Bringing a structural perspective to work: Framing occupational safety and health disparities for nursing assistants with work-related musculoskeletal disorders
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online March 12, 2018
Bringing a structural perspective to work: Framing occupational safety and health disparities for nursing assistants with work-related musculoskeletal disorders
Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) experience a high risk of work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) and are further made vulnerable by their situation in low levels of workplace and societal hierarchies of power and privilege.
OBJECTIVE:
This study applies structural vulnerability theory to CNA WMSD experiences in order to identify structural factors that may influence such injuries.
METHODS:
A sample of CNAs (n = 26) working in Nursing and Residential Care Facilities (NRCFs) was selected from workers who filed a claim during 2011–2014 for a WMSD of the back, shoulder, knee, or hand/wrist in the Washington State Department of Labor & Industries workers’ compensation system. Interviews included questions about workers’ injury experiences and work contexts. Qualitative data was analyzed for themes related to structural vulnerability theory and occupational safety and health (OSH) models.
RESULTS:
Themes illustrate a work environment in NRCFs with major organizational deficiencies for CNA safety and a broader structural environment that appears to mediate them. CNAs described policies and practices that result from management priorities being diverted away from worker safety. These difficulties are compounded by several aspects of CNAs’ socio-economic vulnerability.
CONCLUSIONS:
This study demonstrates the utility of a structural perspective for OSH disparities research and points to the need for occupational health intervention on a structural level.
CollinsJW, OwenBD. NIOSH research initiatives to prevent back injuries to nursing assistants, aides, and orderlies in nursing homes. Am J Ind Med1996;29(4):421–4.
2.
ZhangY, FlumM, NobregaS, BlaisL, QamiliS, PunnettL. Work organization and health issues in long-term care centers. J Gerontol Nurs2011;37(5):32–40.
3.
YokoyamaK, HiraoT, YodaT, YoshiokaA, ShirakamiG. Effort-reward imbalance and low back pain among eldercare workers in nursing homes: A cross-sectional study in Kagawa Prefecture, Japan. J Occup Health2014;56(3):197–204.
4.
SilversteinB, RockefellerK, HowardN, KalatJ, PollisarN. Getting to zero in Washington State nursing homes: Final report on intervention effectiveness. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries 2003 Contract No.: 61-05-2003.
5.
DillJS, MorganJC, MarshallVW. Contingency, employment intentions, and retention of vulnerable low-wage workers: An examination of nursing assistants in nursing homes. Gerontologist2013;53(2):222–34.
6.
AndersonN, AdamsD, BonautoD, HowardN, SilversteinB. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders of the back, upper extremity, and knee in Washington State, 2002-2010. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, 2015 Contract No.: 40-12-2015.
7.
JacksonJ. The nurse’s load. The Lancet1965;286(7413):637.
8.
AmickBC, TullarJM, BrewerS, IrwinE, MahoodQ, PompeiiL, et al. Interventions in health-care settings to protect musculoskeletal health: A systematic review. Toronto, ON, Canada: Institute for Work and Health, 2006.
9.
BLS. BLS Occupational Injuries and Illnesses and Fatal Injuries Profiles. In: Bureau of Labor Statistics USDoL, editor.
10.
ChoiSD, BringsK. Work-related musculoskeletal risks associated with nurses and nursing assistants handling overweight and obese patients: A literature review. WORK2016;53(2):439–48.
11.
YamadaY. Profile of home care aides, nursing home aides, and hospital aides: Historical changes and data recommendations. Gerontologist2002;42(2):199–206.
12.
RomeroM, PérezN. Conceptualizing the foundation of inequalities in care work. Am Behav Sci2016;60(2):172–88.
13.
Price-GlynnK, RakovskiC. Who rides the glass escalator? Gender, race and nationality in the national nursing assistant study. Work, Employ & Soc2012;26(5):699–715.
14.
SilversteinB, SchurkeJ. Implementation of safe patient handling in Washington State hospitals. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, 2012.
15.
WinzelbergG. The quest for nursing home quality: Learning history’s lessons. Arch Intern Med2003;163(21):2552–6.
16.
WalsheK. Regulating U.S. nursing homes: Are we learning from experience?Health Affairs2001;20(6):128–44.
17.
HarringtonC. Residential nursing facilities in the United States. BMJ2001;323(7311):507.
18.
O’neillC, HarringtonC, KitchenerM, SalibaD. Quality of care in nursing homes: An analysis of relationships among profit, quality, and ownership. Med Care2003;41(12):1318–30.
19.
HillmerMP. Nursing home profit status and quality of care: Is there any evidence of an association?Med Care Res Rev2005;62(2):139–66.
20.
GrabowskiDC, AngelelliJJ, MorV. Medicaid payment and risk-adjusted nursing home quality measures. Health Affairs2004;23(5):243–52.
21.
CarayonP, SmithMJ, HaimsMC. Work organization, job stress, and work-related musculoskeletal disorders. Hum Factors1999;41(4):644–63.
22.
MurphyLA, RobertsonMM, CarayonP. The next generation of macroergonomics: Integrating safety climate. Accid Anal Prev2014;68:16–24.
23.
National Research Council. Health care comes home: The human factors.Washington, DC: Committee on the Role of Human Factors in Home Health Care, Board on Human-Systems Integration, Division of Behavioral and Social Sciences and Education, 2011.
24.
BeerJM, McBrideSE, MitznerTL, RogersWA. Understanding challenges in the front lines of home health care: A human-systems approach. Appl Ergon2014;45(6):1687–99.
25.
LipscombHJ, LoomisD, McDonaldMA, ArgueRA, WingS. A conceptual model of work and health disparities in the United States. Int J Health Serv2006;36(1):25–50.
26.
BonautoDK, SmithCK, AdamsDA, FanZJ, SilversteinBA, FoleyMP. Language preference and non-traumatic low back disorders in Washington State workers’ compensation. Am J Ind Med2010;53(2):204–15.
27.
PremjiS, MessingK, LippelK. Broken English, broken bones? Mechanisms linking language proficiency and occupational health in a Montreal garment factory. Int J Health Serv2008;38(1):1–19.
28.
DoedeMS. Black jobs matter: Racial inequalities in conditions of employment and subsequent health outcomes. Public Health Nurs2016;33(2):151–8.
29.
de CastroAB, GarciaG, GeeGC, TsaiJH-C, RueT, TakeuchiDT. Smoking and the Asian American workforce in the National Latino and Asian American Study. Am J Ind Med2010;53(2):171–8.
30.
KriegerN, ChenJT, WatermanPD, HartmanC, StoddardAM, QuinnMM, et al. The inverse hazard law: Blood pressure, sexual harassment, racial discrimination, workplace abuse and occupational exposures in US low-income black, white and Latino workers. Soc Sci Med2008;67(12):1970–81.
31.
ShannonCA, RospendaKM, RichmanJA, MinichLM. Race, racial discrimination, and the risk of work-related illness, injury or assault: Findings from a national study. J Occup Environ Med2009;51(4):441–8.
32.
SimpsonCL, SeversonRK. Risk of injury in African American hospital workers. J Occup Environ Med2000;42(10):1035–40.
33.
TakS, AltermanT, BaronS, CalvertGM. Racial and ethnic disparities in work-related injuries and socio-economic resources among nursing assistants employed in US nursing homes. Am J Ind Med2010;53(10):951–9.
34.
DongX, RingenK, MenY, FujimotoA. Medical costs and sources of payment for work-related injuries among Hispanic construction workers. J Occup Environ Med2007;49(12):1367–75.
35.
de CastroAB, VossJG, RuppinA, DominguezCF, SeixasNS. Stressors among Latino day laborers: A pilot study examining allostatic load. AAOHN J2010;58(5):185–96.
36.
MenzelNN, GutierrezAP. Latino worker perceptions of construction risks. Am J Ind Med2010;53(2):179–87.
37.
Campos-SernaJ, Ronda-PerezE, ArtazcozL, MoenBE, BenavidesFG. Gender inequalities in occupational health related to the unequal distribution of working and employment conditions: A systematic review. Int J Equity Health2013;12:57.
38.
SchenkerMB. A global perspective of migration and occupational health. Am J Ind Med2010;53(4):329–37.
39.
de CastroAB, GeeGC, TakeuchiD. Relationship between job dissatisfaction and physical and psychological health among filipino immigrants. AAOHN J2008;56(1):33–40.
40.
de CastroAB, FujishiroK, SweitzerE, OlivaJ. How immigrant workers experience workplace problems: A qualitative study. Arch Environ Occup Health2006;61(6):249–58.
41.
GrzywaczJG, ArcuryTA, MoraD, AndersonAM, ChenH, RosenbaumDA, et al. Work organization and musculoskeletal health: Clinical findings from immigrant latino poultry processing and other manual workers. J Occup Environ Med2012;54(8):995–1001.
42.
FlynnMA, EggerthDE, JacobsonCJJr.. Undocumented status as a social determinant of occupational safety and health: The workers’ perspective. Am J Ind Med2015;58(11):1127–37.
43.
SmithR. Immigrant workers and worker’s compensation: The need for reform. Am J Ind Med2012;55(6):537–44.
44.
LandsbergisPA, GrzywaczJG, LaMontagneAD. Work organization, job insecurity, and occupational health disparities. Am J Ind Med2014;57(5):495–515.
45.
BoyerJ, GalizziM, CifuentesM, d’ErricoA, GoreR, PunnettL, et al. Ergonomic and socioeconomic risk factors for hospital workers’ compensation injury claims. Am J Ind Med2009;52(7):551–62.
46.
MacDonaldLA, CohenA, BaronS, BurchfielCM. Occupation as socioeconomic status or environmental exposure? A survey of practice among population-based cardiovascular studies in the United States. Am J Epidemiol2009;169(12):1411–21.
47.
SiqueiraCE, GaydosM, MonfortonC, SlatinC, BorkowskiL, DooleyP, et al. Effects of social, economic, and labor policies on occupational health disparities. Am J Ind Med2014;57(5):557–72.
48.
ShresthaPP, MenzelNN. Hispanic construction workers and assertiveness training. WORK2014;49(3):517–22.
49.
NIOSH/ASSE. Overlapping vulnerabilities: The occupational safety and health of young workers in small construction firms. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, DHHS (NIOSH), 2015 Contract No.: 2015-178.
50.
SmithPM, SaundersR, LifshenM, BlackO, LayM, BreslinFC, et al. The development of a conceptual model and self-reported measure of occupational health and safety vulnerability. Accid Anal Prev2015 9;82:234–43.
51.
LayAM, SaundersR, LifshenM, BreslinC, LaMontagneA, TompaE, et al. Individual, occupational, and workplace correlates of occupational health and safety vulnerability in a sample of Canadian workers. Am J Ind Med2016;59(2):119–28.
52.
QuesadaJ, HartLK, BourgoisP. Structural vulnerability and health: Latino migrant laborers in the United States. Med Anthropol2011;30(4):339–62.
53.
HolmesSM. Structural vulnerability and hierarchies of ethnicity and citizenship on the farm. Med Anthropol2011;30(4):425–49.
54.
HunterD, SilversteinB. Perceptions of risk from workers in high risk industries with work related musculoskeletal disorders. WORK2014;49(4):689–703.
55.
HowardN, BaoS, LinJ, HunterD, HaasA. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) in Washington: Health Care, A summary of research study findings. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, 2015.
56.
HowardN, BaoS, LinJ, HunterD, HaasA. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) in Washington State: Wholesale and retail trade, A summary of research study findings. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, 2015.
57.
HowardN, BaoS, LinJ, HunterD, HaasA. Work-related musculoskeletal disorders (WMSDs) in Washington State Manufacturing, A summary of research study findings. Safety & Health Assessment & Research for Prevention, Washington State Department of Labor & Industries, 2015.
LevanonA, EnglandP, AllisonP. Occupational feminization and pay: Assessing causal dynamics using 1950–2000 U.S. census data. Soc Forces2009;88(2):865–91.
60.
GoodM, JamesC, GoodB, BeckerA. The culture of medicine and racial, ethnic, and class disparities in healthcare. In:
SmedleyBD,
StithAY,
NelsonAR, editors. Unequal treatment: Confronting racial and ethnic disparities in health care. Washington, DC: National Academies Press; 2003. pp. 594–625.
61.
HortonS. The double burden on safety net providers: Placing health disparities in the context of the privatization of health care in the US. Soc Sci Med2006;63(10):2702–14.
62.
HortonS, LamphereL. A call to an anthropology of health policy. Anthropology News2006;47(1):33–6.
63.
BishopCE, WeinbergDB, LeutzW, DossaA, PfefferleSG, ZincavageRM. Nursing assistants’ job commitment: Effect of nursing home organizational factors and impact on resident well-being. Gerontologist2008;48(supp1):36–45.
64.
WillgingCE. Power, blame, and accountability: Medicaid managed care for mental health services in New Mexico. Med Anthropol Q2005;19(1):84–102.
65.
DonoghueC, CastleNG. Leadership styles of nursing home administrators and their association with staff turnover. Gerontologist2009;49(2):166–74.
66.
Diez RouxAV. Conceptual approaches to the study of health disparities. Annu Rev Public Health2012;33:41–58.
67.
HolmesSM. An ethnographic study of the social context of migrant health in the United States. PLoS Med2006;3(10):e448.
68.
PattonIMQ. Qualitative research and evaluation methods. Thousand Oaks: Sage; 2002.
