Tuberculosis (TB) bacteria may develop resistance to the drugs, which are used in TB treatment. Multidrug-resistant TB (MDR-TB) is a type of TB that does not respond to at least rifampicin and isoniazid, the 2 most powerful anti-TB drugs. MDR-TB requires a more compelling treatment and it is more difficult to diagnose. The experience of physician is the key factor in the success of MDR-TB diagnose. The existence of TB bacteria in the body can be observed relatively faster with a standard sputum smear however, drug-susceptibility tests require nearly 45 days. To cope with this infectious disease, it is vital to estimate the resistance in a newly diagnosed TB patient to plan the initialization of the treatment in the testing period. Herein, the purpose of this study is to build a framework and establish a mathematical model that will help decision makers (physicians) while estimating the risk of multidrug resistance when a new tuberculosis patient arrives, using intuitionistic fuzzy cognitive maps (IFCM). Intuitionistic fuzzy sets are utilized to reflect the decision makers’ hesitancy degrees in the model.
AibanaO., BachmahaM., KrasiukV., RybakN., FlaniganT.P., PetrenkoV. and MurrayM.B., Risk factors for poor multidrug-resistant tuberculosis treatment outcomes in Kyiv Oblast, Ukraine, BMC Infectious Diseases17 (2017), 129.
2.
AmirkhaniA., PapageorgiouE.I., MosaviM.R. and MohammadiK., A novel medical decision support system based on fuzzy cognitive maps enhanced by intuitive and learning capabilities for modeling uncertainty, Applied Mathematics and Computation337 (2018), 562–582.
3.
AnninouA.P. and GroumposP.P., Modeling of Parkinson’s disease using fuzzy cognitive maps and non-linear hebbian learning, International Journal on Artificial Intelligence Tools23 (2014).
4.
AtanassovK.T., Intuitionistic fuzzy-sets, Fuzzy Sets and Systems20 (1986), 87–96.
5.
AvashiaS., BansalD., BhargavaS., TomarA. and ChoubeyS., A study of epidemiological pattern of multidrug resistant pulmonary tuberculosis patients presenting to a tertiary care centre in central India, Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences-Jemds7 (2018), 962–964.
6.
BackA.L., ArnoldR.M., BaileW.F., TulskyJ.A. and Fryer-EdwardsK., Approaching difficult communication tasks in oncology, Ca-A Cancer Journal for Clinicians55 (2005), 164–177.
7.
BastosG.M., CezarM.C., MelloF.C.D.Q. and CondeM.B., Prevalence of primary drug resistance in pulmonary tuberculosis patients with no known risk factors for such, Jornal Brasileiro de Pneumologia38 (2012), 733–739.
8.
BourganiE., StyliosC.D., ManisG. and GeorgopoulosV.C., Time Dependent Fuzzy Cognitive Maps for Medical Diagnosis, in: Artificial Intelligence: Methods and Applications, A. Likas, K. Blekas and D. Kalles, eds., 2014, pp. 544–554.
9.
BuyukavcuA., AlbayrakY.E. and GokerN., A fuzzy information-based approach for breast cancer risk factors assessment, Applied Soft Computing38 (2016), 437–452.
10.
Chung-DelgadoK., Revilla-MontagA., Guillen-BravoS., Velez-SegoviaE., Soria-MontoyaA., Nuñez-GarbinA., Silva-CasoW. and Bernabe-OrtizA., Factors associated with anti-tuberculosis medication adverse effects: A case-control study in Lima, Peru, PLoS One6 (2011), e27610.
11.
da Silva GarridoM., PennaM.L., Perez-PorcunaT.M., de SouzaA.B.., da Silva MarreiroL., AlbuquerqueB.C., Martínez-EspinosaF.E. and Bührer-SékulaS., Factors associated with tuberculosis treatment default in an endemic area of the Brazilian Amazon: A case control-study, PLoS One7 (2012), e39134.
12.
De BritoM.J.A., NahasF.X., OrtegaN.R.S., CordásT.A., DiniG.M., NetoM.S. and FerreiraL.M., Support system for decision making in the identification of risk for body dysmorphic disorder: A fuzzy model, International Journal of Medical Informatics82 (2013), 844–853.
13.
DessalegnM., DanielE., BehailuS., WagnewM. and NyageroJ., Predictors of multidrug resistant tuberculosis among adult patients at Saint Peter Hospital Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, The Pan African Medical Journal25 (2016).
14.
DoguE. and AlbayrakY.E., Criteria evaluation for pricing decisions in strategic marketing management using an intuitionistic cognitive map approach, Soft Computing22 (2018), 4989–5005.
15.
ElmiO.S., HasanH., AbdullahS., JeabM.Z.M., AlwiZ.B. and NaingN.N., Multidrug-resistant tuberculosis and risk factors associated with its development: A retrospective study, The Journal of Infection in Developing Countries9 (2015), 1076–1085.
16.
FrankeM.F., AppletonS.C., BayonaJ., ArteagaF., PalaciosE., LlaroK., ShinS.S., BecerraM.C., MurrayM.B. and MitnickC.D., Risk factors and mortality associated with default from multidrug-resistant tuberculosis treatment, Clinical Infectious Diseases46 (2008), 1844–1851.
17.
FroelichW., PapageorgiouE.I., SamarinasM. and SkriapasK., Application of evolutionary fuzzy cognitive maps to the long-term prediction of prostate cancer, Applied Soft Computing Journal12 (2012), 3810–3817.
18.
FroelichW. and Wakulicz-DejaA., Medical diagnosis support by the application of associational cognitive maps, Control and Cybernetics39 (2010), 439–456.
19.
GeorgopoulosV.C., MalandrakiG.A. and StyliosC.D., A fuzzy cognitive map approach to differential diagnosis of specific language impairment, Artificial Intelligence in Medicine29 (2003), 261–278.
20.
GiabbanelliP.J., Torsney-WeirT. and MagoV.K., A fuzzy cognitive map of the psychosocial determinants of obesity, Applied Soft Computing Journal12 (2012), 3711–3724.
21.
GlerM., PodewilsL., MunezN., GalipotM., QuelapioM. and TupasiT., Impact of patient and program factors on default during treatment of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis, The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease16 (2012), 955–960.
22.
GobenaD., AmeyaG., HaileK., AbrehaG., WorkuY. and DebelaT., Predictor of multidrug resistant tuberculosis in southwestern part of Ethiopia: A case control study, Annals of Clinical Microbiology and Antimicrobials17 (2018).
23.
HajekP. and FroelichW., Integrating TOPSIS with interval-valued intuitionistic fuzzy cognitive maps for effective group decision making, Information Sciences485 (2019), 394–412.
24.
IakovidisD.K. and PapageorgiouE., Intuitionistic fuzzy cognitive maps for medical decision making, IEEE Transactions on Information Technology in Biomedicine15 (2011), 100–107.
25.
KoskoB., Fuzzy cognitive maps, International Journal of Man-Machine Studies24 (1986), 65–75.
26.
LeeI.K., KimH.S. and ChoH., Design of activation functions for inference of fuzzy cognitive maps: Application to clinical decision making in diagnosis of pulmonary infection, Healthcare Informatics Research18 (2012), 105–114.
27.
LettieriE., MasellaC. and ZanaboniP., A cognitive map to design a performance-oriented RIS-PACS, International Journal of Healthcare Technology and Management9 (2008), 45–59.
28.
NarasimhanP., WoodJ., MacIntyreC.R. and MathaiD., Risk Factors for Tuberculosis, Pulmonary Medicine2013 (2013), 828939.
29.
PapageorgiouE.I., A novel approach on constructed dynamic Fuzzy Cognitive Maps using fuzzified decision trees and knowledge-extraction techniques, in: Studies in Fuzziness and Soft Computing, 2010, pp. 43–70.
30.
PapageorgiouE.I., A new methodology for Decisions in Medical Informatics using fuzzy cognitive maps based on fuzzy rule-extraction techniques, Applied Soft Computing Journal11 (2011), 500–513.
31.
PapageorgiouE.I., Fuzzy cognitive map software tool for treatment management of uncomplicated urinary tract infection, Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine105 (2012), 233–245.
32.
PapageorgiouE.I. and FroelichW., Application of evolutionary fuzzy cognitive maps for prediction of pulmonary infections, IEEE Transactions on Information Technology in Biomedicine16 (2012), 143–149.
33.
PapageorgiouE.I., HuszkaC., De RooJ., DoualiN., JaulentM.C. and ColaertD., Application of probabilistic and fuzzy cognitive approaches in semantic web framework for medical decision support, Computer Methods and Programs in Biomedicine112 (2013), 580–598.
34.
PapageorgiouE.I. and IakovidisD.K., Intuitionistic fuzzy cognitive maps, IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems21 (2013), 342–354.
35.
PapageorgiouE.I., RooJ.D., HuszkaC. and ColaertD., Formalization of treatment guidelines using Fuzzy Cognitive Maps and semantic web tools, Journal of Biomedical Informatics45 (2012), 45–60.
36.
PapageorgiouE.I., SpyridonosP.P., GlotsosD.T., StyliosC.D., RavazoulaP., NikiforidisG.N. and GroumposP.P., Brain tumor characterization using the soft computing technique of fuzzy cognitive maps, Applied Soft Computing8 (2008), 820–828.
37.
PapageorgiouE.I., SpyridonosP.P., StyliosC.D., RavazoulaP., GroumposP.P. and NikiforidisG.N., Advanced soft computing diagnosis method for tumour grading, Artificial intelligence in Medicine36 (2006), 59–70.
38.
PapageorgiouE.I., StyliosC.D. and GroumposP.P., An integrated two-level hierarchical system for decision making in radiation therapy based on fuzzy cognitive maps, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering50 (2003), 1326–1339.
39.
SalmeronJ.L. and PapageorgiouE.I., A Fuzzy Grey Cognitive Maps-based Decision Support System for radiotherapy treatment planning, Knowledge-Based Systems30 (2012), 151–160.
40.
ShariffN.M., ShahS.A. and KamaludinF., Previous treatment, sputum-smear nonconversion, and suburban living: The risk factors of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis among Malaysians, International Journal of Mycobacteriology5 (2016), 51–58.
41.
ShinH.-J. and KwonY.-S., Treatment of drug susceptible pulmonary tuberculosis, Tuberculosis and Respiratory Diseases78 (2015), 161–167.
42.
StyliosC.D. and GeorgopoulosV.C., Fuzzy cognitive maps structure for medical decision support systems, in: Studies in Fuzziness and Soft Computing, 2008, pp. 151–174.
43.
TalayF., KumbetliS. and AltinS., Factors associated with treatment success for tuberculosis patients: A single center’s experience in Turkey, Japanese Journal of Infectious Diseases61 (2008), 25.
44.
TierneyD.B., FrankeM.F., BecerraM.C., ViruF.A.A., BonillaC.A., SánchezE., GuerraD., MuñozM., LlaroK. and PalaciosE., Time to culture conversion and regimen composition in multidrug-resistant tuberculosis treatment, PLoS One9 (2014), e108035.
45.
WHO, Use of high burden country lists for TB by WHO in the post-2015 era, Geneva: World Health Organization (2015).
46.
WHO, Global Tuberculosis Report, in,World Health Organization Press, Geneva, Switzerland, 2016.
47.
WHO, Guidelines for the treatment of drug-susceptible tuberculosis and patient care, 2017 update, in,World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 2017.
48.
WHO, Global Tuberculosis Report, in,World Health Organization Press, Geneva, Switzerland, 2018.
49.
ZhangY.J., QinJ.H., ShiP. and KangY., High-order intuitionistic fuzzy cognitive map based on evidential reasoning theory, IEEE Transactions on Fuzzy Systems27 (2019), 16–30.
