This paper presents a systematic discussion, mainly for non-economists, on economic approaches to the concept of sustainable development. As a first step, the concept of sustainability is extensively discussed. As a second step, the argument that it is not possible to consider sustainability only from an economic or ecological point of view is defended; issues such as economic-ecological integration, inter-generational and intra-generational equity are considered of fundamental importance. Two different economic approaches to environmental issues, i.e. neo-classical environmental economics and ecological economics, are compared. Some key differences such as weak versus strong sustainability, commensurability versus incommensurability and ethical neutrality versus different values acceptance are pointed out.
Aguilera-KlinkF.1994. Some notes on the misuse of clasic writings in economics on the subject of common property, Ecological Economics, 9(4): 221–8.
2.
Aguilera-KlinkF. (ed.) 1996. Economía de los recursos naturales: un enfoque institucional.Madrid: Fundación Argentaria, Economia y Naturaleza (in Spanish).
3.
AyresR.U. and KneeseA.V.1969. Production, consumption and externalities, American Economic Review59: 282–297.
4.
BarbierE.B.1987. The concept of sustainable economic development, Environmental Conservation14(2): 101–110.
5.
BarbierE.B. and MarkandyaA.1990. The conditions for achieving environmentally sustainable growth, European Economic Review34: 659–69.
6.
BressoM.1993. Per un’ economia ecologica.Roma: La Nuova Italia Scientifica (in Italian).
7.
BromleyD.W.1989. Economic interests and institutions. The conceptual foundations of public policy.Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
8.
CastellsN. and MundaG.1996. International environmental issues: towards a new integrated assessment approach, in Proceedings of 'Inaugural Conference of the European branch of the International Society for Ecological Economics’, Paris.
9.
CabezaGutés M.1996. On the concept of weak sustainability, Ecological Economics17(3): 147–56.
10.
CostanzaR.; DalyH.E. and BarthlomewJ.A.1991. Goals, agenda and policy recommendations for ecological economics, in CostanzaR. (ed.), Ecological Economics: the science and management of sustainability, pp. 1–20. New York: Columbia University Press.
DalyH.E. and CobbJ.J.1990. For the common good: redirecting the economy toward community, the environment and a sustainable future.Boston: Beacon Press.
13.
DalyH.E.1991a. Steady-state economics (2nd edition), Washington, DC: Island Press.
14.
DalyH.E.1991b. Elements of environmental macroeconomics, in CostanzaR. (ed.), Ecological Economics: the science and management of sustainability, pp. 32–46. New York: Columbia University Press.
15.
DasguptaP. and HealD.1979. Economic theory and exhaustible resources.Cambridge University Press.
16.
DuchinF. and LangeG.M.1994. The future of the environment.Oxford University Press.
17.
EhrlichP. and RavenP.1964. Butterflies and plants: a study in coevolution, Evolution18: 586–608.
18.
FaucheuxS. and PiletG.1994. Energy metrics: on various valuation properties of energy, in PethigR. (ed.), Valuing the environment. Methodological and measurement issues.Dordrecht: Kluwer.
19.
FaucheuxS.; FrogerG. and MundaG.1994. Des outils d’ aide à la decision pour la multidimensionalité systémique: une application au développement durable, Revue Internationale de Systémique, No. 15 (in French).
20.
FaucheuxS. and NoëlJ.F.1995. Economie des ressources naturelles et de l’ environnement.Paris: Armand Colin, (in French).
21.
FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM.1997. Weak and strong sustainability, in FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds), Valuation for sustainable development: Methods and policy indicators.Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
22.
FolkeC. and KabergerT.1991. Recent trends in linking the natural environment and the economy, in FolkeC. and KabergerT. (eds), Linking the natural environment and the economy: Essays from the Eco-Eco Group, pp. 273–300. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
23.
FolkeC.1991. Socio-economic dependence on the life-supporting environment, in FolkeC. and KabergerT. (eds), Linking the natural environment and the economy: Essays from the Eco-Eco Group, pp. 77–94. Dordrecht: Kluwer.
24.
FrogerG. and MundaG.1997. Methodology for environmental decision support, in FaucheuxS. and O'ConnorM. (eds), Valuation for sustainable development: Methods and policy indicators.Aldershot: Edward Elgar.
25.
FuntowiczS.O. and RavetzJ.R.1990. Uncertainty and quality in science for policy.Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
26.
FuntowiczS.O. and RavetzJ.R.1991. A new scientific methodology for global en vi -ronmental issues, in CostanzaR. (ed.), Ecological Economics, pp. 137–152. New York: Columbia.
27.
FuntowiczS.O. and RavetzJ.R.1994. The worth of a songbird: ecological economics as a post-normal science, Ecological Economics10: 197–207.
28.
GalbraithJ.K.1959. The affluent society.New York: Houghton-Mifflin.
29.
Georgescu-RoegenN.1971. The entropy law and the economic process.Harward University Press.
30.
Georgescu-RoegenN.1984. Feasible recipies and viable technologies, Atlantic Economic Journal12: 21–30.
31.
Georgescu-RoegenN.1993. Thermodynamics and we, the humans, in DraganJ.C., SeifertE.K. and DemetrescuM.C. (eds), Entropy and Bioeconomics. Milan: NA-GARD.
32.
de GrootR.S.1992. Functions of nature. Groningen:Wolters-Noordhoff.
33.
GowdyJ.M.1994. Coevolutionary economics: the economy, society and the environment.Boston: Kluwer.
34.
GowdyJ.M. and O'HaraS.1996. Weak sustainability and viable technologies, paper submitted to Ecological Economics..
35.
HartwickJ.M.1977. Intergenerational equity and the investing of rents from exhaustible resources, American Economic Review67(5): 972–4.
36.
HartwickJ.M.1978. Substitution among exhaustible resources and inter-generational equity, Review of Economic Studies45: 347–54.
37.
HirschF.1977. Social limits to Growth.Harward University Press.
38.
HuetingR.1980. New scarcity and economic growth: more welfare through less production?Amsterdam: North-Holland.
39.
KappK.W.1970. Social costs, economic development, and environmental disruption, in UllmannJ.E. (ed.), University Press of America, London (reprinted, 1983).
40.
KlaassenG.A.J. and OpschoorJ.B.1991. Economics of sustainability or the sustainability of economics: different paradigms, Ecological Economics4: 93–115.
41.
KneeseA.; AyresR. and d'ArgeR.1970. Economics and the environment: a materials balance approach, Resource for the Future, Washington DC.
42.
KuhnT.S.1962. The structure of scientific revolutions.University of Chicago Press.
43.
MalthusT.1798. An essay on the principle of population, reprinted by Macmillan, London, 1909.
Martinez-AlierJ.1994. De la economia ecológica al ecologismo popular.Barcelona: ICARIA (in Spanish).
46.
Martinez-AlierJ.1995. The environment as a luxury good or too poor to be green, Ecological Economics13: 1–10.
47.
Martinez-AlierJ. and O'ConnorM.1996. Ecological and economic distribution conflicts, to appear in CostanzaR., Martinez-AlierJ. and SeguraO. (eds), Getting down to Earth: practical applications of ecological economics. Washington, DC: Island Press/ISEE.
48.
Martinez-AlierJ.; MundaG. and O'NeillJ.1996. Incommensurability of values in ecological economics, in proceedings of 'Inaugural Conference of the European branch of the International Society for Ecological Economics’, Paris.
49.
MarxK.1867. Capital, reprinted by Lawrence and Wishart, London, 1970.
50.
MayumiK.1991. A critical appraisal of two entropy theoretical approaches to resources and environmental problems, and a search for an alternative, in RossiC. and TiezziE. (eds), Ecological physical chemistry, pp. 109–130. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
51.
MayumiK.1992. The new paradigm of Georgescu-Roegen and the tremendous speed of increase in entropy in the modern economic process, The Journal of Interdisciplinary Economics4: 101–29.
52.
MayumiK.1993. Georgescu-Roegen's ‘fourth law of thermodynamics’, the modern energetic dogma, and ecological salvation, in BonatiL., CosentinoU., LasagniM., MoroG., PiteaD. and SchiraldiA. (eds), Trends in ecological physical chemistry.Amsterdam: Elsevier.
53.
MeadowsD.H.; MeadowsD.L.; RandersJ. and BehrensW.W.1972. The limits to growth.New York: Universe Books.
54.
MillJ.S.1857. Principles of political economy.London: Parker.
55.
MishanE.J.1967. The cost of economic growth.London: Staples Press.
56.
MishanE.J.1976. The economic growth debate: an assessment.London: George Allen and Unwin.
57.
MirowskiP.1989. More heat than light.Cambridge University Press.
58.
MundaG.; NijkampP. and RietveldP.1994. Qualitative multicriteria evaluation for environmental management, Ecological Economics10: 97–112.
59.
MundaG.1995. Multicriteria Evaluation in a Fuzzy Environment. Theory and Applications in Ecological Economics. Heidelberg: Physica-Verlag.
60.
MundaG.1996. Cost-benefit analysis in environmental integrated assessment: some methodological issues, Ecological Economics, forthcoming.
61.
MyrdalG.1973. Against the stream. Critical essays on economicsNew York: Random House.
62.
MyrdalG.1978. Institutional economics, J. Econ. Issues12: 771–83.
63.
NijkampP. and BithasK.1995. Scenarios for sustainable cultural heritage planning: a case study of Olympia, in CoccossisH. and NijkampP. (eds), Planning for our cultural heritage.Aldershot: Avebury.
64.
NordhausW.D. and TobinJ.1972. Is growth obsolete?, in National Bureau of Economic Research, Economic Growth, Fiftieth Anniversary Colloquium, vol. 5. New York.
65.
NorgaardR.B.1994. Development Betrayed.London: Routledge.
O'NeillJ.1993. Ecology, policy and politics.London: Routledge.
68.
OpschoorJ.B. and van der StraatenJ.1993. Sustainable development: an institutional approach, Ecological Economics7(3): 203–22.
69.
PassetR.1979. L'economique et le vivant.Paris: Payot (in French).
70.
PearceD.W. and TurnerK.R.1990. Economics of natural resources and the environment.New York: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
71.
PearceD.W. and AtkinsonG.D.1993. Capital theory and the measurement of sustainable development: an indicator of ‘weak’ sustainability, Ecological Economics8: 103–8.
72.
RicardoD.1817. Principles of political economy and taxation. Everyman edition, London 1926.
73.
ScitovskyT.1976. The joyless economy. Oxford University Press.
74.
SimonH.A.1972. Theories of Bounded Rationality. Decision and Organization, edited by RadnerC.B. and RadnerR.. Amsterdam: North Holland.
75.
SimonH.A.1978. On how to Decide What to Do. The Bell Journal of Economics9: 494–507.
76.
SimonH.A.1983. Reason in Human Affairs. Stanford University Press.
77.
SöderbaumP.1992. Neoclassical and institutional approaches to development and the environment, Ecological Economics5: 127–44.
78.
SolowR.M.1974a. The economics of resources or the resources of economics, American Economic Review64: 1–14.
79.
SolowR.M.1974b. Intergenerational equity and exhaustible resources, Review of Economic Studies67: 29–45.
80.
SolowR.M.1986. On the intergenerational allocation of natural resources, Scandinavian Journal of Economics88(1): 141–9.
81.
StiglitzJ.E.1979. A neoclassical analysis of the economics of natural resources, in SmithV.K. (ed.), Scarcity and growth reconsidered, pp. 37–65. Baltimore: The Johns Hopkins University Press.
82.
TurnerR.K.; PearceD.W. and BatemanI.1994. Environmental economics: an elementary introduction.London: Harvester Wheatsheaf.
83.
VictorP.A.1991. Indicators of sustainable development: some lessons from capital theory, Ecological Economics4: 191–213.
