Cognitive integrity is a fundamental driver of health. The exact structure of strategies against cognitive impairment is still under debate.
Objective:
To compare the short-term effects of a multicomponent cognitive training (BrainProtect) with those of general health counseling (GHC) on cognitive abilities and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) in healthy adults in Germany.
Methods:
In this parallel randomized controlled trial (RCT), 132 eligible cognitively healthy adults (age ≥50 years, Beck Depression Inventory ≤9/63; Montreal Cognitive Assessment ≥26/30) were randomized to either GHC (N = 72) or to intervention with BrainProtect (intervention group, IG; N = 60). IG participants received 8 weekly sessions of 90 min of the group-based BrainProtect program focusing on executive functions, concentration, learning, perception, and imagination, plus nutritional and physical exercise units. Before and after intervention, all participants underwent neuropsychological testing and HRQoL evaluation, blinded for pretest.
Results:
No significant training effect was observed for the primary endpoint of global cognition as assessed by CERAD-Plus-z Total Score (p = 0.113; ηp2 = 0.023). Improvements in several cognitive subtests were shown in the IG (N = 53) compared to the GHC (N = 62) without adverse events. Differences reached significance for verbal fluency (p = 0.021), visual memory (p = 0.013), visuo-constructive functions (p = 0.034), and HRQoL (p = 0.009). Significance was lost after adjustment, though several changes were clinically relevant.
Conclusion:
BrainProtect did not significantly impact global cognition in this RCT. Nevertheless, the results of some outcomes indicate clinically meaningful changes, so that a strengthening of the cognitive performance by BrainProtect cannot be excluded. Further studies with larger sample size are needed to confirm these findings.
CanoA, DargentG, CarriazoA, López-SamaniegoL, ApostoloJ, CamposE, HollandC, Varela-NietoI, Luz Sánchez-SánchezM, IllarioM, IaccarinoG, RollerRE, GoossensE, Vollenbroek-HuttenM, PaisS, SchenaF, MusianD, AlvinoS, MaggioM, LiottaG, UssaiS, OrfilaF, O’CaoimhR, PaulC, PazziS, RomanoV, ObbiaP (2018) Tackling frailty and functional decline: Background of the action group A3 of the European innovation partnership for active and healthy ageing. Maturitas115, 69–73.
2.
RagusaFS, VeroneseN, SmithL, KoyanagiA, DominguezLJ, BarbagalloM (2022) Social frailty increases the risk of all-cause mortality: A longitudinal analysis of the English Longitudinal Study of Ageing. Exp Gerontol167, 111901.
3.
PolidoriMC (2019) Dementia. In Encyclopedia of Biomedical Gerontology, RattanS, ed. Elsevier.
4.
GottfredsonLS, DearyIJ (2004) Intelligence predicts health and longevity, but why?Curr Dir Psychol Sci13, 1–4.
5.
WhalleyLJ, DearyIJ (2001) Longitudinal cohort study of childhood IQ and survival up to age 76. BMJ322, 819.
6.
LangaKM, LevineDA (2014) The diagnosis and management of mild cognitive impairment: A clinical review. JAMA312, 2551–2561.
7.
BeardenCE, GlahnDC (2017) Cognitive genomics: Searching for the genetic roots of neuropsychological functioning. Neuropsychology31, 1003–1019.
8.
BouchardTJJr, LykkenDT, McGueM, SegalNL, TellegenA (1990) Sources of human psychological differences: The Minnesota Study of Twins Reared Apart. Science250, 223–228.
9.
ButlerM, McCreedyE, NelsonVA, DesaiP, RatnerE, FinkHA, HemmyLS, McCartenJR, BarclayTR, BrasureM, DavilaH, KaneRL (2018) Does cognitive training prevent cognitive decline? A systematic review. Ann Intern Med168, 63–68.
GavelinHM, LampitA, HallockH, SabatésJ, Bahar-FuchsA (2020) Cognition-oriented treatments for older adults: A systematic overview of systematic reviews. Neuropsychol Rev30, 167–193.
12.
(2019) Risk reduction of cognitive decline and dementia: WHO guidelines. World Health Organization, Geneva.
13.
PolidoriMC, StahlW, GriffithsHR (2021) Nutritional cognitive neuroscience of aging: Focus on carotenoids and cognitive frailty. Redox Biol44, 101996.
14.
WeigertH, StuckenschneiderT, PickertL, RossiA, MeyerAM, NellesG, SchulzRJ, StahlW, SchneiderS, PolidoriMC; NeuroExercise Study Group
(2022) Influence of a 12-month structured exercise program on the micronutrient-cognitive fitness-physical association profiles in mild cognitive impairment. J Alzheimers Dis Rep6, 711–722.
15.
MeyerAM, PodolskiN, PickertL, PolidoriMC (2020) Strategies to prevent age related cognitive decline. Dtsch Med Wochenschr145, 146–150.
16.
ÖhmanH, SavikkoN, StrandbergTE, PitkäläKH. (2014) Effect of physical exercise on cognitive performance in older adults with mild cognitive impairment or dementia: A systematic review. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord38, 347–365.
17.
StuckenschneiderT, SandersML, DevenneyKE, AaronsonJA, AbelnV, ClaassenJAHR, GuinanE, LawlorB, MeeusenR, MontagC, Olde RikkertMGM, PolidoriMC, ReuterM, SchulzRJ, VogtT, WeberB, KesselsRPC, SchneiderS (2021) NeuroExercise: The effect of a 12-month exercise intervention on cognition in mild cognitive impairment-a multicenter randomized controlled trial. Front Aging Neurosci12, 621947.
GergerP, PaiRK, StuckenschneiderT, FalkenreckJ, WeigertH, StahlW, WeberB, NellesG, SpazzafumoL, SchneiderS, PolidoriMC (2019) Associations of lipophilic micronutrients with physical and cognitive fitness in persons with mild cognitive impairment. Nutrients11, 902.
20.
Gómez-SoriaI, Marin-PuyaltoJ, Peralta-MarrupeP, LatorreE, CalatayudE (2022) Effects of multi-component non-pharmacological interventions on cognition in participants with mild cognitive impairment: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Arch Gerontol Geriatr103, 104751.
21.
BuschertVC, FrieseU, TeipelSJ, SchneiderP, MerenskyW, RujescuD, MöllerHJ, HampelH, BuergerK (2011) Effects of a newly developed cognitive intervention in amnestic mild cognitive impairment and mild Alzheimer’s disease: A pilot study. J Alzheimers Dis25, 679–694.
RosenbergA, MangialascheF, NganduT, SolomonA, KivipeltoM (2020) Multidomain interventions to prevent cognitive impairment, Alzheimer’s disease, and dementia: From FINGER to World-Wide FINGERS. J Prev Alzheimers Dis7, 29–36.
24.
PolidoriMC, SinglerK, Roller-WirnsbergerR (2018) Learning Geriatric Medicine: A Study Guide for Medical Students. SpringerBerlin.
25.
LevinsonSC (2012) The original sin of cognitive science. Top Cogn Sci4, 396–403.
26.
FalkenreckJM, RohegerM, WeigertH, FrieseA, JahrP, BeckerI, NellesG, KalbeE, PolidoriMC (2020) BrainProtect® - A cognitive training program with nutritional and physical counseling components: A retrospective analysis of its effects in healthy individuals. Geriatric Care6. 10.4081/gc.2020.9328.
27.
AebiC (2002) Validierung der neuropsychologischen Testbatterie CERAD-NP: Eine Multi-Center Studie. Doktorarbeit, Universität Basel.
28.
SchulzKF, AltmanDG, MoherD, CONSORTGroup (2010) CONSORT 2010 Statement: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. Ann Intern Med152, 726–732.
29.
MoherD, HopewellS, SchulzKF, MontoriV, GøtzschePC, DevereauxPJ, ElbourneD, EggerM, AltmanDG; Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials Group
(2010) CONSORT 2010 explanation and elaboration: Updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials. J Clin Epidemiol63, e1–e37.
BerresM, ZehnderA, BläsiS, MonschAU (2008) Evaluation of diagnostic scores with adjustment for covariates. Stat Med27, 1777–1790.
32.
LilligR, OpheyA, SchulzJB, ReetzK, WojtalaJ, StorchA, Liepelt-ScarfoneI, BeckerS, BergD, Balzer-GeldsetzerM, KassubekJ, Hilker-RoggendorfR, WittK, MollenhauerB, TrenkwalderC, RoeskeS, WittchenHU, RiedelO, DodelR, KalbeE (2021) A new CERAD total score with equally weighted z-scores and additional executive and non-amnestic “CERAD-Plus” tests enhances cognitive diagnosis in patients with Parkinson’s disease: Evidence from the LANDSCAPE study. Parkinsonism Relat Disord90, 90–97.
33.
NasreddineZS, PhillipsNA, BédirianV, CharbonneauS, WhiteheadV, CollinI, CummingsJL, ChertkowH (2005) The Montreal Cognitive Assessment, MoCA: A brief screening tool for mild cognitive impairment. J Am Geriatr Soc53, 695–699.
34.
HerdmanM, GudexC, LloydA, JanssenM, KindP, ParkinD, BonselG, BadiaX (2011) Development and preliminary testing of the new five-level version of EQ-5D (EQ-5D-5L). Qual Life Res20, 1727–1736.
35.
BeckAT, WardCH, MendelsonM, MockJ, ErbaughJ (1961) An inventory for measuring depression. Arch Gen Psychiatry4, 561–571.
36.
KatzS, FordAB, MoskowitzRW, JacksonBA, JaffeMW (1963) Studies of illness in the aged. The index of ADL: A standardized measure of biological and psychosocial function. JAMA185, 914–919.
37.
LawtonMP, BrodyEM (1969) Assessment of older people: Self-maintaining and instrumental activities of daily living. Gerontologist9, 179–186.
38.
RubensteinLZ, HarkerJO, SalvaA, GuigozY, VellasB (2001) Screening for undernutrition in geriatric practice: Developing the Short-Form Mini Nutritional Assessment (MNA-SF). J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci56, M366–M377.
39.
CohenJ (1988) Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences, 2ndedition. Larence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, NJ, USA.
40.
NganduT, LehtisaloJ, SolomonA, LevälahtiE, AhtiluotoS, AntikainenR, BäckmanL, HänninenT, JulaA, LaatikainenT, LindströmJ, MangialascheF, PaajanenT, PajalaS, PeltonenM, RauramaaR, Stigsdotter-NeelyA, StrandbergT, TuomilehtoJ, SoininenH, KivipeltoM (2015) A 2 year multidomain intervention of diet, exercise, cognitive training, and vascular risk monitoring versus control to prevent cognitive decline in at-risk elderly people (FINGER): A randomized controlled trial. Lancet385, 2255–2263.
41.
SandykR (1994) Alzheimer’s disease: Improvement of visual memory and visuoconstructive performance by treatment with picotesla range magnetic fields. Int J Neurosci76, 185–225.
Rodríguez-ArandaC, WaterlooK, JohnsenSH, EldevikP, SparrS, WikranGC, HerderM, VangbergTR (2016) Neuroanatomical correlates of verbal fluency in early Alzheimer’s disease and normal aging. Brain Lang155-156, 24–35.
44.
RebokGW, BallK, GueyLT, JonesRN, KimHY, KingJW, MarsiskeM, MorrisJN, TennstedtSL, UnverzagtFW, WillisSL; ACTIVE Study Group
(2014) Ten-year effects of the advanced cognitive training for independent and vital elderly cognitive training trial on cognition and everyday functioning in older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc62, 16–24.
45.
MewbornCM, LindberghCA, StephenMiller L (2017) Cognitive interventions for cognitively healthy, mildly impaired, and mixed samples of older adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized-controlled trials. Neuropsychol Rev27, 403–439.
46.
ChiuHL, ChuH, TsaiJC, LiuD, ChenYR, YangHL, ChouKR (2017) The effect of cognitive-based training for the healthy older people: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. PLoS One12, e0176742.
47.
BajpaiS, UpadhayayAD, BanerjeeJ, ChakrawarthyA, ChatterjeeP, LeeJ, DeyAB (2022) Discrepancy in fluid and crystallized intelligence: An early cognitive marker of dementia from the LASI-DAD Cohort. Dement Geriatr Cogn Dis Extra12, 51–59.
48.
StrenziokM, ParasuramanR, ClarkeE, CislerDS, ThompsonJC, GreenwoodPM (2014) Neurocognitive enhancement in older adults: Comparison of three cognitive training tasks to test a hypothesis of training transfer in brain connectivity. Neuroimage85(Pt 3), 1027–1039.
49.
BambergerD, FuhrP, GschwandtnerU, MeyerA (2017) Gedächtnistraining – Nutzen und Limitationen. Parkinson: Das Magazin von Parkinson Schweiz128, 8–9.
50.
Melby-LervågM, HulmeC (2013) Is working memory training effective? A meta-analytic review. Dev Psychol49, 270–291.
51.
Melby-LervågM, HulmeC (2016) There is no convincing evidence that working memory training is effective: A reply to Au et al. (2014) and Karbach and Verhaeghen (2014). Psychon Bull Rev23, 324–330.
52.
KalbeE, RohegerM, PaluszakK, MeyerJ, BeckerJ, FinkGR, KukoljaJ, RahnA, SzabadosF, WirthB, KesslerJ (2018) Effects of a cognitive training with and without additional physical activity in healthy older adults: A follow-up 1 year after a randomized controlled trial. Front Aging Neurosci10, 407.
53.
LövdénM, BrehmerY, Shu-ChenL, LindenbergerU (2012) Training-induced compensation of individual differences in memory performances. Front Hum Neurosci6, 141.
54.
SmoleńT, JastrzebskiJ, EstradaE, ChuderskiA (2018) Most evidence for the compensation account of cognitive training is unreliable. Mem Cognit46, 1315–1330.
55.
CloustonSAP, SmithDM, MukherjeeS, ZhangY, HouW, LinkBG, RichardsM (2020) Education and cognitive decline: An integrative analysis of global longitudinal studies of cognitive aging. J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci75, e151–e160.
56.
PitkalaKH, RoutasaloP, KautiainenH, SintonenH, TilvisRS (2011) Effects of socially stimulating group intervention on lonely, older people’s cognition: A randomized, controlled trial. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry19, 654–663.
57.
WongPCM, VuongLC, LiuK (2017) Personalized learning: From neurogenetics of behaviors to designing optimal language training. Neuropsychologia98, 192–200.
GoveD, NielsenTR, SmitsC, PlejertC, RaufMA, ParveenS, JaaksonS, Golan-ShemeshD, LahavD, KaurR, HerzMK, MonseesJ, ThyrianJR, GeorgesJ (2021) The challenges of achieving timely diagnosis and culturally appropriate care of people with dementia from minority ethnic groups in Europe. Int J Geriatr Psychiatr36, 1823–1828.
60.
MonseesJ, SchmachtenbergT, ThyrianJR (2021) EU-atlas dementia and migration. Deutsches Zentrum für Neurodegenerative Erkrankungen, Rostock Greifswald.
61.
CookDA, ArtinoARJr (2016) Motivation to learn: An overview of contemporary theories. Med Educ50, 997–1014.
62.
RyanRM, LynchMF, VansteenkisteM, DeciEL (2010) Motivation and autonomy in counseling, psychotherapy, and behavior change: A look at theory and practice. Couns Psychol39, 193–260.
63.
MeyerAM, BartramMP, AntczakP, BeckerI, BenzingT, PolidoriMC (2022) A tailored discharge program improves frailty and mood in patients undergoing usual rehabilitative care: A randomized controlled trial. J Am Med Dir Assoc23, 1962.e1–1962.e13.
64.
SternY (2021) Cognitive reserve in ageing and Alzheimer’s disease. Lancet Neurol11, 1006–1012.
65.
ChengST (2016) Cognitive reserve and the prevention of dementia: The role of physical and cognitive activities. Curr Psychiatry Rep18, 85.
66.
Gómez-PinillaF (2008) Brain foods: The effects of nutrients on brain function. Nat Rev Neurosci9, 568–578.
67.
Bahar-FuchsA, MartyrA, GohAM, SabatesJ, ClareL (2019) Cognitive training for people with mild to moderate dementia. Cochrane Database Syst Rev3, CD013069.
68.
GatesNJ, RutjesAW, Di NisioM, KarimS, ChongLY, MarchE, MartínezG, VernooijRW (2020) Computerised cognitive training for 12 or more weeks for maintaining cognitive function in cognitively healthy people in late life. Cochrane Database Syst Rev2, CD012277.
69.
DvirZ (2015) Difference, significant difference and clinically meaningful difference: The meaning of change in rehabilitation. J Exerc Rehabil11, 67–73.
70.
BorlandE, EdgarC, StomrudE, CullenN, HanssonO, PalmqvistS (2022) Clinically relevant changes for cognitive outcomes in preclinical and prodromal cognitive stages: Implications for clinical Alzheimer trials. Neurology99, e1142–e1153.
71.
LeeKS, LeeY, BackJH, SonSJ, ChoiSH, ChungYK, LimKY, NohJS, KohSH, OhBH, HongCH (2014) Effects of a multidomain lifestyle modification on cognitive function in older adults: An eighteen-month community-based cluster randomized controlled trial. Psychother Psychosom83, 270–278.
72.
ForoughiCK, MonfortSS, PaczynskiM, McKnightPE, GreenwoodPM (2016) Placebo effects in cognitive training. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A113, 7470–7474.
73.
BootWR, SimonsDJ, StothartC, StuttsC (2013) The pervasive problem with placebos in psychology: Why active control groups are not sufficient to rule out placebo effects. Perspect Psychol Sci8, 445–454.
74.
RedickTS, ShipsteadZ, HarrisonTL, HicksKL, FriedDE, HambrickDZ, KaneMJ, EngleRW (2013) No evidence of intelligence improvement after working memory training: A randomized, placebo-controlled study. J Exp Psychol Gen14, 359–379.
75.
ShipsteadZ, RedickTS, EngleRW (2012) Is working memory training effective?Psychol Bull138, 628–654.
76.
KallioEL, ÖhmanH, KautiainenH, HietanenM, PitkäläK (2017) Cognitive training interventions for patients with Alzheimer’s disease: A systematic review. J Alzheimers Dis56, 1349–1372.
77.
FernandezA, GoldbergE, MichelonP (2013) The SharpBrains Guide to Brain Fitness: How to Optimize Brain Health and Performance at Any Age. SharpBrains.
