Sufficiency and Sustainability: Conceptual Analysis and Ethical Considerations for Sustainable Organisation

Abstract

This article analyses the concept of sufficiency in relation to sustainability and discusses ethical implications for sustainable organisation in time and place. We identify three foundational conceptualisations of sufficiency related to sustainability: (1) a limits model that starts with objective boundaries imposed by the biosphere and basic human needs; (2) a preference model that treats sufficiency as a subjective inclination for moderation defined situationally; and (3) a balancing model that seeks to integrate the objective limits and subjective preferences by focussing on action embedded in the socio-ecological context. This includes balancing the needs of humans with those of non-humans. The limits model builds on universal duty, the preference model on preference utilitarianism and the balancing model on action-oriented virtue ethics. The balancing model of sufficiency is well suited to meeting the needs of present and future generations as well as delivering intra- and inter-generational justice not limited to humans.

Keywords

Ethics justice sufficiency sustainability virtue

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alcott

2006. ‘Assessing energy policy: should rebound count?’ Dissertation for the degree of Master in Philosophy in Land Economy, University of Cambridge.

Alexander

and Rutherford

. 2020. ‘A critique of techno-optimism: efficiency without sufficiency is lost’. In Kalfagianni

, Fuchs

and Hayden

(eds), Routledge Handbook of Global Sustainability Governance, pp. 231–241. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge.

Allievi

, Vinnari

and Luukkanen

. 2015. ‘Meat consumption and production –analysis of efficiency, sufficiency and consistency of global trends’. Journal of Cleaner Production 92 (1): 142–151. Crossref.

Anderson

E.S.

1999. ‘What is the point of equality?’ Ethics 109 (2): 287–337. Crossref.

Arneson

2006. ‘Distributive justice and basic capability equality: “Good enough” is not good enough’. In Kaufman

, (ed.) Capabilities Equality: Basic Issues and Problems, pp. 17–43. London: Routledge.

Banerjee

S.B.

2003. ‘Who sustains whose development? Sustainable development and the reinvention of nature’. Organization Studies 24 (1): 143–180. Crossref.

Barnosky

A.D.

, Hadly

E.A.

, Bascompte

, Berlow

E.L.

, Brown

J.H.

, Fortelius

, . 2012. ‘Approaching a state shift in Earth's biosphere’. Nature 486 (7401): 52–58. Crossref.

Barry

1997. ‘Sustainability and intergenerational justice’. Theoria 44 (89): 43–64. Crossref.

Beckerman

1994. “‘Sustainable development”: Is it a useful concept?’. Environmental Values 3 (3): 191–209. Crossref.

10.

Bocken

N.M.

and Short

S.W.

. 2016. ‘Towards a sufficiency-driven business model: experiences and opportunities’. Environmental Innovation and Societal Transitions 18: 41–61. Crossref.

11.

Bonnedahl

K.J.

and Heikkurinen

(eds). 2019. Strongly Sustainable Societies: Organising Human Activities on a Hot and Full Earth. Abingdon, Oxon: Routledge. Crossref.

12.

Brock

2019. ‘Needs in moral and political philosophy’. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/needs/ (accessed 26 April 2021).

13.

Büchs

and Koch

. 2017. Postgrowth and Wellbeing: Challenges to Sustainable Welfare. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

14.

Daly

H.E.

1996. Beyond Growth: The Economics of Sustainable Development. Boston: Beacon Press.

15.

de Geus

2003. The End of Over-consumption: Towards a Lifestyle of Moderation and Self-Restraint. Utrecht: International Books.

16.

Di Marco

, Watson

J.E.

, Venter

and Possingham

H.P.

. 2016. ‘Global biodiversity targets require both sufficiency and efficiency’. Conservation Letters 9 (6): 395–397. Crossref.

17.

Dworkin

1981. ‘What is equality? Part 2: Equality of resources’. Philosophy and Public Affairs 10 (4): 283–345.

18.

Elkington

1997. Cannibals with Forks: The Triple Bottom Line of 21st Century Business. Oxford: Capstone.

19.

Figge

, Young

and Barkemeyer

. 2014. ‘Sufficiency or efficiency to achieve lower resource consumption and emissions? The role of the rebound effect’. Journal of Cleaner Production 69: 216–224. Crossref.

20.

Frankfurt

1987. ‘Equality as a moral ideal’. Ethics 98 (1): 21–43. Crossref.

21.

Frankfurt

2000. ‘The moral irrelevance of equality’. Public Affairs Quarterly 14 (2): 87–103.

22.

Frankfurt

2015. On Inequality. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

23.

Gardiner

S.M.

2006. ‘A core precautionary principle’. Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (1): 33–60. Crossref.

24.

Gaspar

, Antunes

, Faria

and Meiszner

. 2017. ‘Sufficiency before efficiency: consumers' profiling and barriers/facilitators of energy efficient behaviours’. Journal of Cleaner Production 165: 134–142. Crossref.

25.

Georgescu-Roegen

1975. ‘Energy and economic myths’. Southern Economic Journal 41 (3): 347–381. Crossref.

26.

Glotzbach

and Baumgartner

. 2012. ‘The relationship between intragenerational and intergenerational ecological justice’. Environmental Values 21 (3): 331–355. Crossref.

27.

Giulio

and Fuchs

. 2014. ‘Sustainable consumption corridors: concept, objections and responses’. Gaia 23 (S1): 184–192. Crossref.

28.

Goodland

and Daly

. 1996. ‘Environmental sustainability: universal and non-negotiable’. Ecological Applications 6 (4): 1002–1017. Crossref.

29.

Gosseries

2008. ‘Theories of intergenerational justice: a synopsis’. Surveys and Perspectives Integrating Environment and Society 1 (1): 61–71. Crossref.

30.

Gough

2017. Heat, Greed and Human Need: Climate Change, Capitalism and Sustainable Wellbeing. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

31.

Gowdy

and Mesner

. 1998. ‘The evolution of Georgescu-Roegen's bioeconomics’. Review of Social Economy 56 (2): 136–156. Crossref.

32.

Gutmann

1987. Democratic Education. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

33.

Hare

R.M.

1981. Moral Thinking: Its Levels, Method, and Point. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

34.

Heikkurinen

2017. ‘Management approach: the virtuous corporation as a moral agent for sustainable development’. In Sison

A.J.G.

, Beabout

G.R.

and Ferrero

(eds), Handbook of Virtue Ethics in Business and Management, pp. 1395–1404. Dordrecht: Springer.

35.

Heikkurinen

2018. ‘Degrowth by means of technology? A treatise for an ethos of releasement’. Journal of Cleaner Production 197 (2): 1654–1665. Crossref.

36.

Heikkurinen

, Young

C.W.

and Morgan

. 2019. ‘Business for sustainable change: extending eco-efficiency and eco-sufficiency strategies to consumers’. Journal of Cleaner Production 218 (2): 656–664. Crossref.

37.

Heikkurinen

, Ruuska

T.P.K.

, Valtonen

and Rantala

. 2020. ‘Time and mobility after the Anthropocene’. Sustainability 12 (12): 5159. Crossref.

38.

Helne

and Hirvilammi

. 2015. ‘Wellbeing and sustainability: a relational approach’. Sustainable Development 23 (3): 167–175. Crossref.

39.

Hirvilammi

and Helne

. 2014. ‘Changing paradigms: a sketch for sustainable well-being and ecosocial policy’. Sustainability 6 (4): 2160–2175. Crossref.

40.

Holland

1997. ‘Substitutability: or, why strong sustainability is weak and absurdly strong sustainability is not absurd’. In Foster

, (ed.) Valuing Nature? Ethics, Economics and the Environment, pp. 119–134. London: Routledge.

41.

Hopwood

, Mellor

and O'Brien

. 2005. ‘Sustainable development: mapping different approaches’. Sustainable Development 13 (1): 38–52.

42.

IPCC (Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change). 2014. Fifth Assessment Report (AR5). http://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar5/ (accessed 2 September 2020).

43.

Kanschik

2016. ‘Eco-suffiiciency and distributive sufficientarianism – Friends or foes?’. Environmental Values 25 (5): 553–571. Crossref.

44.

Kant

2004. Critique of Practical Reason, transl. by Abbot

T.K.

. Mineola, NY: Dover Publications.

45.

Kyllönen

2014. ‘Civil disobedience, climate protests and a Rawlsian argument for “atmospheric” fairness’. Environmental Values 23 (5): 593–613. Crossref.

46.

Langhelle

2000. ‘Sustainable development and social justice: expanding the Rawlsian framework of global justice’. Environmental Values 9 (3): 295–323. Crossref.

47.

Linnanen

, Nyfors

, Heinonen

, Liimatainen

, Nissinen

, Regina

, Saarinen

, Seppälä

and Viri

. 2020. The sufficiency perspective in climate policy: How to recompose consumption. Raport 4/2020. Helsinki: The Finnish Climate Change Panel.

48.

Manno

2017. ‘Environmental sustainability/sufficiency’. In Denemark

R.A.

and Marlin-Bennett

, The International Studies Encyclopedia. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell.

49.

Meadows

, Meadows

and Randers

. 2002. The Limits to Growth: The 30-Year Update. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green Publishing.

50.

Mebratu

1998. ‘Sustainability and sustainable development: historical and conceptual review’. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 18 (6): 493–520. Crossref.

51.

Miller

1995. On Nationality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

52.

Muller

2009. ‘Sufficiency: does energy consumption become a moral issue?’ In Broussous

(ed.), Act! Innovate! Deliver! Reducing Energy Demand Sustainably: ECEEE Summer Study, pp. 83–90. Stockholm: European Council for an Energy Efficient Economy.

53.

Nussbaum

1990. ‘Aristotelian social democracy’. In Douglas

R.B.

, Mara

G.M.

and Richardson

(eds), Liberalism and the Good, pp. 203–252. New York: Routledge.

54.

Nussbaum

2000. ‘Aristotle, politics, and human capabilities: a response to Antony, Arneson, Charlesworth, and Mulgan’. Ethics 111 (1): 102–140. Crossref.

55.

Nussbaum

2006. Frontiers of Justice: Disability, Nationality, Species Membership. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

56.

Nyfors

, Linnanen

, Nissinen

, Seppälä

, Saarinen

, Regina

, Heinonen

, Viri

and Liimatainen

. 2020. ‘Ecological sufficiency in climate policy: towards policies for recomposing consumption’. Futura 39 (3): 30–40.

57.

O'Riordan

and Jordan

. 1995. ‘The precautionary principle in contemporary environmental politics’. Environmental Values 4 (3): 191–212. Crossref.

58.

Parrique

, Barth

, Briens

, Kerschner

, Kraus-Polk

, Kuokkanen

and Spangenberg

J.H.

. 2019. Decoupling Debunked: Evidence and Arguments against Green Growth as a Sole Strategy for Sustainability. A Study Edited by the European Environment Bureau. Brussels: EEB.

59.

Pezzey

1992. Sustainable Development Concept: An Economic Analysis. New York: World Bank. Crossref.

60.

Portney

K.E.

2015. Sustainability. Cambridge, MA: Massachusetts Institute of Technology Press.

61.

Princen

2003. ‘Principles for sustainability: from cooperation and efficiency to suf-ficiency’. Global Environmental Politics 3 (1): 33–50. Crossref.

62.

Raworth

2017. Doughnut Economics: Seven Ways to Think Like a 21st Century Economist. London: Cornerstone. Crossref.

63.

Salleh

2009. ‘From eco-sufficiency to global justice’. In Salleh

, (ed.) Eco-Sufficiency and Global Justice: Women Write Political Ecology. London: Pluto Press.

64.

Schäpke

and Rauschmayer

. 2014. ‘Going beyond efficiency: including altruistic motives in behavioral models for sustainability transitions to address sufficiency’. Sustainability: Science, Practice and Policy 10 (1): 29–44. Crossref.

65.

Sen

1984. Resources, Values and Development. Oxford: Blackwell.

66.

Singer

2011. Practical Ethics, Third edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

67.

Spangenberg

J.H.

and Lorek

. 2019. ‘Sufficiency and consumer behaviour: from theory to policy’. Energy Policy 129: 1070–1079. Crossref.

68.

Spash

C.L.

2011. ‘Social ecological economics: understanding the past to see the future’. American Journal of Economics and Sociology 70 (2): 340–375. Crossref.

69.

Steffen

, Richardson

, Rockström

, Cornell

S.E.

, Fetzer

, Bennett

E.M.

. 2015. ‘Planetary boundaries: guiding human development on a changing planet’. Science 347 (6223): 1259855. Crossref.

70.

Tainter

J.A.

2006. ‘Social complexity and sustainability’. Ecological Complexity 3 (2): 91–103. Crossref.

71.

Timmerman

and Cohen

. 2020. ‘The limits of virtue ethics’. Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics 10: 255–282. Crossref.

72.

U-tantada

, Bahaudin

M.G.

, Yolles

and Shoosanuk

. 2016. ‘Sufficiency economy and sustainability’. The 2nd Multidisciplinary Research and Innovation for Globally Sustainable Development (MRIGSD), pp. 1–8.

73.

Wallner

H.P.

1999. ‘Towards sustainable development of industry: networking, complexity and eco-clusters’. Journal of Cleaner Energy 7 (1): 49–58. Crossref.

74.

Walzer

1983. Spheres of Justice: A Defence of Pluralism and Equality. New York: Basic Books.

75.

WCED (The World Commission on Environment and Development). 1987. Our Common Future. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

76.

Wiggins

1998. ‘Claims of need’. In Wiggins

, Needs, Values, Truth: Essays in the Philosophy of Value, Second edition, pp. 1–58. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

77.

Wolff

2009. ‘Disability among equals’. In Brownlee

and Cureton

(eds), Disability and Disadvantage, pp. 112–137. New York: Oxford University Press.

78.

Young

and Tilley

. 2006. ‘Can businesses move beyond efficiency? The shift toward effectiveness and equity in the corporate sustainability debate’. Business Strategy and the Environment 15 (6): 402–415. Crossref.