English people are the largest national or ethnic minority within Scotland but
remain under-researched. This is despite a view taken by many writers, and by
the popular press, that anti-English attitudes within Scotland are a major
social problem. Via 30 in-depth interviews, this paper explores the experiences
of a group of English people living in Scotland and the extent and nature of any
anti-Englishness they have encountered. The paper also focuses on the ways in
which notions of race, ethnicity and essential differences between Scots and
English people are regularly encountered by English people living in Scotland.
The ‘racialisation’ of the English minority in Scotland is also discussed in
this context.
AnthiasF., and
YUVAL-DAVISN. (1992) Racialized
Boundaries: Race, Nation, Gender, Colour and the Anti-Racist
Struggle.London:
Routledge.
2.
ArmstrongB. (1989) A People
Without Prejudice? The Experience of Racism in Scotland.London: Runnymede
Trust.
3.
BaumanZ. (1992)
‘Soil, Blood and Identity’, The
Sociological Review40(4):
675–701.
4.
BechhoferF., McCRONED., KIELYR., and STEWARTR. (1999)
‘Constructing National Identity: Arts and Landed Elite's in
Scotland’, Sociology33: 515–534.
5.
BilligM. (1995) Banal
Nationalism.London:
Sage.
6.
BirklandT. A. (1997) Agenda
Setting, Public Policy and Focusing Events.Washington: Georgetown University
Press.
7.
BowesA., DARN., and SIMD. (1997)
‘Tenure Preference and Housing Strategy: an Exploration of
Pakistani Experiences’, Housing Studies12(1):
63–84.
8.
BowesA., McCLUSKEYJ., and SIMD. (1990)
‘Racism and Harassment of Asians in Glasgow’,
Ethnic and Racial Studies13(1):
71–91.
9.
BrownA., McCRONED., and PATERSONL. (editors) (1996)
Politics and Society in Scotland.Basingstoke:
Macmillan.
10.
CharlesworthS. (2000) A
Phenomenology of Working Class Experience.Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
11.
CohenA. P. (editor) (1982)
Belonging: Identity and Social Organisation in British Social
Cultures.Manchester: Manchester University
Press.
12.
CohenA.P. (1994) Self
Consciousness: An Alternative Anthropology of Identity.London:
Routledge.
13.
CohenA. P. (1996)
‘Personal Nationalism: A Scottish View of Some Rites, Rights
and Wrongs’, American Ethnologist23(4):
802–815.
14.
CohenS. (1972) Folk Devils
and Moral Panics.London: McGibbon and
Kee.
15.
CurticeJ., McCRONED., PARKA., and PATERSONL. (editors) (2002)
New Scotland, New Society?Edinburgh:
Polygon.
16.
DamerS. (2000)
‘Scotland in Miniature? Second Homes on
Arran’, Scottish Affairs31: 37–55.
17.
DevineT. M. (1999) The
Scottish Nation 1700-2000.London: Allen
Lane.
18.
DicksonM. B. (1994)
‘Should Auld Acquaintance be Forgot? A Comparison of the
Scots and English in Scotland’, Scottish
Affairs7: 112–134.
19.
EdensorT. (2002) National
Identity, Popular Culture and Everyday Life.Oxford:
Berg.
20.
EvansN. (1991)
‘Internal Colonialism? Colonisation, Economic Development and
Political Mobilisation in Wales, Scotland and Ireland’, in
DayG., and ReesG. (editors) Regions, Nations and
European integration: Remaking the Celtic Periphery.Cardiff: University of Wales
Press.
21.
GilroyP. (1987) There Ain't
No Black in the Union Jack, Chicago:
Chicago University Press.
22.
GilroyP. (1991)
‘Cultural Studies and Ethnic Absolutism’, in
GrossbergL., TreichlerP., and NelsonG. (editors) Cultural
Studies, New York:
Routledge.
23.
GoffmanE. (1968) Stigma:
Notes on the Management of Spoiled Identity.London:
Penguin.
24.
HallS. (1992) ‘New
Ethnicities’ in DonaldJ., and RattansiA. (editors) ‘Race’, Culture and
Difference, London:
Sage.
25.
HaselerS. (1996) The English
Tribe: Identity, Nation and Europe.Basingstoke:
Macmillan.
26.
HastingsA. (1997) The
Construction of Nationhood. Ethnicity, Religion and Nationalism.Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
27.
HechterM. (1975) Internal
Colonialism. The Celtic Fringe in British National Development
1536-1966.London: Routledge and Kegan
Paul.
28.
HarmanL. D. (1988) The
Modern Stranger: On Language and Membership.Berlin: Mouton de
Gruyter.
29.
IgnatieffM. (1994) Blood and
Belonging: Journeys into the New Nationalism.London:
Vintage.
30.
JarvieG., and BURNETTJ. (editors) (2000)
Sport Scotland and the Scots.Edinburgh: Tuckwell
Press.
31.
JarvieG., and REIDI. (editors) (1994)
Scottish Sport in the Making of the Nation.London: Leicester University
Press.
32.
JarvieG., and REIDI. (1999)
‘Scottish Sport, Nationalist Politics and
Culture’, Culture, Sport and Society2(2):
22–43.
33.
JedrejC., and NUTTALLM. (1996) White
Settlers. The Impact of Rural Re-Population in Scotland.Luxembourg:
Harwood.
34.
KeatingM. (2001) Nations
Against the State: The New Politics of Nationalism in Quebec, Catalonia and
Scotland.London:
Palgrave.
35.
KielyR., BECHHOFERF., STEWARTR., and McCRONED. (2001) ‘The
Markers and Rules of Scottish National Identity’,
Sociological Review49(1):
33–55.
36.
KielyR., McCRONED., BECHHOFERF., and STEWARTR. (2000)
‘Debatable Land: National and Local Identity in a Border
Town’, Sociological Research Online5(2) http://www.socresonline.org.uk/5/2/kiely.html.
37.
LindsayI. (1997) ‘The
Uses and Abuses of National Stereotypes’, Scottish
Affairs20: 133–148.
38.
MacdonaldS. (1997) Reimagining
Culture: Histories, Identities and the Gaelic Renaissance.Oxford:
Berg.
39.
ManningN. (1989)
‘Constructing Social Problems’ in
ManningNick (editor) Social Problems and
Welfare Ideology.Gower Publishing:
Aldershot.
40.
MarrA. (2000) The Day
Britain Died.London: Profile
Books.
41.
MasonA. (2000) Community,
Solidarity and Belonging: Levels of Community and their Normative
Significance.Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
42.
MccroneD. (1997)
‘Unmasking Britannia: the rise and fall of British national
identity’Nations and Nationalism, 3(4):
79–596.
43.
MccroneD. (1998) The
Sociology of Nationalism.London:
Routledge.
44.
McdonaldM. (1986)
‘Celtic Ethnic Kinship and the Problem of Being
English’, Current Anthropology,
27(4):
333–341.
45.
McintoshI., SIMD., and ROBERTSOND. (2004) “We
Hate the English Except for you, cos you're our Pal’: Identification of the
‘English’ in Scotland’.Sociology38(1):
43–59.
46.
MilesR. (1989)
Racism.London:
Routledge.
47.
MilesR. (1993) Racism
after ‘Race Relations’.London:
Routledge.
48.
ModoodT., and BERTHOUDR. (1997) Ethnic
Minorities in Britain: Diversity and Disadvantage.London: Policy Studies
Institute.
49.
MoorhouseH (1989)
“We're of to Wembley; The History of a Scottish Event and the
Sociology of Football Hooliganism’ In
McCroneD., KendrickS., and StrawP. (editors), The Making of
Scotland: Nation, Culture and Social Change,
Edinburgh: Edinburgh
University Press.
50.
MorenoL. (1988)
‘Scotland and Catalonia: the Path to Home
Rule’ In McCroneD., and BrownA. (editors), Scottish Government
YearbookEdinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press.
51.
MorleyD., and CHENK (editors) (1996)
Stuart Hall: Critical Dialogues in Cultural Studies.London:
Routledge.
52.
NairnT. (1981) The Break
Up of Britain: Crisis and Neo- NationalismLondon:
NLB.
53.
NairnT. (2000) After
Britain: New Labour and the Return of Scotland.London:
Granta.
54.
PatersonL., BROWNA., CURTICEJ., HINDSK., McCRONED., PARKA., SPROSTONK., and SURRIDGEP. (2001) New
Scotland, New Politics?, Edinburgh:
Polygon.
55.
PaxmanJ. (1998) The
English. A Portrait of a People.London: Michael
Joseph.
56.
SandisonB. (1998).
‘The invasion of Wupert, Dick and Harry’,
Herald 18.7.98, p. 17.
57.
SchutzA. (1972) The
Phenomenology of the Social World.London:
Heinemann.
58.
ScottP. H. (1988) Still in
Bed with an Elephant.Edinburgh: Saltire
Society.
59.
SmoutT. C. (1994)
‘Perspectives on the Scottish Identity’,
Scottish Affairs6: 101–113.
60.
ThompsonK. (1998) Moral
Panics, London:
Routledge.
61.
TomaneyJ. (1999) ‘In
Search of English Regionalism: The Case of the North East’,
Scottish Affairs28: 62–82.
62.
WatsonM. (2003) Being
English in Scotland.Edinburgh: Edinburgh University
Press.
