Occupational foot-transmitted vibration (FTV) exposure is common in industries like mining, construction, and agriculture, often leading to acute and chronic injuries. Vibration assessments require technical expertise and equipment which can be costly for employers to perform. Alternatively, researchers have observed that self-reported discomfort can be used as an effective indicator of injury risk.
OBJECTIVE:
This study aimed to investigate the effect of standing FTV exposure on self-reported ratings of discomfort, and whether these subjective ratings differed by body area and exposure frequency.
METHODS:
Participants (n = 30) were randomly exposed to standing FTV at six frequencies (25, 30, 35, 40, 45, and 50 Hz) for 20–45 seconds. Following each exposure, participants rated discomfort on a scale of 0–9 in four body areas: head and neck (HN), upper body (UB), lower body (LB), and total body.
RESULTS:
Results indicated that participants experienced the most discomfort in the LB at higher frequencies (p < 0.001), consistent with the resonance of foot structures. The HN discomfort tended to decrease as the exposure frequency increased, although not statistically significant (p > 0.0167). The UB discomfort remained relatively low across all frequencies.
CONCLUSIONS:
The study suggests a potential connection between resonant frequencies and discomfort, potentially indicating injury risk. Although self-reported discomfort is insufficient for directly assessing injury risk from FTV, it provides a simple method for monitoring potential musculoskeletal risks related to vibration exposure at resonant frequencies. While professional vibration assessment remains necessary, self-reported discomfort may act as an early indicated of vibration-induced injuries, aiding in implementing mitigation strategies.
LeducM, EgerT, GodwinA, DickeyJP, HouseR. Examination of vibration characteristics, and reported musculoskeletal discomfort for workers exposed to vibration via the feet. Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control. 2011;30(3):197–206.
2.
SimeonovP, HsiaoH, PowersJ, AmmonsD, KauT, AmendolaA. Postural stability effects of random vibration at the feet of construction workers in simulated elevation. Applied Ergonomics. 2011;42:672–81.
3.
TewariVK, DewanganKN, KarmakarS. Operator’s fatigue in field operation of hand tractors. Biosystems Engineering. 2004;89(1):1–11.
4.
EgerT, ThompsonA, LeducM, KrajnakK, GogginsK, GodwinA, et al.
Vibration induced white-feet: Overview and field study of vibration exposure and reported symptoms in workers. Work. 2014;47(1):101–10.
5.
JensenA, JepsenJR. . Vibration on board and health effects. Int Marit Health. 2014;64(2):58–60.
6.
PascholdHW, SergeevAV. Whole-body vibration knowledge survey of U.S.. occupational safety and health professionals. Journal of Safety Research. 2009;40:171–6.
7.
HutchinsonGNational Hazard Exposure Worker Surveillance - Exposure to vibration and the provision of vibration control measures in Australianworkplaces. Commonwealth of Australia: Safe Work Australia; 2009.
8.
SchweigertM. The relationship between hand-arm vibration and lower extremity clinical manifestations: a review of literature. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health. 2002;75:179–85.
9.
NoelB. Pathophysiology and classification of the vibration white finger. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health. 2000;73:150–5.
10.
HashiguchiT, YanagiH, KinugawaY, SakakibaraH, YamadaSy. Pathological changes of finger and toe in patients with vibration syndrome. Nagoya J Med Sci. 1994;57:129–36.
11.
ThompsonA, HouseR, KrajnakK, EgerT. Vibration-white foot: a case report. Occupational Medicine. 2010;60:572–4.
12.
HedlundU. Raynaud’s phenomenon of fingers and toes of miners exposed to local and whole-body vibration and cold. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health. 1989;61:457–61.
13.
SakakibaraH, AkamatsuY, MiyaoM, KondoTa, FurutaM, YamadaSy, et al.
Correlation between vibration-induced white finger and symptoms of upper and lower extremities in vibration syndrome. International Archive of Occupational and Environmental Health. 1988;60:285–9.
14.
SakakibaraH, HashiguchiT, FurutaM, Kondo Ta, MiyaoM, Yamada Sy. Circulatory disturbances of the foot in vibration syndrome. International Archives of Occupational and Environmental Health. 1991;63:4.
15.
HouseR, JiangD, ThompsonA, EgerT, KrajnakK, SauveJ, et al. Vasospasm in the feet inworkers assessed for HAVS. Occupational Medicine. 2010:1-6.
16.
AhnY, RhieJ, KimM-G. The relevant factors of work-related fatigue for occupational vibration-exposed employees. Annals of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. 2022;34(6):1–12.
17.
GerhardssonL, AhlstrandC, ErssonP, GustafssonE. Vibration-induced injuries in workers exposed to transient and high frequency vibrations. Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology. 2020;15(18):1–9.
18.
KimJH, ZigmanM, DennerleinJT, JohnsonPW. A randomized controlled trial of a truck seat intervention: Part 2 - Associations between whole-body vibration exposures and health outcomes. Annals of Exposures and Health. 2018;62(8):1000–11.
19.
MansfieldNJHuman Response toVibration. London: CRC Press; 2004. 256 p.
20.
GriffinMJHandbook of Human Vibration. 1st ed. London: Academic Press; 1990. 988 p.
21.
KrajnakK, MillerGR, WaughS. Contact area affects frequency-dependent responses to vibration in the peripheral vascular and sensorineural systems. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health, Part A. 2018;81(1-3):6–19.
22.
AdamoF, AttivissimoF, LanzollaAML, SaponaroF, CervelleraV. Assessment of the uncertainty in human exposure to vibration: An experimental study. IEEE Sensors. 2014;14(2):474–81.
23.
BoileauP-E, WuZ, RakhejaS. Definition of a range of idealized values to characterize seated body biodynamic response under vertical vibration. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 1998;215(4):841–62.
24.
RandallJM, MatthewsRT, StilesMA. Resonant frequencies of standing humans. Ergonomics. 1997;40(9):879–86.
25.
HarazinB, GrzesikJ. The transmission of vertical whole-body vibration to the body segments of standing subjects. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 1998;215(4):775–87.
26.
ShihP-J, GuoY-R. Resonance frequency of fluid-filled and prestressed spherical shell - A model of the human eyeball. J Acoust Soc Am. 2016;139(4):1784–92.
27.
DongRG, SchopperAW, McDowellTW, WelcomeDE, WuJZ, SmutzWP, et al.
Vibration energy absorption (VEA) in human fingers-hand-arm system. Medical Engineering and Physics. 2004;26:483–92.
28.
RuoxunF, JieL, JunL, WeijunW. Presentation of an approach on determination of the natural frequency of human lumbar spine using dynamic finite element analysis. Applied Bionics and Biomechanics. 2019;2019:1–8.
29.
GuoL-X, ZhangC. Development and validation of a whole human body finite element model with detailed lumbar spine. World Neurosurgery. 2022;163:579–92.
GogginsK, TarabiniM, LieversWB, EgerT. Biomechanical response of the human foot when standing in a natural position exposed to vertical vibration from 10–200Hz. Ergonomics. 2019;62(5):644–56.
32.
AkinnuliBO, DahunsiOA, AyodejiSP, BodundeOP. Whole-body vibration exposure on earthmoving equipment operators in construction industries. Cogent Engineering. 2018;5(1):1–14.
33.
KimJH, DennerleinJT, JohnsonPW. The effect of a multi-axis suspension on whole body vibration exposures and physical stress in the neck and low back in agricultural tractor applications. Applied Ergonomics. 2018;68:80–9.
34.
UpadhyayR, SenapatiA, ChauK, BhattacherjeeA, PatraAK, ChauNDevelopment of an intervention program to reduce whole-body vibration exposure based on occupational and individual determinants among dumper operators. International Journal of Occupational Safety and Ergonomics. 2023:1-15.
35.
MaytonAG, KimBY. Using a mobile app to estimate whole-body vibration and seat isolation performance in surface mining. International Journal of Heavy Vehicle Systems. 2021;28(4):487–502.
36.
Hamberg-van ReenenHH, van der BeekAJ, BlatterBM, van der GrintenMP, van MechelenW, BongersPM. Does musculoskeletal discomfort at work predict future musculoskeletal pain?Ergonomics. 2008;51(5):637–48.
37.
HuangY, ZhangP. Subjective discomfort caused by vertical whole-body vibration in the frequency range 2-100Hz. Ergonomics. 2019;62(3):420–30.
38.
ThuongO, GriffinMJ. The vibration discomfort of standing persons: 0.5-16Hz fore-and-aft, lateral, and vertical vibration. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 2011;330:816–26.
39.
DeShawJ, RahmatallaS. Predictive discomfort in single- and combined-axis whole-body vibration considering different seated postures. Human Factors. 2014;56(5):850–63.
40.
MatsumotoY, GriffinMJ. Effect of phase on discomfort caused by vertical whole-body vibration and shock - Experimental investigation. J Accoust Soc Am. 2002;111:1280–8.
41.
DickeyJP, OliverML, BoileauP-E, EgerTR, TrickLM, EdwardsMA. Multi-axis sinusoidal whole-body vibrations: Part 1 - How long should the vibration and rest exposures be for reliable discomfort measures?Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control. 2006;25(3):175–84.
42.
GogginsKA, KellyEA, ThompsonTJ, EgerTR. Examining the impact of rotated neck and trunk postures on vertical seat-to-head vibration transmissibility and self-reported discomfort. Vibration. 2022;5:306–25.
43.
NolanAJ, CoversME, OliverML. Effect of fatigue on muscle latency, muscle activation and perceived discomfort when exposed to whole-body vibration. Ergonomics. 2021;64(10):1281–96.
44.
BorgE, BorgG. A comparison of AME and CR100 for scaling perceived exertion. Acta Psychologica. 2002;109:157–75.
45.
WilliamsN. The Borg Rating of Perceived Exertion (RPE) scale. Occupational Medicine. 2017;67:404–5.
46.
BS-6841. Guide to measurement and evaluation of human exposure to whole-body mechanical vibration and repeated shock. British Standards Institute; 1987.
47.
MatsumotoY, GriffinMJ. Nonlinear subjective and biodynamic responses to continuous and transient whole-body vibration in the vertical direction. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 2005;287:919–37.
48.
ZhouZ, GriffinMJ. Response of the seated human body to whole-body vertical vibration: biodynamic responses to sinusoidal and random vibration. Ergonomics. 2014;57(5):693–713.
49.
ISO-2631-1. Mechanical vibration and shock –Evaluation of human exposure to whole-body vibration –whole-body vibration –Part 1: General Requirements. Geneva, Switzerland: International Organization for Standardization; 1997.
50.
PlewaKM, EgerTR, OliverML, DickeyJP. Comparison between ISO -1 comfort prediction equations and self-reported comfort values during occupational exposure to whole-body vehicular vibration. Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control. 2012;31(1):43–53.
51.
ConwayGE, SzalmaJL, HancockPA. A quantitative meta-analytic examination of whole-body vibration effects on human performance. Ergonomics. 2007;50(2):228–45.
52.
GogginsK, GodwinA, LariviereC, EgerT. Study of the biodynamic response of the foot to vibration exposure. Occupational Ergonomics. 2016;13:53–66.
53.
DickeyJP, EgerTR, OliverML, BoileauP-E, TrickLM, EdwardMA. Multi-axis sinusoidal whole-body vibrations: Part 2 - Relationship between vibration total value and discomfort varies between vibration axes. Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control. 2007;26(3):195–204.
54.
KrajnakK, MillerGR, WaughS, JohnsonC, KashonML. Characterization of frequency-dependent responses of the vascular system to repetitive vibration. JOEM. 2012;54(8):1010–6.
55.
MoriokaM, GriffinMJ. Magnitude-dependence of equivalent comfort contours for fore-and-aft, lateral and vertical whole-body vibration. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 2006;298:755–72.
56.
NawaysehN, SinanHA, AlteneijiS, HamdanS. Effect of gender on the biodynamic responses to vibration induced by a whole-body vibration training machine. Engineering in Medicine. 2019;233(3).
57.
SonzaA, VölkelN, ZaroMA, ArchavalM, HennigEM. A whole body vibration perception map and associated acceleration loads at the lower leg, hip and head. Medical Engineering and Physics. 2015;37:642–9.
58.
KinchingtonM, BallK, NaughtonG. Monitoring of lower limb comfort and injury in elite football. Journal of Sports Science and Medicine. 2010;9:652–63.
59.
OlsenN. Diagnostic aspects of vibration-induced white finger. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 2002;75:6–13.
60.
AhmadS, HouseDL, NisenbaumR, ThompsonAMSEvaluation of neurological testing for hand-arm vibration syndrome. Occupational Medicine. 2022:1-6.
61.
FillingimRBIndividual differences in pain: Understanding the mosaic that makes pain personal. Pain. 2017;158:S11-S8.
62.
ZeemanME, MarthaS, JaumardNV, BaigHA, StablowAM, LeeJ, et al.
Whole-body vibration at thoracic resonance induces sustained pain and widespread cervical neuroinflammation in the rat. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. 2015;473:2936–47.
63.
BhambriK, SinghI, SinghH, SinghT. Occupational whole body vibration transmitted from feet to head in Indian forging unit. Industrial Engineering and Management. 2018;7(3):1–4.
64.
JackRJ, EgerTR. The effects of posture on seat-to-head whole-body vibration transmission. Journal of Low Frequency Noise, Vibration and Active Control. 2008;27(4):309–25.
65.
ErikssonK, BurströmL, NilssonTBlood biomarkers for vibration-induced white fingers. A case-comparison study. American Journal of Industrial Medicine. 2020:1-8.
66.
JohanssonN, RagnebroO, StjernbrandtA, GraffP, BryngelssonI-L, VihlborgP. Effects on blood parameters from hand-arm vibrations exposure. Toxicology and Industrial Health. 2023;39(6):291–7.
67.
PopeM, MagnussonM, LundstromR, HulshofC, VerbeekJ, BovenziM. Guidelines for whole-body vibration health surveillance. Journal of Sound and Vibration. 2002;253(1):131–67.
68.
BovenziM, WelshAJL, GriffinMJ. Acute effects of continuous and intermittent vibration on finger circulation. Int Arch Occup Environ Health. 2004;77:255–63.
69.
SammondsGM, MansfieldNJ, FrayM. Improving long term driving comfort by taking breaks - How break activity affects effectiveness. Applied Ergonomics. 2017;65:81–9.
