It has been shown that mechanical ventilation by itself can cause lung injury and affect outcomes. Ventilator-induced lung injury is associated with high tidal volumes in lungs afflicted with ARDS. However, the question is: Do high tidal volumes have this same effect in normal lungs or lungs that have respiratory compromise stemming from something other than ARDS? Many clinicians believe that a tidal volume strategy of 6 mL/kg predicted body weight should be standard practice in all patients receiving mechanical ventilation. There is a growing body of evidence related to this issue, and this is the debate that will be tackled in this paper from both pro and con perspectives.
TenneySM, RemmersJE. Comparative quantitative morphology of the mammalian lung: diffusing area. Nature, 1963; 197:54–56.
2.
DreyfussD, SolerP, BassetG, SaumonG. High inflation pressure pulmonary edema: respective effects of high airway pressure, high tidal volume, and positive end-expiratory pressure. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1988; 137(5):1159–1164.
3.
TremblayL, ValenzaF, RibeiroSP, LiJ, SlutskyAS. Injurious ventilatory strategies increase cytokines and c-fos m-RNA expression in an isolated rat lung model. J Clin Invest, 1997; 99(5):944–952.
4.
HernandezLA, PeevyKJ, MoiseAA, ParkerJC. Chest wall restriction limits high airway pressure-induced lung injury in young rabbits. J Appl Physiol, 1989; 66(5):2364–2368.
5.
TsunoK, PratoP, KolobowT. Acute lung injury from mechanical ventilation at moderately high airway pressures. J Appl Physiol, 1990; 69(3):956–961.
6.
AdkinsWK, HernandezLA, CokerPJ, BuchananB, ParkerJC. Age effects susceptibility to pulmonary barotrauma in rabbits. Crit Care Med, 1991; 19(3):390–393.
7.
HegemanMA, HemmesSN, KuipersMT, BosLD, JongsmaG, RoelofsJJ, et al. The extent of ventilator-induced lung injury in mice partly depends on duration of mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Res Pract, 2013; 2013:435236.
8.
MenendezC, Martinez-CaroL, MorenoL, NinN, Moral-SanzJ, MoralesD, et al. Pulmonary vascular dysfunction induced by high tidal volume mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Med, 2013; 41(8):e149–e155.
9.
BrochardL, Roudot-ThoravalF, RoupieE, DelclauxC, ChastreJ, Fernandez-MondéjarE, et al. Tidal volume reduction for prevention of ventilator-induced lung injury in acute respiratory distress syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 1998; 158(6):1831–1838.
10.
AmatoMB, BarbasCS, MedeirosDM, MagaldiRB, SchettinoGP, Lorenzi-FilhoG, et al. Effect of a protective-ventilation strategy on mortality in the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med, 1998; 338(6):347–354.
11.
StewartTE, MeadeMO, CookDJ, GrantonJT, HodderRV, LapinskySE, et al. Evaluation of a ventilation strategy to prevent barotrauma in patients at high risk for acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med, 1998; 338(6):355–361.
12.
The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network. Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med, 2000; 342(18):1301–1308.
13.
PlatakiM, HubmayrRD. The physical basis of ventilator-induced lung injury. Expert Rev Respir Med, 2010; 4(3):373–385.
14.
GajicO, DaraSI, MendezJL, AdesanyaAO, FesticE, CaplesSM, et al. Ventilator-associated lung injury in patients without acute lung injury at the onset of mechanical ventilation. Crit Care Med, 2004; 32(9):1817–1824.
15.
GajicO, Frutos-VivarF, EstebanA, HubmayrRD, AnzuetoA. Ventilator settings as a risk factor for acute respiratory distress syndrome in mechanically ventilated patients. Intensive Care Med, 2005; 31(7):922–926.
16.
MasciaL, ZavalaE, BosmaK, PaseroD, DecaroliD, AndrewsP, et al. High tidal volume is associated with the development of acute lung injury after severe brain injury: an international observational study. Crit Care Med, 2007; 35(8):1815–1820.
17.
MasciaL, PaseroD, SlutskyAS, ArguisMJ, BerardinoM, GrassoS, et al. Effect of a lung protective strategy for organ donors on eligibility and availability of lungs for transplantation: a randomized controlled trial. JAMA, 2010; 304(23):2620–2627.
18.
DetermannRM, RoyakkersA, WolthuisEK, VlaarAP, ChoiG, PaulusF, et al. Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with conventional tidal volumes for patients without acute lung injury: a preventive randomized controlled trial. Crit Care, 2010; 14(1):R1.
19.
Pinheiro de OliveiraR, HetzelMP, dos Anjos SilvaM, DallegraveD, FriedmanG. Mechanical ventilation with high tidal volume induces inflammation in patients without lung disease. Crit Care, 2010; 14(2):R39.
20.
SutherasanY, VargasM, PelosiP. Protective mechanical ventilation in the non-injured lung: review and meta-analysis. Crit Care, 2014; 18(2):211.
21.
Serpa NetoA, CardosoSO, ManettaJA, PereiraVG, EspósitoDC, Pasqualucci MdeO, et al. Association between use of lung-protective ventilation with lower tidal volumes and clinical outcomes among patients without acute respiratory distress syndrome: a meta-analysis. JAMA, 2012; 308(16):1651–1659.
22.
Serpa NetoA, SimonisFD, BarbasCS, BiehlM, DetermannRM, ElmerJ, et al. Association between tidal volume size, duration of ventilation, and sedation needs in patients without acute respiratory distress syndrome: An individual patient data meta-analysis. Intensive Care Med, 2014; 40(7):950–957.
23.
Serpa NetoA, HemmesSN, BarbasCS, BeiderlindenM, BiehlM, BinnekadeJM, et al. Protective versus conventional ventilation for surgery: systematic review and individual patient data meta-analysis. Anesthesiology, 2015; 123(1):66–78.
24.
CanetJ, GallartL, GomarC, PaluzieG, VallèsJ, CastilloJ, et al. Prediction of postoperative pulmonary complications in a population-based surgical cohort. Anesthesiology, 2010; 113(6):1338–1350.
25.
KorDJ, LingineniRK, GajicO, ParkPK, BlumJM, HouPC, et al. Predicting risk of postoperative lung injury in high-risk surgical patients: a multicenter cohort study. Anesthesiology, 2014; 120(5):1168–1181.
26.
KorDJ, WarnerDO, AlsaraA, Fernández-PérezER, MalinchocM, KashyapR, et al. Derivation and diagnostic accuracy of the surgical lung injury prediction model. Anesthesiology, 2011; 115(1):117–128.
27.
Fernández-PérezER, SprungJ, AfessaB, WarnerDO, VachonCM, SchroederDR, et al. Intraoperative ventilator settings and acute lung injury after elective surgery: a nested case control study. Thorax, 2009; 64(2):121–127.
28.
BendixenHH, Hedley-WhyteJ, LaverMB. Impaired oxygenation in surgical patients during general anesthesia with controlled ventilation: a concept of atelectasis. N Engl J Med, 1963; 269:991–996.
29.
JaberS, CoiselY, ChanquesG, FutierE, ConstantinJM, MicheletP, et al. A multicentre observational study of intra-operative ventilatory management during general anaesthesia: tidal volumes and relation to body weight. Anaesthesia, 2012; 67(9):999–1008.
30.
HessDR, KondiliD, BurnsE, BittnerEA, SchmidtUH. A 5-year observational study of lung-protective ventilation in the operating room: a single-center experience. J Crit Care, 2013; 28(4):533.e9–533.e15.
31.
ZupancichE, PaparellaD, TuraniFMD, MunchCMD, RossiAMD, MassaccesiS, RanieriVM. Mechanical ventilation affects inflammatory mediators in patients undergoing cardiopulmonary bypass for cardiac surgery: a randomized clinical trial. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg, 2005; 130(2):378–383.
32.
SchillingT, KozianA, HuthC, BühlingF, KretzschmarM, WelteT, HachenbergT, et al. The pulmonary immune effects of mechanical ventilation in patients undergoing thoracic surgery. Anesth Analg, 2005; 101(4):957–965, table of contents.
33.
MicheletP, D'JournoXB, RochA, DoddoliC, MarinV, PapazianL, et al. Protective ventilation influences systemic inflammation after esophagectomy: a randomized controlled study. Anesthesiology, 2006; 105(5):911–919.
34.
WolthuisEK, ChoiG, DessingMC, BresserP, LutterR, DzoljicM, et al. Mechanical ventilation with lower tidal volumes and positive end-expiratory pressure prevents pulmonary inflammation in patients without preexisting lung injury. Anesthesiology, 2008; 108(1):46–54.
35.
FutierE, ConstantinJM, Paugam-BurtzC, PascalJ, EurinM, NeuschwanderA, et al. A trial of intraoperative low-tidal-volume ventilation in abdominal surgery. N Engl J Med, 2013; 369(5):428–437.
36.
SevergniniP, SelmoG, LanzaC, ChiesaA, FrigerioA, BacuzziA, et al. Protective mechanical ventilation during general anesthesia for open abdominal surgery improves postoperative pulmonary function. Anesthesiology, 2013; 118(6):1307–1321.
37.
LadhaK, Vidal MeloMF, McLeanDJ, WandererJP, GrabitzSD, KurthT, EikermannM. Intraoperative protective mechanical ventilation and risk of postoperative respiratory complications: hospital based registry study. BMJ, 2015; 351:h3646.
38.
Fernández-PerezER, KeeganMT, BrownDR, HubmayrRD, GajicO. Intraoperative tidal volume as a risk factor for respiratory failure after pneumonectomy. Anesthesiology, 2006; 105(1):14–18.
39.
ZhangZ, HuX, ZhangX, ZhuX, ChenL, ZhuL, et al. Lung protective ventilation in patients undergoing major surgery: a systematic review incorporating a Bayesian approach. BMJ Open, 2015; 5(9):e007473.
40.
GuWJ, WangF, LiuJC. Effect of lung-protective ventilation with lower tidal volumes on clinical outcomes among patients undergoing surgery: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. CMAJ, 2015; 187(3):E101–E109.
41.
WeingartenTN, WhalenFX, WarnerDO, GajicO, SchearsGJ, SnyderMR, SchroederD. R., et al. Comparison of two ventilatory strategies in elderly patients undergoing major abdominal surgery. Br J Anaesth, 2010; 104(1):16–22.
42.
YangM, AhnHJ, KimK, KimJA, YiCA, KimMJ, KimHJ. Does a protective ventilation strategy reduce the risk of pulmonary complications after lung cancer surgery? A randomized controlled trial. Chest, 2011; 139(3):530–537.
43.
TreschanTA, KaisersW, SchaeferMS, BastinB, SchmalzU, WaniaV, et al. Ventilation with low tidal volumes during upper abdominal surgery does not improve postoperative lung function. Br J Anaesth, 2012; 109(2):263–271.
44.
MaslowAD, StaffordTS, DavignonKR, NgT. A randomized comparison of different ventilator strategies during thoracotomy for pulmonary resection. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg, 2013; 146(1):38–44.
45.
ShenY, ZhongM, WuW, WangH, FengM, TanL, WangQ. The impact of tidal volume on pulmonary complications following minimally invasive esophagectomy: a randomized and controlled study. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg, 2013; 146(5):1267–1273; discussion 1273-1274.
46.
QutubH, El-TahanMR, MowafiHA, El GhoneimyYF, RegalMA, Al SaflanAA. Effect of tidal volume on extravascular lung water content during one-lung ventilation for video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery: a randomised, controlled trial. Eur J Anaesthesiol, 2014; 31(9):466–473.
47.
PaparellaD, YauTM, YoungE. Cardiopulmonary bypass induced inflammation: pathophysiology and treatment: an update. Eur J Cardiothorac Surg, 2002; 21(2):232–244.
48.
MirandaDR, GommersD, StruijA, DekkerR, MekelJ, FeeldersR, et al. Ventilation according to the open lung concept attenuates pulmonary inflammatory response in cardiac surgery. European J Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, 2005; 28(6):889–895.
49.
LelloucheF, DionneS, SimardS, BussièresJ, DagenaisF. High tidal volumes in mechanically ventilated patients increase organ dysfunction after cardiac surgery. Anesthesiology, 2012; 116(5):1072–1082.
50.
SundarS, NovackV, JervisK, BenderSP, LernerA, PanzicaP, et al. Influence of low tidal volume ventilation on time to extubation in cardiac surgical patients. Anesthesiology, 2011; 114(5):1102–1110.
51.
BroccardAF, HotchkissJR, VannayC, MarkertM, SautyA, FeihlF, SchallerMD. Protective effects of hypercapneic acidosis on ventilator-induced lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2001; 164(5):802–806.
52.
ContrerasM, AnsariB, CurleyG, HigginsBD, HassettP, O'TooleD, LaffeyJG. Hypercapneic acidosis attenuates ventilator-induced lung injury by a nuclear factor kappaB-dependent mechanism. Crit Care Med, 2012; 40(9):2622–2630.
53.
SinclairSE, KregenowDA, LammWJ, StarrIR, ChiEY, HlastalaMP. Hypercapneic acidosis is protective in an in vivo model of ventilator-induced lung injury. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2002; 166(3):403–408.
54.
PeltekovaV, EngelbertsD, OtulakowskiG, UematsuS, PostM, KavanaghBP. Hypercapneic acidosis in ventilator-induced lung injury. Intensive Care Med, 2010; 36(5):869–878.
55.
IjlandMM, HeunksLM, van der HoevenJG. Bench to bedside review: hypercapneic acidosis in lung injury: from “permissive” to “therapeutic”. Crit Care, 2010; 14(6):237.
56.
RubenfeldGD, CooperC, CarterG, ThompsonBT, HudsonLD. Barriers to providing lung-protective ventilation to patients with acute lung injury. Crit Care Med, 2004; 32(6):1289–1293.
57.
MehtaS, CookDJ, SkrobikY, MuscedereJ, MartinCM, StewartTE, et al. A ventilator strategy combining low tidal volume ventilation, recruitment maneuvers, and high positive end-expiratory pressure does not increase sedative, opioid, or neuromuscular blocker use in adults with acute respiratory distress syndrome and may improve patient comfort. Ann Intensive Care, 2014; 4:33.
58.
KahnJM, AnderssonL, KarirV, PolissarNL, NeffMJ, RubenfeldGD. Low tidal volume ventilation does not increase sedation use in patients with acute lung injury. Crit Care Med, 2005; 33(4):766–771.
59.
ChengIW, EisnerMD, ThompsonBT, WareLB, MatthayMA, Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network. Acute effects of tidal volume strategy on hemodynamics, fluid balance, and sedation in acute lung injury. Crit Care Med, 2005; 33(1):63–70; discussion 239-240.
60.
AmatoMB, MeadeMO, SlutskyAS, BrochardL, CostaEL, SchoenfeldDA, et al. Driving pressure and survival in the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med, 2015; 372(8):747–755.
61.
FowlerWS. Lung function studies; the respiratory dead space. Am J Physiol, 1948; 154(3):405–416.
62.
Vieillard-BaronA, PrinS, AugardeR, DesfondsP, PageB, BeauchetA, JardinF, et al. Increasing respiratory rate to improve CO2 clearance during mechanical ventilation is not a panacea in acute respiratory failure. Crit Care Med, 2002; 30(7):1407–1412.
63.
KoulourisNG, LatsiP, DimitroulisJ, JordanoglouB, GagaM, JordanoglouJ, et al. Noninvasive measurement of mean alveolar carbondioxide tension and Bohr's dead space during tidal breathing. Eur Respir J, 2001; 17(6):1167–1174.
64.
KalletRH, ZhuoH, LiuKD, CalfeeCS, MatthayMA, National Heart Lung and Blood Institute ARDS Network Investigators. The association between physiologic dead-space fraction and mortality in subjects with ARDS enrolled in a prospective multi-center clinical trial. Respir Care, 2014; 59(11):1611–1618.
65.
KalletRH, CampbellAR, DickerRA, KatzJA, MackersieRC. Effects of tidal volume on work of breathing during lung-protective ventilation in patients with acute lung injury and acute respiratory distress syndrome. Crit Care Med, 2006; 34(1):8–14.
66.
O'CroininD, Ni ChonghaileM, HigginsB, LaffeyJG. Bench-to-bedside review: permissive hypercapnia. Crit Care, 2005; 9(1):51–59.
67.
KregenowDA, RubenfeldGD, HudsonLD, SwensonER. Hypercapnic acidosis and mortality in acute lung injury. Crit Care Med, 2006; 34(1):1–7.
68.
MarhongJ, FanE. Carbon dioxide in the critically ill: too much or too little of a good thing?. Respir Care, 2014; 59(10):1597–1605.
69.
PuybassetL, StewartT, RoubyJJ, CluzelP, MourgeonE, BelinMF, et al. Inhaled nitric oxide reverses the increase in pulmonary vascular resistance induced by permissive hypercapnia in patients with acute respiratory distress syndrome. Anesthesiology, 1994; 80(6):1254–1267.
70.
KregenowDA, SwensonER. The lung and carbon dioxide: implications for permissive and therapeutic hypercapnia. Eur Respir J, 2002; 20(1):6–11.
71.
ChatburnRL. Simulation studies for device evaluation. Respir Care, 2014; 59(4):e61–e66.
72.
TuxenDV, WilliamsTJ, ScheinkestelCD, CzarnyD, BowesG. Use of a measurement of pulmonary hyperinflation to control the level of mechanical ventilation in patients with acute severe asthma. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1992; 146(5 Pt 1):1136–1142.
73.
García VinenteE, Sandoval AlmengorJC, Díaz CaballeroLA, Salgado CampoJC. [Invasive mechanical ventilation in COPD and asthma]. Med Intensiva, 2011; 35(5):288–298.
74.
PhippsP, GarrardCS. The pulmonary physician in critical care: 12: acute severe asthma in the intensive care unit. Thorax, 2003; 58(1):81–88.
75.
DarioliR, PerretC. Mechanical controlled hypoventilation in status asthmaticus. Am Rev Respir Dis, 1984; 129(3):385–387.
76.
FranklinPK. Review of acute severe asthma. West J Med, 1989; 150(5):552–556.
77.
Vieillard-BaronA, JardinF. The issue of dynamic hyperinflation in acute respiratory distress syndrome patients. Eur Respir J Suppl, 2003; 42:43s–47s.
78.
YounesM. Proportional assist ventilation, a new approach to ventilatory support. Theory Am Rev Respir Dis, 1992; 145(1):114–120.
79.
Mireles-CabodevilaE, ChatburnRL. Work of breathing in adaptive pressure control continuous mandatory ventilation. Respir Care, 2009; 54(11):1467–1472.
80.
KollefMH, LevyNT, AhrensTS, SchaiffR, PrenticeD, ShermanG. The use of continuous i.v. sedation is associated with prolongation of mechanical ventilation. Chest, 1998; 114(2):541–548.
81.
KressJP, PohlmanAS, O'ConnorMF, HallJB. Daily interruption of sedative infusions in critically ill patients undergoing mechanical ventilation. N Engl J Med, 2000; 342(20):1471–1477.
82.
ThilleAW, RodriguezP, CabelloB, LelloucheF, BrochardL. Patient-ventilator asynchrony during assisted mechanical ventilation. Intensive Care Med, 2006; 32(10):1515–1522.
83.
TremblayLN, SlutskyAS. Ventilator-induced lung injury: from the bench to the bedside. Intensive Care Med, 2006; 32(1):24–33.
84.
BrowerRG, ShanholtzCB, FesslerHE, ShadeDM, WhitePJr, WienerCM, et al. Prospective, randomized, controlled clinical trial comparing traditional versus reduced tidal volume ventilation in acute respiratory distress syndrome patients. Crit Care Med, 1999; 27(8):1492–1498.
85.
EichackerPQ, GerstenbergerEP, BanksSM, CuiX, NatansonC. Meta-analysis of acute lung injury and acute respiratory distress syndrome trials testing low tidal volumes. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2002; 166(11):1510–1514.
86.
PetrucciN, IacovelliW. Lung protective ventilation strategy for the acute respiratory distress syndrome. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2013;(2):CD003844. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003844.pub3.
87.
ChiumelloD, CarlessoE, CadringherP, CaironiP, ValenzaF, PolliF, et al. Lung stress and strain during mechanical ventilation for acute respiratory distress syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2008; 178(4):346–355.
88.
GattinoniL, PesentiA. The concept of “baby lung”. Intensive Care Med, 2005; 31(6):776–784.
89.
MeadJ, TakishimaT, LeithD. Stress distribution in lungs: a model of pulmonary elasticity. J Appl Physiol, 1970; 28(5):596–608.
90.
GattinoniL, CarlessoE, CadringherP, ValenzaF, VagginelliF, ChiumelloD. Physical and biological triggers of ventilator-induced lung injury and its prevention. Eur Respir J Suppl, 2003; 47:15s–25s.
91.
AmatoMBP, MeadeMO, SlutskyAS, BrochardL, CostaELV, SchoenfeldDA, et al. Driving pressure and survival in the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J med, 2015; 372(8):747–755.
92.
SuterPM, FairleyB, IsenbergMD. Optimum end-expiratory airway pressure in patients with acute pulmonary failure. N Engl J Med, 1975; 292(6):284–289.
93.
DeansKJ, MinneciPC, CuiX, BanksSM, NatansonC, EichackerPQ. Mechanical ventilation in ARDS: one size does not fit all. Crit Care Med, 2005; 33(5):1141–1143.
94.
The Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network. Ventilation with lower tidal volumes as compared with traditional tidal volumes for acute lung injury and the acute respiratory distress syndrome. N Engl J Med, 2000; 342(18):1301–1308.
95.
ChiumelloD, CarlessoE, CadringherP, CaironiP, ValenzaF, PolliF, et al. Lung stress and strain during mechanical ventilation for acute respiratory distress syndrome. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2008; 178(4):346–355.
WandererJP, EhrenfeldJM, EpsteinRH, KorDJ, BartzRR, Fernandez-BustamanteA, et al. Temporal trends and current practice patterns for intraoperative ventilation at U.S. academic medical centers: a retrospective study. BMC Anesthesiology, 2015; 15:40.
