A Comparison of Gender Differences in Academic Self-Concept and Motivation Between High-Ability and Average Chinese Adolescents

Abstract

This study examined gender differences in academic self-concept, self-esteem, and academic motivation among high-ability Chinese adolescents. Study 1 studied gender differences in a key school as compared to a regular school using a school-type-by-gender MANOVA design. Participants were 208 10th-grade students from the two schools. Consistent with the extent literature on American adolescents, boys at the regular school demonstrated higher math self-concept, and girls demonstrated higher verbal self-concept. In contrast, for the key school, girls and boys had comparable math self-concept and girls had higher general academic self-concept than boys, which is at variance with the findings on high-ability American and European adolescents. As a replication, Study 2 used a between-class design with a group of 148 10th-grade students from a regular school that grouped the top 50 students in one class. Gender differences in math and verbal self-concepts were comparable between the high-ability class and two regular classes and more consistent with what was found with regular school students than with the key school students in Study 1. The discrepancies of the findings of the two studies are discussed in light of the social-contextual nature of academic self-concept and designs of the two studies.