Older people with cognitive impairment, including dementia and delirium, are high users of acute care services internationally. Potentially inappropriate medication (PIM) use may be associated with adverse outcomes, including hospital re-admission, functional disability, and mortality.
Objective:
This systematic review aimed to quantify and compare the prevalence of PIMs in older inpatients with and without cognitive impairment.
Methods:
A systematic search of observational studies was performed independently assessed by two reviewers in Embase, Medline, PsycINFO, International Pharmaceutical Abstracts, Scopus, and Informit. Articles published in English during the period January 2007–June 2017 that reported PIM prevalence in hospital inpatients ≥ 65 years were included. PIMs were defined as the presence of polypharmacy (multiple medication use) and using implicit or explicit tools, such as the Beers criteria, and ‘Screening Tool of Older Person’s Prescriptions’ (STOPP).
Results:
47 articles were included. In studies measuring polypharmacy (n = 15), the prevalence of PIMs ranged from 53.2% to 89.8% and 30.4% to 97.1% for inpatients with and without cognitive impairment, respectively, and 24.0% to 80.0% when cognitive status was unreported. In studies employing explicit and implicit tools (n = 35), the prevalence of PIMs when cognitive impairment was reported ranged from 20.6% to 80.5% using the Beers criteria, and 39.3% to 88.5% using STOPP. When cognitive status was unreported, the prevalence of PIMs ranged from 7.0% to 79.2% using the Beers criteria, and 20.0% to 63.4% using STOPP.
Conclusion:
Our findings suggest a high prevalence of PIMs in older inpatients with and without cognitive impairment. Future studies should investigate the impact of PIM use on patient-centered outcomes, such as functional status and quality of life, to inform enhanced acute care services.
DalleurO, SpinewineA, HenrardS, LosseauC, SpeybroeckN, BolandB (2012) Inappropriate prescribing and related hospital admissions in frail older persons according to the STOPP and START criteria. Drugs Aging29, 829–837.
2.
HamiltonH, GallagherP, RyanC, ByrneS, O’MahonyD (2011) Potentially inappropriate medications defined by STOPP criteria and the risk of adverse drug events in older hospitalized patients. Arch Intern Med171, 1013–1019.
3.
PrudentM, DrameM, JollyD, TrenqueT, ParjoieR, MahmoudiR, LangPO, SommeD, BoyerF, LanieceI, GauvainJB, BlanchardF, NovellaJL (2008) Potentially inappropriate use of psychotropic medications in hospitalized elderly patients in France: Cross-sectional analysis of the prospective, multicentre SAFEs cohort. Drugs Aging25, 933–946.
4.
BestO, GnjidicD, HilmerSN, NaganathanV, McLachlanAJ (2013) Investigating polypharmacy and drug burden index in hospitalised older people. Intern Med43, 912–918.
5.
CadoganCA, RyanC, FrancisJJ, GormleyGJ, PassmoreP, KerseN, HughesCM (2016) Development of an intervention to improve appropriate polypharmacy in older people in primary care using a theory-based method. BMC Health Serv Res16, 661.
6.
JorgensenT, JohanssonS, KennerfalkA, WallanderMA, SvardsuddK (2001) Prescription drug use, diagnoses, and healthcare utilization among the elderly. Ann Pharmacother35, 1013–1019.
7.
MasnoonN, ShakibS, Kalisch-EllettL, CaugheyGE (2017) What is polypharmacy? A systematic review of definitions. BMC Geriatr17, 230.
8.
FriedTR, O’LearyJ, TowleV, GoldsteinMK, TrentalangeM, MartinDK (2014) Health outcomes associated with polypharmacy in community-dwelling older adults: A systematic review. J Am Geriatr Soc62, 2261–2272.
9.
Di GiorgioC, ProvenzaniA, PolidoriP (2016) Potentially inappropriate drug prescribing in elderly hospitalized patients: An analysis and comon of explicit criteria. Int J Clin Pharm38, 462–468paris.
10.
The American Geriatrics Society Expert Panel (2015) American Geriatrics Society 2015 updated Beers criteria for potentially inappropriate medication use in older adults. J Am Geriatr Soc63, 2227–2246.
11.
GallagherP, O’MahonyD (2008) STOPP (Screening Tool of Older Persons’ potentially inappropriate Prescriptions): Application to acutely ill elderly patients and comparison with Beers criteria. Age Ageing37, 673–679.
12.
StormsH, MarquetK, AertgeertsB, ClaesN (2017) Prevalence of inappropriate medication use in residential long-term care facilities for the elderly: A systematic review. Eur J Gen Pract23, 69–77.
13.
ParsonsC (2017) Polypharmacy and inappropriate medication use in patients with dementia: An underresearched problem. Ther Adv Drug Saf8, 31–46.
14.
GnjidicD, HilmerSN, HartikainenS, TolppanenAM, TaipaleH, KoponenM, BellJS (2014) Impact of high risk drug use on hospitalization and mortality in older people with and without Alzheimer’s disease: A national population cohort study. PLoS Onee83224.
15.
NaplesJG, MarcumZA, PereraS, GraySL, NewmanAB, SimonsickEM, YaffeK, ShorrRI, HanlonJT (2015) Concordance among anticholinergic burden scales. J Am Geriatr Soc63, 2120–2124.
16.
TjiaJ, BriesacherBA, PetersonD, LiuQ, AndradeSE, MitchellSL (2014) Use of medications of questionable benefit in advanced dementia. JAMA Intern Med174, 1763–1771.
17.
PatelT, SlonimK, LeeL (2017) Use of potentially inappropriate medications among ambulatory home-dwelling elderly patients with dementia: A review of the literature. Can Pharm J150, 169–183.
18.
TimmonsS, ManningE, BarrettA, BradyNM, BrowneV, O’SheaE, MolloyDW, O’ReganNA, TrawleyS, CahillS, O’SullivanK, WoodsN, MeagherD, Ni ChorcorainAM, LinehanJG (2015) Dementia in older people admitted to hospital: A regional multi-hospital observational study of prevalence, associations and case recognition. Age Ageing44, 993–999.
19.
NobiliA, LicataG, SalernoF, PasinaL, TettamantiM, FranchiC, De VittorioL, MarengoniA, CorraoS, IorioA, MarcucciM, MannucciPM (2011) Polypharmacy, length of hospital stay, and in-hospital mortality among elderly patients in internal medicine wards: The REPOSI study. Eur J Clin Pharmacol67, 507–519.
ZekryD, HerrmannFR, GrandjeanR, VitaleAM, De PinhoMF, MichelJP, GoldG, KrauseKH (2009) Does dementia predict adverse hospitalization outcomes? A prospective study in aged inpatients. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry24, 283–291.
22.
Epstein-LubowG, GaudianoB, DarlingE, HinckleyM, TremontG, KohnR, MarinoLJ, SallowayS, GrinnellR, MillerIW (2012) Differences in depression severity in family caregivers of hospitalized individuals with dementia and family caregivers of outpatients with dementia. Am J Geriatr Psychiatry20, 815–819.
23.
Gutierrez-ValenciaM, IzquierdoM, MalafarinaV, Alonso-RenedoJ, Gonzalez-GlariaB, Larrayoz-SolaB, Monforte-GasqueMP, Latasa-ZamalloaP, Martinez-VelillaN (2017) Impact of hospitalization in an acute geriatric unit on polypharmacy and potentially inappropriate prescriptions: A retrospective study. Geriatr Gerontol Int, doi: 10.1111/ggi.13073
24.
HanlonJT, SchmaderKE, SamsaGP, WeinbergerM, UttechKM, LewisIK, CohenHJ, FeussnerJR (1992) A method for assessing drug therapy appropriateness. J Clin Epidemiol45, 1045–1051.
25.
WengerNS, ShekellePG (2001) Assessing care of vulnerable elders: ACOVE project overview. Ann Intern Med135, 642–646.
26.
MoherD, LiberatiA, TetzlaffJ, AltmanDG (2010) Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. Int J Surg8, 336–341.
Sevilla-SanchezD, Molist-BrunetN, Amblás-NovellasJ, Roura-PochP, Espaulella-PanicotJ, Codina-JanéC (2017) Adverse drug events in patients with advanced chronic conditionswho have a prognosis of limited life expectancy at hospitaladmission. Eur J Clin Pharmacol73, 79–89.
29.
HubbardRE, PeelNM, ScottIA, MartinJH, SmithA, PillansPI, PoudelA, GrayLC (2015) Polypharmacy among inpatients aged 70 years or older in Australia. Med J Aust202, 373–378.
30.
JensenLD, AndersenO, HallinM, PetersenJ (2014) Potentially inappropriate medication related to weakness in older acute medical patients. Int J Clin Pharm36, 570–580.
31.
HeinC, ForguesA, PiauA, SommetA, NourhashemiF, VellasB (2014) Impact of polypharmacy on occurrence of delirium in elderly emergency patients. J Am Med Dir Assoc15, 850.
RostedE, SchultzM, SandersS (2016) Frailty and polypharmacy in elderly patients are associated with a high readmission risk. Dan Med J63, A5274.
34.
WalshKA, O’ReganNA, ByrneS, BrowneJ, MeagherDJ, TimmonsS (2016) Patterns of psychotropic prescribing and polypharmacy in older hospitalized patients in Ireland: The influence of dementia on prescribing. Int Psychogeriatr28, 1807–1820.
35.
WawruchM, ZikavskaM, WsolovaL, KuzelovaM, TisonovaJ, GajdosikJ, UrbanekK, KristovaV (2008) Polypharmacy in elderly hospitalised patients in Slovakia. Pharm World Sci30, 235–242.
36.
SalweKJ, KalyansundaramD, BahurupiY (2016) A study on polypharmacy and potential drug-drug interactions among elderly patients admitted in department of medicine of a tertiary care hospital in puducherry. J Clin Diagn Res10, FC06–FC10.
37.
ZyoudSH, Abd-AlhafezAB, HusseinAO, Abu-ShehabIS, Al-JabiSW, SweilehWM (2014) Patterns of use of medications, herbal products and nutritional supplements and polypharmacy associating factors in Palestinian geriatric patients. Eur Geriatr Med5, 188–194.
38.
ManiasE, KusljicS, BerryC, BrownE, BryceE, CliffeJ, SmykowskyA (2015) Use of the Screening Tool of Older Person’s Prescriptions (STOPP) in older people admitted to an Australian hospital. Australas J Ageing34, 15–20.
39.
RahmawatiF, PramantaraIDP, RohmahW, SulaimanSAS (2009) Polypharmacy and unnecessary drug therapy on geriatric hospitalized patients in Yogyakarta Hospitals, Indonesia. Int J Pharm Pharm Sci1, 6–11.
40.
ChanVT, WooBK, SewellDD, AllenEC, GolshanS, RiceV, MinassianA, DalyJW (2009) Reduction of suboptimal prescribing and clinical outcome for dementia patients in a senior behavioral health inpatient unit. Int Psychogeriatr21, 195–199.
41.
LangPO, HassoY, DrameM, Vogt-FerrierN, PrudentM, GoldG, MichelJP (2010) Potentially inappropriate prescribing includingunder-use amongst older patients with cognitive or psychiatricco-morbidities. Age Ageing39, 373–381.
42.
CorsonelloA, PedoneC, LattanzioF, LucchettiM, GarastoS, DiMuzioM, GiuntaS, OnderG, Di IorioA, VolpatoS, CoricaF, MussiC, Antonelli IncalziR (2009) Potentially inappropriatemedications and functional decline in elderly hospitalizedpatients. J Am Geriatr Soc57, 1007–1014.
43.
FrankenthalD, LermanY (2015) The impact of hospitalization on potentially inappropriate prescribing in an acute medical geriatric division. Int J Clin Pharm37, 60–67.
44.
RongenS, KramersC, O’MahonyD, FeuthTB, Olde RikkertMG, AhmedAI (2016) Potentially inappropriate prescribing in older patients admitted to psychiatric hospital. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry31, 137–145.
45.
FormigaF, VidalX, AgustiA, ChiviteD, RosonB, BarbeJ, Lopez-SotoA, TorresOH, Fernandez-MoyanoA, GarciaJ, Ramirez-DuqueN, San JoseA (2016) Inappropriate prescribing in elderly people with diabetes admitted to hospital. Diabet Med33, 655–662.
46.
MoL, DingD, PuSY, LiuQH, LiH, DongBR, YangXY, HeJH (2016) Patients aged 80 years or older are encountered more potentially inappropriate medication use. Chin Med J129, 22–27.
47.
ArellanoC, SaldiviaG, CordovaP, FernandezP, MoralesF, LopezM, VillaL (2016) Using two tools to identify potentially inappropriate medications (PIM) in elderly patients in Southern Chile. Arch Gerontol Geriatr67, 139–144.
48.
San-JoseA, AgustiA, VidalX, FormigaF, Gomez-HernandezM, GarciaJ, Lopez-SotoA, Ramirez-DuqueN, TorresOH, BarbeJ (2015) Inappropriate prescribing to the oldest old patients admitted to hospital: Prevalence, most frequently used medicines, and associated factors. BMC Geriatr15, 42.
49.
WahabMS, Nyfort-HansenK, KowalskiSR (2012) Inappropriate prescribing in hospitalised Australian elderly as determined by the STOPP criteria. Int J Clin Pharm34, 855–62.
50.
TosatoM, LandiF, MartoneAM, CherubiniA, CorsonelloA, VolpatoS, BernabeiR, OnderG (2014) Potentially inappropriate drug use among hospitalised older adults: Results from the CRIME study. Age Ageing43, 767–773.
51.
SakumaM, MorimotoT, MatsuiK, SekiS, KuramotoN, ToshiroJ, MurakamiJ, FukuiT, SaitoM, HiraideA, BatesDW (2011) Epidemiology of potentially inappropriate medication use in elderly patients in Japanese acute care hospitals. Pharmacoepidemiol Drug Saf20, 386–392.
52.
SubeeshKV, ShivashakarV, CgouriN, SriramS (2015) A study on prevalence and impact of potentially inappropriate medication use in geriatrics at a private corporate hospital. Pharmanest6, 2845–2848.
53.
KimuraT, OguraF, YamamotoK, UdaA, NishiokaT, KumeM, MakimotoH, YanoI, HiraiM (2017) Potentially inappropriate medications in elderly Japanese patients: Effects of pharmacists’ assessment and intervention based on Screening Tool of Older Persons’ potentially inappropriate Prescriptions criteria ver.2. J Clin Pharm Ther42, 209–214.
54.
WidagdoIS, Nyfort-HansenK, KowalskiSR (2011) Prevalence of potentially inappropriate medication use in elderly hospitalised patients. J Pharm Pract Res41, 122–125.
55.
NixdorffN, HusteyFM, BradyAK, VajiK, LeonardM, Messinger-RapportBJ (2008) Potentially inappropriate medications and adverse drug effects in elders in the ED. Am J Emerg Med26, 697–700.
56.
NapolitanoF, IzzoMT, Di GiuseppeG, AngelilloIF (2013) Frequency of inappropriate medication prescription in hospitalized elderly patients in Italy. PLoS One8, e82359.
57.
BorahL, DeviD, DebnathPK, DekaD (2017) A study of drug utilization pattern of the geriatric patients in the department of geriatric medicine in a tertiary care hospital in Assam, India. Asian J Clin Pharm Res10, 122–126.
58.
BattulaP, ShekarKC, Chandra MohanK, Durga PrasadTS, RanganayakuluD (2015) A pilot study on inappropriate drug utilization in geriatric patients at a tertiary care teaching hospital. J Global Trends Pharm Sci6, 2840–2847.
59.
ManiasE, KusljicS, LamDL (2015) Use of the Screening Tool of Older Persons’ Prescriptions (STOPP) and the Screening Tool to Alert doctors to the Right Treatment (START) in hospitalised older people. Australas J Ageing34, 252–258.
60.
LiH, PuS, LiuQ, HuangX, KuangJ, ChenL, ShenJ, ChengS, WuT, LiR, LiY, MoL, JiangW, SongY, HeJ (2017) Potentially inappropriate medications in Chinese older adults: The beers criteria compared with the screening tool of older persons’ prescriptions criteria. Geriatr Gerontol Int17, 1951–1958.
61.
KondoN, NakamuraF, YamazakiS, YamamotoY, AkizawaT, AkibaT, SaitoA, KurokawaK, FukuharaS (2015) Prescription of potentially inappropriate medications to elderly hemodialysis patients: Prevalence and predictors. Nephrol Dial Transplant30, 498–505.
62.
FinlaysonE, MaselliJ, SteinmanMA, RothbergMB, LindenauerPK, AuerbachAD (2011) Inappropriate medication use in older adultsundergoing surgery: A national study. J Am Geriatr Soc59, 2139–2144.
63.
MazharF, AkramS, MalhiSM, HaiderN (2017) A prevalence study of potentially inappropriate medications use in hospitalized Pakistani elderly. Aging Clin Exp Res, doi: 10.1007/s40520-017-0742-7
64.
RothbergMB, PekowPS, LiuF, Korc-GrodzickiB, BrennanMJ, BellantonioS, HeelonM, LindenauerPK (2008) Potentiallyinappropriate medication use in hospitalized elders. J HospMed3, 91–102.
65.
HudhraK, Garcia-CaballosM, JucjaB, Casado-FernandezE, Espigares-RodriguezE, Bueno-CavanillasA (2014) Frequency of potentially inappropriate prescriptions in older people at discharge according to Beers and STOPP criteria. Int J Clin Pharm36, 596–603.
66.
LuoR, ScullinC, MullanAMP, ScottMG, McElnayJC (2012) Comparison of tools for the assessment of inappropriate prescribing in hospitalized older people. J Eval Clin Pract18, 1196–1202.
67.
MekonnenAB, BhagavathulaAS (2014) Inappropriate medication use in the elderly population attending gondar university hospital: A preliminary assessment. Int J Pharm Pharm Sci6, 540–543.
68.
KarandikarYS, ChaudhariSR, DalalNP, SharmaM, PanditVA (2013) Inappropriate prescribing in the elderly: A comparison of two validated screening tools. J Clin Gerontol Geriatr4, 109–114.
69.
RecocheI, LebaudyC, CoolC, SourdetS, PiauA, Lapeyre-MestreM, VellasB, CestacP (2017) Potentially inappropriate prescribing in a population of frail elderly people. Int J Clin Pharm39, 113–119.
70.
SkoldungerA, FastbomJ, WimoA, FratiglioniL, JohnellK (2015) Impact of inappropriate drug use on hospitalizations, mortality, and costs in older persons and persons with dementia: Findings from the SNAC study. Drugs Aging32, 671–678.
71.
ClagueF, MercerSW, McLeanG, ReynishE, GuthrieB (2017) Comorbidity and polypharmacy in people with dementia: Insights from a large, population-based cross-sectional analysis of primary care data. Age Ageing46, 33–39.
72.
TimmonsS, O’SheaE, O’NeillD, GallagherP, de SiunA, McArdleD, GibbonsP, KennellyS (2016) Acute hospital dementia care: Results from a national audit. BMC Geriatr16, 113.
73.
BradfordA, KunikME, SchulzP, WilliamsSP, SinghH (2009) Missed and delayed diagnosis of dementia in primary care: Prevalence and contributing factors. Alzheimer Dis Assoc Disord23, 306–314.
74.
KrysinskaK, SachdevPS, BreitnerJ, KivipeltoM, KukullW, BrodatyH (2017) Dementia registries around the globe and their applications: A systematic review. Alzheimers Dement13, 1031–1047.
75.
KouladjianL, GnjidicD, ChenTF, MangoniAA, HilmerSN (2014) Drug Burden Index in older adults: Theoretical and practical issues. Clin Interv Aging9, 1503–1515.
