The ecology of fear has become a common rhetoric in efforts to support climate mitigation. The thesis of the collapse is an extreme version, asserting the inevitable collapse of the world. Fear, then, becomes the ultimate emotion for spurring action. In this article, drawing on the work of the pragmatist John Dewey, we show that fear is an ambiguous emotion. Dewey stressed the quality of an emotion. Following his reasoning, this article draws a distinction between intense and moderate fear. Intense fear annihilates action, while moderate fear fulfils the conditions for an emotion of quality (in the Deweyan sense), which enables action. For this reason, the thesis of the collapse must be rejected, while an ecology of fear, drawing on moderate fear, may be maintained.
BeckA.T.1979. Cognitive Therapy of Depression. New York: Guilford Press.
2.
BeckU.1992. Risk Society: Toward a New Modernity. London: Sage Publications.
3.
BeckU.2018. Ecological Politics in an Age of Risk. Oxford: Polity Press.
4.
BlondéJ. and GirandolaF.2016. ‘Faire «appel à la peur» pour persuader? Revue de la littérature et perspectives de recherche’. L'Année psychologique116 (1): 67–103. Crossref
5.
ButlerC., DemskiC., ParkhillK., PidgeonN. and SpenceA.2015. ‘Public values for energy futures: Framing, indeterminacy and policy making’. Energy Policy87: 665–672. Crossref
6.
CabanasE. and IllouzE.2019. Manufacturing Happy Citizens: How the Science and Industry of Happiness Control Our Lives. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
7.
ChadwickA.E.2015. ‘Toward a theory of persuasive hope: Effects of cognitive appraisals, hope appeals, and hope in the context of climate change’. Health Communication30 (6): 598–611. Crossref
8.
CharbonnierP.2019. ‘The splendor and squalor of collapsology’. Revue du Crieur2 (13): 88–95. Crossref
9.
ChenM.F.2016. ‘Impact of fear appeals on pro-environmental behavior and crucial determinants’. International Journal of Advertising35 (1): 74–92. Crossref
10.
ClaytonS., Devine-WrightP., SternP.C., WhitmarshL., CarricoA., StegL., SwimJ. and BonnesM.2015. ‘Psychological research and global climate change’. Nature Climate Change5 (7): 640–646. Crossref
11.
CochetY.2019. Devant l'effondrement. Essai de collapsologie [Behind the collapse. An essay on collapsology]. Paris: Les liens qui libèrent.
12.
CrippenM.2018. ‘Pragmatism and the valuative mind’. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society54 (3): 341–360. Crossref
13.
DarwinC., 1872. The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals. London, John Murray.
14.
DavisM.1998. Ecology of Fear: Los Angeles and the Imagination of Disaster. London: Macmillan.
15.
DeweyJ.1894a [1971]. ‘The theory of emotion (I): Emotional attitudes’. In BoydstonJ.A. (ed.), The Early Works of John Dewey, 1882–1898, vol. 4: 152–169. Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
16.
DeweyJ.1894b [1971]. ‘A general analysis of conduct (IX): The nature of impulse’. In BoydstonJ.A. (ed.), The Early Works of John Dewey, 1882–1898, vol. 4: 235–239. Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
17.
DeweyJ.1895 [1971]. ‘The theory of emotion (II): The significance of emotions’. In BoydstonJ.A. (ed.), The Early Works of John Dewey, 1882–1898, vol. 4: 169–188. Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
18.
DeweyJ.1896 [1971]. ‘The reflex arc concept in psychology’. In BoydstonJ.A. (ed.), The Early Works of John Dewey, 1882–1898, vol. 4: 96–109. Carbondale and Edwardsville: Southern Illinois University Press.
19.
DeweyJ.1910. How We Think. New York, Chicago: D.C. Heath & Co., Publishers.
20.
DeweyJ.1922. Human Nature and Conduct: An Introduction to Social Psychology.New York: Carlton House. Crossref
21.
DeweyJ.1925 [1958]. Experience and Nature. New York: Dover Publications.
22.
DeweyJ.1929. The Quest for Certainty: A Study of Relation of Knowledge and Action. New York: Minton, Balch and Co.
23.
DeweyJ.1934a. Art as Experience. New York: Minton, Balch & Company.
24.
DeweyJ.1934b. A Common Faith. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.
25.
DeweyJ.1935. Liberalism and Social Action. New York: G.P. Putnam.
DupuyJ.P.2004. Pour un catastrophisme éclairé. Quand l'impossible est certain [For an enlightened catastrophism. When the impossible is certain]. Paris: Seuil.
28.
DupuyJ.P.2020. ‘Les paradoxes de la prophétie de malheur. Critique de la collapsologie’. Annales des Mines-Responsabilité et Environnement2 (98): 18–21. Crossref
29.
EreautG. and SegnitN.2006. Warm Words: How Are We Telling the Climate Story and Can We Tell It Better?London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
30.
FeinbergM. and WillerR.2011. ‘Apocalypse soon? Dire messages reduce belief in global warming by contradicting just-world beliefs’. Psychological Science22 (1): 34–38. Crossref
31.
FeldmanL. and HartP.S.2018. ‘Is there any hope? How climate change news imagery and text influence audience emotions and support for climate mitigation policies’. Risk Analysis38 (3): 585–602. Crossref
32.
FirebaughC.M., ZolnikovT.R., FurioF. and NgG.2021. ‘Population levels of climate change fear in the United States’. American Journal of Climate Change10 (1): 1–11. Crossref
33.
FormisB.2015. Esthétique de la vie ordinaire [Aesthetics of ordinary life]. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.
34.
GarretaG.2002. ‘Une régularité sans répétition? L'habitude comme schème dynam-ique’. In ChauviréC. (ed.), La régularité: habitude, disposition et savoir-faire dans l'explication de l'action, pp. 137–160. Paris: Éditions de l'École des hautes études en sciences sociales. Crossref
35.
GarretaG.2007. ‘L'éthique située de Dewey. Émotions, états d'esprit et sens des jugements moraux’. L'Art du Comprendre16: 27–48.
36.
GarrisonJ.2003. ‘Dewey's theory of emotions: The unity of thought and emotion in naturalistic functional co-ordination of behavior’. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society39 (3): 405–443.
37.
GiffordR.2011. ‘The dragons of inaction: Psychological barriers that limit climate change mitigation and adaptation’. American Psychologist66 (4): 290–302. Crossref
38.
GiffordR. and ComeauL.A.2011. ‘Message framing influences perceived climate change competence, engagement, and behavioral intentions’. Global Environmental Change21 (4): 1301–1307. Crossref
39.
GiffordE. and GiffordR.2016. ‘The largely unacknowledged impact of climate change on mental health’. Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists72 (5): 292–297. Crossref
40.
GourevitchA.2010. ‘Environmentalism—long live the politics of fear’. Public Culture22 (3): 411–24. Crossref
41.
GroveK. and ChandlerD.2017. ‘Introduction: Resilience and the Anthropocene: The stakes of “renaturalising” politics’. Resilience5 (2): 79–91. Crossref
42.
HamiltonC., GemenneF. and BonneuilC. (eds) 2015. The Anthropocene and the Global Environmental Crisis: Rethinking Modernity in a New Epoch. Abingdon: Routledge. Crossref
43.
HeadL.2016. Hope and Grief in the Anthropocene: Re-Conceptualising Human–Nature Relations. Abingdon: Routledge. Crossref
44.
HohrH.2010. ‘Aesthetic emotion: An ambiguous concept in John Dewey's aesthetics’. Ethics and Education5 (3): 247–261. Crossref
45.
HohrH.2013. ‘The concept of experience by John Dewey revisited: Conceiving, feeling and “enliving”’. Studies in Philosophy and Education32 (1): 25–38. Crossref
46.
JamesW.1884. ‘What is an emotion?’Mind9: 188–205.
47.
KabelA. and ChmidlingC.2014. ‘Disaster prepper: Health, identity, and American survivalist culture’. Human Organization73 (3): 258–266. Crossref
48.
LarrèreC. and LarrèreR.2020. Le pire n'est pas certain. Essai sur l'aveuglement catastrophique [The worst is not certain. An essay on catastrophic blindness]. Paris: Premier Parallèle.
49.
LeiserowitzA.2006. ‘Climate change risk perception and policy preferences: The role of affect, imagery, and values’. Climatic Change77 (1–2): 45–72. Crossref
50.
MacyJ. and BrownM.Y.1998. Coming Back to Life: Practices to Reconnect our Lives, our World.Gabriola Island, British Columbia: New Society Publishers.
51.
MarkowitzE.M. and ShariffA.F.2012. ‘Climate change and moral judgment’. Nature Climate Change2: 243–247. Crossref
52.
MendonçaD.2012. ‘Pattern of sentiment: Following a Deweyan suggestion’. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society: A Quarterly Journal in American Philosophy48 (2): 209–227. Crossref
53.
MorseD.J.2010. ‘Dewey on the emotions’. Human Affairs3: 224–231. Crossref
54.
MoserS.C.2007. ‘More bad news: The risk of neglecting emotional responses to climate change information’. In S.C. Moser and DillingL (eds), Creating a Climate for Change, pp. 64–80. New York: Cambridge University Press. Crossref
55.
MoserS.C. and DillingL.2004. ‘Making climate hot: Communicating the urgency and challenge of global climate change’. Environment46: 32–46. Crossref
56.
MichotD., SteffanL. and SutterP.E.2020. Rapport-Etude 2020. OBVECO.
MyersT.A., NisbetM.C., MaibachE.W. and LeiserowitzA.A.2012. ‘A public health frame arouses hopeful emotions about climate change’. Climatic Change113 (3–4): 1105–12. Crossref
59.
NabiR.L., GustafsonA. and JensenR.2018. ‘Framing climate change: Exploring the role of emotion in generating advocacy behavior’. Science Communication40 (4): 442–468. Crossref
60.
NelissenR.M., DijkerA.J. and de VriesN.K.2007. ‘Emotions and goals: Assessing relations between values and emotions’. Cognition and Emotion21 (4): 902–911. Crossref
61.
NicholsenS.W.2002. The Love of Nature and the End of the World.Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
NorgaardK.M.2006. ‘People want to protect themselves a little bit: Emotions, denial, and social movement nonparticipation’. Sociological Inquiry76 (3): 372–396. Crossref
64.
NorgaardK.M.2011. Living in Denial: Climate Change, Emotions, and Everyday Life. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Crossref
65.
OjalaM.2012. ‘Hope and climate change: The importance of hope for environmental engagement among young people’. Environmental Education Research18 (5): 625–42. Crossref
66.
OjalaM., CunsoloA., OgunbodeC.A. and MiddletonJ.2021. ‘Anxiety, worry, and grief in a time of environmental and climate crisis: A narrative review’. Annual Review of Environment and Resources46: 35–58. Crossref
67.
OliveiraJ.2014. ‘Le statut heuristique de la crainte dans la réflexion éthique de Hans Jonas’. Alter – Revue de phénoménologie22: 195–209. Crossref
68.
O'NeillS. and Nicholson-ColeS.2009. ‘Fear won't do it: Promoting positive engagement with climate change through visual and iconic representations’. Science Communication30 (3): 355–379. Crossref
69.
PappasG.F.2016. ‘John Dewey's radical logic: The function of the qualitative in thinking’. Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society52 (3): 435–468. Crossref
70.
PeirceC.S.1877. ‘The fixation of belief’. Popular Science Monthly12: 1–15.
71.
PetitE. and BalletJ.2021. ‘Habit and emotion: John Dewey's contribution to the theory of change’. Cambridge Journal of Economics45: 655–674. Crossref
72.
PihkalaP.2018. ‘The wicked problem of climate change’. Zygon53 (2): 545–569. Crossref
73.
QuéréL.2018. ‘L'émotion comme facteur de complétude et d'unité dans l'expérience. La théorie de l'émotion de John Dewey’. Pragmata1: 10–59.
74.
RachlinskiJ.J.2000. ‘The psychology of global climate change’. University of Illinois Law Review2000 (1): 299–319.
75.
SartreJ.P.1939. Esquisse d'une théorie des émotions [Sketch of a theory of emotions]. Paris: Hermann.
76.
SchererK.R.2005. ‘What are emotions? And how can they be measured?’. Social Science Information44 (4): 695–729. Crossref
77.
SèveB.1993. ‘La peur comme procédé heuristique et comme instrument de persuasion’ [Fear as a heuristic device and as an instrument of persuasion]. In HottoisG. (ed.), Aux fondements d'une éthique contemporaine. H. Jonas et H.T. Engelhardt en perspective [On the foundations of contemporary ethics. H. Jonas and H.T. Engelhardt in perspective], pp. 107–125. Paris: Vrin.
Sinnott-ArmstrongW.2005. ‘It's not my fault: Global warming and individual moral obligations’. In HowarthR. and Sinnott-ArmstrongW. (eds), Perspectives on Climate Change: Science, Economics, Politics, Ethics, pp. 293–315. Advances in the Economics of Environmental Research, vol. 5. Amsterdam: Elsevier.
80.
SmithN. and LeiserowitzA.2014. ‘The role of emotion in global warming policy support and opposition’. Risk Analysis34 (5): 937–948.
81.
SternP.C.2012. ‘Fear and hope in climate messages’. Nature Climate Change2(8): 572–573.
82.
SwimJ.K., SternP.C., DohertyT.J., ClaytonS., ReserJ.P., WeberE.U., GiffordR. and HowardG.S.2011. ‘Psychology's contributions to understanding and addressing global climate change’. American Psychologist66 (4): 241–250.
83.
TappoletC.2016. Emotions, Values, and Agency. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
84.
TheysJ.2020. ‘Prospective, catastrophe et collapsologie’ [Foresight, catastrophe and collapsology]. Annales des Mines – Responsabilité et environnement2 (98): 22–28.
85.
VerplankenB., MarksE. and DobromirA.I.2020. ‘On the nature of eco-anxiety: How constructive or unconstructive is habitual worry about global warming?’Journal of Environmental Psychology72: 101528. Crossref
86.
VerplankenB. and RoyD.2013. ‘My worries are rational, climate change is not: Habitual ecological worrying is an adaptive response’. PLoS One8(9): e74708. Crossref
87.
WhitehouseP.G.1978. ‘The meaning of “Emotion” in Dewey's Art as Experience’. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism37 (2): 149–156.
88.
WillistonB.2012. ‘Climate change and radical hope’. Ethics & the Environment17 (2): 165–86.
