Governing Household Waste Management: An Empirical Analysis and Critique

Abstract

We conducted a survey of residents of Kingston, Ontario, Canada, (n = 107) to understand their attitudes to and experiences of waste management and governance. Currently, the municipality is emphasising waste diversion and exploring new waste processing systems (WPS; e.g., incineration) to reduce costs. Using Foucault's governmentality theory, our data suggest Kingston's reliance on an attitude-behaviour-context model of behaviour change successfully fosters an environmental citizenship identity based on waste diversion (e.g., recycling). However, we argue that the neoliberal governmentality upon which the attitude-behaviour-context model is predicated elides the need for, and inhibits consideration of, broader societal change concerning urgent environmental issues involving consumption and waste.

Keywords

Governmentality waste management environmental citizenship politics

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ajzen

1991. ‘The theory of planned behavior’. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 50 (2): 179–211. CrossRef.

Ali

S.H.

1999. ‘The search for a landfill site in the risk society’. Canadian Review of Sociology 36 (1): 1–19. CrossRef.

Barr

and Gilg

. 2006. ‘Sustainable lifestyles: Framing environmental action in and around the home’. Geoforum 37 (6): 906–920. CrossRef.

Barr

, Gilg

and Ford

. 2001. ‘A conceptual framework for understanding and analysing attitudes towards household-waste management’. Environment and Planning A 33 (11): 2025–2048. CrossRef.

Braun

and Schultz

. 2010. “‘… a certain amount of engineering involved”: Constructing the public in participatory governance arrangements’. Public Understanding of Science 19 (4): 403–419. CrossRef.

Bulkeley

, Watson

and Hudson

. 2007. Modes of governing municipal waste. Environment and Planning A 39 (11): 2733–2753. CrossRef.

Bulkeley

, Watson

, Hudson

and Weaver

. 2005. Governing municipal waste: towards a new analytical framework. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning 7 (1): 1–23. CrossRef.

Canadian Institute for Environmental Law and Policy. 2008. A Brief History of Waste Diversion in Ontario, http://www.cielap.org/pdf/WDA_BriefHistory.pdf (accessed 8 February 2016).

Chapman

2004. ‘Technology as world building’. Ethics, Place & Environment 7 (1–2): 59–72. CrossRef.

10.

Cheung

S.F.

Chan

D.K-S.

and Wong

Z.S-Y.

. 1999. ‘Reexamining the theory of planned behavior in understanding wastepaper recycling’. Environment and Behavior 31 (5): 587–612. CrossRef.

11.

City of Kingston 2012a Audited Financial Statements And Other Financial Information Of Corporation Of The City Of Kingston Year Ended December 31, 2012 https://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/57852/2012+Audited+Financial+Statements/833dff62-4130-488b-8271-78cc152a1bfc (accessed 20 February 2014).

12.

City of Kingston. 2012b. EI&TP Committee Minutes for Tuesday October 9th. http://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/90257/EIT_Minutes-0912.pdf/cc997fd0–9210–470e-9453-cf540b1abb6f (accessed 10 January 2014).

13.

City of Kingston. 2013a. ‘City Wants to Recognize Remarkable Recyclers’. City of Kingston News and Public Notices, http://www.cityofkingston.ca/-/city-wants-to-recognize-remarkable-recyclers (accessed 18 December 2013).

14.

City of Kingston. 2013b. Options to Maximize the Reduction, Reuse and Recycling of Kingston's Waste Stream, https://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/634489/EIT_A0413-13002.pdf/f6f533eb-de00-4c51-bc67-fdba4d5c1096 (accessed 8 February 2016).

15.

City of Kingston. 2013c. Report to Council 13–051. 13–051, http://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/58881/COU_Agenda-0313.pdf/3f70e388-d70a-469e-97b7–604ece57662c (accessed 14 October 2013).

16.

City of Kingston. 2013d. Waste Recycling Strategy 2010–2013 Volume III. City of Kingston Solid Waste Division, http://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/967935/COU_A1413-13186.pdf/e2060cfc-e3da-41b0-907b-48e2b3a72142 (accessed 8 February 2016).

17.

City of Kingston Planning and Development. 2008. City of Kingston and Census Metropolitan Area Statistical Profile. http://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/61431/2008+Statistical+Profile+of+City+and+Census+Metropolitan+Area%20/5eefe728-ee0c-48ef-bd8c-cabd19d4dbbe (accessed 20 February 2014).

18.

Corvellec

and Hultman

. 2012. ‘From”less landfilling“to”wasting less”: Societal narratives, socio-materiality, and organizations’. Journal of Organizational Change Management 25 (2): 297–314. CrossRef.

19.

Darier

1996a. ‘Environmental governmentality: The case of Canada's green plan’. Environmental Politics 5 (4): 585–606. CrossRef.

20.

Darier

1996b. ‘The politics and power effects of garbage recycling in Halifax, Canada’. Local Environment 1 (1): 63–86. CrossRef.

21.

Davies

2008. The Geographies of Garbage Governance Interventions, Interactions, and Outcomes. Aldershot, Hampshire, England; Burlington, VT: Ashgate.

22.

Davies

, Foxall

G.R.

and Pallister

. 2002. ‘Beyond the intention-behaviour mythology: an integrated model of recycling’. Marketing Theory 2 (1): 29–113. CrossRef.

23.

Dean

2009. Governmentality: Power and Rule in Modern Society. London: Sage Publications Limited.

24.

Duroy

2011. ‘The path to a sustainable economy: sustainable consumption, social identity and ecological citizenship’. International Journal of Green Economics 5 (1): 1–14. CrossRef.

25.

Ellen

P. S.

1994. Do we know what we need to know? Objective and subjective knowledge effects on pro-ecological behaviors. Journal of Business Research, 30(1), 43–52. Crossref.

26.

Gilg

, Barr

and Ford

. 2005. ‘Green consumption or sustainable lifestyles? Identifying the sustainable consumer’. Futures 37 (6): 481–504. CrossRef.

27.

Hargreaves

2012. ‘Questioning the virtues of pro-environmental behaviour research: Towards a phronetic approach’. Geoforum 43 (2): 315–324. CrossRef.

28.

Hawkins

2006. Ethics of Waste: How We Relate to Rubbish. Lanham MD: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

29.

HDR Corporation. 2011. Investigation of Residual Waste Processing Systems. 172826, http://archive.cityofkingston.ca/pdf/waste/WMS_ResidualWasteProcessing.pdf (accessed 16 September 2013).

30.

Hird

, Lougheed

, Rowe

R.K.

and Kuyvenhoven

. 2014. Making waste management public (or falling back to sleep). Social Studies of Science 44 (5): 441–465. CrossRef.

31.

Hobson

2006. ‘Bins, bulbs, and shower timers: On the ‘techno-ethics’ of sustainable living’. Ethics, Place & Environment 9 (3): 317–336. CrossRef.

32.

Hobson

2013. ‘On the making of the environmental citizen’. Environmental Politics 22 (1): 56–72. CrossRef.

33.

Hobson

and Hill

. 2010. ‘Cultivating citizen-subjects through collective praxis: Organized gardening projects in Australia and the Philippines’. In: Lewis

and Potter

(eds), Consuming Ethics, pp. 216–230. London: Routledge.

34.

Jackson

2009. Kingston Community Profile: A Socio-Demographic Analysis of Kingston, Ontario, Canada. http://spckingston.ca/kcp/Kingston_Community_Profile_SPC_2009-05-28_BW.pdf (accessed 1 March 2014).

35.

Jacques Whitford. 2008a. Kingston Integrated Waste Management Study Phase A. https://www.cityofkingston.ca/documents/10180/27835/Study_IntegratedWasteManagementStudy.pdf/74f16834-524c-4857-ae50-15ff5a9fe9bf (accessed 10 March 2014).

36.

Jacques Whitford. 2008b. Kingston Integrated Waste Management Study Phase B. http://archive.cityofkingston.ca/pdf/waste/IntegratedWasteManagementStudy_PhaseB.pdf (accessed 10 March 2014).

37.

Kingston Solid Waste Task Force. 2002. Solid Waste Services Situation Analysis Review. http://www.docstoc.com/docs/31519902/Solid-Waste-Services-Situation-Analysis-Review (accessed 23 September 2013).

38.

Krausz

2012. ‘All for naught? A critical study of zero waste to landfill initiatives’. PhD Dissertation, Lincoln University, http://hdl.handle.net/10182/5301.

39.

Latour

2007. ‘Turning around politics: A note on Gerard de Vries' paper’. Social Studies of Science 37 (5): 811–820. CrossRef.

40.

Lee

and Roth

W-M.

. 2003. ‘Science and the “good citizen”: Community-Based scientific literacy’. Science, Technology and Human Values 28 (3): 403–424. CrossRef.

41.

Malpas

and Wickham

. 1995. Governance and failure: On the limits of sociology. Journal of Sociology 31 (3): 37–50. CrossRef.

42.

McKenzie-Mohr

2000. ‘New ways to promote proenvironmental behavior: Promoting sustainable behavior: An introduction to community-based social marketing’. Journal of Social Issues 56 (3): 543–554. CrossRef.

43.

McKenzie-Mohr

, Nemiroff

L.S.

, Beers

and Desmarais

. 1995. ‘Determinants of responsible environmental behaviour’. Journal of Social Issues 51 (4): 139–156. CrossRef.

44.

McKerlie

, Knight

and Thorpe

. 2006. Advancing Extended Producer Responsibility in Canada. Journal of Cleaner Production 14 (6): 616–628. CrossRef.

45.

Michael

1996. ‘Ignoring science: Discourses of ignorance in the public understanding of science’. In: Irwin

and Wynne

(eds), Misunderstanding Science? The Public Reconstruction of Science and Technology, pp. 107–125. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

46.

Petts

1997. ‘The public-expert interface in local waste management decisions: Expertise, credibility and process’. Public Understanding of Science 6 (4): 359–381. CrossRef.

47.

Reno

2011. ‘Beyond risk: Emplacement and the production of environmental evidence’. American Ethnologist 38 (3): 516–530. CrossRef.

48.

Roth

W-M

and Désautels

. 2004. ‘Educating for citizenship: Reappraising the role of science education’. Canadian Journal of Science, Mathematics and Technology Education 4 (2): 149–168. CrossRef.

49.

Rutherford

2007. ‘Green governmentality: Insights and opportunities in the study of nature's rule’. Progress in Human Geography 31 (3): 291–307. CrossRef.

50.

Shove

2003. Comfort, Cleanliness and Convenience: The Social Organization of Normality. New York: Berg Publishers.

51.

Shove

2010. ‘Beyond the ABC: Climate change policy and theories of social change’. Environment and Planning A 42 (6): 1273–1285. CrossRef.

52.

Shove

and Walker

. 2007. ‘CAUTION! Transitions ahead: Politics, practice, and sustainable transition management’. Environment and Planning A 39 (4): 763–770. CrossRef.

53.

Stafford

2011. ‘Kingston investigates thermal treatment for waste’. The Kingston Whig-Standard, 27 November, http://www.thewhig.com/2011/11/27/kingston-in-vestigates-thermal-treatment-for-waste (accessed 21 February 2014).

54.

Stern

P.C.

1999. ‘Information, incentives, and proenvironmental consumer behaviour’. Journal of Consumer Policy 22 (4): 461–478. CrossRef.

55.

Van Vliet

, Chappells

and Shove

. 2005. Infrastructures of Consumption: Environmental Innovation in the Utility Industries. London: Earthscan.

56.

Vicente

and Reis

. 2008. ‘Factors influencing households' participation in recycling’. Waste Management & Research 26 (2): 140–146. CrossRef.

57.

Waste Diversion Ontario. 2012. Municipal Data Call: 2012 Diversion Rate by Municipality. http://www.wdo.ca/index.php/download_file/1218/231/ (accessed 20 February 2014).