Use of appropriate types of cells could potentially improve the functionality and structure of tissue engineered constructs, but little is known about the optimal cell source for ligament tissue engineering. The object of this study was to determine the optimal cell source for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tissue engineering. Fibroblasts isolated from anterior cruciate ligament, medial collateral ligament (MCL), as well as bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) were compared using the following parameters: proliferation rate, collagen excretion, expression of collagen type I, II, and III, as well as α-smooth muscle actin. Green fluorescent protein (GFP) transfected MSCs were used to trace their fate in the knee joints. MSC, ACL, and MCL fibroblasts were all highly stained with antibodies for collagen types I and III and α-smooth muscle actin while negatively stained with collagen type II. Proliferation rate and collagen excretion of MSCs were higher than ACL and MCL fibroblasts (p < 0.05), and MSCs could survive for at least 6 weeks in knee joints. In summary, MSC is potentially a better cell source than ACL and MCL fibroblasts for anterior cruciate ligament tissue engineering.
AlbertsB.JohnsonA.LewisJ.RaffM.RobertsK.WalterP.Cell junctions, cell adhesion, and the extracellular matrix. In: Anonymous molecular biology of the cell.New York: Garland Science; 2002: 1090–1104.
2.
AliniM.RoughleyP. J.AntoniouJ.StollT.AebiM.A biological approach to treating disc degeneration: Not for today, but maybe for tomorrow.Eur. Spine J.11(Suppl. 2): S215–S220; 2002.
3.
AmielD.KleinerJ. B.RouxR. D.The phenomenon of “ligamentization”: Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with autogenous patellar tendon.J. Orthop. Res.4: 162–172; 1986.
4.
AroraP. D.McCullochC. A. G.Dependence of collagen remodeling on a-smooth muscle actin expression by fibroblasts.J. Cell. Physiol.159: 161–175; 1994.
BadylakS. F.The extracellular matrix as a scaffold for tissue reconstruction.Semin. Cell Dev. Biol.13(5): 377–383; 2002.
7.
BellincampiL. D.CloskeyR. F.PrasadR.ZawadskyJ. P.DunnM. G.Viability of fibroblast-seeded ligament analogs after autogenous implantation.J. Orthop. Res.16: 414–420; 1998.
8.
BonannoE.ErcoliL.MissoriP.RocchiG.SpagnoliL. G.Homogeneous stromal cell population from normal human adult bone marrow expressing alpha-smooth muscle actin filaments.Lab. Invest.71(2): 308–315; 1994.
9.
BruderS. P.JaiswalN.RicaltonN. S.MoscaJ. D.KrausK. H.KadiyalaS.Mesenchymal stem cells in osteobiology and applied bone regeneration.Clin. Orthop.355(Suppl.): 247–256; 1998.
10.
CabralW. A.MerttsM. V.MakareevaE.ColigeA.TekinM.PandyaA.LeikinS.MariniJ. C.Type I collagen triplet duplication mutation in lethal osteogenesis imperfecta shifts register of a chain throughout the helox and disrupts incorporation of mutant helices into fibrils and extracellular matrix.J. Biol. Chem.278: 10006–10012; 2003.
11.
CaiD.Marty-RoixR.HsuH. P.SpectorM.Lapine and canine bone marrow stromal cells contain smooth muscle actin and contract a collagen-glycosaminoglycan matrix.Tissue Eng.7(6): 829–841; 2001.
12.
CaplanA. I.Embryonic development and the principles of tissue engineering.Novartis Found. Symp.249: 17–25; 2003.
13.
ColterD. C.ClassR.DiGirolamoC. M.ProckopD.Rapid expansion of recycling stem cells in cultures of plastic-adherent cells from human bone marrow.Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA97: 3213–3218; 2000.
14.
De KokI. J.PeterS. J.ArchambaultM.van denB. C.KadiyalaS.AukhilI.CooperL. F.Investigation of allogeneic mesenchymal stem cell-based alveolar bone formation: Preliminary findings.Clin. Oral Implants Res.14(4): 481–489; 2003.
15.
DonovanP. J.GearhartJ.The end of the beginning for pluripotent stem cells.Nature414: 92–97; 2001.
16.
FaryniarzD. A.ChaponnierC.GabbianiG.YannasI. V.SpectorM.Myofibroblasts in the healing lapine medial collateral ligament: Possible mechanisms of contraction.J. Orthop. Res.14: 228–237; 1996.
17.
FriedensteinA. J.GorskajaU.KaluginaN. N.Fibroblast precursors in normal and irradiated mouse hematopoietic organs.Exp. Hematol.4: 267–274; 1976.
18.
FuF. H.BennettC. H.LattermannC.MaC. B.Current trends in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Part 1: Biology and biomechanics of reconstruction.Am. J. Sports Med.27(6): 821–830; 1999.
19.
GalmicheM. C.KotelianskyV. E.BriereJ.HerveP.CharbordP.Stromal cells from human long-term marrow cultures are mesenchymal cells that differentiate following a vascular smooth muscle differentiation pathway.Blood82(1): 66–76; 1993.
20.
GaoJ.CaplanA. I.Mesenchymal stem cells and tissue engineering for orthopaedic surgery.Chir. Organi Mov.88(3): 305–316; 2003.
21.
HautR. C.The mechanical and viscoelastic properties of the anterior cruciate ligement and of ACL fascicles. In: JacksonD. W.ArnoczkyS. P.FrankC. B.WooS. L.-Y.SimonT. M., eds. The anterior cruciate ligament: Current and future concepts.New York: Raven Press;1993: 63
22.
HaynesworthS. E.GoshimaJ.GoldbergV. M.CaplanA. I.Characterization of cells with osteogenic potential from human marrow.Bone13: 81–90; 1992.
23.
HilldebrandK. A.JiaF.WooS. L.Response of donor and recipient cells after transplantation of cells to the ligament and tendon.Microsc. Res. Tech.58: 34–38; 2002.
24.
HuibregtseA. A.JohnstoneB.GoldbergV. M.CaplanA. I.Effect of age and sampling site on the chondro-osteogenic potential of rabbit marrow-derived mesendchymal progenitor cells.J. Orthop. Res.18: 18–24; 2000.
25.
HuiskeyR.BlankevoortL.Anatomy and biomechanics of the anterior cruciate ligament: A three-dimensional problem. In: JakobR. P.StaubliH. U., eds. The knee and the cruciate ligaments: Anatomy, biomechanics, clinical aspects, reconstruction, complications, rehabilitation.Berlin: Springer-Verlag;1992: 92–110.
26.
HuntT. K.The physiology of wound healing.Ann. Emerg. Med.17: 1265–1273; 1988.
27.
HunzikerE. B.Structural molecules in articular cartilage, tendons, and ligaments. In: JakobR. P.StaubliH. U., eds. The knee and the cruciate ligaments: Anatomy, biomechanics, clinical aspects, reconstruction, complications, rehabilitation.New York: Springer-Verlag;1992: 62–77.
28.
JacksonD. W.SimonT. M.Donor cell survival and repopulation after intraarticular transplantation of tendon and ligament allografts.Microsc. Res. Tech.58: 25–33; 2002.
29.
JiangY.JahagirdarB. N.Pluripotency of mesenchymal stem cells derived from adult marrow.Nature418: 41–49; 2002.
30.
JoynerC. J.BennettA.TriffittJ. T. I.Identification and enrichment of human osteoprogenitor by differentiation stage-specific monoclonal antibody.Bone21: 1–6; 1997.
31.
KnuutinenA.KokkonenN.RisteliJ.VähäkangasK.KallioinenM.SaloT.OikarinenA.Smoking affects collagen synthesis and extracellular matrix turnover in human skin.Br. J. Dermatol.146: 588–594; 2002.
32.
KobayashiK.HealeyR. M.SahR. L.ClarkJ. J.TuB. P.GoonerW. H.AhesonW. H.MoriyaH.AmielD.Novel method for the quantitative assessment of cell migration: A study on the motility of rabbit anterior cruciate (ACL) and medial collateral ligament (MCL) cells.Tissue Eng.6(1): 29–39; 2000.
33.
KramperaM.GlennieS.DysonJ.ScottD.LaylorR.SimpsonE.DazziF.Bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells inhibit the response of naive and memory antigen-specific T cells to their cognate peptide.Blood101(9): 3722–3729; 2003.
34.
McCullochC. A. G.MelcherA. H.Cell density and cell generation in the periodontal ligament of mice.Am. J. Anat.167: 43–48; 1983.
McLarenA.Ethical and social considerations of stem cell research.Nature414: 129–131; 2001.
37.
MenovskyT.De VriesJ.Van Den BerghW. M.GrotenhuisJ. A.Stability of fibrin sealant in cerebrospinal fluid: An in-vitro study.Neurosurgery51(6): 1453–1456; 2002.
38.
MetsT.VerdonkG.Variations in the stromal cell population of human bone marrow during aging.Mech. Ageing Dev.15: 41–49; 1981.
MurrayM. M.SpectorM.Fibroblast distribution in the anteromedial bundle of the human anterior cruciate ligament: The presence of a-smooth muscle actin-positive cells.J. Orthop. Res.17: 18–27; 1999.
41.
NagineniC. N.AmielD.GreenM. H.BerchuckM.AkesonW. H.Characterization of the intrinsic properties of the anterior cruciate and medical collateral ligament cells: An in vitro cell culture study.J. Orthop. Res.10(4): 465–475; 1992.
42.
NakaharaH.GoldbergV. M.CaplanA. I.Culture-expanded human periosteal-derived cells exhibit osteochondral potentials in vivo.J. Orthop. Res.9: 465–476; 1991.
43.
NathansonM. A.HayE. D.Analysis of cartilage differentiation from skeletal muscle grown on bone matrix II.Chondroitin sulfate synthesis and reaction to exogenous glycosaminoglycans. Dev. Biol.78: 332–351; 1980.
44.
OikarinenA.UntioP.KiistalaU.RisteliL.RisteliJ.A new method to measure type I and III collagen synthesis in human skin in vivo: Demonstratin of decreased collagen synthesis after topical glucocorticoid treatment.J. Invest. Dermatol.98: 220–225; 1992.
45.
OuyangH. W.GohJ. C.LeeE. H.Use of bone marrow stromal cells for tendon graft-to-bone healing: Histological and immunohistochemical studies in a rabbit model.Am. J. Sports Med.32(2): 321–327; 2004.
46.
PeledA.ZiporiD.AbramskyO.Expression of alpha-smooth muscle actin in murine bone marrow stromal cells.Blood78: 304–312; 1991.
PittengerM. F.MackayA. M.Multipineage potentials of adult human mesenchymal stem cells.Science284: 143–147; 1999.
49.
SolchagaL. A.JohnstoneB.YooJ. U.GoldbergV. M.CaplanA. I.High variability in rabbit bone marrow-derived mesenchymal cell preparations.Cell Transplant.8: 511–519; 1999.
50.
TriaA. J.AliceaJ. A.Ligament and capsular structures. In: TriaA. J., ed. Ligaments of the knee.New York: Churchill Livingstone;1995: 20.
51.
Vunjak-NovakovicG.AltmanG.HoranR.KaplanD. L.Tissue engineering of ligaments.Annu. Rev. Biomed. Eng.6(14): 1–26; 2004.
52.
WatanabeN.TakaiS.MoritaN.KawataM.HirasawaY.A method of tracking donor cells after simulated autologous transplantation: A study using synovial cells of transgenic rats.Cell Tissue Res.298: 519–525; 1999.
53.
WooS. L.HildebrandK.WatanabeN.FenwickJ. A.PapageorgiouC. D.WangJ. H.Tissue engineering of ligament and tendon healing.Clin. Orthop.367(Suppl.): 312–323; 1999.
54.
WooS. L.VogrinT. M.AbramowitchS. D.Healing and repair of ligament injuries in the knee.J. Am. Acad. Orthop. Surg.8(6): 364–372; 2000.
55.
WuG. D.NoltaJ. A.JinY. S.BarrM. L.YuH.StarnesV. A.CramerD. V.Migration of mesenchymal stem cells to heart allografts during chronic rejection.Transplantation75(5): 679–685; 2003.
56.
ZukP. A.ZhuM.MizunoH.HuangJ.FutrellJ. W.KatzA. J.BenhaimP.LorenzH. P.HedrickM. H.Multilineage cells from human adipose tissue: Implications for cell-based therapies.Tissue Eng.7: 211–228; 2001.
