Abstract
West Nile virus (WNV) is a human pathogen which is rapidly expanding worldwide. It is a member of the Flavivirus genus and it is transmitted by mosquitos between its avian hosts and occasionally in mammalian hosts. In humans the infection is often asymptomatic, however, the most severe cases result in encephalitis or meningitis. Approximately 10% of cases of neuroinvasive disease are fatal. To date there is no effective human vaccine or effective antiviral therapy available to treat WNV infections. For this reason, research in this field is rapidly growing. In this article we will review the latest efforts in the design and development of novel WNV inhibitors from a medicinal chemistry point of view, highlighting challenges and opportunities for the researchers working in this field.
Introduction
West Nile virus (WNV) is a member of the genus Flavivirus, a group of enveloped viruses with a positive-sense RNA genome. This genus contains many important human pathogens (for example, dengue, Japanese encephalitis and yellow fever viruses), which together infect millions of people worldwide and are the cause of tens of thousands of fatalities annually [1]. WNV has been reported in dead or dying birds of at least 326 species [2]. In humans, it was first isolated in the West Nile province of Uganda in 1937 from the blood of a woman suffering from a mild febrile illness [3].
WNV is an emerging human pathogen with an expanding geographical distribution, spreading rapidly in recent years throughout North America [4,5]. It has been the cause of an increasing number of human infections with associated severe disease and fatalities. WNV is transmitted by mosquitoes within its avian host populations and to incidental vertebrate hosts, including humans and horses. Infection in humans is generally asymptomatic or causes a mild febrile disease in about 20–30% of cases. The most severe cases of WNV infection result in encephalitis or meningitis. Around 10% of cases of neuroinvasive disease are fatal and the survivors may suffer from long-term cognitive and neurological impairment [6]. The most important risk factors for these more serious complications are aging and a compromised immune system [7]. Although vaccines are available against some flaviviruses, unfortunately there is no effective human vaccine or effective antiviral therapy available for WNV, indeed, their development remains a high priority for the World Health Organization [8,9].
The present review will concentrate primarily on the medicinal chemistry effort in the development of potential inhibitors of WNV. Other aspects of flavivirus infections, including WNV, are covered excellently elsewhere [10–12].
West Nile virus protein targets
WNV contains a single-stranded positive sense RNA genome (Figure 1), which encodes three structural proteins, capsid, pre-membrane and envelope (C, prM and E), and seven non-structural proteins (NS1, NS2A, NS2B, NS3, NS4A, NS4B and NS5). Non-structural protein 1 (NS1) has been implicated in host immune response evasion, however the function of NS2A is poorly defined. NS2B functions as a cofactor protein in the protease function of NS3, which is a multifunctional protein, consisting of the N-terminal protease domain and C-terminal helicase, nucleoside triphosphatase and RNA triphosphatase activities [13]. The function of NS4A is a matter of debate and NS4B membrane protein is thought to anchor and target the replication complex to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) membrane. NS5 is the largest of the non-structural proteins and it contains a classic RNA-dependent RNA polymerase domain as well as methyltransferase and guanylyltransferase domains for mRNA capping necessary for viruses that replicate their mRNA in the cytoplasm [14].

The RNA genome of West Nile virus
E protein inhibitors
Wang et al. [15] from Novartis performed a virtual screening using a 586,000 compound library (a subset of the corporate compound collection) revealing a hydrophobic pocket in the DENV-2 strain S1 envelope protein. The top-ranked compounds were also docked in the crystal structure of the WNV E protein [16,17], which contains a hydrophobic pocket that is presumably important for low-pH mediated membrane fusion. After performing a high-throughput docking within this hydrophobic pocket, compound

Chemical structures of West Nile virus E protein inhibitors
An in silico screening of the Maybridge chemical database was performed on the dengue E protein structure. The biological evaluation of the most promising compounds obtained from the computer-based simulation revealed two hit structures with low micromolar antiviral activity against dengue virus. Interestingly, one of these compounds (
NS2B/NS3 protease inhibitors
Historically, WNV NS3 protease and the NS2B cofactor have always been indicated as attractive targets for drug development, due to their essential catalytic activity [19,20]. The WNV NS2B-NS3 is a serine-like protease, important for viral replication. Viral proteases in general are proving to be successful antiviral targets (for example, for HIV) and inhibitors of serine protease in particular look promising for treating flaviviruses (for example, hepatitis C [21]). Several homology models for WNV NS2B/NS3 protease were reported [22–24], unfortunately all these structures were significantly different from the subsequent crystal structures of the active protease (PDB id: 2FP7 [25], PDB id: 2IJO [26]) because of the unusual binding mode of the NS2B cofactor which encircles and stabilizes the protease structure [27].
Peptide-like inhibitors
A common strategy used for the inhibition of the NS2B/NS3 protease involved covalent inhibitors that compete with the substrate for the catalytic site. Such peptide-based inhibitors have their C-terminal carboxyl group chemically modified into reactive electrophilic ‘warheads’. A popular warhead is the aldehyde functional group and peptide-aldehydes have been shown to inhibit the WNV NS2B/NS3 protease at submicromolar concentrations [28]. In this study peptidomimetics containing a P1 decarboxylated arginine (agmatine) compound (4-phenyl-phenacetyl-Lys-Lys-agmatine) showed potent inhibition of the WNV protease (50% inhibitory concentration [IC50] 4.7 ±1.2 μM). This inhibitor does not bind covalently to the catalytic serine in the active site but instead competes with the natural substrate for the active site with a binding affinity of Ki 2.05 ±0.13 μM. Selectivity for WNV NS2B/NS3 protease was demonstrated using thrombin, a mammalian serine protease involved in blood clotting that is selective for peptide substrates with a P1 Arg. The compound did not inhibit thrombin at a concentration of 100 μM, showing a good selectivity towards the WNV NS2B/NS3 protease [29]. In 2013 the same research group has reported 37 novel agmatine dipeptides [30]. The most potent inhibitor displayed an IC50 of 2.6 ±0.3 μM against the WNV NS2B/NS3 protease, a twofold improvement over the inhibitor described previously.
Recently, a series of new substrate analogues of NS2B/NS3 protease based on trans-(4-guanidino) cyclohexylmethylamide (GCMA) were identified. These GCMA inhibitors are stable, readily accessible and have a better selectivity profile than the previously described agmatine analogues. Furthermore, they possess negligible affinity for the trypsin-like serine proteases thrombin, factor Xa, and matriptase. A crystal structure in complex with the WNV protease was determined for one of the most potent inhibitors, 3,4-dichlorophenylacetyl-Lys-Lys-GCMA (Ki=0.13 μM) [31].
It should be noted that, despite their potency, warhead peptidomimetics have several undesirable characteristics, including lack of selectivity over other trypsin-like proteases due to their high reactivity and low chemical stability, limiting their potential for drug development [32].
Non-peptide inhibitors
Recently, different non-peptidomimetic inhibitors have been reported in the literature. Compound

Chemical structures of West Nile virus NS2B/NS3 protease inhibitors
A more potent compound, the sultam thiourea TYT-1 (
Exploratory studies, using a combinatorial approach based on the 1-oxo-1,2,3,4-tetrahydroisoquinoline scaffold, have led to the identification of a hit (
Compounds
The aminobenzamide scaffold was also utilized in the synthesis of a series of structurally diverse meta and para-substituted derivatives [38]. The four analogues that exhibited activity against WNV protease, all have a (pehnoxy)phenyl group present in the meta or para position. The most potent aminobenzamide derivative is compound
Recently, Tiew et al. [39] have identified a series of triazolic compounds active on both dengue virus and WNV NS2B/NS3 protease. The compounds were obtained from the benz[d]isothiazol-3(2H)-one scaffold using a click-chemistry derived library. The most interesting molecules (
3-Aryl-2-cyanoacrylamides were identified as a new class of nitrile-containing inhibitors of the NS3/NS2B protease by Nitsche et al. [40]. The most relevant structural features required for activity are: a para-substituted aromatic system with high electron density, an amide or acid residue and a planar geometry. Consequently, the most active molecule was the hydroxyl derivative (
The 5-amino-1-(phenyl)sulfonyl-pyrazol-3-yl based inhibitors seem to interfere with the binding of the NS2B cofactor with the NS3 protease. The hit compounds (
NS5 – RNA-dependent RNA polymerase inhibitors
Puig-Basagoiti et al. [43] reported the results of an HTS study, which was performed by screening nearly 100,000 compounds in WNV replicon assay. From this exercise, five novel inhibitors have been identified with EC50 values of <10μM and therapeutic index (TI) values of >10. Viral titre reduction assays, using various flaviviruses and non-flaviviruses, showed that the compounds have distinct antiviral spectra. One compound (

Chemical structures of West Nile virus NS5 inhibitors
NTPase/helicase inhibitors
Compound

Chemical structures of West Nile virus NTPase/helicase inhibitors
Other inhibitors
Many investigators have noted the broad antiviral properties of ribavirin (25, Figure 6) [50], currently a mainstay of therapy in combination with interferon-α for the treatment of HCV. Although ribavirin shows some activity against WNV in vitro (EC50 approximately 200 μM), in vivo studies have been less promising, with reports of ribavirin treatment increasing mortality in Syrian golden hamsters infected with WNV New York strain CDC996625 [51].

Chemical structures of inhibitors with a non-specific or unknown mode of action
A recent paper has reported weak anti-WNV activity of the tetracycline antibiotic minocycline (26) in a cytopathic effect assay in Vero cells, with an IC50 of approximately 20 μM [52]. Olivo et al. [53] have also disclosed a series of aminoquinoline compounds that possess antiviral activity against a range of viruses, including WNV, although no details on the mechanism of action have been provided. Compound 27 has activity against a DENV-2 sub-genomic replicon cell line with EC50 5 μM and against a WNV sub-genomic replicon cell line with an EC50 of 1.9 μM [53].
Conclusions
WNV virus is rapidly spreading worldwide and, despite the possibility that viral infection could lead to severe encephalitis, neither a vaccine nor an antiviral therapy is currently available. In this paper we have provided a summary of the current medicinal chemistry efforts in identifying small molecule inhibitors of WNV. Indeed, several interesting leads are now appearing in the literature. However, we believe there are still areas that require a more intensive investigation. In particular, it is easy to notice that researchers have been focusing their attention mainly on the NS3 protease, whereas, in comparison, little has been reported on the inhibition of the NS5 polymerase and methyltransferase. Interestingly, several crystal structures of the latter have become available in the last few years (Table 1) and they could be used in virtual screening simulations or other structure-based drug design methodologies. For this reason, it is possible to foresee an increase in interest around this target in the near future. It should be mentioned that the research around the development of antiviral compounds active against dengue virus is at a more advanced stage compared to WNV [54,55]. Given the close similarity between these two viruses, it is likely that some of the anti-dengue molecules reported in the literature could also be useful against WNV. Indeed, several of the compounds reported in this review show activity against both viruses. Furthermore, the knowledge and the insight gained with the exciting development of novel anti-HCV agents could also be used as a foundation for the identification of suitable WNV inhibitors. Finally, it should not be overlooked that the most severe cases affect the central nervous system, thus any future antiviral therapy agents should be able to cross the blood–brain barrier. This clearly represents one of the biggest challenges for the researchers in the field.
Crystallographic structures of West Nile virus proteins available in the Protein Data Bank
Footnotes
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to acknowledge the Egyptian National Research Centre and the Egyptian Higher Education Ministry for the support to SAE.
The authors declare no competing interests.
