Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2019-01-08
The Frontotemporal Dementia versus Primary Psychiatric Disorder (FTD versus PPD) Checklist: A Bedside Clinical Tool to Identify Behavioral Variant FTD in Patients with Late-Onset Behavioral Changes
Differentiating early behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD) and primary psychiatric disorders (PPD) is complex and biomarkers have limited accuracy, leading to inaccurate diagnoses.
Objectives:
Develop a simple bedside clinical tool to differentiate bvFTD from PPD.
Methods:
A checklist of clinical features differentiating bvFTD from PPD was developed based on literature and clinical experience. The checklist was filled prospectively for 29 consecutive patients (Montreal Neurological Hospital) with late-onset (≥ age 40) behavioral changes suggestive of bvFTD. The checklist was subsequently retrospectively completed on the baseline visit (N = 137) of the Late-Onset Frontal Lobe study (Amsterdam). In both cohorts, patients were followed 2 years to establish a final best clinical diagnosis, categorizing patients into Probable FTD (N = 46), Possible FTD (N = 8), Other Cognitive Disorder (N = 36), Other Neurological Disorder (N = 10), or PPD (N = 66).
Results:
All items distinguished the two groups except “duration more than 5 years”, which was removed to create a final 17-item version. Mean checklist scores were significantly different across all groups (Oneway ANOVA F(4,161) = 27.462, p < 0.001). The PPD group had lower scores than all other dementia categories, with the largest difference between Probable FTD (= 12.04) and PPD (= 7.48). A score ≥11 was found to be strongly indicative of bvFTD (specificity 93.9%, sensitivity 71.1%, PPV 89.2%). Scores ≤8 were strongly indicative of a PPD (specificity 91.3%, sensitivity 77.3%, PPV 92.7%). Patient with scores of 9–10 are considered indeterminate.
Conclusions:
Although further prospective validation is required, the “FTD vs PPD Checklist” could provide a simple tool to improve diagnostic accuracy, particularly in non-specialized settings.
OnyikeCU, Diehl-SchmidJ (2013) The epidemiology of frontotemporal dementia. Int Rev Psychiatry25, 130–137.
2.
BlockNR, ShaSJ, KarydasAM, FongJC, De MayMG, MillerBL, RosenHJ (2016) Frontotemporal dementia and psychiatric illness: Emerging clinical and biological links in gene carriers. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry24, 107–116.
3.
DucharmeS, PriceBH, LarvieM, DoughertyDD, DickersonBC (2015) Clinical approach to the differential diagnosis between behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia and primary psychiatric disorders. Am J Psychiatry172, 827–837.
4.
PoseM, CetkovichM, GleichgerrchtE, IbànezA, TorralvaT, ManesF (2013) The overlap of symptomatic dimensions between frontotemporal dementia and several psychiatric disorders that appear in late adulthood. Int Rev Psychiatry25, 159–167.
5.
VijverbergEG, WattjesMP, DolsA, KrudopWA, MollerC, PetersA, KerssensCJ, GossinkF, PrinsND, StekML, ScheltensP, van Berckel BN, BarkhofF, PijnenburgYA (2016) Diagnostic accuracy of MRI and additional [18F]FDG-PET for behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia in patients with late onset behavioral changes. J Alzheimers Dis53, 1287–1297.
6.
WoolleyJD, KhanBK, MurthyNK, MillerBL, RankinKP (2011) The diagnostic challenge of psychiatric symptoms in neurodegenerative disease; rates of and risk factors for prior psychiatric diagnosis in patients with early neurodegenerative disease. J Clin Psychiatry72, 126.
7.
ShinagawaS, CatindigJA, BlockNR, MillerBL, RankinKP (2016) When a little knowledge can be dangerous: False-positive diagnosis of behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia among community clinicians. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord41, 99–108.
8.
KrudopWA, KerssensCJ, DolsA, PrinsND, MollerC, SchouwsS, BarkhofF, van Berckel BN, TeunissenCE, van der Flier WM, ScheltensP, StekML, PijnenburgYA (2014) Building a new paradigm for the early recognition of behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia: Late Onset Frontal Lobe Syndrome study. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry22, 735–740.
9.
VijverbergEG, DolsA, KrudopWA, PetersA, KerssensCJ, van Berckel BN, WattjesMP, BarkhofF, GossinkF, PrinsND, StekML, ScheltensP, PijnenburgYA (2016) Diagnostic accuracy of the frontotemporal dementia consensus criteria in the late-onset frontal lobe syndrome. Dement Geriatr Cogn Disord41, 210–219.
10.
KrudopWA, DolsA, KerssensCJ, EikelenboomP, PrinsND, MöllerC, SchouwsS, RhebergenD, Van Exel E, Van Der Flier WM, SikkesS, ScheltensP, StekML, PijnenburgYAL (2017) The pitfall of behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia mimics despite multidisciplinary application of the FTDC criteria. J Alzheimers Dis60, 959–975.
11.
VijverbergEGB, SchouwsS, MeestersPD, VerwijkE, ComijsH, KoeneT, SchreuderC, BeekmanA, ScheltensP, StekM, PijnenburgY, DolsA (2017) Cognitive deficits in patients with neuropsychiatric symptoms: A comparative study between behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia and primary psychiatric disorders. J Clin Psychiatry78, e940–e946.
12.
VijverbergEGB, GossinkF, KrudopW, SikkesS, KerssensC, PrinsN, StekM, ScheltensP, PijnenburgY, DolsA (2017) The diagnostic challenge of the late-onset frontal lobe syndrome: Clinical predictors for primary psychiatric disorders versus behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia. J Clin Psychiatry78, e1197–e1203.
13.
KrudopWA, KerssensCJ, DolsA, PrinsND, MöllerC, SchouwsS, van der FlierWM, ScheltensP, SikkesS, StekML, PijnenburgYAL (2015) Identifying bvFTD within the wide spectrum of late onset frontal lobe syndrome: A clinical approach. Am J Geriat Psychiatry23, 1056–1066.
14.
BertouxM, DelavestM, de Souza LC, FunkiewiezA, LépineJP, FossatiP, DuboisB, SarazinM (2012) Social cognition and emotional assessment differentiates frontotemporal dementia from depression. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry83, 411–416.
15.
VijverbergEG, DolsA, KrudopWA, Del Campo MilanM, KerssensCJ, GossinkF, PrinsND, StekML, ScheltensP, TeunissenCE, PijnenburgYA (2017) Cerebrospinal fluid biomarker examination as a tool to discriminate behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia from primary psychiatric disorders. Alzheimers Dement (Amst)7, 99–106.
16.
MollerC, PijnenburgYA, van der Flier WM, VersteegA, TijmsB, de Munck JC, HafkemeijerA, RomboutsSA, van der Grond J, van Swieten J, DopperE, ScheltensP, BarkhofF, VrenkenH, WinkAM (2016) Alzheimer disease and behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia: Automatic classification based on cortical atrophy for single-subject diagnosis. Radiology279, 838–848.
Saint-AubertL, LemoineL, ChiotisK, LeuzyA, Rodriguez-VieitezE, NordbergA (2017) Tau PET imaging: Present and future directions. Mol Neurodegener12, 19.
19.
DolsA, van LiemptS, GossinkF, KrudopWA, SikkesS, PijnenburgYA, StekML (2016) Identifying specific clinical symptoms of behavioral variant frontotemporal dementia versus differential psychiatric disorders in patients presenting with a late-onset frontal lobe syndrome. J Clin Psychiatry77, 1391–1395.
