The effects of sensory re-education on hand function recovery after peripheral nerve repair: A systematic review

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Peripheral nerve injury can result in both sensory and motor deficits, and these impairments can last for a long period after nerve repair.

OBJECTIVE:

To systematically review the effects of sensory re-education (SR) on facilitating hand function recovery after peripheral nerve repair.

METHODS:

This systematic review was limited to articles published from 1970 to 20 December 2020. Electronic searching was performed in CINAHL, Embase, PubMed, Web of Science, and Medline databases to include trials investigating the effects of SR training on hand function recovery after peripheral nerve repair and included only those studies with controlled comparisons.

RESULTS:

Sixteen articles were included in final data synthesis. We found that only four studies could be rated as having good quality and noted obvious methodological limitations in the remaining studies. The current evidence showed that early SR with mirror visual feedback and the combinational use of classic SR and topical temporary anesthetic seemed to have long- and short-term effects, respectively on improving the sensibility and reducing the disabilities of the hand. The evidence to support the effects of conventional classical SR on improving hand functions was not strong.

CONCLUSIONS:

Further well-designed trials are needed to evaluate the effects of different SR techniques on hand function after nerve repair over short- and long-term periods.

Keywords

Hand injury peripheral nerve injury nerve repair sensory reeducation hand function

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Antonopoulos,

D. K.

, Mavrogenis,

A. F.

, Megaloikonomos,

P. D.

, Mitsiokapa,

, Georgoudis,

, Vottis,

C. T.

, ... Spyridonos,

S. G.

(2019). Similar 2-point discrimination and stereognosia but better locognosia at long term with an independent home-based sensory reeducation program vs no reeducation after low-median nerve transection and repair. Journal of Hand Therapy, 32(3), 305–312.

Bai,

, Fong,

K. N. K.

, Zhang,

, & Hu,

(2019). Cortical mapping of mirror visual feedback training for unilateral upper extremity: a functional near-infrared spectroscopy study. Brain and Behavior, 10(1)(n/a), e01489.

Bavelier,

, & Neville,

H. J.

(2002). Cross-modal plasticity: where and how? Nature Reviews Neuroscience, 138(6), 177–188.

Cheng,

A. S. K.

(2000). Use of early tactile stimulation in rehabilitation of digital nerve injuries. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 54(2), 159–165.

Dellon,

A. L.

, Curtis,

, & Edgerton,

(1971). Re-education of sensation in hand following nerve injury. Paper presented at the Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery-American Volume, Journal Bone Joint Surgery Inc 20 Pickering St, Needham, MA 02192.

Dellon,

A. L.

, (1997a). Cortical plasticity. In Somatosensory testing & rehabilitation (pp. 192-213). Rockville, Maryland: American Occupational Therapy Association.

Dellon,

A. L.

, (1997b). Nerve reconstrunction. In Somatosensory testing & rehablitaition (pp. 31-53). Maryland: Rockville: American Occupational Therapy Association.

Dellon,

A. L.

, (1997c). Sensroy reeducation. In Somatosensory testing & rehabilitation (pp. 214-254). Rockville, Maryland: American Occupational Therapy Association.

Dellon,

A. L.

, & Jabaley,

M. E.

(1982). Reeducation of sensation in the hand following nerve suture. Clinical Orthopaedics And Related Research, (163), 75-79.

10.

Duffau,

(2006). Brain plasticity: from pathophysiological mechanisms to therapeutic applications. Journal of Clinical Neuroscience, 13(9), 885–897.

11.

Hassan-Zadeh,

, Lajevardi,

, Esfahani,

A. R.

, & Kamali,

(2009). Improvement of hand sensibility after selective temporary anaesthesia in combination with sensory re-education. Neurorehabilitation, 24(4), 383–386.

12.

Imai,

, Tajima,

, & Natsuma,

(1989). Interpretation of cutaneous pressure threshold (Semmes-Weinstein monofilament measurement) following median nerve repair and sensory reeducation in the adult. Microsurgery, 10(2), 142–144.

13.

Imai,

, Tajima,

, & Natsumi,

(1991). Successful reeducation of functional sensibility after median nerve repair at the wrist. The Journal Of Hand Surgery, 16(1), 60–65.

14.

Jerosch-Herold,

(2011). Sensory relearning in peripheral nerve disorders of the hand: a web-based survey and Delphi consensus method. Journal of Hand Therapy, 24(4), 292–299.

15.

Lundborg,

(2010). Nerve injury and repair –a challenge to the plastic brain. Journal of the Peripheral Nervous System, 8(4), 209–226.

16.

Lundborg,

(2000). Brain plasticity and hand surgery: an overview. Journal of Hand Surgery British & European Volume, 25(3), 242–252.

17.

Lundborg,

, Bjorkman,

, Hansson,

, Nylander,

, Nyman,

, & Rosen,

(2005). Artificial sensibility of the hand based on cortical audiotactile interaction: a study using functional magnetic resonance imaging. Scandinavian Journal Of Plastic And Reconstructive Surgery And Hand Surgery, 39(6)(0284-4311 ((Print)), 370–372.

18.

Lundborg,

, Bjorkman,

, & Rosen,

(2007). Enhanced sensory relearning after nerve repair by using repeated forearm anaesthesia: aspects on time dynamics of treatment. Acta Neurochirurgica Supplementum, 100, 121–126.

19.

Lundborg,

, & Rosén,

(2001). Sensory relearning after nerve repair. Lancet (London, England), 358(9284), 809–810.

20.

Lundborg,

, Rosén,

, Dahlin,

, Holmberg,

, & Rosén,

(2004). Tubular repair of the median or ulnar nerve in the human forearm: a 5-year follow-up. Journal of Hand Surgery, 29(2), 100–107.

21.

Mahaniah,

K. J.

, & Rao,

(2004). Intention-to-treat analysis: protecting the integrity of randomization. Journal of Family Practice, 53(8), 644.

22.

Maher,

C. G.

, Catherine,

, Herbert,

R. D.

, Moseley,

A. M.

, & Mark,

(2003). Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials. Physical Therapy, 83(8), 713–721.

23.

Mavrogenis,

A. F.

, Spyridonos,

S. G.

, Antonopoulos,

, Soucacos,

P. N.

, & Papagelopoulos,

P. J.

(2009). Effect of sensory re-education after low median nerve complete transection and repair. The Journal Of Hand Surgery, 34(7), 1210–1215.

24.

Mendes,

R. M.

, Barbosa,

R. I.

, Salmon,

C. E. G.

, Rondinoni,

, Escorsi-Rosset,

, Delsim,

J. C.

, ... Mazzer,

(2013). Auditory stimuli from a sensor glove model modulate cortical audiotactile integration. Neuroscience Letters, 548, 33–37.

25.

Mendes,

R. M.

, Rondinoni,

, Fonseca,

M. D. R.

, Barbosa,

R. I.

, Salmon,

C. E. G.

, Barbieri,

C. H.

, & Mazzer,

(2018). Cortical and functional responses to an early protocol of sensory re-education of the hand using audio-tactile interaction. Hand Therapy, 23(2), 45–52.

26.

Merzenich,

M. M.

, & Jenkins,

W. M.

(1993). Reorganization of cortical representations of the hand following alterations of skin inputs induced by nerve injury, skin island transfers, and experience. Journal of Hand Therapy, 6(2), 89.

27.

Miller,

L. K.

, Chester,

, & Jerosch-Herold,

(2012). Effects of sensory reeducation programs on functional hand sensibility after median and ulnar repair: a systematic review. Journal Of Hand Therapy: Official Journal Of The American Society Of Hand Therapists, 25(3), 297–306.

28.

Moher,

, Liberati,

, Tetziaff,

, & Douglas

G, A.

(2009). Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA statement. Revista Española De Nutrición Humana Y Dietética, 18(3), e123.

29.

Oud,

, Beelen,

, Eijffinger,

, & Nollet,

(2007). Sensory re-education after nerve injury of the upper limb: a systematic review. Clinical Rehabilitation, 21(6), 483–494.

30.

Parry,

C. W.

, & Salter,

(1976). Sensory re-education after median nerve lesions. The Hand, 8(3), 250–257.

31.

Paula,

M. H.

, Barbosa,

R. I.

, Marcolino,

A. M.

, Elui,

V. M. C.

, Rosen,

, & Fonseca,

M. C. R.

(2016). Early sensory re-education of the hand after peripheral nerve repair based on mirror therapy: a randomized controlled trial. Brazilian Journal Of Physical Therapy, 20(1), 58–65.

32.

Priya,

B. A.

(2012). Effectiveness of sensory re-education after nerve repair (median or ulnar nerve) at the wrist level. Indian Journal of Physiotherapy & Occupational Therapy, 6(3), 62–68.

33.

Rosén,

(1996). Recovery of sensory and motor function after nerve repair: a rationale for evaluation. Journal of Hand Therapy, 9(4), 315.

34.

Rosén,

, Balkenius,

, & Lundborg,

(2003). Sensory re-education today and tomorrow: a review of evolving concepts. British Journal of Hand Therapy, 8(2), 48–56.

35.

Rosén,

, Björkman,

, & Lundborg,

(2006). Improved sensory relearning after nerve repair induced by selective temporary anaesthesia - a new concept in hand rehabilitation. Journal Of Hand Surgery (Edinburgh, Scotland), 31(2), 126–132.

36.

Rosén,

, & Lundborg,

(2003). A new model instrument for outcome after nerve repair. Hand Clinics, 19(3), 463–470.

37.

Rosén,

, & Lundborg,

(2004). Sensory re-education after nerve repair: aspects of timing. Handchirurgie Mikrochirurgie Plastische Chirurgie, 37(01), 8–12.

38.

Rosen,

, & Lundborg,

(2007). Enhanced sensory recovery after median nerve repair using cortical audio-tactile interaction: a randomised multicentre study. Journal of Hand Surgery-British and European Volume, 32(1), 31–37.

39.

Rosén,

, Lundborg,

, Dahlin,

L. B.

, Holmberg,

, & Karlson,

(1994). Nerve repair: correlation of restitution of functional sensibility with specific cognitive capacities. Journal of Hand Surgery, 19(4), 452–458.

40.

Rosen,

, Vikstrom,

, Turner,

, McGrouther,

D. A.

, Selles,

R. W.

, Schreuders,

T. A.

, & Bjorkman,

(2015). Enhanced early sensory outcome after nerve repair as a result of immediate post-operative re-learning: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Hand Surgery-European Volume, 40(6), 598–606.

41.

Saberi,

, Lajevardi,

, Azad,

, Mirzaie,

, Taghizadeh,

, & Abdolrazaghi,

H. A.

(2018). Can mirror visual feedback improve sensory relearning outcomes following median/ulnar nerve repair? International Journal of Therapy & Rehabilitation, 25(10), 552–559.

42.

Schulz,

K. F.

, Altman,

D. G.

, & David,

(2011). CONSORT 2010 Statement: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. International Journal of Surgery, 9(8)(7), 672–677.

43.

Shieh,

S. J.

, Chiu,

H. Y.

, Lee,

J. W.

, & Hsu,

H. Y.

(1995). Evaluation of the effectiveness of sensory reeducation following digital replantation and revascularization. Microsurgery, 16(8), 578–582.

44.

Svens,

, & Rosén,

(2009). Early sensory relearning after median nerve repair using mirror training and sense substitution. Hand Therapy, 14(3), 75–82.

45.

Vikström,

, Carlsson,

, Rosén,

, & Björkman,

(2018). Patients’ views on early sensory relearning following nerve repair—a Q-methodology study. Journal of Hand Therapy, 31(4), 443–450.

46.

Vikström,

, Rosén,

, Carlsson,

I. K.

, & Björkman,

(2018). The effect of early relearning on sensory recovery 4 to 9 years after nerve repair: a report of a randomized controlled study. The Journal Of Hand Surgery, European Volume, 43(6), 626–630.

47.

Zink,

P. J.

, & Philip,

B. A.

(2020). Cortical Plasticity in Rehabilitation for Upper Extremity Peripheral Nerve Injury: A Scoping Review. The American journal of occupational therapy: official publication of the American Occupational Therapy Association, 74(1), 1–15.