Occupational tasks involve awkward upper limb postures, especially movement of forearm with repetitive combined gripping and torqueing exertions, which may lead to development of WMSDs. From the literature survey it was observed that there was a lack of studies focussed on the combined effect of torque and grip exertions on forearm discomfort.
OBJECTIVE:
The present study was to investigate the effects of grip force, stroke rotation and frequency of exertions on discomfort and Electromyography (EMG) activities of the forearm muscles in a repetitive torqueing task.
METHOD:
Twenty-seven male participants volunteered in this study. The participants performed repetitive exertions for a 5 minutes duration for each combination of the different levels of stroke rotation, grip force and frequency of exertions. Three levels of stroke rotation, three levels of grip force and three levels of frequency of exertion were chosen as independent variables. Therefore a 3 × 3 customized factorial design was used for the experiment for each level of grip force. Hence, the study was divided into three groups on the basis of grip force (50N, 70N and 90N).
RESULTS:
The ANOVA showed that stroke rotation and frequency of exertion were significant on discomfort. Further Students Newmann test (SNK) revealed that discomfort was increased with increasing stroke rotation and frequency of exertion. The multivariate analysis of variances (MANOVA) performed on EMG data instead of ANOVA because EMG activities of five muscles simultaneously were recorded. The Results found that extensor muscles were more fatigued in torqueing with gripping task.
CONCLUSIONS:
It was found that stroke rotation for the torqueing tasks must be kept below 45°. It was concluded that it is important to control stroke rotation to improve performance of repetitive torqueing activity.
FanZJ, SilversteinBA, BaoS, BonautoDK, HowardNL, SpielholzPO, Viikari-JunturaE. Quantitative exposure-response relations between physical workload and prevalence of lateral epicondylitis in a working population. Am J Ind Med2009;52(6):479–90.
2.
HarrisC, EisenE, GoldbergR, KrauseN, RempelD. 1st place, PREMUS best paper competition: Workplace and individual factors in wrist tendinosis among blue-collar workers. The San Francisco study. Scand J Work Environ Health2011;37(2):85–98.
3.
SilversteinBA, FanZJ, BonautoDK, BaoS, SmithCK, HowardN, et al. The natural course of carpal tunnel syndrome in a working population. Scand J Work Environ Health2010;36(5):384–93.
4.
BernardBP. Musculoskeletal disorders and workplace factors: Cincinnati: National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health; 1997.
5.
KumarS. Theories of musculoskeletal injury causation. Ergonomics2001;44(1):17–47.
6.
WikerS, ChaffinDB, LangolfGD. Shoulder posture and localized muscle fatigue and discomfort. Ergonomics1989;32:211–37.
7.
Bureau of Labor Statistics (USA), 2004. Lost-work time injuries and illnesses. Characteristics and resulting days away from work, 2002. U.S. Department of Labor.
8.
MukhopadhyayP, O’SullivanL, GallweyTJ. Estimating upper limb discomfort level due to intermittent isometric pronation torque with various combinations of elbow angles, forearm rotation angles, force and frequency with upper arm at 90° abduction. Int J Ind Ergon2007a;37(4):313–25.
9.
HughesRE, SilversteinBA, EvanoffBA. Risk factors for work-related musculoskeletal disorders in an aluminium smelter. Am J Ind Med1997;32:66–75.
10.
HerbertR, DropkinJ, WarrenN, et al. Impact of joint labor-management ergonomics program on upper extremity musculoskeletal symptoms among garment workers. Appl Ergon2001;32:453–60.
11.
HagbergM, WegmanDH. Prevalence rates and odds ratios of shoulder-neck diseases in different occupational groups. Occup Environ Med1987;44(9):602–10.
O’SullivanL, ClancyP. Guideline threshold limit values (TLVs) for discomfort in repetitive assembly work. HumFactors Ergon Manuf2007;17(5):423–34.
18.
FinneranA, O’SullivanL. Force, posture and repetition induced discomfort as a mediator in self-paced cycle time. Int J Ind Ergon2010;40(3):257–66.
19.
MukhopadhyayP, O’SullivanLW, GallweyTJ. Upper limb discomfort profile due to intermittent isometric pronation torque at different postural combinations of the shoulder-arm system. Ergonomics2009;52(5):584–600.
20.
MehtaRK, AgnewMJ. Analysis of individual and occupational risk factors on task performance and biomechanical demands for a simulated drilling task. Int J Ind Ergon2010;40(5):584–91.
21.
O’SullivanLW, GallweyTJ. Upper-limb surface electro-myography at maximum supination and pronation torques: The effect of elbow and forearm angle. J Electromyogr Kinesiol2002;12(4):275–85.
22.
DimbergL. The prevalence and causation of tennis elbow (lateral epicondylitis) in a population of workers in an engineering industry. Ergonomics1987;30:573–80.
23.
O’SullivanLW, GallweyTJ. Forearm torque strengths and discomfort profiles in pronation and supination. Ergonomics2005;48:703–21.
24.
MukhopadhyayP, O’SullivanLW, GallweyTJ. Effects of upper arm articulations on shoulder- arm discomfort profile in a pronation task. Occupational Ergonomics2007b;7:1–13.
25.
KhanAA, O’SullivanL, GallweyTJ. Effects of combined wrist flexion/extension and forearm rotation and two levels of relative force on discomfort. Ergonomics2009a;52(10):1265–75.
26.
KhanAA, O’SullivanL, GallweyTJ. Effects of combined wrist deviation and forearm rotation on discomfort score. Ergonomics2009b;52(3):345–61.
27.
KhanAA, O’SullivanL, GallweyTJ. Effect on discomfort of frequency of wrist exertions combined with wrist articulations and forearm rotation. Int J Ind Ergon2010;40(5):492–503.
28.
FarooqM, KhanAA. Effect of shoulder rotation, upper arm rotation and elbow flexion in a repetitive gripping task. Work2012;43(3):263–78.
29.
ChangCH, WangMJJ. Evaluating factors that influence hand- arm stress while operating an electric screwdriver. Appl Ergon2000;31:283–9.
30.
ChangCH, WangMJJ. Evaluating the effects of activation mode, torque and horizontal operating distance on hand-arm response while operating pneumatic screwdrivers. Int J Ind Ergon2001;28:171–9.
31.
CirielloVM, WebsterBS, DempseyPG. Maximal Acceptable Torques of Highly Repetitive Screw Driving, Ulnar Deviation, and Handgrip Tasks for 7-Hour Workdays. AIHA J2002;63(5):594–604.
32.
MukhopadhyayP, GallweyTJ, O’SullivanLW. Effect of grip force and shoulder abduction angles in repetitive clockwise forearm pronation/supination. In: Proceedings of the International Annual Occupational Ergonomics and Safety Conference. 2003.
33.
BanoF, MallickZ, KhanAA. Effect of grip, stroke rotation and handle size on discomfort for screwing task. Int J Hum Factors Ergon2012;1(4):390.
34.
EksiogluM. Endurance time of grip-force as a function of grip-span, posture and anthropometric variables. Int J Ind Ergon2011;41(5):401–9.
35.
HoozemansMJM, van DieënJH. Prediction of handgrip forces using surface EMG of forearm muscles. J Electromyogr Kinesiol2005;15(4):358–66.
36.
MogkJPM, KeirPJ. The effects of posture on forearm muscle loading during gripping. Ergonomics2003;46(9):956–75.
37.
CareyEJ, GallweyTJ. Wrist discomfort levels for combined movements at constant force and repetition rate. Ergonomics2005;48(2):171–86.
38.
LinML, RadwinRG, SnookSH. A single metric for quantifying biomechanical stress in repetitive motions and exertions. Ergonomics1997;40(5):543–58.
39.
CareyEJ, GallweyTJ. Effects of wrist posture, pace and exertion on discomfort. Int J Ind Ergon2002;29:85–94.
40.
GescheiderGA, editor. Psychophysics – Method, theory, and application. 2nd ed. Hillsdale (NJ): Lawrence Earlbaum; 1985.
41.
StrasserH. Electromyography: Methods and techniques. In:
KarwowskiW, editors. International Encyclopaedia of Ergonomics and Human factors. London: Taylor and Francis; 2001;3:1801–4.
42.
KongY-K, KimD-M, LeeK-S, JungM-C. Comparison of comfort, discomfort, and continuum ratings of force levels and hand regions during gripping exertions. Appl Ergon2012;43(2):283–9.
43.
AldienY, WelcomeD, RakhejaS, DongR, BoileauP-E. Contact pressure distribution at hand– handle interface: Role of hand forces and handle size. Int J Ind Ergon2005;35(3):267–86.
44.
MarcotteP, AldienY, BoileauP, RakhejaS, BoutinJ. Effect of handle size and hand– handle contact force on the biodynamic response of the hand–arm system under zh-axis vibration. J Sound Vib2005;283:1071–91.
45.
EttemaGJ, StylesG, KippersV. The moment arms of 23 muscle segments of the upper limb with varying elbow and forearm positions: Implications for motor control. Hum Mov Sci1998;17(2):201–20.
46.
GonzalezRV, BuchananTS, DelpSL. How muscle architecture and moment arms affect wrist flexion-extension moments. J Biomech1997;30(7):705–12.
47.
KhanAA. Effect of wrist articulation combined with forearm rotation on discomfort, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Limerick, Ireland. 2004.
48.
ArmstrongTJ. Ergonomics and cumulative trauma disorders of the hand and wrist. In:
HunterJM,
SchneiderLH,
MackinEJ,
CallahanAD editors. Rehabilitation of the hand surgery and therapy. Philadelphia: Mosby; 1990.
49.
MarrasWS, SchoenmarklinRW. Quantification of wrist motion in highly repetitive, hand intensive industrial jobs. Final Report. Grant nos. 1 R01 OH02621-01 and 02 funded by NIOSH. 1991.
50.
AttebrantM, WinkelJ, MathiassenSE, KjellbergA. Shoulder-arm muscle load and performance during control operation in forestry machines. Appl Ergon1997;28(2):85–97.
51.
BuchholzB, ParkJ-S, GoldJE, PunnettL. Subjective ratings of upper extremity exposures: Inter-method agreement with direct measurement of exposures. Ergonomics2008;51(7):1064–77.
52.
TomatisL, NakasekoM, LäubliT. Co-activation and maxima EMG activity of forearm muscles during key tapping. Int J Ind Ergon2009;39:749–55.
53.
JohnsonPW, CirielloVM, KerinKJ, DennerleinJT. Using electrical stimulation to measure physiological changes in the human extensor carpi ulnaris muscle after prolonged low-level repetitive ulnar deviation. Appl Ergon2013;44(1):35–41.
54.
SjøgaardG, ChriestensenH, PedersenMB. Neck and shoulder disorders due to prolonged uncomfortable working postures. In Proc. of Eleventh Congress of the International Ergonomics1991;1: 123–25. Paris.
55.
LiKW. Ergonomic design and evaluation of wire-tying hand tools. Int J Int Ergon2002;30:149–61.
56.
LiKW. Ergonomic evaluation of a fixture used for power driven wire-tying hand tools. Int J Int Ergon2003;32:71–79.
57.
ByströmSEG, MathiassenSE, Fransson-HallC. Physiological effects of micropauses in isometric handgrip exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol Occup Physiol1991;63(6):405–11.
58.
HäggG, MileradE. Forearm extensor and flexor muscle exertion during simulated gripping work — an electromyographic study. Clin Biomech1997;12(1):39–43.
59.
Roman-LiuD, TokarskiT. EMG of arm and forearm muscle activities with regards to handgrip force in relation to upper limb location. Acta Bioeng Biomech2002;4(2):33–44.
60.
LjungB-O, FridénJ, LieberRL. Sarcomere length varies with wrist ulnar deviation but not forearm pronation in the extensor carpi radialis brevis muscle. J Biomech1999;32(2):199–202.
61.
LorenGJ, ShoemakerSD, BurkholderTJ, JacobsonMD, FridánJ, LieberRL. Human wrist motors: Biomechanical design and application to tendon transfers. J Biomech1996;29(3):331–42.
