Promising and evidence-based practices in vocational rehabilitation: Results of a national Delphi study

Abstract

BACKGROUND:

Recently, Leahy and his colleagues (Anderson, Leahy, Valle, Sherman, & Tansey, 2014; Del Valle, Leahy, Sherman, Anderson, Tansey, & Schoen, 2014; Leahy, Leahy, Chan, Lui, Rosenthal, Tansey, Wehman, P, & Menz, 2014; Sherman, Leahy, Del Valle, Anderson, Tansey, & Lui, 2014; Tansey, Bezyak, Chan, Leahy, & Lui, 2014) completed a comprehensive qualitative case study of four state VR agencies (Maryland, Mississippi, Texas, and Utah) to identify promising or evidence-based practices that can be used to improve management and clinical rehabilitation counseling practices. Fourteen promising or evidence-based VR practices were reported by administrators, supervisors, and counselors in those four VR agencies as useful for improving psychosocial and employment outcomes of persons with disabilities receiving services from state rehabilitation agencies.

OBJECTIVE:

The purpose of this article is to describe the outcomes of a Delphi study of experts on evidence-based VR practices.

METHODS:

A Delphi study was conducted to obtain the consensus of 35 national experts in vocational rehabilitation (VR) on the relevance and levels of scientific evidence of 26 promising or evidence-based VR practices in state agency settings.

RESULTS:

Consensus was achieved through three rounds of the Delphi process. National experts rated the employment-based interventions as highly relevant to state VR service delivery practices, but rated their scientific evidence in the lower end of the hierarchy of evidence. Experts rated psychosocial and counseling interventions, except for motivational interviewing and working alliance, as less relevant to state VR, but as having high levels of scientific evidence.

CONCLUSION:

This study represents an important step towards identifying specific promising or evidence-based VR practices in state agency settings that could be used to improve psychosocial and employment outcomes for people with disabilities. The results can also be used to plan the in-service training agenda for state VR agencies in terms of professional development and in pre-service academic programs to ensure that rehabilitation counseling students are adequately trained in relation to these promising or evidence-based VR practices.

Keywords

Evidence-based practice Delphi study and vocational rehabilitation

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anderson

C. A.

, Leahy

M. J.

, Valle

R. D.

, Sherman

, & Tansey

T. N.

(2014). Methodological application of multiple case study design using modified consensual qualitative research (CQR) analysis to identify best practices and organizational factors in the public rehabilitation program, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 41, 87–98.

Campbell

, Bond

G. R.

, & Drake

R. E.

(2011). Who benefits from supported employment: A meta-analytic study, Schizophrenia Bulletin, 37(2), 370–380.

Chan

, & Berven N. L. Thomas

K. R.

(Eds.). (2015), Counseling theories and techniques for rehabilitation and mental health professionals. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

Chan

, Chronister

, & Cardoso

E. D. S.

(2009) An introduction to evidence-based practice approach to psychosocial interventions for people with chronic illness and disability. In

Chan ,

Da Silva Cardoso &

J. A.

Chronister (Eds.), Understanding psychosocial adjustment to chronic illness and disability: A handbook for evidence-based practitioners in rehabilitation; (pp. 3–19). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

Chan

, Keegan

, Muller

, Kaya

, Flowers

, & Iwanaga

(2016) Evidence-based practice and research in rehabilitation counseling. In Marini & I.. Stebnicki

M.A

(Eds.), The professional counselor’s desk reference (2nd ed., pp. 605–610). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

Chan

, Sung

, Muller

, Wang

C. C.

, Fujikawa

, & Anderson

C. A.

(2011) Evidence-based practice and research utilization. In Maki,&D. Tarvydas

V. M.

(Eds.), Professional practice of rehabilitation counseling (pp. 391–412). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

Chan

, Shaw

, McMahon

B. T.

, Koch

, & Strauser

(1997). A model for enhancing consumer-counselor working relationships in rehabilitation, Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 41, 122–137.

Chan

, Tarvydas

, Blalock

, Strauser

, & Atkins

B. J.

(2009). Unifying and elevating rehabilitation counseling through model-driven, diversity-sensitive evidence-based practice, Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 52, 114–119.

Cook

D. W.

(2004) Counseling people with physical disabilities. In Chan

, Berven, &K. R. (Eds) Counseling theories and techniques for rehabilitation health professionals (pp. 328–341). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

10.

Del Valle

R. J.

, Leahy

M. J.

, Sherman

, Anderson

C. A.

, Tansey

, & Schoen

(2014). Promising best practices that lead to employment in vocational rehabilitation: Findings from a four-state multiple case study, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 41, 99–113.

11.

Delin

B. S.

, Hartman

E. C.

, & Sell

C. W.

(2012). The impact of work incentive benefits counseling on employment outcomes: Evidence form two return-to-work demonstrations, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 36, 97–107.

12.

Dutta

, Gervey

, Chan

, Chou

C. C.

, & Ditchman

(2008). Vocational rehabilitation services and employment outcomes for people with disabilities: A United States study, Journal of Occupational Rehabilitation, 18(4), 326–334.

13.

Fleming

A. R.

, Del Valle

, Kim

, & Leahy

M. J.

(2013). Best practice models of effective vocational rehabilitation service delivery in the public rehabilitation program: A review and synthesis of the empirical literature, Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 56(3), 146–159.

14.

Horvath

A. O.

, Del Re

A. C.

, Flückiger

, & Symonds

(2011). Alliance in individual psychotherapy, Psychotherapy, 48(1), 9–16.

15.

Hsu

C. C.

, & Standford

B. A.

(2007). The Delphi technique: Making sense of consensus, Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation, 12(10), 1–8.

16.

Leahy

M. J.

, Chan

, Lui

, Rosenthal

, Tansey

T. N.

, Wehman

, & Menz

F. E.

(2014). An analysis of evidence-based best practices in the public vocational rehabilitation program: Gaps, future directions, and recommended steps to move forward, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 41, 147–163.

17.

Leahy

M. J.

, Thielsen

V. A.

, Millington

M. J.

, Austin

, & Fleming

(2009). Quality assurance and program evaluation: Terms, models, and applications, Journal of Rehabilitation Administration, 33(2), 69–82.

18.

Manthey

, Brooks

, Chan

, Hedenblad

, & Ditchman

(2015) Motivational interviewing in rehabilitation health settings. In Chan

, Berven,&K. (Eds.), Counseling theories and techniques for rehabilitation and mental health professionals (2nd ed., pp. 247–278). New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

19.

Martin

, West-Evans

, & Connelly

(2010). Vocational rehabilitation: Celebrating 90 years of careers and independence, American Rehabilitation, 15–18.

20.

Moorhead

S. A.

, Hazlett

D. E.

, Harrison

, Carroll

J. K.

, Irwin

, & Hoving

(2013). A new dimension of health care: Systematic review of the uses, benefits, and limitations of social media for health communication, Journal of Medical Internet Research, 15(4), 118–133.

21.

Mueser

K. T.

, Drake

R. E.

, & Bond

G. R.

(2016). Recent advances in supported employment for people with serious mental illness, Current Opinion in Psychiatry, 29(3), 196–201.

22.

Nazarov

Z. E.

(2013), Can benefits and work incentives counseling be a path to future economic self-sufficiency for SSI/SSDI beneficiaries?Chestnut Hill, MA: Center for Retirement Research at Boston College.

23.

Paul

(1967). Strategy of outcome research in psychotherapy, Journal of Counseling Psychology, 31(2), 109–188.

24.

Rubin

S. E.

, Chan

, & Thomas

D. L.

(2003). Assessing changes in life skills and quality of life resulting from rehabilitation services, Journal of Rehabilitation, 69(3), 4–9.

25.

Ruiz-Quintanilla

S. A.

, Weathers II

R. R.

, Melburg

, Campbell

, & Madi

(2006). Participation in programs designed to improve employment outcomes for persons with psychiatric disabilities: Evidence from the New York WORKS demonstration project, Social Security Bulletin, 66(2), 49–79.

26.

Saunders

J. L.

, Leahy

M. J.

, McGlynn

, & Estrada-Hernandez

(2006). Predictors of employment outcomes for persons with disabilities: An integrative review of potential evidence-based factors, Journal of Applied Rehabilitation Counseling, 37(2), 3–20.

27.

Sherman

S. G.

, Leahy

M. J.

, Del Valle

, Anderson

C. A.

, Tansey

T. N.

, & Lui

(2014). Organizational and cultural factors that promote creative best practices in the public rehabilitation program: Findings from a four-state multiple case study, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 41(2), 115–125.

28.

Tansey

T. N.

, Bezyak

, Chan

, Leahy

M. J.

, & Lui

(2014). Social-cognitive predictors of readiness to use evidence-based practice: A survey of state vocational rehabilitation counselors, Journal of Vocational Rehabilitation, 41(2), 127–136.

29.

Tansey

T. N.

, Bezyak

J. L.

, Iwanaga

, Anderson

, & Ditchman

(2016). Path analysis of a self-determination model of work motivation in vocational rehabilitation. A paper presented at the 2016 National Council on Rehabilitation Education Spring Conference, Newport Beach, CA.

30.

Tremblay

, Smith

, Xie

, & Drake

R. E.

(2006). Effect of benefits counseling services on employment outcomes for people with psychiatric disabilities, Psychiatric Services, 57(6), 816–821.

31.

U.S.Department of Education. (2014) The Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act overview of Title IV: Amendments to the Rehabilitation Act of 1973Retrieved from https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/osers/rsa/publications/wioa-changes-to-rehab-act.pdf

32.

U.S. Government Accountability Office. (2005), Vocational rehabilitation—Better measures and monitoring could improve the performance of the VR Program (GAO-05-865). Washington, DC: Author.

33.

U.S. Office of Management and Budget and Federal agencies. (2006) The PART process. [Electronic version].Retrieved from http://wwww.whitehouse.gov/omb/.expectmore/

34.

Vazques-Ramso

, Leahy

M. J.

, & Hernandez

(2007). The Delphi method in rehabilitation counseling research, Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 50(2), 111–118.

35.

Wagner

C. C.

, & McMahon

B. T.

(2004). Motivational interviewing and rehabilitation counseling practice, Rehabilitation Counseling Bulletin, 47(3), 152–161.

36.

Wampold

B. E.

(2001) The great psychological debate. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates .

37.

Wampold

B. E.

, & Imel

Z. E.

(2015), The great psychotherapy debate: The research evidence for what works in psychotherapy (2nd ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.

38.

Wilson

K. B.

, Turner

, & Jackson

R. L.

(2002). Vocational rehabilitation services received after successful closure: A comparison by race, Journal of Applied Rehabilitation Counseling, 33(1), 26–34.