The upper airway humidifies and warms inspired gases before they reach the trachea, a process bypassed by the insertion of a tracheostomy, necessitating humidification of inspired gases. The optimal method of humidification is not known.
METHODS:
We conducted a short-term 20-hour study and a long-term 10-week randomized crossover study comparing a heated humidifier (HH) to a heat and moisture exchanger (HME) in children with established tracheostomies. Subjects were assessed for clinical events, clinical examination findings, airway cytokine levels, and airway secretion viscoelasticity.
RESULTS:
For the short-term study, 15 children were recruited; for the long-term study, 14 children were recruited. Children using the HH had decreased respiratory examination score (P < .001) but no change in clinical events over the short term. There was a decrease in acute clinical events (P = .008) in the long-term study. No differences were found in airway secretion viscoelasticity results or cytokine levels in either study, but these sample numbers were limited.
CONCLUSIONS:
Over 20 hours use, HH, compared to HME, improved work of breathing. Over a longer 10 week treatment period HH resulted in decreased adverse clinical events.
PrimianoFPJr, MontagueFWJr, SaidelGM. Measurement system for respiratory water vapor and temperature dynamics. J Appl Physiol Respir Environ Exerc Physiol, 1984; 56(6):1679–1685.
2.
IrlbeckD. Normal mechanisms of heat and moisture exchange in the respiratory tract. Respir Care Clin N Am, 1998; 4(2):189–198.
3.
ShermanJM, DavisS, Albamonte-PetrickS, ChatburnRL, FittonC, GreenC, et al. Care of the child with a chronic tracheostomy. This official statement of the American Thoracic Society was adopted by the ATS Board of Directors, July 1999. Am J Respir Crit Care Med, 2000; 161(1):297–308.
4.
EdwardsEA, ByrnesCA. Humidification difficulties in two tracheostomized children. Anaesth Intensive Care, 1999; 27(6):656–658.
5.
LiuLL, GallaherMM, DavisRL, RutterCM, LewisTC, MarcuseEK. Use of a respiratory clinical score among different providers. Pediatr Pulmonol, 2004; 37(3):243–248.
6.
SuzukawaM, UsadaY, NumataK. The effects on sputum characteristics of combining an unheated humidifier with a heat-moisture exchanging filter. Respir Care, 1989; 34(10):976–984.
7.
BransonRD, DavisKJr, CampbellRS, JohnsonDJ, PorembkaDT. Humidification in the intensive care unit. Prospective study of a new protocol utilizing heated humidification and a hygroscopic condenser humidifier. Chest, 1993; 104(6):1800–1805.
8.
KingM, RubinBK. Mucus rheology: relationship with transport. In: TakishimaT, editor. Airway secretion: physiological bases for the control of mucus hypersecretion. New York: Marcel Dekker; 1994:283–314.
9.
SennS. Cross-over trials in clinical research. Chichester: John Wiley & Sons; 2002.
10.
WilliamsR, RankinN, SmithT, GallerD, SeakinsP. Relationship between the humidity and temperature of inspired gas and the function of the airway mucosa. Crit Care Med, 1996; 24(11):1920–1929.
11.
CohenIL, WeinbergPF, FeinIA, RowinskiGS. Endotracheal tube occlusion associated with the use of heat and moisture exchangers in the intensive care unit. Crit Care Med, 1988; 16(3):277–279.
12.
MartinC, PerrinG, GevaudanMJ, SauxP, GouinF. Heat and moisture exchangers and vaporizing humidifiers in the intensive care unit. Chest, 1990; 97(1):144–149.
13.
KollefMH, ShapiroSD, BoydV, SilverP, Von HarzB, TrovillionE, et al. A randomized clinical trial comparing an extended-use hygroscopic condenser humidifier with heated-water humidification in mechanically ventilated patients. Chest, 1998; 113(3):759–767.
14.
RoustanJP, KienlenJ, AubasP, AubasS, du CailarJ. Comparison of hydrophobic heat and moisture exchangers with heated humidifier during prolonged mechanical ventilation. Intensive Care Med, 1992; 18(2):97–100.
15.
DoyleA, JoshiM, FrankP, CravenT, MoondiP, YoungP. A change in humidification system can eliminate endotracheal tube occlusion. J Crit Care, 2011; 26(6):637;e1–e4.
16.
KolaA, EckmannsT, GastmeierP. Efficacy of heat and moisture exchangers in preventing ventilator-associated pneumonia: meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Intensive Care Med, 2005; 31(1):5–11.
17.
JonesAS, YoungPE, HanafiZB, MakuraZG, FentonJE, HughesJP. A study of the effect of a resistive heat moisture exchanger (Trachinaze) on pulmonary function and blood gas tensions in patients who have undergone a laryngectomy: a randomized control trial of 50 patients studied over a 6-month period. Head Neck, 2003; 25(5):361–367.
18.
MerolJC, CharpiotA, LangagneT, HemarP, AckerstaffAH, HilgersFJ. Randomized controlled trial on postoperative pulmonary humidification after total laryngectomy: external humidifier versus heat and moisture exchanger. Laryngoscope; 122(2):275–281.
19.
VitaccaM, CliniE, PortaR, AmbrosinoN. Breathing pattern and respiratory mechanics in chronically tracheostomized patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease breathing spontaneously through a hygroscopic condenser humidifier. Respiration, 1997; 64(4):263–267.
20.
Le BourdellesG, MierL, FiquetB, DjedainiK, SaumonG, CosteF, et al. Comparison of the effects of heat and moisture exchangers and heated humidifiers on ventilation and gas exchange during weaning trials from mechanical ventilation. Chest, 1996; 110(5):1294–1298.
21.
JohnsonPA, RaperRF, FisherMM. The impact of heat and moisture exchanging humidifiers on work of breathing. Anaesth Intensive Care, 1995; 23(6):697–701.
22.
IottiG, OliveiM, PaloA, GalbuseraC, VeronesiR, ComelliA, et al. Unfavorable mechanical effects of heat and moisture exchangers in ventilated patients. Intensive Care Med, 1997; 23(4):399–405.
23.
RomanoE, GulloA, VacriA, BonifacioR, CaristiD. Effects of a heat and moisture exchanger on carbon dioxide equilibrium during mechanical ventilation with the Bain circuit. Eur J Anaesthesiol, 1987; 4(3):183–186.
24.
JaberS, ChanquesG, MateckiS, RamonatxoM, SoucheB, PerrigaultPF, et al. Comparison of the effects of heat and moisture exchangers and heated humidifiers on ventilation and gas exchange during non-invasive ventilation. Intensive Care Med, 2002; 28(11):1590–1594.
25.
PelosiP, SolcaM, RavagnanI, TubioloD, FerrarioL, GattinoniL. Effects of heat and moisture exchangers on minute ventilation, ventilatory drive, and work of breathing during pressure-support ventilation in acute respiratory failure. Crit Care Med, 1996; 24(7):1184–1188.
26.
BusseWW, LemanskeRFJr. Asthma. N Engl J Med, 2001; 344(5):350–362.
27.
McNamaraDG, DickinsonAR, ByrnesCA. The perceptions and preferences of parents of children with tracheostomies in a study of humidification therapy. J Child Health Care, 2009; 13(3):179–197.
