was performed to analyze the MBL during each surgery, before and after the implant placement and at 3-month intervals after the procedure.
Results
In total, 57 samples were included. There was less MBL (p<0.05) in the IIP + IL3 group (1.22 ± 0.63 mm) compared to the DIP + IL3 group (1.89 ± 0.9 mm). The longer the loading time, the more bone loss appeared in the IIP + IL group; however, the results were reversed in the IIP + DL group. The MBL during the latter 3-month period was dramatically decreased compared to the former 3-month period in the IIP + DL3 group (p<0.05).
Conclusions
The IIP + IL group seems superior to the DL protocol and the MBL changed significantly during the first three months and thereafter became stable.
BrånemarkP.I., HanssonB.O., AdellR.Osseointegrated implants in the treatment of the edentulous jaw. Experience from a 10-year period.Scand J Plast Reconstr Surg Suppl.1977; 16: 1–132.
2.
SchnitmanP.A., WohrleP.S., RubensteinJ.E.Immediate fixed interim prostheses supported by two-stage threaded implants: methodology and results.J Oral Implantol.1990; 16(2): 96–105.
3.
AdellR., LekholmU., RockierB., BrånemarkP.I.A 15-year study of osseointegrated implants in the treatment of the edentulous jaw.Int J Oral Surg.1981; 10(6): 387–416.
4.
RomanosG., TohC.G., SiarC.H.Peri-implant bone reactions to immediately loaded implants. An experimental study in monkeys.J Periodontol.2001; 72(4): 506–511.
5.
SchnitmanP.A., WöhrleP.S., RubensteinJ.E., DaSilvaJ.D., WangN.H.Ten-year results for Brånemark implants immediately loaded with fixed prostheses at implant placement.Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants.1997; 12(4): 495–503.
6.
BaroneA., MarconciniS., GiammarinaroE., MijiritskyE., GelpiF., CovaniU.Clinical outcomes of implants placed in extraction sockets and immediately restored: a 7-year single-cohort prospective study.Clin Implant Dent Relat Res.2016; 18(6): 1103–1112.
7.
GuruprasadaB.S., ThapliyalG.K., BrigV.R.P.A Comparative analysis of periimplant bone levels of immediate and conventionally loaded implants.Medical Journal Armed Forces India.2013; 69(1): 41–47.
8.
HuangY., Van DesselJ., LiangX.Effects of immediate and delayed loading on peri-implant trabecular structures: a cone beam CT evaluation.Clin Implant Dent Relat Res.2014; 16(6): 873–883.
9.
RismanchianM., AttarB.M., RazaviS.M., ShamsabadA.N., RezaeiM.Dental implants immediate loading versus the standard 2-staged protocol: an experimental study in dogs.J Oral Implanted.2012; 38(1): 3–10.
10.
ZhangS., WangS., SongY.Immediate loading for implant restoration compared with early or conventional loading: a metaanalysis.J Craniomaxillolacial Surg.2017; 45(6): 793–803.
11.
KühlS., ZürcherS., ZitzmannN.U., FilippiA., PayerM., Dagassan-BerndtD.Detection of peri-implant bone defects with different radiographic technique-a human cadaver study.Clin Oral Impl Res.2016; 27(5): 529–534.
12.
BotticelliD., BerglundhT., PerssonL.G., LindheJ.Bone regeneration at implants with turned or rough surfaces in self-contained defects. An experimental study in the dog.J Clin Periodontol.2005; 32(5): 448–455.
13.
LamE.W., RuprechtA., YangJ.Comparison of two-dimensional orthoradially reformatted computed tomography and panoramic radiography for dental implant treatment planning.J Prosthet Dent.1995; 74(1): 42–46.
14.
DegidiM., PiattelliA., GehrkeP., FeliceP., CarinciF.Five-year outcome of 111 immediate nonfunctional single restorations.J Oral Implantol.2006; 32(6): 277–285.
15.
WagenbergB.D., GinsburgT.R.Immediate implant placement on removal of the natural tooth: retrospective analysis of 1,081 implants.Compend Contin Educ Dent.2001; 22(5): 399–404, 406, 408 passim, quiz 412.
16.
LadinskyG.A., VasilicB., PopescuA.M.Trabecular structure quantified with the MRI-based virtual bone biopsy in postmenopausal women contributes to vertebral deformity burden independent of areal vertebral BMD.J Bone Miner Res.2008; 23(1): 64–74.
17.
AlbrekstssonT., IsidorF.Consensus report of session V. In: LangN.P., KarringT., eds. Proceedings of 1st European Workshop on Periodontology.Hanover Park, IL: Quintessence Publishing1993; 365–369.
18.
GhoveiziR., AlikhasiM., SiadatM.R., SiadatH., SorouriM.A radiographic comparison of progressive and conventional loading on crestal bone loss and density in single dental implants: a randomized controlled trial study.J Dent (Tehran).2013; 10(2): 155–163.
19.
AppletonR.S., NummikoskiP.V., PignoM.A., CroninR.J., ChungK.H.A radiographic assessment of progressive loading on bone around single osseointegrated implants in the posterior maxilla.Clin Oral Implants Res.2005; 16(2): 161–167.
20.
BansGüncü M.B., AsianY., TümerC., GüncüG.N., UysalS.In-patient comparison of immediate and conventional loaded implants in mandibular molar sites within 12 months.Clin Oral Implants Res.2008; 19(4): 335–341.
21.
DanzaM., TortoraP., QuarantaA., PerrottiV., VozzaI., PiattelliA.Randomised study for the 1-year crestal bone maintenance around modified diameter implants with different loading protocols: a radiographic evaluation.Clin Oral Investig.2010; 14(4): 417–426.
22.
Sanz-SanzinedI., Sanz-MartinI., FigueroE., SanzM.Clinical efficacy of immediate implant loading protocols compared to conventional loading depending on the type of the restoration: a systematic review.Clin Oral Implants Res.2015; 26(8): 964–982.
23.
ElsyadM.A., ElsaihE.A., KhairallahA.S.Marginal bone resorption around immediate and delayed loaded implants supporting a locator-retained mandibular overdenture. A 1-year randomised controlled trial.J Oral Rehabil.2014; 41(8): 608–618.
24.
GrandiT., GuazziP., SamaraniR.Immediate, early (3 weeks) and conventional loading (4 months) of single implants: Preliminary data at 1 year after loading from a pragmatic multicenter randomised controlled trial.Eur J Oral Implantol.2015; 8(2): 115–126.
25.
KokovicV., JungR., FeloutzisA., TodorovicV.S., JurisicM., HammerleC.H.Immediate vs. early loading of SLA implants in the posterior mandible: 5-year results of randomized controlled clinical trial.Clin Oral Implants Res.2014; 25(2): e114–e119.
DegidiM., NardiD., PiattelliA.Immediate versus one-stage restoration of small-diameter implants for a single missing maxillary lateral incisor: a 3-year randomized clinical trial.J Periodontol.2009; 80(9): 1393–1398.
28.
SchincagliaG.P., MarzolaR., GiovanniG.F., ChiaraC.S., ScottiR.Replacement of mandibular molars with single-unit restorations supported by wide-body implants: immediate versus delayed loading. A randomized controlled study.Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants.2008; 23(3): 474–480.
29.
KohenJ., MatalonS., BlockJ., OrmianerZ.Effect of implant insertion and loading protocol on long-term stability and crestal bone loss: A comparative study.J Prosthet Dent.2016; 115(6): 697–702.
30.
BarewalR.M., OatesT.W., MeredithN., CochranD.L.Resonance frequency measurement of implant stability in vivo on implants with a sandblasted and acid-etched surface.Int J Oral Maxillofac Implants.2003; 18(5): 641–651.
31.
GhanavatiF., ShayeghS.S., RahimiH.The effects of loading time on osseointegration and new bone formation around dental implants: a histologic and histomorphometric study in dogs.J Periodontol.2006; 77(10): 1701–1707.
32.
JacobsR., PittayapatP., van SteenbergheD.A split-mouth comparative study up to 16 years of two screw-shaped titanium implant systems.J Clin Periodontol.2010; 37(12): 1119–1127.
33.
RismanchianM., BajoghliF., GholamrezaT., RazaviM.Dental implants: early versus standard 2-stage loading (animal study).J Oral Implantol.2014; 40(1): 84–93.
34.
FischerK., BäckströmM., SennerbyL.Immediate and early loading of oxidized tapered implants in the partially edentulous maxilla: a 1-year prospective clinical, radiographic, and resonance frequency analysis study.Clin Implant Dent Relat Res.2009; 11(2): 69–80.
