The main stakeholders in oral risk management are ``Ordinary people living their daily lives'', (``seikatsusya'' in Japanese), and dentists. The mutual awareness and understanding of oral risk management are supposed to be the indispensable bases to improve dental and oral health treatment quality. This study aims to examine their views of oral health and oral risk management to generate their mutual awareness and understanding.
The authors conducted interviews with seikatsusya and dentists. We analyzed all their narratives with KeyGraph (which is a text mining tool), extracted the keywords, and enumerated the key concepts. Then, we arranged these key concepts by KJ method or affinity diagram, which is a brainstorming tool for organizing a large number of ideas into their natural relationships.
Through this analysis, the authors obtained the similarities and differences between the views of oral health and oral risk management of Japanese seikatsusyas and those of dentists. It is probable that taking notice of these similarities and differences contributes to better oral risk communication and management. In addition, this study revealed that it is feasible to apply a combination of KeyGraph and the KJ method.
AbeA., OzakuH., KuwaharaN. and KogureK., Scenario violation in nursing activities - nursing risk management from the viewpoint of chance discovery, Soft Computing Journal11(8) (2007), 799-809.
2.
ChaSen, http://chasen.naist.jp/hiki/ChaSen/?%C3%E3%E4% A5%A4%CE%C7%DB%C9%DB, accessed on 24.
3.
Codern-BovéN., Pujol-RiberaE., PlaM., González-BonillaJ., GranollersS., BallvéJ.L., FanloG. and CabezasC., ISTAPS study group, motivational interviewing interactions and the primary health care challenges presented by smokers with low motivation to stop smoking: A conversation analysis, BMC Public Health (2014), 1225.
4.
FukaiK., Assessing the dental care needs of the dependent elderly and a short-term plan of the provision of home dental care in Japan, Health Science and Health Care7(2) (2007), 88-107.
5.
FunasimaN. and SugimoriM., The construction of theoretical framework for qualitative and inductive research methodology in nursing education, Chiba Academy of Nursing Science3(1) (1997), 8-14.
6.
GlaserB., StraussA. and StrutzelE., The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research, Nursing Research17(4) (1968), 364.
7.
GoffmanE., Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience, Northeastern University Press, Boston, 1986.
8.
HanadaN., A conceptual framework for measuring oral health: A preventive strategy and risk factors, Health Science and Health Care9(2) (2009), 50-53.
9.
Japan dental association, The current evidence of dental care and oral health for achieving healthy longevity in an aging society 2015, http://www.jda.or.jp/dentist/program/pdf/world_ concgress_2015_evidence_en.pdf, accessed on 2015.
10.
RichJ.A. and GreyC.M., Qualitative research on trauma surgery: Getting beyond the numbers, World Journal of Surgery27(8) (2003), 957-961.
11.
ParkJ. and RyuY.U., Online discourse on fibromyalgia: Text-mining to identify clinical distinction and patient concerns, Medical Science Monitor: International Medical Journal of Experimental And Clinical Research20 (2014), 1858-1864.
12.
KawakitaJ., K.J. Method: It let speak chaos, Chuokoronsya, Tokyo, 1986.
13.
KäkilehtoT., SaloS. and LarmasM., Data mining of clinical oral health documents for analysis of the longevity of different restorative materials in finland, International Journal of Medical Informatics78(12) 68-74.
14.
KeyGraph, http://www.panda.sys.t.u-tokyo.ac.jp/ohsawa/vis-ual.html, accessed on 2013.
15.
KobayashiF. and NaraY., A narrative analysis by text mining technique using key graph: Similarity and difference of a view of oral health and oral risk cognition between japanese living people and dentists, 2014 IEEE International Conference on Data Mining Workshop, ICDMW 2014 Proceedings, (2014), 455-461.
16.
KreftingL., Rigor in qualitative research: The assessment of trustworthiness, American Journal of Occupational Therapy45 (1991), 214-222.
17.
KushimaM., ArakiK., SuzukiM., ArakiS. and NikamaT., Text data mining of in-patient nursing records within electronic medical records using KeyGraph, IAENG International Journal of Computer Science38(3) (2011), 383-388.
18.
LachD., Challenges of interdisciplinary research: Reconciling qualitative and quantitative methods for understanding human-landscape systems, Environmental Management53(1) (2014), 88-93.
19.
Ministry of health, labour and welfare, http://www.mhlw.go. jp/toukei/saikin/hw/kanja/10syoubyo/dl/h23syobyo.pdf, 2011, accessed on 2015.
20.
Ministry of health, labour and welfare, http://www.mhlw.go. jp/bunya/shakaihosho/iryouseido01/pdf/info03k-05.pdf, 2012, accessed on 2015.
21.
Minister of health, labour and welfare, A basic direction for comprehensive implementation of national health promotion, http://www.mhlw.go.jp/file/06-Seisakujouhou-10900000-Kenkoukyoku/0000047330.pdf, accessed on 2015.
22.
MoritaK., ShinoharaR., SugisawaY., SawadaY., TanakaE., HiranoM. et al., Oral health behaviors and mortality in a 6-year cohort study of community - dwelling elderly people, Journal of Society18(1) (2011), 87-92.
23.
MorrisonZ., FernandoB., KalraD., CresswellK. and SheikhA., National evaluation of the benefits and risks of greater structuring and coding of the electronic health record: Exploratory qualitative investigation, J Am Med Inform Assoc21(3) (2014), 492-500.
24.
NakamuraT., TomodaM., YamashitaS., NakamuraK., UranoH., AndoH. et al., A questionnaire survey related to dental treatment fee: Comparison among patients, dentists and dental students, Matsumoto Dental University Repository36(3) (2010), 199-208.
25.
NaraY., Risk management and everyday life, Association for promoting education of the open University of Japan, Tokyo, 2011, 11.
26.
NaraY., Risk management and everyday life, Association for promoting education of the open University of Japan, Tokyo, 2011, 246.
27.
NaraY. and OhsawaY., Exploring collaboration topics from documented foresights of experts, Knowledge-Based and Intelligent Information and Engineering Systems 2004, KES2004 Proceedings (2004), 823-830.
28.
NaraY. and OhsawaY., Application to questionnaire analysis (Chapter19), Chance Discovery and Information Technology, OhsawaY., ed., Tokyo Denki University Press, Tokyo, 2003, pp. 280-297.
29.
NaraY. and OhsawaY., Application to questionnaire analysis (Chapter23), Chance Discovery, OhsawaY. and McBurneyP., eds, Springer Verlag, 2003, pp. 351-366.
30.
Ohsawa and laboratory on chance discovery-data systems for systems design, http://www.panda.sys.t.u-tokyo.ac.jp/lab_ en.html, accessed on 2015.
31.
OhsawaY. and BensonN.E., KeyGraph: Automatic indexing by co-occurrence graph based on building construction metaphor, Research and Technology Advances in Digital Libraries, ADL 98, Proceedings, (1998), 12-14.
32.
OkadaK., Qualitative research on academic construction of ``Yogo'' teacher and its challenges, J School Health51 (2010), 366-370.
33.
LeeS.K.J., Quantitative versus qualitative research methods - two approaches to organisation studies, Asia Pacific Journal of Management9(1) (1992), 87-94.
34.
SandelowskiM., Rigor or rigor mortis: The problem of rigor in qualitative research revisited, Advances in Nursing Science16(2) (1993), 1-8.
35.
SandelowskiM., One is the liveliest number: The case orientation of qualitative research, Research in Nursing and Health19(6) (1996), 525-529.
36.
SawaragiT., ItoK., HoriguchiY. and NakanishiH., Identifying latent similarities among near-miss incident records using a text-mining method and a scenario-based approach, human interface and the management of information, Information and Interaction5618 (2009), 594-603.
37.
ScupinR., the KJ method: A technique for analyzing data derived from japanese ethnology, Human Organization56(2) (1997), 233-237.
38.
UedaH., The general public's awareness of the importance of oral health: Findings from a community survey in Japan, Graduate School of Human Science Osaka University Bulletin40 (2014), 157-173.
39.
8020 promotion foundation, Dental health in japan, http:// www.8020zaidan.or.jp/newtest3/english/dhj.html, accessed on 2015.
