Recent advances in photon counting detection technology have led to significant research interest in X-ray imaging.
OBJECTIVE:
As a tutorial level review, this paper covers a wide range of aspects related to X-ray photon counting detector characterization.
METHODS:
The tutorial begins with a detailed description of the working principle and operating modes of a pixelated X-ray photon counting detector with basic architecture and detection mechanism. Currently available methods and techniques for charactering major aspects including energy response, noise floor, energy resolution, count rate performance (detector efficiency), and charge sharing effect of photon counting detectors are comprehensively reviewed. Other characterization aspects such as point spread function (PSF), line spread function (LSF), contrast transfer function (CTF), modulation transfer function (MTF), noise power spectrum (NPS), detective quantum efficiency (DQE), bias voltage, radiation damage, and polarization effect are also remarked.
RESULTS:
A cadmium telluride (CdTe) pixelated photon counting detector is employed for part of the characterization demonstration and the results are presented.
CONCLUSIONS:
This review can serve as a tutorial for X-ray imaging researchers and investigators to understand, operate, characterize, and optimize photon counting detectors for a variety of applications.
BarberW.C., et al., Characterization of a novel photon counting detector for clinical CT: Count rate, energy resolution, and noise performance, Proc SPIE 7258, Medical Imaging (2009).
CamminJ., et al., A tabletop clinical x-ray CT scanner with energy-resolving photon counting detectors, Proc SPIE 7961, Medical Imaging (2011).
4.
CamminJ., et al., Compensation of nonlinear distortions in photon-counting spectral CT: Deadtime loss, spectral response, and beam hardening effects, Proc SPIE 8313, Medical Imaging (2012).
5.
KobayashiT., et al., Accuracy of linear attenuation coefficients measured with a photon counting CT system, Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC) (2012).
6.
KaibukiF., MatsumotoM. and OgawaK., Evaluation of CT images in the very low x-ray exposure with a photon counting detector with a CdTe semiconductor, Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC)2013.
7.
TaguchiK. and IwanczykJ.S., Vision 20/20: Single photon counting x-ray detectors in medical imaging, Medical Physics40(10) (2013), 100901.
8.
LeeS., ChoiY.-N. and KimH.-J., A simulation study of high-resolution x-ray computed tomography imaging using irregular sampling with a photon-counting detector, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment726 (2013), 175–180.
9.
TomitaY., et al., X-ray color scanner with multiple energy differentiate capability, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference (2004).
10.
SteadmanR., et al., ChromAIX: Fast photon-counting ASIC for Spectral Computed Tomography, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment648(Supplement 1) (2011), S211–S215.
11.
KraftE., et al., Counting and Integrating Readout for Direct Conversion X-ray Imaging: Concept, Realization and First Prototype Measurements, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science54(2) (2007), 383–390.
12.
AtakH. and ShikhalievP.M., Photon counting x-ray imaging with K-edge filtered x-rays: A simulation study, Medical Physics43(3) (2016), 1385–1400.
13.
SilkwoodJ.D., MatthewsK.L. and ShikhalievP.M., Photon counting spectral breast CT: Effect of adaptive filtration on CT numbers, noise, and contrast to noise ratio, Medical Physics40(5) (2013), 051905.
14.
RoesslE. and ProksaR., K-edge imaging in x-ray computed tomography using multi-bin photon counting detectors, Physics in Medicine and Biology52(15) (2007), 4679.
15.
SchlomkaJ.P., et al., Experimental feasibility of multi-energy photon-counting K-edge imaging in pre-clinical computed tomography, Physics in Medicine and Biology53(15) (2008), 4031.
16.
KraftP., et al., Characterization and Calibration of PILATUS Detectors, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science56(3) (2009), 758–764.
17.
KanaiY., et al., Diagnosis of Periodontitis with the Energy Information in Dental Panoramic Image, World Congress on Medical Physics and Biomedical Engineering May 26-31, 2012, Beijing, China, LongM., Editor, 2013, Springer Berlin Heidelberg: Berlin, Heidelberg; pp. 1117–1120.
18.
LanglaisR., et al., The cadmium telluride photon counting sensor in panoramic radiology: Gray value separation and its potential application for bone density evaluation, Oral Surgery, Oral Medicine, Oral Pathology and Oral Radiology120(5) (2015), 636–643.
19.
YuZ., et al., Evaluation of conventional imaging performance in a research whole-body CT system with a photon-counting detector array, Physics in Medicine and Biology61(4) (2016), 1572.
20.
AlessioA.M. and MacDonaldL.R., Quantitative material characterization from multi-energy photon counting CT, Medical Physics40(3) (2013), 031108.
21.
MajiT., et al., Material decomposition using a singular value decomposition method, Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC) (2013).
22.
NiwaN., et al., Development of Mammography System Using CdTe Photon Counting Detector for Exposure Dose Reduction, in Breast Imaging: 12th International Workshop, IWDM 2014, Gifu City, Japan, June 29 – July 2, 2014. Proceedings, 2014, Springer International Publishing: Cham; pp. 468–474.
23.
BushbergJ.S.LeidholdtM.Jr, BooneJ., The Essential Physics of Medical Imaging. Third ed. 2012: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins.
24.
PacellaD., BellazziniR. and FinkenthalM., Energy resolved two-dimensional soft x-ray radiography with a micropattern gas detector, Review of Scientific Instruments77(4) (2006), 043702.
25.
PacellaD., et al., X-VUV spectroscopic imaging with a micropattern gas detector, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment508(3) (2003), 414–424.
26.
MartinN., Scintillation detectors for X-rays, Measurement Science and Technology17(4) (2006), R37.
27.
MikerovV., et al., Multi-energy X-ray sensors based on pixilated scintillator, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science60(2) (2013), 963–967.
28.
PrekasG., et al., Direct and indirect detectors for X-ray photon counting systems, Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (NSS/MIC) (2011).
29.
PonchutC., et al., Evaluation of a photon-counting hybrid pixel detector array with a synchrotron X-ray source, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment484(1–3) (2002), 396–406.
30.
BergamaschiA., et al., The MYTHEN detector for X-ray powder diffraction experiments at the Swiss Light Source, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation17(5) (2010), 653–668.
31.
RuatM. and PonchutC., Characterization of a pixelated CdTe X-ray detector using the timepix photon-counting readout chip, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science59(5) (2012), 2392–2401.
32.
ChoH.-M., et al., Characteristic performance evaluation of a photon counting Si strip detector for low dose spectral breast CT imaging, Medical Physics41(9) (2014), 091903.
33.
DingH., et al., Characterization of energy response for photon-counting detectors using x-ray fluorescence, Medical Physics41(12) (2014), 121902.
34.
XuC., et al., Performance characterization of a silicon strip detector for spectral computed tomography utilizing a laser testing system, Proc SPIE 7961, Medical Imaging (2011).
35.
WangX., et al., MicroCT with energy-resolved photon-counting detectors, Physics in Medicine and Biology56(9) (2011), 2791.
36.
SpartiotisK., et al., A photon counting CdTe gamma- and X-ray camera, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment550(1–2) (2005), 267–277.
37.
LockerM., et al., Single photon counting X-ray imaging with Si and CdTe single chip pixel detectors and multichip pixel modules, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science51(4) (2004), 1717–1723.
38.
LlopartX., et al., Timepix, a 65k programmable pixel readout chip for arrival time, energy and/or photon counting measurements, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment581(1–2) (2007), 485–494.
39.
SongJ., LiuQ.H., JohnsonG.A. and BadeaC.T., Sparseness prior based iterative image reconstruction for retrospectively gated cardiac micro-CT, Medical Physics34 (2007), 4476.
40.
YuL., LiuX. and McColloughC.H., Pre-reconstruction three-material decomposition in dual-energy CT, SPIE Medical Imaging, Int Society for Optics and Photonics7258 (2009), 72583V.
41.
YuZ., et al., Initial results from a prototype whole-body photon-counting computed tomography system, Proc SPIE 9412, Medical Imaging (2015).
42.
GutjahrR., et al., Human imaging with photon counting–based computed tomography at clinical dose levels: Contrast-to-noise ratio and cadaver studies, Investigative Radiology51(7) (2016), 421–429.
43.
KalenderW.A., et al., Technical feasibility proof for high-resolution low-dose photon-counting CT of the breast, European Radiology (2016), 1–6.
44.
PourmortezaA., et al., Abdominal imaging with contrast-enhanced photon-counting CT: First human experience, Radiology279(1) (2016), 239–245.
45.
RenL., et al., Optimized acquisition time for x-ray fluorescence imaging of gold nanoparticles: A preliminary study using photon counting detector, Proc SPIE 9709, Biophotonics and Immune Responses XI (2016).
46.
YuZ., et al., How low can we go in radiation dose for the data-completion scan on a research whole-body photon-counting computed tomography system, Journal of Computer Assisted Tomography40(4) (2016), 663–670.
47.
ZhangQ., et al., Progress in the Development of CdZnTe Unipolar Detectors for Different Anode Geometries and Data Corrections, Sensors13(2) (2013), 2447.
48.
BallabrigaR., et al., Review of hybrid pixel detector readout ASICs for spectroscopic X-ray imaging, Journal of Instrumentation11(01) (2016), P01007.
49.
LiuX., et al., Energy calibration of a silicon-strip detector for photon-counting spectral CT by direct usage of the X-ray tube spectrum, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science62(1) (2015), 68–75.
50.
IwanczykJ.S., et al., Photon counting energy dispersive detector arrays for X-ray imaging, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science56(3) (2009), 535–542.
51.
ProczS., et al., Optimization of medipix-2 threshold masks for spectroscopic X-ray imaging, IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science56(4) (2009), 1795–1799.
52.
UherJ. and JakubekJ., Equalization of Medipix2 imaging detector energy thresholds using measurement of polychromatic X-ray beam attenuation, Journal of Instrumentation6(11) (2011), C11012.
53.
BatesR., et al., Performance of an energy resolving X-ray pixel detector, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment477(1–3) (2002), 161–165.
54.
BarberW.C., et al., Large area photon counting X-ray imaging arrays for clinical dual-energy applications, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference (2009).
55.
ThomasK., et al., Imaging properties of small-pixel spectroscopic x-ray detectors based on cadmium telluride sensors, Physics in Medicine and Biology57(21) (2012), 6743.
56.
XuC., et al., Energy resolution of a segmented silicon strip detector for photon-counting spectral CT, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment715 (2013), 11–17.
57.
BarberW.C., et al., Energy dispersive CdTe and CdZnTe detectors for spectral clinical CT and NDT applications, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment784 (2015), 531–537.
58.
TaguchiK., et al., Modeling the performance of a photon counting x-ray detector for CT: Energy response and pulse pileup effects, Medical Physics38(2) (2011), 1089–1102.
59.
AbbeneL., GerardiG. and PrincipatoF., Digital performance improvements of a CdTe pixel detector for high flux energy-resolved X-ray imaging, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment777 (2015), 54–62.
60.
OgawaK., et al., Development of an energy-binned photon-counting detector for X-ray and gamma-ray imaging, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment664(1) (2012), 29–37.
61.
AbbeneL. and GerardiG., High-rate dead-time corrections in a general purpose digital pulse processing system, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation22(5) (2015), 1190–1201.
62.
JakubekJ., Precise energy calibration of pixel detector working in time-over-threshold mode, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment633(Supplement 1) (2011), S262–S266.
63.
BallabrigaR., et al., Characterization of the Medipix3 pixel readout chip, Journal of Instrumentation6(01) (2011), C01052.
64.
UherJ., HarveyG. and JakubekJ., X-ray fluorescence imaging with the Medipix2 single-photon counting detector, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record (2010).
65.
ChoH.M., et al., Energy response calibration of photon-counting detectors using x-ray fluorescence: A feasibility study, Physics in Medicine and Biology59(23) (2014), 7211.
66.
Campbell-RickettsT. and DasM., Direct spectral recovery using X-ray fluorescence measurements for material decomposition applications using photon counting spectral X-ray detectors, Proc SPIE 9033, Medical Imaging (2014).
67.
RenL., et al., Detection of posteriorly located breast tumors using gold nanoparticles: A breast-mimicking phantom study, Journal of X-ray Science and Technology22(6) (2014), 785–796.
68.
RenL., et al., Background estimation methods for quantitative x-ray fluorescence analysis of gold nanoparticles in biomedical applications, Proc SPIE 8944, Biophotonics and Immune Responses IX (2014).
69.
RenL., et al., Three-dimensional x-ray fluorescence mapping of a gold nanoparticle-loaded phantom, Medical Physics41(3) (2014), 031902.
70.
RenL., et al., Method for determining the modulation transfer function of X-ray fluorescence mapping system, Optics Express22(18) (2014), 21199–21213.
71.
BooneJ.M. and SeibertJ.A., An accurate method for computer-generating tungsten anode x-ray spectra from 30 to 140kV, Medical Physics24(11) (1997), 1661–1670.
72.
HubbellJ.H. and SeltzerS.M., Tables of X-ray mass attenuation coefficients and mass energy-absorption coefficients 1keV to 20MeV for elements Z=1 to 92 and 48 additional substances of dosimetric interest, National Inst. of Standards and Technology-PL, Gaithersburg, MD (United States). Ionizing Radiation Div. (1995).
73.
YounH., et al., Energy calibration of energy-resolved photon-counting pixel detectors using laboratory polychromatic x-ray beams, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment760 (2014), 79–85.
74.
TlustosL., et al., Imaging properties of the Medipix2 system exploiting single and dual energy thresholds, Nuclear Science Symposium Conference (2004).
75.
MaierD. and LimousinO., Energy calibration via correlation, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment812 (2016), 43–49.
76.
TomitaY., et al., X-ray color scanner with multiple energy discrimination capability, Proc SPIE 5922, Hard X-Ray and Gamma-Ray Detector Physics VII (2005).
77.
MatsumotoM., KaibukiF. and OgawaK., K-edge imaging with a photon counting CT system, Nuclear Science Symposium and Medical Imaging Conference (2013).
78.
ChoH.M., et al., The effects of photon flux on energy spectra and imaging characteristics in a photon-counting x-ray detector, Physics in Medicine and Biology58(14) (2013), 4865.
79.
TaguchiK., et al., An analytical model of the effects of pulse pileup on the energy spectrum recorded by energy resolved photon counting x-ray detectors, Medical Physics37(8) (2010), 3957–3969.
80.
TaguchiK., et al., Pulse pileup statistics for energy sensitive photon counting detectors with pulse height analysis, Proc SPIE 8313, Medical Imaging (2012).
81.
RoesslE., DaerrH. and ProksaR., A Fourier approach to pulse pile-up in photon-counting x-ray detectors, Medical Physics43(3) (2016), 1295–1298.
82.
BroennimannC., et al., The PILATUS 1M detector, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation13(2) (2006), 120–130.
83.
MarinhoF. and AkibaK., A GEANT4 based simulation for pixelated X-ray hybrid detectors, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment772 (2015), 50–51.
84.
BergerM.J., et al., Stopping-power and range tables for electrons, protons, and helium ions, 1998: NIST Physics Laboratory.
85.
C. Using XRAYLIB, et al., XRAYLIB tables (X-ray fluorescence cross-section); 2003.
86.
BrunettiA., et al., A library for X-ray–matter interaction cross sections for X-ray fluorescence applications, Spectrochimica Acta Part B: Atomic Spectroscopy59(10–11) (2004), 1725–1731.
87.
KnollG.F., Radiation detection and measurement, 2010: John Wiley & Sons.
88.
WuD., et al., Characterization of a high-energy in-line phase contrast tomosynthesis prototype, Medical Physics42(5) (2015), 2404–2420.
89.
WuD., et al., DQE characterization of a high-energy in-line phase contrast prototype under different kVp and beam filtration, Proc SPIE 9324, Biophotonics and Immune Responses X (2015).
90.
GhaniM.U., et al., Investigation of spatial resolution characteristics of an in vivo microcomputed tomography system, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment807 (2016), 129–136.
91.
GhaniM.U., et al., Characterization of operating parameters of an in vivo micro CT system, Proc SPIE 9709, Biophotonics and Immune Responses XI (2016).
92.
ZhouZ., et al., Monotone spline regression for accurate MTF measurement at low frequencies, Optics Express22(19) (2014), 22446–22455.
93.
WongM.D., ZhangD. and LiuH., Step by step analysis toward optimal MTF algorithm using an edge test device, Journal of X-ray science and technology17(1) (2009), 1–15.
94.
ZhangD., et al., Imaging characteristics of a high resolution computed radiography system, Journal of X-ray Science and Technology14(4) (2006), 273–282.
95.
ZhouZ., et al., Improving the accuracy of MTF measurement at low frequencies based on oversampled edge spread function deconvolution, Journal of X-ray Science and Technology23(4) (2015), 517–529.
96.
ZhangD., LiuH. and WuX., DQE analysis on a dual detector phase x-ray imaging system, Physics in Medicine and Biology53(18) (2008), 5165.
97.
GhaniM.U., et al., Noise power characteristics of a micro–computed tomography system, Journal of Computer Assisted Tomography41(1) (2017), 82–89.
98.
LiuH., FajardoL.L. and PennyB.C., Signal-to-noise ratio and detective quantum efficiency analysis of optically coupled CCD mammography imaging systems, Academic Radiology3(10) (1996), 799–805.
99.
JiangH., ChenW.R. and LiuH., Techniques to improve the accuracy and to reduce the variance in noise power spectrum measurement, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering49(11) (2002), 1270–1278.
100.
OuandjiF., et al., Characterization of a CCD-based digital x-ray imaging system for small-animal studies: Properties of spatial resolution, Applied Optics41(13) (2002), 2420–2427.
101.
ZhangD., et al., Preliminary feasibility study of an in-line phase contrast X-ray imaging prototype, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering55(9) (2008), 2249–2257.
102.
WuX.,
WongM. D.,
DeansA. E., and LiuH., X-ray diagnostic techniques, in Biomedical Photonics Handbook, Vol. II: Biomedical Diagnostics, Vo-DinhT., Editor, 2015, CRC Press. pp. 415–451.
103.
DammannH., Model MTF for Conventional X-ray Imaging Systems, Optica Acta: International Journal of Optics24(4) (1977), 385–390.
104.
KozyrevE.A., KuperK.E., LemzyakovA.G., PetrozhitskiyA.V. and PopovA.S., Performance and Characterization of CsI: Tl thin Films for X-ray Imaging Application, Physics Procedia84, 245.
105.
DuanY., et al., Non-uniform sampling knife-edge method for camera modulation transfer function measurement, Proc SPIE 10023, Optical Metrology and Inspection for Industrial Applications IV (2016).
106.
GhaniM.U., et al., Characterization of continuous and pulsed emission modes of a hybrid micro focus x-ray source for medical imaging applications, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment853 (2017), 70–77.
107.
TanguayJ., et al., Detective quantum efficiency of photon-counting x-ray detectors, Medical Physics42(1) (2015), 491–509.
108.
MichelT., et al., A fundamental method to determine the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and detective quantum efficiency (DQE) for a photon counting pixel detector, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment568(2) (2006), 799–802.
109.
PonchutC., Characterization of X-ray area detectors for synchrotron beamlines, Journal of Synchrotron Radiation13(2) (2006), 195–203.
