INTRODUCTION: Clinical complications like thrombosis or anaphylaxis have been described to go along with the intra-venous or intra-arterial injection of iodinated contrast media (CM). It has been suggested that the administration of CM affects rheological parameters and thereby causes reduced blood velocity in microvessels. In vitro studies revealed significant buckling of endothelial cells after exposure to CM reducing the lumen of vessels. The aim of this study was to test the influence of CM on three-dimensional microvascular tubules with open lumina within an organotypic soft-tissue co-culture assay in vitro. This model, which is based on the co-culture of endothelial cells and fibroblasts, allows the analysis and quantitation of different parameters of microvascular endothelial capillary structures.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: Human dermal fibroblasts and human dermal microvascular endothelial cells were co-cultured for 10 days. Fibroblasts were adapted to the endothelial cell medium before co-culture and allowed to proliferate as well as produce extracellular matrix. The co-cultures were exposed to three different CM, i.e., Iomeprol (Imeron 400MCT), Iodixanol (Visipaque 320) or Iohexol (Accupaque 350) for 1.5 minutes or 5.0 minutes, respectively. For this, a mixture of CM and cell culture medium in a ratio of 30% CM by volume was prepared. After fixation in methanol/acetone, the endothelial cells were immunolabeled with the endothelial marker anti-CD31 and the tubular structures were assessed morphometrically.
RESULTS: In the organotypic soft-tissue co-cultures with fibroblasts, the endothelial cells developed three-dimensional capillary-like structures which expanded via sprouting branches. After incubation with the different CM, the numbers of endothelial tubes (p = 0.001) and their lengths (p = 0.003) were significantly lower after the 5 minutes incubation time, when compared to the 1.5 minutes incubation time. The tubular diameters were significantly reduced after 5 minutes (p < 0.001), when compared to the 1.5 minutes incubation duration. Interestingly, Iomeprol and Iodixanol induced an elongation of the tubular branches during incubation duration of 1.5 minutes (p = 0.015). However, after 5 minutes incubation, the tubular branches were drastically shorter in the presence of Iomeprol and Iodixanol than the tubular branches of the control (p = 0.007).
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION: All CM exerted a negative effect on the parameters of in vitro blood vessel development.
AndreucciM., SolomonR. and TasanarongA., Side effects of radiographic contrast media: Pathogenesis, risk factors, and prevention, Biomed Res Int2014 (2014), 741018.
2.
AuerbachR., LewisR., ShinnersB., KubaiL. and AkhtarN., Angiogenesis assays: A critical overview, Clin Chem49 (2003), 32–40.
3.
BahramsoltaniM. and PlendlJ., Different ways to antiangiogenesis by angiostatin and suramin, and quantitation of angiostatin-induced antiangiogenesis, Apmis115 (2007), 30–46.
4.
DawsonP., Chemotoxicity of contrast media and clinical adverse effects: A review, Invest Radiol20 (1985), S84–S91.
5.
EcclesS.A., CourtW. and PattersonL., In vitro assays for endothelial cell functions required for angiogenesis: Proliferation, motility, tubular differentiation, and matrix proteolysis, Methods Mol Biol1430 (2016), 121–147.
6.
FrankeR.P., FuhrmannR., HieblB. and JungF., Influence of radiographic contrast media (iodixanol und iomeprol) on the morphology of human arterial and venous endothelial cells on extracellular matrix in vitro, Clin Hemorheol Microcirc48 (2011), 41–56.
7.
FrankeR.P., FuhrmannR., ParkJ.W., RickertD., HieblB. and JungF., The effect of radiographic contrast media on the morphology of human venous endothelial cells, Clin Hemorheol Microcirc37 (2007), 329–338.
8.
GabelmannA., HaberstrohJ. and WeyrichG., Ionic and non-ionic contrast agent-mediated endothelial injury. Quantitative analysis of cell proliferation during endothelial repair, Acta Radiol42 (2001), 422–425.
9.
HetheridgeC., MavriaG. and MellorH., Uses of the in vitro endothelial-fibroblast organotypic co-culture assay in angiogenesis research, Biochem Soc Trans39 (2011), 1597–1600.
10.
JungF. and FrankeR.P., Extreme reduction of the capillary lumen in segments of the venular legs of human cutaneous capillaries, Microvasc Res78 (2009), 241–245.
11.
JungF., MrowietzC., RickertD., HieblB., ParkJ.W. and FrankeR.P., The effect of radiographic contrast media on the morphology of human erythrocytes, Clin Hemorheol Microcirc38 (2008), 1–11.
12.
KuchlerS., HenkesD., EcklK.M., AckermannK., PlendlJ., KortingH.C., HenniesH.C. and Schafer-KortingM., Hallmarks of atopic skin mimicked in vitro by means of a skin disease model based on FLG knock-down, Altern Lab Anim3 (2011), 471–480.
13.
MavriaG., VercoulenY., YeoM., PatersonH., KarasaridesM., MaraisR., BirdD. and MarshallC.J., ERK-MAPK signaling opposes Rho-kinase to promote endothelial cell survival and sprouting during angiogenesis, Cancer Cell9 (2006), 33–44.
14.
MayerB., LeoA., HerzigerA., HoubenP., SchemmerP. and SalamaA., Intravascular immune hemolysis caused by the contrast medium iomeprol, Transfusion53 (2013), 2141–2144.
15.
PeerA., AverbukhZ., BermanS., ModaiD., AverbukhM. and WeissgartenJ., Contrast media augmented apoptosis of cultured renal mesangial, tubular, epithelial, endothelial, and hepatic cells, Invest Radiol38 (2003), 177–182.
16.
RichardsM. and MellorH., In vitro coculture assays of angiogenesis, Methods Mol Biol143 (2016), 159–166.
17.
SchnittlerH., Contraction of endothelial cells, 40 years of research, but the debate still lives, Histochem Cell Biol146 (2016), 651–656.
18.
SendeskiM.M., Pathophysiology of renal tissue damage by iodinated contrast media, Clin Exp Pharmacol Physiol38 (2011), 292–299.
19.
SendeskiM.M., PerssonA.B., LiuZ.Z., BuschJ.F., WeikertS., PerssonP.B., HippenstielS. and PatzakA., Iodinated contrast media cause endothelial damage leading to vasoconstriction of human and rat vasa recta, Am J Physiol Renal Physiol303 (2012), F1592–F1598.
20.
ShreenivasS. and OparilS., The role of endothelin-1 in human hypertension, Clin Hemorheol Microcirc37 (2007), 157–178.
21.
ThomsenH.S. and EuropeanR., Society of Urogenital, European Society of Urogenital Radiology guidelines on contrast media application, Curr Opin Urol17 (2007), 70–76.
22.
TymlK., WeigeltH. and LubbersD.W., Occurrence of the “capillary contractility” phenomenon and its significance in the distribution of microvascular flow in frog skeletal muscle, Microvasc Res27 (1984), 135–151.
23.
WeigeltH. and LubbersD.W., The fine adjustment of capillary blood flow through excitation of the capillary wall, Adv Exp Med Biol169 (1984), 731–737.
24.
XiaoY., ZengG., LiuX., PengC., LaiC. and ZhouP., Safety enhancement in adult body computed tomography scanning: Comparison of iodixanol versus iohexol, Springerplus5 (2016), 148.
25.
ZhangH., HoltC.M., MalikN., ShepherdL. and MorcosS.K., Effects of radiographic contrast media on proliferation and apoptosis of human vascular endothelial cells, Br J Radiol73 (2000), 1034–1041.
