Hot and humid indoor environment of the kitchen affects worker performance. The Indian Railway’s pantry car culinary is one of them that cooks food for the on-board passengers, which could be bothered by the hot indoor climate.
OBJECTIVE:
The current study aimed to identify the indoor working environment of the railway “pantry car” using heat stress indices such as “Universal Thermal Climate Index-UTCI,” “Wet-Bulb Globe Temperature-WBGT,” “Discomfort Index-DI,” “Tropical Summer Index-TSI,” “Heat Index-HI,” and Heart Rate-HR with clothing insulation. METHODS: The study was performed in 2018 (August-summer season) to collect field survey data on 6 railway pantry cars. Measurements were carried out during peak cooking times such as morning “7 : 00 am”, day “11 : 30 am”, evening “4 : 00 pm,” and night “6 : 30 pm”. This study’s descriptive and Pearson’s correlation analysis was accomplished using SPSS version 2016 software.
RESULTS:
The analysis results revealed that the average values were for UTCI (37.77±5.26°C), WBGT (30.42±2.28°C), DI (30.05±2.70°C), TSI (33.21±2.90°C), HI (48.53±4.86°C), correspondingly. During analysis, the strongest correlation association was observed between “TSI and DI” (r = 0.985, p < 0.000) and WBGT and TSI (r = 0.958, p < 0.000). A “significant correlation” was found between UTCI and HI (r = 0.637, p < 0.05). While no signification correlation was found between “heat stress indices and physiological parameters (p > 0.05)”.
CONCLUSION:
In this study, all the heat stress index limit values showed highly harsh working conditions inside the pantry car, which created unfavorable circumstances for the culinarians. Inappropriate “ventilation design” could be a reason for discomfort in the railway pantry car.
ZhangGHanLYaoJYangJXuZCaiXHuangJPeiL. Assessing future heat stress across China: Combined effects of heat and relative humidity on mortality. Frontiers in Public Health. 2023;11:1282497.
2.
SchiermeierQ. Climate change made North America’s deadly heatwave 150 times more likely. Nature. 2021.
3.
SharmaMSarfarazALSuriNMSumanKA. Occupational heat stress under high-heat furnace work environments-a comprehensive review on developing countries. Journal of Thermal Engineering. 2021;7(Supp 14):2068–92.
4.
LogeswariSMrunaliniA. Heat stress among large kitchen workers in hostel. International Journal of Pure and Applied Bioscience. 2017;5(6):607–10.
5.
AlamMSMuthiahASalveUR. Thermal comfort of the kitchen in pantry cars on Indian railways. Instrum Mesure Métrol. 2019;18(5):465–77.
6.
AlamMSMuthiahASalveUR. Appraisal of thermal comfort in non-air-conditioned and air-conditioned railway pantry car kitchens. International Journal of Integrated Engineering. 2020;12(8):318–27.
7.
ZareSShirvanHEHemmatjoRNadriFJahaniYJamshidzadehKPaydarP. A comparison of the correlation between heat stress indices (UTCI, WBGT, WBDT, TSI) and physiological parameters of workers in Iran. Weather and Climate Extremes. 2019;26:100213.
8.
VataniJGolbabaeiFDehghanSFYousefiA. Applicability of Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) in occupational heat stress assessment: A case study in brick industries. Industrial Health. 2016;54(1):14–9.
9.
IsmailARJusohNAsriMAZeinRMRahmanIAMakhtarNKMohamedD. The factor affecting heat stress in industrial workers exposed to extreme heat: A case study of methodology. In Journal of Physics: Conference Series2020 Sep 1 (Vol. 1630, No. 1, p. 012001). IOP Publishing.
10.
TawatsupaBLimLLKjellstromTSeubsmanSASleighA, Thai Cohort Study Team. Association between occupational heat stress and kidney disease among 37 816 workers in the Thai Cohort Study (TCS). Journal of Epidemiology. 2012;22(3):251–60.
11.
CrandallCGWilsonTE. Human cardiovascular responses to passive heat stress. Comprehensive Physiology. 2015;5(1):17.
12.
ZareSShirvanHEHemmatjoRNadriFJahaniYJamshidzadehKPaydarP. A comparison of the correlation between heat stress indices (UTCI, WBGT, WBDT, TSI) and physiological parameters of workers in Iran. Weather and Climate Extremes. 2019;26:100213.
13.
KrishnamurthyMRamalingamPPerumalKKamalakannanLPChinnaduraiJShanmugamRSrinivasanKVenugopalV. Occupational heat stress impacts on health and productivity in a steel industry in Southern India. Safety and Health at Work. 2017;8(1):99–104.
14.
LangnerMScherberKEndlicherWR. Indoor heat stress: An assessment of human bioclimate using the UTCI in different buildings in Berlin. DIE ERDE–Journal of the Geographical Society of Berlin. 2013;144(3-4):260–73.
15.
SrivastavaAKumarRJosephEKumarA. Heat exposure study in the workplace in a glass manufacturing unit in India. The Annals of occupational hygiene. 2000;44(6):449–53.
16.
VenugopalVKrishnamoorthyMVenkatesanVJaganathanVShanmugamRKanagarajKPaulSF. Association between occupational heat stress and DNA damage in lymphocytes of workers exposed to hot working environments in a steel industry in Southern India. Temperature. 2019;6(4):346–59.
17.
MohammadianFSahl AbadiASGiahiOKhoubiJZareiAABoghsaniGTAbbaspourS. Evaluation of occupational exposure to heat stress and physiological responses of workers in the rolling industry. The Open Public Health Journal. 2019;12(1):114–20.
18.
HajizadehRGolbabaeiFDehghanSFBeheshtiMHJafariSMTaheriF. Validating the heat stress indices for using in heavy work activities in hot and dry climates. Journal of Research in Health Sciences. 2016;16(2):90.
19.
NurmayaEMAbidinAUHasanahNAAsmaraAA. Heat Stress Analysis Using the Discomfort Index Method: Impact on Macro Environmental in Yogyakarta. Journal of Ecological Engineering. 2022;23(1):286–95.
20.
YangYCWeiMCHongSJ. Evaluation of occupation hot exposure in industrial workplaces in a subtropical country. International Journal of Occupational Medicine and Environmental Health. 2017;30(3):379–95.
21.
SumanBMAgarwalKNVermaVV. Moisture influence in building for thermal comfort in hot humid region. Journal of Scientific and Industrial Research. 2000;59:229–34.
22.
Garzón-VillalbaXPAshleyCDBernardTE. Benchmarking Heat Index as an occupational exposure limit for heat stress. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene. 2019;16(8):557–63.
23.
BurgstallACasanuevaAKotlarskiSSchwierzC. Heat warnings in Switzerland: Reassessing the choice of the current heat stress index. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2019;16(15):2684.
24.
AlamMSMuthiahASalveUR. Thermal comfort study in Indian railway pantry cars kitchen. Instrum Mesure Métrol, 2020;19(4):289–95.
25.
AlamMSSalveUR. Enhancement of thermal comfort inside the kitchen of non-airconditioned railway pantry car. International Journal of Heat & Technology. 2021;1;39(1):275–91.
26.
AlamMSSalveUR. Factors affecting on human thermal comfort inside the kitchen area of railway pantry car-a review. Journal of Thermal Engineering. 2021;7(Supp 14):2093–106.
27.
AlamMSMuthiahASalveU. A Field Investigation of the Average Indoor Thermal Comfort Parameters on the Railway Pantry Car Kitchen at the Different Cooking Period. InDesign for Tomorrow—Volume 1: Proceedings of ICoRD2021 (pp. 203–12). SpringerSingapore.
28.
AlamMSMuthiahASalveUR. Thermal comfort assessment of a pantry car coaches in Indian railway. InAIP Conference Proceedings2020 Nov 2 (Vol. 2273, No. 1). AIP Publishing.
29.
AlamMSSharmaMSalveUR. Investigating thermal environment inside the kitchen of air-conditioned pantry car on Indian Railway using CFD. Human Factors and Ergonomics in Manufacturing & Service Industries. 2022;32(5):359–72.
30.
AlamMSSharmaMSalveUR. Assessment of thermal comfort in a hot and humid indoor built environment of a kitchen at a university canteen. Work. 2022;72(1):189–99.
31.
HuangCJChanHLChangYJChenSMHsuMJ. Validity of the polar V800 monitor for assessing heart rate variability in elderly adults under mental stress and dual task conditions. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 2021;18(3):869.
32.
SimoneAOlesenBWStoopsJLWatkinsAW. Thermal comfort in commercial kitchens (RP-1469): Procedure and physical measurements (Part 1). Hvac& r Research. 2013;19(8):1001–15.
33.
ZareSHasheminejadNShirvanHEHemmatjoRSarebanzadehKAhmadiS. Comparing Universal Thermal Climate Index (UTCI) with selected thermal indices/environmental parameters during 12 months of the year. Weather and climate extremes. 2018;19:49–57.
34.
MohammadianMHeidariHCharkhlooEDehghaniA. Heat stress and physiological and perceptual strains of date harvesting workers in palm groves in Jiroft. Work. 2020;66(3):625–36.
35.
XuHHuXGuanHHeG. Development of a fine-scale discomfort index map and its application in measuring living environments using remotely-sensed thermal infrared imagery. Energy and Buildings. 2017;150:598–607.
36.
MavrakisAKapsaliATsirosIXPantavouK. Air quality and meteorological patterns of an early spring heatwave event in an industrialized area of Attica, Greece. Euro-Mediterranean Journal for Environmental Integration. 2021;6:25.
37.
SharmaMRAliS. Tropical summer index—a study of thermal comfort of Indian subjects. Building and Environment. 1986;21(1):11–24.
38.
RajibMAMortuzaMRSelmiSAnkurAKRahmanMM. Increase of heat index over Bangladesh: Impact of climate change. International Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering. 2011;5(10):434–7.
39.
Sarfaraz AlamMSalveUR. Evaluating Indoor and Outdoor Thermal Comfort Parameters Affecting Work Environment of Railway Pantry Car. In International Conference of the Indian Society of Ergonomics2021 Dec 8 (pp. 1269–77). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
40.
BaldiviezLMKeimNLLaugeroKDHwangDHHuangLWoodhouseLRBurnettDJZerofskyMSBonnelELAllenLHNewmanJW. Design and implementation of a cross-sectional nutritional phenotyping study in healthy US adults. BMC Nutrition. 2017;3:1–3.
41.
BiswasSGuhaSBhattacharyaR. Validity and reliability of Polar v800 smart watch to measure cricket-specific movements. Physical Education Theory and Methodology. 2022;22(3):316–22.
42.
AvramRTisonGHAschbacherKKuharPVittinghoffEButznerMRungeRWuNPletcherMJMarcusGMOlginJ. Real-world heart rate norms in the Health eHeart study. NPJ Digital Medicine. 2019;2(1):58.
43.
SebastianLAReederSWilliamsM. Determining target heart rate for exercising in a cardiac rehabilitation program: A retrospective study. Journal of Cardiovascular Nursing. 2015;30(2):164–71.
44.
GolmohammadRHassaniMZamanparvarAOliaeiMAliabadiMMahdaviS. Comparing the heat stress index of HSI and WBGT in bakeryworkplaces in Hamadan. Iran Occupational Health. 2006;3(2):46–51.
45.
GolbabaieFMonazam EsmaieliMRHemmatjouRPour YaaghoubGRHosseiniM. Comparing the heat stress (DI, WBGT, SW) indices and the men physiological parameters in hot and humid environment. Iranian Journal of Health and Environment. 2012;5(2):245–52.
46.
MonazzamMGolbabaeiFHematjoRHosseiniMNassiriPDehghanSF. Evaluation of DI, WBGT, and SWreq/PHS heat stress indices for estimating the heat load on the employees of a petrochemical industry. International Journal of Occupational Hygiene. 2014;6(1):6–10.
47.
AnyiamAFArinze-AnyiamOCOyindamolaAMObeaguEI. Impact of occupational heat exposure on selected haematological parameters of bakery workers: A comprehensive study in Ilorin, Kwara State. Medicine. 2024;103(2):e36914.
48.
AbbasiMGolbabaeiFYazdaniradSDehghanHAhmadiA. Validity of ten analytical heat stress indices in predicting the physiological parameters of people under various occupational and meteorological conditions. International Journal of Biometeorology. 2024;68(1):163–77.
49.
EsmailDAEssaSI. Assessment of industrial thermal stress impacts in omdurman locality. International Journal of Innovation Scientific Research and Review. 2024;06(03):6081–90.
