Virtual reality (VR)-based physical exercise is an innovative and effective intervention strategy for healthcare in older adults.
OBJECTIVE:
This meta-analysis aimed to clarify the effects of VR-based balance exercise programs on various balancing abilities of older adults. In addition, the effect size of each variable was computed by total exercise time, sensor type, avatar presence, and feedback type to determine influencing factors that lead to the success of VR-based rehabilitation programs.
METHODS:
The databases searched were PubMed/Medline, CINAHL, NDSL, and Google Scholar. Inclusion criteria were: (1) independent older adults; (2) non-immersive VR exercise; (3) randomized controlled design; (4) both balance and gait data; and (5) written in English and Korean. The studies without information to compute effect sizes were excluded. Standardized mean difference was used to analyze the effect size (d).
RESULTS:
Twenty-five studies were finally included in this study. The main findings of this meta-analysis were as follows: (1) Non-immersive VR-based balance exercises are moderately and largely effective for improving overall balance function, (2) VR balance exercise was more effective for static balance than for gait, (3) VR exercise is more effective when avatars are presented and KP is provided as feedback.
CONCLUSION:
Total exercise time and mode of feedback are influencing factors that affect the effectiveness of VR-based balance exercises.
WoollacottMHShumway-CookANashnerLM. Aging and posture control: Changes in sensory organization and muscular coordination. Int J Aging Hum Dev. 1986; 23(2): 97-114. doi: 10.2190/VXN3-N3RT-54JB-X1.
2.
ShinBMHanSJJungJHKimJEFregniF. Effect of mild cognitive impairment on balance. J Neurol Sci.2011; 305(1-2): 121-125. doi: 10.1016/j.jns.2011.02.031.
3.
World Health Organization. Ageing and health. 2021. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/ageing-and-health.
4.
PrataMGScheicherME. Correlation between balance and the level of functional independence among elderly people. Sao Paulo Med J.2021; 130(2): 97-101. doi: 10.1590/s1516-31802012000200005.
5.
ThomasEBattagliaGPattiABrusaJLeonardiVPalmaA, et al. Physical activity programs for balance and fall prevention in elderly. Medicine (Baltimore).2019; 98(27): e16218. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000016218.
6.
MirelmanAMaidanIHermanTDeutschJGiladiNHausdorffJ. Virtual reality for gait training: can it induce motor learning to enhance complex walking and reduce fall risk in patients with Parkinson’s disease? J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci.2011; 66(2): 234-240. doi: 10.1093/gerona/glq201.
7.
ShiYDuJAhnCRRaganE. Impact assessment of reinforced learning methods on construction workers’ fall risk behavior using virtual reality. Autom Constr.2019; 104(3): 197-214. doi: 10.1016/j.autcon.2019.04.015.
8.
Shumway-CookAGruberWBaldwinMLiaoS. The Effect of multidimensional exercises on balance, mobility, and fall risk in community-dwelling older adults. Phys Ther.1997; 77(1): 46-57. doi: 10.1093/ptj/77.1.46.
9.
WeechSKennySBarnett-CowanM. Presence and cybersickness in virtual reality are negatively related: A review. Frontiers in Psychology. 2019; 10: 158. Please this reference in the manuscript.
10.
De AmorimJSCLeiteRCBrizolaRYonamineCY. Virtual reality therapy for rehabilitation of balance in the elderly: A systematic review and META-analysis. Adv Rheumatol.2018; 58(1): 18. doi: 10.1186/s42358-018-0013-0.
11.
NeriSGCardosoJRCruzLLimaRMOliveiraRIversenMD, et al. Do virtual reality games improve mobility skills and balance measurements in community-dwelling older adults? Systematic review and meta-analysis. Clin Rehabil.2017; 31(10): 1292-1304. doi: 10.1177/0269215517694677.
12.
MagillRAndersonD. Motor learning and control. 10 ed. New York: McGraw-Hill Publishing; 2010; 1-480.
13.
HwangNKChoiJBChoiDKParkJMHongCWParkJS, et al. Effects of semi-immersive virtual reality-based cognitive training combined with locomotor activity on cognitive function and gait ability in community-dwelling older adults. Healthcare (Basel).2021; 9(7): 814. doi: 10.3390/healthcare9070814.
14.
LaiCHPengCWChenYLHuangCPHsiaoYLChenSC. Effects of interactive video-game based system exercise on the balance of the elderly. Gait Posture.2013; 37(4): 511-515. doi: 10.1016/j.gaitpost.2012.09.003.
15.
ParkECKimSGLeeCW. The effects of virtual reality game exercise on balance and gait of the elderly. Journal of Physical Therapy Science.2015; 27(4): 1157-1159. doi: 10.1589/jpts.27.1157.
16.
LeeWHChoHKKimSHLeeJH. The effect of a virtual reality-based exercise program using a video game on the balance, gait and fall prevention in the elderly women. Journal of Sport and Leisure Studies.2011; 44(2): 605-614.
17.
BachaJMRGomesGCVde FreitasTBViveiroLAda SilvaKGBuenoGC, et al. Effects of kinect adventures games versus conventional physical therapy on postural control in elderly people: A randomized controlled trial. Games Health J.2018; 7(1): 24-36. doi: 10.1089/g4h.2017.0065.
18.
GandolfiMGeroinCDimitrovaEBoldriniPWaldnerABonadimanS, et al. Virtual reality telerehabilitation for postural instability in Parkinson’s disease: A multicenter, single-blind, randomized, controlled trial. Biomed Res Int.2017; 2017: 7962826. doi: 10.1155/2017/7962826.
19.
GomesGCVdo Socorro SimõesMLinSMBachaJMViveiroLAVariseEM, et al. Feasibility, safety, acceptability, and functional outcomes of playing Nintendo Wii Fit Plus for frail older adults: A randomized feasibility clinical trial. Maturitas.2018; 118: 20-28. doi: 10.1016/j.maturitas.2018.10.002.
20.
González-BernalJJJahouhMGonzález-SantosJMielgo-AyusoJFernández-LázaroDSoto-CámaraR. Influence of the use of wii games on physical frailty components in institutionalized older adults. Int J Environ Res Public Health.2021; 18: 2723. doi: 10.3390/ijerph18052723.
21.
HsiehCCLinPSHsuWCWangJSHuangYCLimAY, et al. The effectiveness of a virtual reality-based tai chi exercise on cognitive and physical function in older adults with cognitive impairment. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord.2019; 46(5-6): 358-370. doi: 10.1159/000494659.
22.
JeonSKimJ. Effects of augmented-reality-based exercise on muscle parameters, physical performance, and exercise self-efficacy for older adults. Int J Environ Res Public Health.2020; 17(9): 3260. doi: 10.3390/ijerph17093260.
23.
KimYGKangSH. The effect of virtual reality-based exercise program on balance, gait, and falls efficacy in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Journal of The Korean Society of Physical Medicine.2019; 14(4): 103-113. doi: 10.13066/kspm.2019.14.4.103.
24.
LeeJHParkSUKangJIYangDJParkSK. Effects of virtual reality exercise program on muscle activity and balance abilities in elderly women. J Korean Soc Phys Ther.2011; 23(4): 37-44.
25.
LeeYChoiWLeeKSongCLeeS. Virtual reality training with three-dimensional video games improves postural balance and lower extremity strength in community-dwelling older adults. J Aging Phys Act.2017; 25(4): 621-627. doi: 10.1123/japa.2015-0271.
26.
LeeK. Virtual reality gait training to promote balance and gait among older people: A randomized clinical trial. Geriatrics (Basel).2021; 6(1): 1. doi: 10.3390/geriatrics6010001.
27.
SchwenkMGrewalGSHonarvarB. Interactive balance training integrating sensor-based visual feedback of movement performance: A pilot study in older adults. J Neuroeng Rehabil.2014; 11: 164. doi: 10.1186/1743-0003-11-164.
28.
LeeSShinS. Effectiveness of virtual reality using video gaming technology in elderly adults with diabetes mellitus. Diabetes Technol Ther.2013; 15(6): 489-496. doi: 10.1089/dia.2013.0050.
29.
LiaoYYYangYRChengSJWuYRFuhJLWangRY. Virtual reality-based training to improve obstacle-crossing performance and dynamic balance in patients with Parkinson’s disease. Neurorehabil Neural Repair.2015; 29(7): 658-667. doi: 10.1177/1545968314562111.
30.
KuJKimYJChoSLimTLeeHSKangYJ. Three-dimensional augmented reality system for balance and mobility rehabilitation in the elderly: A randomized controlled trial. Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw.2019; 22(2): 132-141. doi: 10.1089/cyber.2018.0261.
31.
SinghDKARajaratnamBSPalaniswamyVRamanPBongPSPearsonH. Effects of balance-focused interactive games compared to therapeutic balance classes for older women. Climacteric.2013; 16(1): 141-146. doi: 10.3109/13697137.2012.664832.
32.
SongCHShinWSLeeKJLeeSW. The effect of a virtual reality-based exercise program using a video game on the muscle strength, balance and gait abilities in the elderly. J Korean Gerontol Soc.2009; 29(4): 1261-1275. doi: 10.1589/jpts.27.1157.
33.
ToulotteCTourselCOlivierN. Wii Fit training vs. Adapted Physical Activities: Which one is the most appropriate to improve the balance of independent senior subjects? A randomized controlled study. Clin Rehabil.2012; 26(9): 827-835. doi: 10.1177/0269215511434996.
34.
TsangWWFuAS. Virtual reality exercise to improve balance control in older adults at risk of falling. Hong Kong Med J.2016; 22 Suppl 2: S19-S22.
35.
YeşilyaprakSSYildirimMŞTomrukMErtekinOAlgunZC. Comparison of the effects of virtual reality-based balance exercises and conventional exercises on balance and fall risk in older adults living in nursing homes in Turkey. Physiother Theory Pract.2016; 32(3): 191-201. doi: 10.3109/09593985.2015.1138009.
36.
LeeS. The effects of a virtual reality exercise program on physical function and falls efficacy in elderly persons with type 2 diabetes. The Graduate School of Ewha Womans University Master’s Thesis, South Korea, 2010.
37.
CohenJ. Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences. New York: Routledge; 2013.
38.
AliSFAzmatSANoorAUSiddiquiHNoorS. Virtual reality as a tool for physical training. In: 2017 First International Conference on Latest trends in Electrical Engineering and Computing Technologies (INTELLECT). IEEE. 2017; pp. 1-6.
39.
OppiciLDixANarcissS. When is knowledge of performance (KP) superior to knowledge of results (KR) in promoting motor skill learning? A systematic review. Int Rev Sport Exerc Psychol. 2021; 1-25. doi: 10.1080/1750984X.2021.1986849.
40.
GranuloEBećarLGurbetaLBadnjevićA. Telemetry System for Diagnosis of Asthma and Chronical Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). In: HealthyIoT. 2016; Lecture Notes of the Institute for Computer Sciences, Social Informatics and Telecommunications Engineering, vol 187. Springer, Cham. 2016. doi: 10.1007/978-3-319-51234-1_18.
41.
BadnjevićAAvdihodžićHGurbeta PokvićL. Artificial intelligence in medical devices: Past, present and future. Psychiatr Danub.2021; 33(Suppl 3): 101-106.
42.
ŠećkanovićAŠehovacMSpahićLRamićIMamatnazarovaNPokvićLGKacilaM. Review of Artificial Intelligence Application in Cardiology. In: 2020 9th Mediterranean Conference on Embedded Computing (MECO). IEEE. 2020. doi: 10.1109/MECO49872.2020.9134333.
43.
OhHLeeG. Feasibility of full immersive virtual reality video game on balance and cybersickness of healthy adolescents. Neurosci Lett.2021; 760(24): 136063. doi: 10.1016/j.neulet.2021.136063.
