Sustainability of What? Recognising the Diverse Values that Sustainable Agriculture Works to Sustain

Abstract

The contours of sustainable systems are defined according to communities’ goals and values. As researchers shift from sustainability-in-the-abstract to sustainability-as-a-concrete-research-challenge, democratic deliberation is essential for ensuring that communities determine what systems ought to be sustained. Discourse analysis of dialogue with Michigan direct marketing farmers suggests eight sustainability values – economic efficiency, community connectedness, stewardship, justice, ecologism, self-reliance, preservationism and health – which informed the practices of these farmers. Whereas common heuristics of sustainability suggest values can be pursued harmoniously, we discuss how this typology reflects the more intricate project of balancing values in tension with one another.

Keywords

Sustainability agricultural ethics environmental ethics sustainability values

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahuvia

2001. ‘Traditional, interpretive, and reception based content analyses: Improving the ability of content analysis to address issues of pragmatic and theoretical concern’. Social Indicators Research 54: 139–172. CrossRef.

Borgmann

1987. Technology and the Character of Contemporary Life: A Philosophical Inquiry. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Brundtland

G.H.

1987. Report of the World Commission on Environment and Development: Our Common Future. United Nations.

Carolan

2006. ‘Do you see what I see? Examining the epistemic barriers to sustainable agriculture’. Rural Sociology 71(2): 232–260. CrossRef.

Conway

G.R.

and Barbier

E.B.

. 1990. After the Green Revolution: Sustainable Agriculture for Development. London: Earthscan.

Crompton

2010. Common Cause: The Case for Working with our Cultural Values. World Wildlife Fund.

Dawe

N.K.

, and Ryan

K.L.

. 2003. ‘The faulty three-legged-stool model of sustainable development’. Conservation Biology: 1458–1460. CrossRef.

DeLind

L.B.

2011. ‘Are local food and the local food movement taking us where we want to go? Or are we hitching our wagons to the wrong stars?’ Agriculture and Human Values 28: 273–283. CrossRef.

Drainville

A.C.

2008. ‘Present in the world economy: The Coalition of Immokalee Workers (1996–2007)’. Globalizations 5(3): 357–377. CrossRef.

10.

Dresner

2008. The Principles of Sustainability. New York: Routledge.

11.

Dryzek

J.S.

2013. The Politics of the Earth: Environmental Discourses. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

12.

Elliott

K.C.

2013. ‘Selective ignorance and agricultural research’. Science, Technology, & Human Values 38(3): 328–350. CrossRef.

13.

Ellis

2013. ‘The symbiotic ideology: Stewardship, husbandry, and dominion in beef production’. Rural Sociology 17(4): 429–449. CrossRef.

14.

Escobar

1998. ‘Whose knowledge, whose nature? Biodiversity, conservation, and the political ecology of social movements’. Journal of Political Ecology 5(1): 53–82.

15.

Feenestra

2002. ‘Creating space for sustainable food systems: Lessons from the field’. Agriculture and Human Values 19(2): 99–106. CrossRef.

16.

Flint

R.W.

and Houser

W.L.

. 2001. Living a Sustainable Lifestyle for our Children's Children. Bloomington: iUniverse Press.

17.

Garrison

D.R.

, Cleveland-Innes

, Koole

and Kappelman

. 2006. ‘Revisiting methodological issues in transcript analysis: Negotiated coding and reliability’. Internet and Higher Education 9: 1–8. CrossRef.

18.

Goldberger

J.R.

2011. ‘Conventionalization, civic engagement, and the sustainability of organic agriculture’. Journal of Rural Studies 27(3): 288–296. CrossRef.

19.

Goodland

1997. ‘Environmental sustainability in agriculture: Diet matters’. Ecological Economics 23: 189–200. CrossRef.

20.

Goodman

Leo A.

1961. ‘Snowball sampling’. The Annals of Mathematical Statistics 32(1): 148–170. CrossRef.

21.

Heberlein

T.A.

2012. Navigating Environmental Attitudes. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.

22.

Holling

C.S.

1973. ‘Resilience and stability of ecological systems’. Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics 4: 1–23. CrossRef.

23.

Horrigan

, Lawrence

R.S.

and Walker

. 2002. ‘How sustainable agriculture can address the environmental and human health harms of industrial agriculture’. Environmental Health Perspective 110(5): 445–456. CrossRef.

24.

Leith

and Vanclay

. 2015. ‘Translating science to benefit diverse publics: Engagement pathways for linking climate risk, uncertainty, and agricultural identities’. Science, Technology & Human Values 40(6): 939–964. CrossRef.

25.

Longino

2002. The Fate of Knowledge. Princeton NJ: Princeton University Press.

26.

Lozano

2008. ‘Envisioning sustainability three-dimensionally’. Journal of Cleaner Production 16(17): 1838–1846. CrossRef.

27.

Lyson

T.A.

2004. Civic Agriculture: Reconnecting Farm, Food, and Community. Medford, MA: Tufts University Press.

28.

Morse

J.M.

1997. “‘Perfectly healthy but dead”: The myth of inter-rater reliability’. Qualitative Health Research 7(4): 445–447. CrossRef.

29.

National Research Council. 2010. Toward Sustainable Agricultural systems in the 21st Century. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

30.

Norton

B.G.

2005. Sustainability: A Philosophy of Adaptive Ecosystem Management. Chicago, Illinois: University of Chicago Press. CrossRef.

31.

Noy

Chaim

. 2008. ‘Sampling knowledge: The hermeneutics of snowball sampling in qualitative research’. International Journal of Social Research Methodology 11(4): 327–344. CrossRef.

32.

Perfecto

, Vandermeer

and Wright

. 2009. Nature's Matrix: Linking Agriculture, Conservation and Food Sovereignty. Sterling, VA: Earthscan Press.

33.

Raffaelle

, Robinson

and Selinger

. 2010. Sustainability Ethics: 5 Questions. New York: Automatic Press.

34.

Schwartz

S.H.

1994. Beyond Individualism/Collectivism: New Cultural Dimensions of Values. SAGE publications, Inc.

35.

Seghezzo

2009. ‘The five dimensions of sustainability’. Environmental Politics 18(4): 539–556. CrossRef.

36.

Shrader-Frechette

K.S.

2010. ‘Analyzing public participation in risk analysis: How the wolves of environmental injustice hide in the sheep's clothing of science’. Environmental Justice 3(4): 119–123. CrossRef.

37.

Stock

P.V.

2007. “‘Good farmers” as reflexive producers: An examination of family organic farmers in the US Midwest’. Sociologia Ruralis 47(2): 83–102. CrossRef.

38.

Thompson

P.B.

1992. ‘The varieties of sustainability’. Agriculture and Human Values 9(3): 11–19. CrossRef.

39.

Thompson

P.B.

2000. ‘Farming as a focal practice’, in Higgs

and Strong

(eds), Technology and the Good Life? Chicago: University of Chicago Press. CrossRef.

40.

Thompson

P.B.

2010. The Agrarian Vision: Sustainability and Environmental Ethics. Lexington: University of Kentucky Press. CrossRef.

41.

Thompson

P.B.

2015. From Field to Fork: Food Ethics for Everyone. Oxford: Oxford University Press. CrossRef.

42.

United States Department of Agriculture. 2013. Know Your Farmer Know Your Food. USDA.gov. Accessed 22 Jan. 2014 from http://www.usda.gov/knowyourfarmer/.

43.

Werkheiser

and Piso

. 2015. ‘People work to sustain systems: A framework for understanding sustainability’. Journal of Water Resources Planning and Management 141(12). CrossRef.

44.

White

M.D.

and Marsh

E.E.

. 2006. ‘Content analysis: A flexible methodology’. Library Trends 55(1): 22–45. CrossRef.

45.

Williams

C.C.

and Millington

A.C.

. 2004. ‘The diverse and contested meanings of sustainable development’. The Geographical Journal 170: 99–104. CrossRef.

46.

Wodak

and Meyer

. 2009. ‘Critical discourse analysis: History, agenda, theory and methodology’. Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis 2: 1–33.

47.

Yates

J.J.

2012. ‘Abundance on trial: The cultural significance of “sustainability”’. The Hedgehog Review 14(2): 1–8.